← All interviews
Interview · January 2007 · Calgary

Andrew McMahon (Jack's Mannequin) Interview

Andrew McMahon talks how Jack's Mannequin came together, writing for Something Corporate versus on his own, "The Mixed Tape" and Dire Straits, "Holiday from Real", the Beach Boys and not being pop punk, and "Last Straw", in this 2007 interview with Matt Schichter in Calgary. McMahon is also known for Something Corporate's "Punk Rock Princess" and "If You C Jordan", and later "Cecilia and the Satellite" as Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness.

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusicians

Lennon or McCartney? Andrew McMahon’s answer: McCartney. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Andrew McMahon said about the songs

“The Mixed Tape”

Andrew McMahon explained that instead of sending an ex a real mixtape, he wrote a song about making one.

“I got this idea, like, maybe I'll make her some epic mixtape and then try and send it her way... So instead of actually giving it to her, I wrote a song about giving it to her. That was the idea. And instead of making the mixtape per se, I actually just wrote a song about making a mixtape.”

Watch the moment

Andrew McMahon said he wrote the song on piano even though he heard it as a guitar song.

“I barely know how to play the guitar. I wrote The Mixed Tape on piano, and I definitely had every intention behind it being more of a guitar song. It felt much more of a rock song.”

Watch the moment

“Dark Blue”

Andrew McMahon explained why the last song he wrote for the album sits in the middle of it.

“Dark Blue, it was the last song I wrote for the record, and it ended up being in the middle of the album, but philosophically speaking, that song was really about coming full circle, so I thought it would be interesting to put it in the middle”

Watch the moment

“Holiday from Real”

Asked about this line, Andrew McMahon said it was drawn from life around his Santa Monica studio, and explained why the song opens the album.

“I work out of a studio in Santa Monica, and yes, there's definitely a contingent of the lesbian traffickers that ride their bikes around and make deliveries for us... Holiday was really the song... that sort of propelled the philosophy of the album”

Watch the moment

“Last Straw”

Andrew McMahon explained the drawing that started the song and its original title.

“What started the entire writing of that song was a drawing that I had done. It started off as a drawing of Snoop Dogg... with a picture of Snoop Dogg bitch-slapping George Bush... It was actually titled Snoop Dogg Versus the Evildoer.”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

Andrew McMahon InterviewInterview · 24:46 · 31 views
Archive footage

24:46 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #91 · Andrew McMahon (Jack's Mannequin)January 2007 · 00:24:46

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00[inaudible] Andrew? Oh hey, what's going on, man? Hey. I'm great. Where are you guys? I am backstage at the Orleans Arena. We're in Orleans Arena, we're in Las Vegas, Nevada. There you go. What hotel are you staying at? You know, we push out at like three tonight, so I'm just gonna get dragged around the Strip wasted until three o'clock and then get on the bus and roll out to San Diego for the last show of the tour. Nice. And then what? And then I'm gonna go home and I'm gonna get married. Yeah. Thank you very much. Yeah, and then I get a couple weeks off and then we head out to Japan, do a Japanese tour, and then back to the States to do a full headlining tour in February. Cool. Are the dates lined up for that? Are you coming up to Calgary? You know, I don't know that we're gonna make it up to Calgary. I think the only Canadian date is going to be Toronto, just because basically what we did was we

1:00sort of tried to mimic the routing of the Panic tour, or just kind of capitalize on the new, you know, new fan mix on this new tour. So we're just going to, and not to mention we've been on the road for like a year, like, get us home. So we got a short tour, but we'll be home by March to start working on new music and just kind of chill out and hang around town a little while. Jack's stuff or Something Corporate stuff? Probably Jack's stuff is my guess. I mean, I don't claim to really have any clear idea what I plan on doing next, other than the fact that it involves going home and resting and writing new music, you know? Yeah. At this point, for me, it's like we sort of went from the [inaudible], sort of that whole heavy year being sick, right back on the tour. I'm just anxious to kind of get back to living a normal life for a second, see if that doesn't inspire some good new tunes, you know? Yeah, maybe a little happier now with the whole marriage thing. You never know. Yeah, oh yeah. You know, everything's been great. I mean, obviously it was an interesting year, but it's all been really positive and, you know, it's

2:01been great being back out on the road. The tours have been insane and the band's having a great time, so we're all really enjoying ourselves, but I think we'll definitely look forward to getting a little bit of time at home and getting to see what our own beds look like for more than a night, you know? Yeah, exactly. How did you hook up with these guys? I mean, I know a lot of artists put out solo records just because, you know, they feel maybe it won't fit with the band and stuff, and I'm wondering, right, how'd you hook up with these guys? Like, how come no Something Corporate guys decided, you know, maybe I'll just drum on tour, something like that? No, I mean, you know, it was one of these things where the band, all of us in Something Corporate, we got back, it was kind of like, I guess probably just spring of 2004, we were all just burnt out. Burnt out on being on the road, burnt out on each other. I mean, not to say, and I still see the guys all the time, we talk every, you know, [inaudible], and we're the best of friends, but the reality was we just spent three or four long years on the road, you know, kind of in our early 20s, like

3:01and not having really any grasp of reality whatsoever. We kind of lost our minds, so we were like, screw this, let's go home and chill out. In that time, Josh wrote a record with his band Firescape, and I sort of went off on my own, really not with the intention of putting a record out, but just kind of started writing music. I was finally home for the first time in eight years and doing what came so naturally, which was just going out, living my life, writing songs about it, you know. And so then eventually, after I'd done that, you know, when I [inaudible] producer for several months, we had like a stockpile of tunes that we really liked, and then Bob, who plays guitar with Something Corporate, actually came out and he played guitar on the remaining songs we hadn't done guitar on, and overdubbed other guitar tracks. And at that point I'd been working with Tommy Lee on his record, so he played the drums on most of the Jack's stuff. And you know, I had known Bob, you know, my

4:03guitarist, from obviously playing with Something Corporate, and his band River City High was one of the first bands Something Corporate ever toured with, and his drummer from River City High, Jay McMillan, came over to play drums for us. And one of their friends, another Richmond, Virginia guy named Jon Sullivan, came out to play bass, and we sort of put the band together pretty much after the record was completed, or right as the record was being finished, and got the show on the road. I got sick in the middle there, but recovered and then got the show back on the road, and that's sort of how it all came to be, you know. I feel great. Yeah, I feel fantastic. You know, it's been a long road back, but having music as kind of my motivator was a huge factor, you know, being able to know that as soon as I was well enough I'd be able to go out and play shows and see the fans that I'd been missing in my time off the road. It was definitely a big incentive to get

5:03healthy as fast as possible, and I worked every angle to push myself as hard as I could, and it really sort of got me back on my feet, I would say, a lot quicker than I probably would have had I not had this great job. Mm-hmm. Now, you mentioned Josh, you used to co-write with him, and now you're doing the stuff by yourself. Is it, right, how is it different? Well, yeah, truthfully, we never actually co-wrote anything. I mean, on each of the albums that we put out, he wrote two or three songs on each of those records, but even those songs he sort of wrote individually. To some extent, I would go in there, and if the lyric didn't really make sense to me, or for me to connect to, I would [inaudible] here and there. But for the most part, I mean, the songs that Josh wrote on our records were 100% his songs, and the songs that I wrote on the records were 100% mine. So really the writing strategy has been exactly the same. You know, I've been writing music since I was nine years old, and Josh and I and the band

6:03sort of got together my junior year of high school. But for me, I would argue it's even, sort of, the method behind Jack's Mannequin is probably a lot more true to my original form than what I was doing in Something Corporate, in that sense. Not to say that we're not going to do another record, because I think we definitely will, and I'm sure we're going to tour here soon enough, you know. But getting back home and writing songs, just vegging out and figuring my own head out, is kind of always how I've written since I was a little kid, you know. Yeah. Do you ever write on guitar? I mean, The Mixed Tape sounds like it's a guitar, it could be a Something Corporate song at least. That seems like the one on the record that kind of fits in musically with the rest of that stuff. Yeah, I mean, no, no, I don't really. I mean, I barely know how to play the guitar. I wrote The Mixed Tape on piano, and I definitely had every intention behind it being more of a guitar song. It felt much more of a rock song. The riff at the top of that is something that Bobby and myself and our

7:03producer really collaborated on, and really tried to sink our teeth into it as a real kind of guitar rock track. The album itself, you know, most of the guitar sounds are not very heavy. We kind of went for a little bit more of, you know, the fidelity of the guitars being a little bit more of a clean, kind of dirty, raw but clean kind of sound, as opposed to what a lot of bands are doing out there, which is just super hyped-up heavy distortion, you know what I mean? Which I feel like has sort of lost its strength in rock music, it's been so overdone at this point, so we kind of decided to go the other direction. But yeah, we really collaborated with Bob on that song, because he's a fantastic guitarist and he's really helped bring the rock and roll element out of that track. That's awesome. I heard a Dire Straits song kind of inspired The Mixed Tape. The idea behind The Mixed Tape was sort of propelled by this Dire Straits song, Walk in the Wild West End, which basically prompted me to have this idea,

8:05this thought, to start collecting songs in the time that I was, you know, the girl I wrote the record for, who I was separated from at the time. And I got this idea, like, maybe I'll make her some epic mixtape and then try and send it her way. And I kind of got that idea after listening to this song, Walk in the Wild West End, and it really just made me think of her. And so I started, kind of as songs would pop up that I would hear throughout the days or weeks or months or whatever that really reminded me of, you know, [inaudible], I started compiling all these songs. And then it got to the point where I was like, when am I ever going to give this to her that it's going to make sense? So instead of actually giving it to her, I wrote a song about giving it to her. That was the idea. And instead of making the mixtape per se, I actually just wrote a song about making a mixtape. That's awesome. I mean, same girl the whole record's about pretty much, right? Is it who you're marrying now? Yeah. It's a pretty harsh record at times. I mean, there's some good stuff

9:06there. What does she think when she hears it now? You know, I think you'd probably have to ask her. You know, it's one of these things. We've dated for many, many years, since before I was even putting out records, but at the same time, it's one of these things that with any girl that I've ever dated in my life, I've always been very upfront about the fact that I write music about what goes on in my life, and if you happen to be in my life, there's a good chance you're going to be a target, or at least a subject matter, you know. And it's [inaudible], the good, the bad, the ugly. And I think in some senses it's unfortunate, but it's the only way that I can be true to what's been true to me for my whole life, which is songwriting, and being able to express myself through it. So yeah, she's a trooper. I mean, obviously when she heard it for the first time, after it was done, and we had since sort of gotten back together, and I sort of [inaudible] my

10:08piece and put it out there, and I was like, you know, check it out. It may not all make sense, but just know that really, at the end of the day, it was all about coming full circle and realizing that this was the place I was supposed to be, [inaudible]. And I think for the most part she gets it. Yeah. She hasn't stopped showing up to gigs or anything yet, so I think we're okay. That's good. I want to go through a couple of tracks on the record, you know, kind of track by track type thing. Sure. First track, Holiday from Real. I mean, it establishes a whole bunch of themes on the record, stuff that, well, same kind of Something Corporate themes that you were writing about back then, but now, I mean, California is a big, huge influence on this one. It's drinking, weed, living freely, the breakup, all that kind of stuff. Yes, absolutely. Yeah. And I know you're a big pot, well, not a big pot, pot brownies? Oh, goodness gracious. Oh, no, you know, I mean, whatever. I'm not going to, I'm not a liar, come right out and say anything different, from one sense or the other. But yeah, I think, I mean, you get the idea from the record. Yeah, yeah. I'm just, a line in the song I just love, scoring eighths from the lesbians in Venice. Yeah. Do you actually get

11:08your stuff? Yeah, yeah. I mean, largely while we were recording this record, I work out of a studio in Santa Monica, and yes, there's definitely a contingent of the lesbian traffickers that ride their bikes around and make deliveries for us. So it's a, yeah, I mean, all that said, Holiday was really the song, you know, the reason it's first, largely, on my record is because it was really the song that sort of propelled the philosophy of the album, and almost really the life I chose to lead while recording the album, which was essentially, like you said, just coming from a place where I really felt kind of bound up and frustrated and didn't really have an outlet for those frustrations, and [inaudible] came home and said screw it, just chilled out, and then tried to, like you said, live a very free and somewhat irresponsible life, and

12:08Then, and in turn write songs about it, you know. And it was a, and California, being in Southern California and living by the beach, it was such a huge part of it that I wanted the record to be really visual, and that when people listened to it, I wanted them to be able to sort of put themselves in the place of each song, you know, and where the song was coming from, and kind of connect to it on not just a, maybe, emotional level, but maybe, you know, they actually see what I was seeing at the time that I was thinking about a lot of the things that, you know, I was writing about. Yeah. Was there a lot of thought process that went into the order of the record? Was it written in that order? I mean, it's not chronological. It's largely written in that order. Some things got sort of mixed around. Some of the songs were a little broader, that, you know, sort of lent themselves to pushing the album order along, and got moved around. Like Dark Blue, it was the last song I wrote for the record, and it ended up being in the middle of the album, but philosophically speaking, that song was really about

13:08coming full circle, so I thought it would be interesting to put it in the middle, you know, and kind of prove that it was just a big circle, you know. Yeah, well, I think that comes after La La Lie, which, I mean, talked about being done writing songs about that girl and everything like that, right? Yeah, and then there I come right back, write some more, you know. So yeah, I mean, that was really the thing. That was kind of the story of that year, was like, you know, the push and pull of what a breakup is, you know. It's like you think, you know, you get to a point, and it changes from day to day, and you think you've gotten over it, you think you've moved on, or you think at least it's the last time you're going to talk about it for a while, and that just comes right back at you, especially when you still care, when you've been with somebody for a long time, you know. And that's sort of, you know, really [inaudible] what the record was about, was just that kind of push and pull, and kind of constantly retreading the same ground, but, you know, in a different place in time, you know. Mm-hmm. Your vocal melodies are just unreal. It reminds me very much of Brian Wilson, the Beach Boys,

14:10especially La La Lie. I mean, Made for Each Other sounds like a Beach Boys song, or it could have been. That was the idea. Yeah, absolutely. There was that, I mean, for me, I really liked it, you know. One of the biggest things that kick-started my writing process for this record was really falling in love with that sound, you know. It was a huge motivator, and it was sort of like, you know, with Something Corporate, we had really, you know, not even intentionally so, but just by our affiliations with Drive-Thru Records and the tours that came our way as a result of that, you know, had sort of been, in my opinion, pigeonholed into a scene, you know. And not to say, I mean, the scene has been extremely good to us, but it's still kind of like, I felt it was a little ironic, you know, that my, like, piano band, singing kind of more or less sappy songs about girls, was somehow pop punk, you know. And I was like, well, there's nothing punk rock about me or my band. And [inaudible], exactly, you know.

15:12But that was about her, not me, you know. I mean, in that sense, I didn't really feel like, you know, I never listened to punk music at that point, you know. I mean, I didn't know anything about punk, so like, how could I be punk? I don't even know what they're talking about, you know. And so I think I sort of got to the point where I was in a position to kind of expand with this record, and, you know, by doing it on my own and not really attaching the Something Corporate name to it, the hope was that people would sort of start listening to the songs for what they were, as opposed to, like, what they had been, you know, what I'd been perceived to be over the course of several years, which was somehow a, you know, a pop punk frontman or something, you know. No. And which was very much not ever what I intended to be, you know. Well, as long as it's kind of punk rock, at least in the idea. Last Straw, I know it's not on the record, but I just downloaded it the other day. I mean, I know you said go and download it, whatever. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

16:12But, uh, writing about politics, now that's different. Yeah, I mean, I sort of, I mean, I generally avoid it. I don't know if it's going to be as easy to avoid on the next one, just with the way that the past four years have gone. Yeah. But I mean, it was funny, because it wasn't really so much trying to write about politics as it was just like, that was a, you know, it was a really interesting time, you know. Like I said, the subject matter of the record is pretty evident, but the reason the politics came up just happened to be because, like, in the middle of all of this stuff that was going on in my life, we were in the middle of this election, which was, you know, obviously, where we live, just a huge battle, you know. And it was so heated everywhere in America, everywhere you went, and you couldn't avoid it, and, you know, it wasn't possible not to have an opinion about it. And, you know, unfortunately, right around that election was just another one of these, like, kind of dark periods of time. I just, I was holed up in my house, just, like, you know, drowning my sorrows, watching, you know, President Bush when he

17:13had another election, and definitely different words fill it. Yeah, it made it a, yeah, exactly. Steal. Yeah, and it definitely manifested itself into that track, no question about it. What started the entire writing of that song was a drawing that I had done. It started off as a drawing of Snoop Dogg that I copied out of, like, a Rolling Stone, and then somehow I managed to copy a picture of George Bush, like, right below it, with a picture of Snoop Dogg bitch-slapping George Bush. And the original lyric was, and I wrote the lyric, now it says, "Sometimes all I can do when I think about the President," but the original lyric was, uh, God, it was, that's when I drew that sketch of Snoop Dogg beating up the President, or something to that effect. Just throw it up on the website. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I guess it hasn't probably popped up, but yeah, it's pretty funny. It was actually

18:14titled Snoop Dogg Versus the Evildoer. But, uh, yeah, I'll try and get it up there for something for Entertainment News. Yeah. Talking about that song, it's not on the record, but you said go download it. [inaudible] How do you feel about the downloading of music, and do you think it's helping you or harming you more? You know, I gotta be honest, my opinion of it has really gotten to a very simple place, which is, it's not gonna stop, don't fight it, you know. I mean, you want your fans to buy records, you know. I mean, you want to be getting, you know, that actual tangible support of your band, because, like, when you're signed to a record deal, you know, and when you work hard and you do what you do, it's like, yeah, it would be great if your fans, you know, respect what you did enough to go out and actually, you know, spend the money on it, especially when you've paid a lot of money to make it. But that being said, it's like there are so many benefits to it, and in my opinion, the reality is, if you're making good records, you know, I feel like the first time a kid discovers you, they may

19:14end up downloading, and if you do a good job, you know, connecting to them, and they like the music you make, I'd, you know, venture a guess that on the next record, when the next record comes out, they're not going to download it, they're gonna buy it, you know, and everything. [inaudible] I think the downloading really has done something that has accounted for something that the music industry has stopped doing, which is artist development, you know. And it's like, you know, downloading tracks now, in some ways, is the way that artists go from being sort of unknown to actually developing a career, and, you know, having their record sales growing and whatnot, because the more people find out about you, they'll eventually buy your next record if you [inaudible] and stay true to your art. Now it keeps, they keep this, so you have to do sort of, I mean, it keeps you working, you know. And I mean, but it's like people want everything handed to them, and it's like, yeah, it's not a day and age where now you can just put a great pop song together and on one song sell a few million records, you know. But should it be that? You know, I don't necessarily think so.

20:15I think bands should have to work for it, you know. And downloading makes us all work a little bit harder, but it also gives access, you know, quick access to music that the radio doesn't provide for our bands anymore, because the radio stopped playing the kind of music that we all listen to, you know, largely, at least. You know, there are stations that have really carried the torch, but they're few and far between. Most of them are dominated by corporate radio infrastructure that just does not, you know, whose goal is to [inaudible] advertising, not to propel good musicians or good music, you know. Our station's different, that's our goal. [inaudible] the thing, and, you know, we appreciate it. Like, to any station that's going to play my band, it's like, I'm extremely grateful, and I'm always willing to do whatever it takes to help them and be involved with the station, you know. But that being said, to the stations that don't, I'm very thankful that downloading exists, because how else is a kid going to decide whether or not he wants to hear your band or buy your record if you

21:16can't, if he doesn't have access to your music, you know. And downloading gives that access, you know. And whatever, yeah, it's free and it's stolen, but those kids come to the shows and they buy t-shirts, and like I said, if you're good to your fans, they'll buy your next record. They won't steal it, you know. No, I wonder, a song like The Mixed Tape, I mean, it went to what, was it number one on VH1 or MTV or something? Yeah, yeah, number one on VH1. Yeah, not on the radio. Like, it doesn't make sense to me, if a song is doing that well in the video, why do... If I could understand any of it, if any of it made any sense to me, I would, you know, I'd already have a hit, you know. But the reality is, for me, it's like every record I've made has sold over 200,000 copies, you know what I mean? And it's like, you know, [inaudible], and in the years I've been on tour, it has been a rarity that we've, you know, had shows bomb and that we haven't had people come to the gigs, you know. I mean, and like, I own a house

22:17and I have a good life, and, you know, everybody in my camp is well fed and well taken care of. And, you know, at the [inaudible], it's not necessarily, like, you know, as glamorous as selling a gazillion records, but over the past six or seven years, I've made a great living being a working musician. And if that's what I did for the rest of my life, you know, and I never had the radio blow up a track for me and put me at number one somewhere, then so be it, as long as I've still got people who want to buy my records, you know. I'll keep flying. You know, I hope [inaudible]. Yeah, I appreciate that. Well, we'll take all the love we can get, that's for sure, you know. I think, I'm not one of these screw radio guys. I'm just like, but I do get confused by it, you know. The stuff that gets played that doesn't sell, and the stuff that sells because it just gets jammed down people's throats. It's like, it is what it is, you know. I figure one of these days, I'm just going to keep writing songs, and one of these days something's going to click

23:17and the stations [inaudible] decide to play some of our music, and we'll see what happens. Yes. I'm taking up a lot of your time. I got five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay, cool. Alcohol or marijuana? Oh man, you've got me in a, [inaudible]. That's a tough question to answer. And, oh, because I've been doing Imagine lately, [inaudible]. Well, I just saw the Imagine movie the other day, and I'm, like, really boning up on my, because I would definitely say, historically speaking, I've been a McCartney person, you know. And I'll say this, I'll go McCartney, but with the reverence for the fact that Lennon is still very high at the top of the list, and in strong contention. Fair enough. iPod or CDs? I mean, I'm using my iPod a lot now, but I still buy records, vinyl records and CDs. Yeah, I'm also, yeah.

24:18Favourite, so many, play live. Favourite song to play live? We do this cover of the Everly Brothers' Dream, which I really enjoy. [inaudible] Yeah. And one word, Jack's Mannequin. Beach. Beach, one, I'll give you one. Now, no, you know, so with a beach, I'm going Beach. [inaudible] the record, gonna

Transcript edited for readability from the video's captions; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →