Lennon or McCartney? Atom Egoyan’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
VIDEOWatch
3:33 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #589 · Atom EgoyanSeptember 2013 · 00:05:40
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:07Where's the boy? He went out riding bikes with Michael. But I told him he better be home by 4:30. I haven't seen the boy, no. We are doing everything we can. [inaudible] We have three boys missing from Holiday Garden. It's a very delicate situation. I'm in the woods by that little creek they call Devil's Den. I found something. I wanted to tell this story, Devil's Knot, because I think it's one of the most amazing crime stories in contemporary history. It's inexplicable at some level how this horrifying event could have occurred with no hard evidence around the crime scene.
1:00You couldn't have made that up. The fact that these three young boys were murdered so viciously in this forest, and that their bodies were found with absolutely no evidence of any human presence at the scene of the crime, was supernatural. It's a combination of that supernatural sort of event with the all-too-human, natural response to it, which is that we need to find an answer. I love that this was a take where we saw, of course, what happened with the West Memphis Three, but the film also kind of explores all the possible paths that weren't followed
1:46and all the threads that were unexamined. It also creates these two characters that stand aside and begin to see that something is wrong. The character that Witherspoon is playing and that Firth is playing, they're beginning, over the course of this, to understand that justice won't be served. And then what? How do you live with doubt? How do you live with this idea that you may not have an answer? All of that was just so compelling. Well, I guess you have to leave without an answer. It's what you're feeling leaving the theatre with this movie, and it's nice, because you don't get that from many movies. Well, you can't get that from a lot of movies, because any dramatically constructed story would need a third act. I mean, it'd be crazy. That's why I'm saying, if you were to make this up, anyone would say, okay, so then you've given us this crime,
2:36and you've given us a courtroom, you better have an answer. And so it's interesting that in this case you have all of these signifiers for a resolution, but there is no resolution. And it doesn't even have the comfort of some of the documentaries, which say, okay, well, now look at this, because that is the answer, this person. We're not saying that either. We're saying these are all possible, and maybe some of the real answers are going to be lost to us. We can't actually follow them anymore, because the blood evidence was lost, or, you know, that witness was let go, and time has passed. And so it's troubling and unresolved in a way that can only happen in a case based on actual circumstance. And I think it's kind of a unique sort of feeling that you're left with at the end, where you have every reason to believe that there's going to be a resolution and a reason.
3:26I think it's even more powerful for people who know nothing about the story, who are going to this and see all this unfold and have every reason to believe it's going to go somewhere. So it's a challenge, and it's actually unique. I think as a filmmaker I just thought it was a unique opportunity, and I got really excited about being able to tell it. I've got to ask you some questions. I'll let you go, but we do something called five questions. Five quick questions. Sure. One-word answers. Okay. All right. Film or digital? Now digital, sadly. Three words. It's a bad idea like that. Writing or directing? Both. Okay. You get to do it all. Lennon or McCartney? Oh, Lennon, yeah. Hitchcock or Kubrick? Hitchcock. In one word,
4:11Devil's Knot? Supernatural. Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley will be charged in the murders of the three boys found last month in the Robin Hood Hills woods. Apparently some residents suspect a satanic cult is responsible. That looks like [inaudible]. You don't look like that when you're like a normal person. My name's Ron Lax. I'm an investigator. This crime is unthinkable. What if they did it? What if they didn't? Did you kill any of those three boys? No. Anytime anything weird happens around here, people blame it on devil worshippers. Did you ever find any evidence linking these murders to Damien? Why do you think it should not be imposed? Because I'm innocent. There was blood on the knife. They wouldn't do anything. [inaudible] people say what they want to hear.
4:57Killing three eight-year-olds would make you feel good? Whoever did it must have. Satanism is out there. The police, the judge, everybody, this is all just some sort of game to them. Whatever it takes. I'll be able to prove the cops never really tried to find out who did it. Would you want three more families to lose their children too? I don't know what you mean.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.