← All interviews
Interview · c. 2004–2005 · Kitchener, ON

Collective Soul Interview

Collective Soul talk "Goodnight, Good Guy", "Precious Declaration" and "Counting the Days", the Christian rock label, leaving Atlantic Records, Dosage, recording with Pro Tools and the song "Youth", in this interview with Matt Schichter. Collective Soul are best known for "Shine", "December", "The World I Know" and "Heavy".

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusicians

SONGSWhat Collective Soul member said about the songs

“Precious Declaration”

A member of Collective Soul ties the chorus to the band's lawsuit with its first manager.

“That's the one that probably encapsulates what we were going through at that time more than any other song... we were going through a big lawsuit with our first manager, and 'Precious Declaration' is about, you know, the chorus: 'Yours is yours, and mine you leave alone.'”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

Collective Soul InterviewInterview · 22:45 · 126 views
Archive footage

22:45 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00Start right off with a tune, the way we do it here. I name two tunes, you pick one, say why. I just made a list of basically all my favorites. Okay, so go off the first time. We'll go either "Shine" or "Goodnight, Good Guy." Go ahead, Dean. I'm gonna say "Goodnight, Good Guy." I think we've all heard "Shine." I think "Goodnight, Good Guy" is always been my favorite song. Yeah, we haven't played it in the past few months. This interview right here, I think it's gonna spur us to get that back in the repertoire. How long does it take for you guys to rehearse a song like that? Like, let's say you want to throw it back in, can you just do it automatically? Yeah, it just depends. It just depends on how much you played the song in the past, pretty much, and that one we should be able to

0:50sling right back in the set. Yeah, "Goodnight" would be a song we would just have one run-through of at soundcheck or something. A lot of people think you guys are a Christian rock band, or you started off as a Christian rock band. Do you want to dispel those rumors, or is it true? Well, it's always been a spiritual band, I think. Yeah, as far as the labeling there, we've always tried to step away from any kind of label. You know, we just made music. You know, we make rock pop music. As far as our faith and our person, those things exist on a personal level. I don't mind the label. I would always like to think that Collective Soul music could lend itself towards any religion. It's more of a spiritual thing than it is a

1:36secular thing, a certain religion. And I think our perspective is more of a hopeful one, and that's a common thread that exists in many different faiths, central themes. I think that to call it anything, not even just Christian rock, just to call it modern rock or classic rock, I think sort of sells the music short. So that music's universal? I don't know. Sorry. Well, I just wanted to talk to the brothers in the band, the big brother in the band. I was on the road with my brother, it was a concert, [inaudible]. I guess you guys are older, so you know. Is it hard to be on the road with the bro all the time? No, not really. We manage to make it work. We're a bunch of eight other guys,

2:24nine other guys. It's all about having tolerance and giving each other space and still trying to figure out how to communicate properly and make it all work. But we obviously have moments, but for the most part... What about the rest of the guys? Fight a lot, or not fight a lot? Do you get along pretty well? Yeah, we get along pretty well overall. Yeah. We genuinely like each other. So in the long run, you have to realize you're in a relationship here, and there are little humps that happen in everyday relationships. Okay. I'm kind of getting into Ross a little bit, but we'll go through that. I know you probably don't get too much, but [inaudible] a little bit. Do you want "When the Waterfall" or "Untitled"?

3:19Well, I'll take this one. I'll go with "Untitled." It was one of my favorite songs that we did prior to releasing the record. It was one of the favorite ones of mine, and I haven't heard that song in a long time. And we'll keep rocking too. We'll keep the rock and pop going, as opposed to "Waterfall," it's kind of laid back. Now, Ross... where did he go? I've been looking on the internet. Where did he go? I don't know. The ghost. I think he's with a band from up here, right? I think he's working on some music and has recorded some songs with a singer from Canada. I forget which band he was in. He just made a decision to go a different way, and that's pretty much the generalization of it.

4:18It was sort of a decision on both sides, but we knew that it was time, that he couldn't be in the band any longer. It was a certain circumstance. You guys have Joel in the band now, replacing Ross. Have you played a little more lead now? Are you playing more of the stuff? No, not really. Joel's got it covered. Where did you guys meet up with him? He's been playing with us for about... but as far as before, he's been in bands around Atlanta, and he worked with us in the [inaudible], and he actually made and built amps. Yeah, so he's been a technical consultant, guitar tech, friend of ours for a decade, probably. So he fit right in personality-wise. We were already buddies.

5:15So sometimes personality is almost more important than actual skill on guitar. You saying he's a bad guitar player? No, but I was going to follow that up with he's an excellent guitar player. So does he play the same way Ross had it, with the... I need to quit bringing up Ross. Yeah, he definitely tries to mimic what Ross did on the earlier stuff, but he definitely throws his own twist on all of it. So, play another tune? Either "The World I Know" or "She Gathers Rain." Wow, well, I would say "She Gathers Rain," because it's one of my favorite songs of ours altogether. [inaudible]. "She Gathers Rain." Four-year break. I know you're probably sick of talking about it. Where did you guys go?

5:58What did you guys do? Was more than one record recorded? I heard you guys went in the studio a few times and didn't like what you were hearing. We definitely... Yeah, well, the four years started off just basically as a way for us to recharge our batteries. We were really tired. We had recorded five records plus the greatest hits in a period of a little less than eight years. We were really tired. And we had a lot of different things going on at that time too. Contractually, we were out of the Atlantic Records contract, and we were dealing with a lot of different personal issues. So we kind of just spread out across America, from L.A. all the way back to Atlanta. And we kind of just barely stayed in touch and

6:47just found ourselves on a personal level, outside of Collective Soul. Yeah, it was... But like you said, there were a lot of songs that we recorded over this time, you know, trying to get another record back out. So there's some B-sides or whatever, you know, that have been recorded, that people might hear, might never hear ever. There are some B-sides out of that stuff? You were playing those songs live? Maybe it was one song. Well, there was a song called "Youth," which is where the title of the CD came from. We recorded it. We all dug the song too, but for some reason we decided not to put it on the CD. Every once in a while, Ed will play it acoustic.

7:42Actually, we did that for the live DVD. We actually recorded that song for the live DVD that's coming out this year. So we recorded with the Atlanta Youth Symphony about two weeks ago, a hundred-person orchestra, kids from 14 to 19 years old, with 20-something Collective Soul arrangements. A friend of ours did them, and, you know, we had some input here and there. Well, some of the songs had already... like "The World I Know," some of the songs, yeah, the arrangements were there, you just had to put them on paper. But it was an amazing experience. We did two nights at Atlanta Symphony Hall and brought in a lot of production, made a big spectacle of the whole thing. So we're really looking forward to the final product.

8:45It was really exciting. It's our first live DVD, and it'll be a live CD as well, late September, early October, I think. Where did the idea come from, doing the CD, putting it out? At the end of last year, we were doing a lot of acoustic promo-type stuff, and we were spending a lot of time, which we had never done before, with our acoustic scenario. And we ended up sort of digging it. And we had a couple of days off in Atlanta, we went into the studio, and I think it was eight songs. And we just wanted to present them in the life that they are before we go into the studio and add all the bells and whistles to it. Yeah, and some of them were just worth capturing, because they were totally different vibes that we had kind of worked out over the whole promo tour thing that we were doing when the record first came out.

9:47So yes, we wanted to capture it, you know, things like... we did a version of "Counting the Days," it's a real laid-back, total blues version. And I think it was just cool to capture what was going on. Also, we've put our own record label together, and I think in our own way, we're kind of enjoying that freedom of being able to do something spontaneous and put it out in stores, and stretching our arms out a bit. Not that we've done it before, but we've just seen it a little bit. I don't know, like we have a little bit more room to maneuver. We made that decision, went and made that CD happen, all over, in like a week. Yeah, so it was quick. Hey guys, so you have your own record label now.

10:38Do you basically record your own stuff yet? Do you have your own studio, or do you rent studios? We have a studio. We don't have a frame to build it up. We have the brains, we just don't have the body. We've done different situations where it was our studio. One of them was a log cabin for the Disciplined Breakdown sessions, and that was a space that was pretty much Ed's place that we recorded some of this stuff at. But it's pretty much like, with the new technology, you pretty much bring a Pro Tools rig into a building and you have a studio. I feel like with Pro Tools, you can basically go into a corner and [inaudible]. No, it's all about... You still have to... You still can't polish a turd.

11:28That's a good one. Yeah. So... That's a good one, bro. You can polish it, there's still going to be a turd there, right? It's going to be a polished turd. It's all about technology. That's what, you know, you try to learn as a musician, as an artist. You want to use it, but you don't want it to use you. I think that a lot of that's happening in music today, actually. I noticed you guys do, like, some stuff off Dosage, I'd say, is computer heavy, but you know, it's got those sounds there, a little sound, like you've altered them somehow, a patch or, you know, different effects. And a lot of those are actually old vintage analog drum machines and keyboards and stuff. But yeah, we've always been using Pro Tools. We were one of the

12:19first bands to use Pro Tools, back in '95, you know, the second record. Yeah. But you know, it's just a tool. You can overuse any tool, and we try not to. We definitely try to play it first. It starts with our hands and our mind. And there's always been effects no matter what system you use. You can go back to cut and tape. It was the exact same thing that people are doing with Pro Tools right now, when you cut tape. We were talking about the Black Album the other day, the Metallica record, where Lars pretty much had a system where it was like Pro Tools, but it was cut tape, building them, and it was pre-Pro Tools. You know, splitting a tune. "December" or "Gel"? Well, we've been rocking a lot. We'll go with "December." We'll go with the five-minute laid-back tune. Talking with... El Music Group.

13:17Why did you guys leave Atlantic? Well, it wasn't really a thing where we left Atlantic. We signed a five-record deal plus greatest hits, so the deal was done. Was that right off the bat? Five records and the greatest hits? I think we renegotiated after the first record. But contractually, we were non-obligated. So at that point in time, that's when we started the whole four-year hiatus, and we had nobody knocking on our door for a record. So what we needed to do was rest and, like I said, gather our wits personally. We all kind of spread out across the U.S. and did our own personal soul searching. No pun intended. We decided to start our own label in the long run.

14:10We talked to some different labels during the time that we were recording the tracks for Youth, and nothing really made sense to us. We knew how the corporate label structure thing worked, and nobody was really offering us, to be blunt, nobody was really offering us enough cash to make it worth our time. So we financed the whole record ourselves and released it on our own label. We have a label called El Music Group, and we have one band signed to it: Collective Soul. Any more signings at all? I mean, that would be ideal, for the label to become strong and for us to be able to produce and do some side projects on the label. Would you be interested in producing? For sure. I was producing some things in my time off, some different projects in Atlanta.

14:59Bands I would have heard about? No, I don't think so. A solo artist named Bain Maddox, you can check him out online. I did some songs with him. But the other rock band I was working with pretty much disbanded, so they're not even on the map anymore. But yeah, I mean, ultimately that would be the deal, but we're not in a rush to do that. We don't want to become the thing we decided to get away from, where, technically, a lot of bands on major labels think that they've got it made when they get signed, and it's really just the beginning. What they find out is when they're signed, everybody's interested in them and everybody's happy about it, but the record comes out and maybe the single doesn't do so well.

15:45The next thing you know, you don't really have any friends at the label, and you can't get anybody to answer your phone call. You know, it might be some of the best work you've ever done in your life, and because of the way the music industry is today, with timing and things of that nature, your record's on the back shelf and you don't really have any friends at the label that you can depend on. So, not that that was gonna happen to us, but, you know, that's a common thing in today's music industry. Artist development has disappeared. There's no such thing. Yeah, definitely completely changed from the '60s. Yeah, '60s, even '70s and early '80s, you know, you had a chance to fail. And if the label believed in you,

16:27you got other chances, second, third chances. Do you think it's gonna be more indie labels in the future, just with the whole... Well, what is working now is kind of going away. Technology is definitely gonna play a role in how the whole industry is gonna go. So it's going to shift, for sure. There's going to be a shift. But for the most part, if you're a young band and you're just starting out, still the only game in town is to go talk to a major, for better or for worse. It's kind of hard. You don't really have the resources, which means money, and the business relationships, aka radio people that will play your songs and people that will put your record on the shelves, that a band like Collective Soul does.

17:21So as much as technology is lending itself to make it easier to release and own your own music, if you want to break out on that larger scale, the major labels are still pretty much the only game in town. But there's a shift going on, and technology is going to play a big part in where the music industry goes in the next ten years. I agree. How do you feel about downloading music? Do you think it's helped you or hurt? I think it's helped Collective Soul. I mean, yeah, there's probably some people who have downloaded our record and didn't buy it. I mean, I can't say that that's necessarily hurt the band. I definitely didn't think that it was fair to have the whole file sharing thing go on forever.

18:11And I know that you can't really stop it totally, but it was a little ridiculous there in the beginning, because, you know, eventually people weren't going to ever buy a record, you know? And it's hard for us to put a lot of money into the production of a record and then give it away for free. Especially when you're financing it yourself. Yes, especially when we're financing it ourselves. But overall, I think of downloading as a friend to all musicians, especially when it comes to downloading some of our live tracks. We put some stuff on the internet that wasn't released. There's a song called "Burn" that we put on our website. You could download it for free. And it was a full mix, a song that was done.

19:04So I mean, I think more than anything else, the whole technology, file sharing thing is positive for music. Cool. Let's play another tune. "Precious Declaration" or "Listen"? Let's see. "Precious Declaration" or "Listen," both off Disciplined Breakdown. That's right. Let's go with "Precious Declaration." Cool. That's the one that probably encapsulates what we were going through at that time more than any other song. Which would be what? Well, we were going through a big lawsuit with our first manager, and "Precious Declaration" is about, you know, the chorus: "Yours is yours, and mine you leave alone." We do this thing on the show called Five Questions. Five quick questions, one-word answers. Favorite album

19:55of all time? Favorite album of all time? Abbey Road. Nice. What's your favorite track? Favorite track? Let's go with the George Harrison tune. Is "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" on there? That's on the White Album. "Here Comes the Sun" is on Abbey Road. "I Want You (She's So Heavy)," how about that? Yeah. Good tune. Cool. Lennon or McCartney? That's a debate that happens on the bus all the time. I have to say Lennon and McCartney. I like them both for totally different reasons. But when it comes down to my vote, I have to say, musically, I say McCartney. He's a bass player too. He's a bass player, and I'm such a Beatles connoisseur, I can kind of

20:45hand-pick the things that Paul did and the things that John did, and they're actually a two-headed monster. And it's one of those arguments for me that you can't really separate, because together they were a force. You separate them and you try to pick who was better, and it's really a no-win argument for me. But I'll just go with Paul and leave it at that. Awesome. Alcohol or marijuana? Alcohol or marijuana? You've got to choose one? Yep. I've got to say marijuana. There you go. Cool. Alcohol is too much of a hangover. Agreed. Song you've written you're most proud of? Something off Dosage, probably, maybe "No More, No Less." Cool. And one word, Collective Soul. One word about Collective Soul?

21:27One word. First thing that comes to your mind when you think of your band. Positive. Cool. "Counting the Days" or "Crazy Train" live at Woodstock? Ooh. "Counting the Days," that's a hard one, though. "Counting the Days," we'll go with that one. It's off the new record. Let's hear it. We've been playing almost two hours right now. So yeah, we're well over 20 songs at this point, but we're gonna play most all of the hits you know, and we're playing at least six tunes off of Youth right now also. Nice. And, you know, we're throwing a lot of energy out there right now. We're really feeling good on stage, and I feel like we're playing on a level we've never really attained before, so it's really exciting for me right now. We've

22:12always tried to keep ticket prices down. Yeah, so check them out. Pick any tune off any record. What do you want to hear? You want the listeners to hear any tune? Well, off our record? Oh, one of ours? Yeah. Okay, so it's got to be a Collective Soul song. Well, let's see. Let's go with "Heavy" off of Dosage. For me, Dosage was a great time in our career, and I really enjoyed the whole record. So here we go. Thanks so much. Yep, thank you.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →