Lennon or McCartney? Alan Doyle’s answer: McCartney. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Great Big Sea said about the songs
“Consequence Free”
The band confirmed the title of "Consequence Free" came from a line in an Austin Powers movie.
“Yeah, that's where the original lyric came from. It's a memory of some line in that movie... That's one of the lines I was like, consequence-free environment, that would be awesome. That's where that came from.”
VIDEOWatch

2 clips · 25:34 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #256 · Great Big SeaDecember 2010 · 00:15:41
Episode #438 · Great Big Sea #3November 2012 · 00:10:45
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00How you doing, man? I'm good, how are you? Awesome. Where are you calling from? St. John's, Newfoundland. Oh really? Yeah, man. Still living out there? Oh yeah. How come... well, let's actually start the interview there. How come you decided to stay there? How come you never felt the need to move to, you know, you guys are a big band, to move to a bigger city for the music business? That's a really good question. We just love it here, you know. This is where our home is, this is where our families are, and our goal from the beginning, like many Newfoundlanders, was to try to find a way to make work for ourselves so we could stay here. And it's funny, in all the traveling and all the places and cool places we've gone, it's never really even occurred to me to live anywhere else. It's the only province I haven't been to, so I'm wondering what compares to it? There's Canada, but St. John's is, you know,
0:50on the east coast and it was really British. And it's only been a Canadian place for 50 or 60 years. Right. It was a British place for a few hundred years before that. So it has more in common with North America, to be honest. Well, even the sound of your band comes from that, I would think. Now, the mold's kind of being broken with the new bands from St. John's like Hey Rosetta!, they're not sounding like you guys at all, for that matter. But what is the scene there? Is it more your sound? Is it more of this new indie rock that's coming out of there? There's always been a mix of both. They're really cool and exciting to us.
1:37Be celebrating that if those diverse bands were all really good, I'd be going like, yeah, go on. I guess we've got heavy metal bands, but they're not any good. My world class amazing. Hey Rosetta! are fantastic. You know, I can see somewhere in our gal. You know, it's just so much cool. Everyone I just mentioned is, you know, so it's an exciting kind. Have you thought about producing any of them? I know you did Russell's record and you did the one,
2:23you've only produced one Great Big Sea record, haven't you? Yeah, we did a couple. Well, we did the first one together and we did our traditional record together. And, you know, a few others. Yes, I have thought about producing them all the time. The time is always the issue, and I mean, some of the bands I could probably help out on. I'm not sure, you know, there's much I could teach Tim from Hey Rosetta!. Right. And they're all on their own, right, so I'd be honored to get a chance to work with any of them, but who knows? Right, well, you've worked with a lot of people. This new disc's got a lot of co-writes on it, Safe Upon the Shore. Yeah, it was great fun, man. What made you bring all these people in, like Joel Plaskett, Randy Bachman, Paul Lamb from a band called Crush that people might remember?
3:11It was just fun, great fun. We had a chance, Russell or whoever, made this little retreat for ourselves in Western Newfoundland for a week. I think, often, China, Bob and Joel Plaskett and Jeremy Fisher in five days, and five or six of them made the record, so. Do you feel like you enjoy writing with people more? Because I assume in the beginning you want to write your own songs, right? You want to be the songwriter. Yeah, I don't know. I've never had that bug.
3:56I'm a collaborator more than anything. I've written a bunch of songs on my own, but I don't know, I get such a kick out of sitting in the room with other people doing it. And I just feel more confident about a song. Not a lot of people share that, but I don't know. Maybe I'm just about... I always wanted someone else in the room. Is that maybe why Sean's singing? I feel like Sean's singing a lot more lead recently. Well, Sean has become a really prolific writer as well. And so he's had a lot of really, really good songs lately. And he's got a couple of solo records out there, and I think one about to come out there. I think when we sat down to do the Safe Upon the Shore record,
4:41I think Sean submitted, kind of offered, 54 songs. Wow. And usually good. And so Sean is a serious weapon. He's a serious gun. There's a couple of covers on there too. It's funny that you do Gallows Pole, the Zeppelin tune, and then you have a song on the record called Over the Hills and Far Away that is not the Zeppelin song. I like Sean's freakishly high voice, and it sounded like the folk song from...
5:35Oh, wow. Right. Is there any lute on this record? I heard you had to learn lute for the Robin Hood film. I do lute on one track. Oh, really? Yeah, of course. Well, I guess if you know the instrument, why wouldn't you throw it in there? Are you thinking about... Not much of a stretch, really. I mean, we play bouzoukis and we play, you know, if you're starting to play weird, a lot becomes pretty common. I guess so. It's still a string instrument at the end of the day. We haven't got two places. But in the court, you're upside down and backwards. Are you thinking about putting out a lute record like Sting? No. No, okay.
6:21No, I'm not that advanced. I can press, although it would be fun. Yeah, I'm sure it would be. So tell me about this Robin Hood experience, because that must have been extremely different for you. And I heard you left straight from the Junos, when we all saw you perform with Hawksley, and then flew right to set. That's exactly what happened. It was just a real journey, man. It was like getting the chance to walk in someone else's shoes for six months almost, you know. Like I did all the stuff that all those guys had, training and learned my lines and, you know, do all that stuff that friends of mine do all the time, you know. But it was just such a cool opportunity to do something with the best people in the world at it.
7:07You lit Wayne Gretzky. Yeah. It was amazing. Is it something you'd want to do again? Oh, definitely. You know, I really would. I'd love to be a part of, especially something that big. My God, it was like, you can't imagine the... comes together to make a single frame of that. Like every day, it was amazing to watch. Either one of the other actors, or to watch the stunt guys. How does the collaborative process differ from making a record with a band and a producer, and I guess the studio execs that have a say at the end of the day and everything like that? Well, how do you mean, how is it different for you? Yeah, well, how does it compare? The process of making a record to making a film.
7:53I know they're very different, but I feel like they're still collaborative efforts at the end of the day. Yeah, and there's somebody or a group of people's passion to tell a story, you know, and then to do their own bit of art. And I said, like, the good, a couple of dozen things formed and it needs to be, well, whatever. You know, I think there's a couple of dozen things that need to happen. Right. I think for a movie, it becomes, or 2,400, you know, it's just,
8:38I mean, it's got to be the most single discipline going on there, right? Uniting all the performance. Must be interesting to play a theater for you guys, because I, I don't know, I saw you at Nathan Phillips Square in Toronto a couple of years ago, outside, and it was a big party. There was people dancing, and you don't really get that in a theater, but I guess these new records are a little more mellow. So maybe it does work for you guys. Well, we've always done theaters, you know, like even since our first little step outside the pubs of Newfoundland, we were to play the
9:24theaters of Atlantic Canada, ones that were poignant enough to, you know, and that's one of the joys of being in a pub band, we can do a pub or a posh theater in the city. And not many bands get to do that. No, fair enough. And you guys are big enough that you're going to sell out these theaters. And like you said, songs like, I don't know, Clearest Indication would do marvels in a theater, right? The great thing to do is, I could tell there was a quieter, a couple or two off-mic.
10:19Yeah, I was going to say that would be cool. Donkey Riding would be cool, just off-mic and just with the little, what is that little drum that you guys have? What's that called? Bodhrán. Bodhrán. Speaking of the live show, do you still remember the words to End of the World? Can you still remember every single word? I'm not sure I ever knew it. Fair enough. I'm not sure I ever knew it. It's not an easy song. I just said a bunch of stuff in some protest kind of way and it felt appropriate. Sounds good. There's something people did not know. That's awesome. I'd love to get some Storytellers bits from you, if you don't mind, just, you know, some quick words on a few songs. And let's start with Clearest Indication, because we just mentioned that one. I wrote it, myself and Sean, and it was primarily a
11:08a game time, it was kind of a... How did the referendum line come into play in that song? Well, we just got jamming about different points, to grow up in a place like Newfoundland, the political uncertainty is kind of lived here. Oh.
11:53It's the '49 thing, which was, oh, Brandon. Yeah, I did. I guess not. And we weren't. Look at that. I went through this, that works as well. Yeah. No, it was about it in 1999. Ordinary Day. It's got a very Who-sounding, even the harmonies sound like The Who. Oh, thank you. Ordinary Day, myself and Sean wrote in that, signed, maybe this 1995, but I have to be got signed and won her in, started writing this song that I wanted to capture the kind of essence of the song.
12:48And I can be a better word for everything. And the new one, Nothing but a Song. Nothing but a Song is a song that Sean and I wrote about a, and we didn't have to play that. Of course. So, but somewhere between Toronto and, I don't remember what it was, but I know that I was right.
13:39Of course. Apologetic. Anything for that? What's next for you? I mean, you said Sean's got a solo disc. What about you? You have a solo disc in the works? I do.
14:34And can we expect a new Russell Crowe disc as well that you worked on? Russell and I are working on, had been working on, a movie that has a lot of music in it. Oh, okay. It's been in development. Right. Fair enough. In those meetings. Before I let you go... I know a guy. Right. Exactly. Before I let you go, we do something on the show called Five Questions. Five quick questions, one-word answers. Do it. Road or studio? Road. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon or McCartney.
15:19Yeah. Lennon or McCartney. Which one? Lennon or McCartney. No, man. Choose one. Come on. No, I can't do it. All right. All right. I'm going to throw this one in as a bonus question, because I think a lot of people want to know. What's your favorite beer? Yes. All right. And in one word, Great Big Sea. Danny.
0:06Nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh, nuh. Sir, Great Big Sea XX. XX? Oh, yes. XX, but XX seems a better ring. Close. Yeah, like it sounds... Right. GBS XX. I mean, yeah. Get this one custom. When we're 30 years old, you're not gonna want to buy the TRBLEX one. That's trying to be... You're gonna want to pass on that one right now. There's so much stuff in here. I thought maybe we could hold some of it up. This is some of the stuff that's in the larger box set.
0:51So we have a calendar, a book. I've only said 100 pages, I think. Yes, it's a full issue of classes. When we put it together, the idea was that we would give fans a big box of, you know, a big sort of Christmas box full of Great Big Sea stuff. And we had a ton of music, we had DVD, we knew we wanted to do the book, the calendar, which is essentially a timeline of Great Big Sea history.
1:37Plus the stuff that fans love to keep for themselves, you know, the backstage passes and the stickers and the lures. You know, we had boxes and boxes and boxes of that stuff. And we wanted people to see it. And how much of this came from the book and research for the book? Well, we started with the book. We started looking for photographs, you know, and everyone had stuff. Most of us were doing, you know, just sort of snapshots and things people had given to us. When everyone pulled it, and then we started asking around, you know, guys who've been in the crew or whatever, stuff just came out of the woodwork. To the point where, by the end of it, we had too much, we had to start leaving stuff out. And what about the songs, curation of these songs? There's three discs. You got folk songs on one, pop songs on another, and then Roblades is a bunch of... It's a missus. It's a missus. And a French song. Yeah, the Roblades disc is really a collection of two groups of music, one of which is popular
2:22Great Big Sea songs that you may have known from the finished versions on records or live or whatever. On the Roblades, you might hear, for example, the original demo of Ordinary Day. Or a song recorded around the coffee table, the day we wrote the song, or a live version of it from some radio show or something like that. There's that kind of thing. There's also a group of music on there that are songs that we worked really hard on. We even produced them to the last moment, but they didn't make it to Great Big Sea records. And in almost every case, thank God they didn't make it to Great Big Sea records, because they're, in some cases, awful. There was a lot of music that people kind of heard about, you know, didn't they? The song, I've never heard anyone play that live, whatever.
3:08So there's also a chance to kind of put some of that out there and say, no, here it is. There's no secrets anymore. Is that what the new songs are, too? Each of those songs kind of speaks to an era of the band. You know, the bottom of the door, but he speaks to the early kind of pop cover era of the band when we were just trying to fill three hours a night, you know, and play everything. Three hours a night? Well, we started playing the bubble of St. Joseph's, doing three-hour-long sets. So we would, you know, play everything we could think of. And Run Runaway, for example, which was our first single, came out of that era, and that kind of, you know, Run Runaway, great, I'll play it, too. You know, there was a lot of that. One of the things that I've always tried to keep my ear open for is that, for some reason, we have this thing where we have, you know, odd instruments compared to most bands, you know, like we have, it's not played so many
3:55of them. And this is live in our world, you know. Like Hawksley, Hawksley was jumping in at the Great Big Sea studio in Newfoundland and said, this is the only studio I've ever been in where someone says, pass the bouzouki, and someone says, which one? So whenever I hear a pop song, you know, that has something in it that I think would work really well on one of our wacky instruments, I sort of make a mental note of it. Like, for example, Run Runaway, I always thought that, you know, that riff, duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh duh, it sounds like the tin whistle to me, it always has, but it was played on electric guitar, you know. And even with the Townshend song, I always said that, you know, sounds like a horn thing,
4:44play the keyboard on his record, but it always reminds me of Bob's accordion, because of the way Bob plays, like I'm Going Off, for example, you know, that kind of horn section accordion, I call it. It's where Bob plays a horn riff on the button accordion, you know. So it's like, you know, that one, I always love that song. You know, it's sort of one of the things, my role, as I was like, hey, I got a numbers on course they do, but see, that's one, not often, it doesn't work, right? It's interesting the R.E.M. cover's not on this record. And the rules on those songs too, that we played so much when it was popular, that it definitely wore out its welcome for us and from that, the audience, and then we just forgot about it, you know. I was like, okay, we're gonna play this again, this sucks. More so than a cover, it's something that was in the set list and it just never came back to the top again. One thing we're able to do as we
5:31tour this record over the next year is really dig into that catalog and, you know, bring back some of those unloved children and put them out on the front of the stage again. Yeah, we're doing a two-set show, so it gives us a bit more time to do a few songs that we haven't done at all. But we're going through some of the songs that are on here that are obviously some of our favorites from different times, and fan favorites, but we haven't played in a long time. Like a song like Goin' Up, for example. I don't think we played that song regularly, or at all, in a decade, for whatever reason, you know, just because, well, it's an accordion one that's in G, you know, I have this other one or two others, and that slot in the set list was occupied by another thing for a while. But I said, let's play Goin' Up, and what a act. And some of those songs that are
6:17on the earlier records, there's a lot of people that have come to see us for a long time, they probably never heard us play those songs, even though we played them thousands of times, you know, early on, because we only had one record to play, all twelve of them. I mean, it's over a career. Like Aaron said, we didn't really become popular in America until the early 2000s, and why, which was a huge era of the band for Canadian fans, you know, the early records never made any impression out there at all. So, you know, the bulk of our career in America was records like Sea of No Cares and Something Beautiful, and that forces, favors, that material dominates shows down there. There's no Newfoundland shows on this tour? Well, there's a few. There's a few things, like these two legs that we've announced already, these are the first ones, but then sneakily there's a whole bunch of summer stuff that we're
7:04not releasing yet, which will include Toronto, which is not on the list. Convex cities not on the list. I don't think St. John's is. Nothing in Europe. There's a ton of America that's out there, just because there's other four legs of the tour to be done, so. Wow. You know, we're doing a little well into 2014. What I love about a box set, and interviewing you about the box, is I get to ask you about songs that I wouldn't usually be able to ask about, because we're always promoting a new record. Yeah. So I thought there were some cool stories, like Consequence Free is Austin Powers-inspired. Yeah, that's where the original lyric came from. It's a memory of some line in that movie where he says, as long as people are still having unprotected sex in a consequence-free environment, movie fun. So he's where you look as he's come, comes on frozen or something.
7:49I can't remember what that's... That's one of the lines I was like, consequence-free environment, that would be awesome. That's where that came from. A lot of songs that me and Sean wrote over the years were kind of like songs that Sean had, that was like, you have to go at this for a while, and we played it back and forth, or vice versa, whatever. But that's honestly one of the ones that we literally sat next to each other and laughed and kept passing lyrics. You brought one of them up to the band, it's not one of your own songs. You know, it's funny the way that one came to me. A friend in England, who, you know, made tapes, like people did then, you know, pre-internet era, and he saved this tape, and you know, it's fire to car, and he had very clunky taste,
8:35so the every hundred song very little, which I would like to put now to get into the gym and put it in the first line, you know, and the fiddle riff. And nobody had heard of the Oysterband, they didn't tour at that stage, and they hadn't any releases, you know. So it wasn't like, okay, we're doing a well-known song here, you know. It just felt like it had been written for us, you know, kind of, really philosophically and musically, and the way John Jones sang it was perfect for you. Like, literally, I was like, yeah, I remember you bringing it on a tape for that, the play record, right? It's really clear. And Bob laid down, put it, except ours, we had to record this song. We listened to them, yeah, we had to
9:22record that song. Who's this band, the Oysterband? And John Jones, half grandmother, and they're listed on one of the early, like as a thanks, on the Spirit of the West record or something. That's all I ever heard about them. Go look, I encourage you to go look into the Oysterband and have a look. We could have done one of the same, in songs, and, you know, it just occurred to me, the most underrated songwriters in British history, I think. They're fantastic. We could go through all 60 or whatever these days. So, five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay. Road or studio? Oh, road. Road. Lennon or McCartney? George. That's good. First, when you hear a song, usually what hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Is there a song you've written you're most proud of, or do you day to
10:11recruit your surgeon? And in one word, Great Big Sea. Awesome. [laughter] That's awesome. Thank you so much, guys. Really appreciate it. And deadly, is that what you are?
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.