SONGSWhat Matt Nathanson said about the songs
“Laid”
Matt Nathanson explained how his cover of the James song for the American Wedding soundtrack came about.
“The president of Universal saw a show, heard me do some stuff. He's like, you know what song would be great for you to do? I'd like you to take a crack at this Laid song... And so we did it in a day just for fun”
VIDEOWatch
15:09 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #10 · Matt NathansonNovember 2003 · 00:34:30
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Tonight's Backstage Pass exclusive feature is on singer-songwriter Matt Nathanson. Started making records about 10 years ago,
2:50when I was in college, because I had amassed these songs that I'd written, and I had a buddy that had a studio. And he was like, oh, you know, let's make a record, and I was like, let's do it, you know. But I've been a musician for, I guess I've been playing guitar since I was in sixth grade, and I've had bands since then, you know. But we used to do like U2 covers and Police covers, and so I started writing songs that I liked around high school, you know. I started playing acoustic guitar right around like 14, 15. I thought I don't need an electric guitar, you know, I used to want to be in Poison, you know, if I even rocked it. But so I started to realize that the acoustic guitar might be more suited to my stuff. And since then I've been writing songs, and kind of writing really bad ones at that time,
3:35you know. And then as I got to college I started to kind of amass ones that I was like, oh, these are cool, like this one's okay, this one's okay, and then kind of put out a record from it. There's two phases of songwriting. There's the creative vomit phase, you know, where whatever's in you comes out, and then there's the refinement period, which is where you sift through it and you're like, this is terrible, this is terrible, and this is good. Okay, cool, I got it. And usually that process happens for a while with both lyrics and melodies and guitar parts, and then I'll sit down and kind of try and put those two together. So they kind of come separate and they cook on their own, and then I see which ones feel like they fit together, and in the process of trying to fit them together, other parts come and things kind of grow and,
4:21you know, the song kind of starts to take shape. Multiple songs kind of take shape all at once, because you'll be like, oh, this verse doesn't work, but boy, it goes under this chord progression better than it did that one, you know, and then all of a sudden you're kind of juggling like three songs. It's a cool way to write, because you feel like it's always on the stove, you know, you've got three fucking pans going on. 88.3 CJIQ, we're continuing on with our feature with Matt Nathanson. Right there, Answering Machine; before that you heard Wings.
8:28World famous record producer Ron Aniello produced Matt's debut album for Universal Records. Every record that Ron made, whether I liked the record or not, had every aspect of what I thought a record should have. All the engineers that he used, all the studios that he recorded in, all the band members that he used, and he used different people on every record, you know, but they were always people that I'd go, God, I love that player. God, I love that drummer. It would be Matt who would play on one record, or Jim Keltner would play on one record, or whoever was the bass player on whatever record that he did, it would always be like, that's the guy. And no matter if I liked the songs, I got kind of a vibe over all of his records about what he was trying to make happen. And so for me it was kind of this thing of like, if I get along with this guy,
9:17I feel like we're going to be in good shape. And I went to his house for a couple days and just hung out, and it was great. Totally cool. He was actually sort of the bomb. He's kind of a spacey cat, you know, he's just sort of creative, spacey. He's an amazing guitar player, like unbelievably good. And he has a really good vision of what the end result is, but everything getting to that place for him is a feel-based situation, and anybody that works from feel only is seemingly disorganized, you know, because they'll be kind of orchestrating this thing and you're like, what are you doing? Where is this going? And for me it took a while, because that was the hardest part. I felt like I trusted him, but for me to let go of the reins of production and to not be so obsessive about the way the record was supposed to sound, I
10:07felt like there were moments where I'd call my wife and I'd be like, I think this is going completely out of control, you know. But then he would just always reel it back in. He always had the end result in his, that's his gift, is that, you know, he doesn't get bogged down by the details. He kind of does it by feel, and then you end up at the spot where you're like, yeah, you totally had it, that's amazing. I thought there were moments where I was like, the song's a wash, you know, and then he'd just pull it together. It was great. So he was a really good person to steer the ship and keep everybody on course and keep everybody corralled into the right ideas. It was nice. The good news about this time: since I'd made all those records before, I would have to guide the musicians that played. I'd be like, you know,
10:55I was thinking more like this kind of feel, or I was thinking more this. But when I got to do this record, I got to have people that I've always wanted to play with, because they were the people that made records that influenced the way I write and the way that I do things. So to have V play guitar, to have Glen sing backup, Glen Phillips from Toad, to have Matt play drums, to have Jamie play keys, it was one of these things where I didn't have to guide them anymore. Instead I got to just let them spend their energy, instead of trying to figure out where I wanted them to go. Because I trusted how they did their thing, I got to just let them do their thing, and so their energy was spent creatively, as opposed to trying to be like, oh, is this what you mean? You know, with Matt Chamberlain, anything he played, there's probably a 95% success rate for me. You know, he'd do something and I'd be like, you're the man.
11:41All right, here we go, you know. Or David would do this thing, and maybe occasionally I'd be like, that's not the tone I was thinking, but pretty much not at all, you know. It was just like, oh, you're the man, you're the reason I'm here, and you can do whatever you want to do. Because everything felt like they treated the songs, they were really attentive to what the songs wanted, and I felt really safe with them going in whatever direction they felt like they needed to go in. And so it was a pleasure to make it, you know, it was a pleasure. With Matt and the band deciding mainly how the music was going to go, I wondered how the label affected any of the music. No, they had no involvement in the record. That was why I signed the deal with them, because the A&R person that I was dealing with, I felt like she and I see eye to eye creatively. I knew that they wouldn't get involved. It was really a hands-off creative thing, and I got to pick Ron. I got to pick the studio.
12:31I got to pick the engineer. I got to pick the band. I got to pick the songs. It was just because I'd been making records for so long that I really wasn't into the idea of having someone come in and try and tell me how my career could be better, you know what I mean? I mean, I'm into people being like, you know what you could try to do? Try to do this. But I'm not into people being like, this is the producer for you, because music is my life and I know every producer and I know every engineer, because that's my obsession, you know. I listen to records and I can name who engineered your favorite record, you know what I mean? Because I just love it so much. And so it was the kind of thing where anything they would recommend, I'd be like, no, I didn't like those three records that person did. I kind of have an idea actually, so just don't worry about it. And it kind of worked out well. They gave ideas and they kind of lobbed them my way,
13:16but I would be like, mmm, not right now. No, let's do this, you know, because I kind of had a vision of how I wanted it to go, and so it worked out really well. It's not like I'm arrogant about it, but it's just sort of like, I know what kind of record I've always wanted to make, and so I've kind of been dreaming of the day when I'd have the opportunity to get the players or get the studio or get the engineers. So I wasn't really down with anybody else kind of ruining my day, you know what I mean, being like, no, you should use this producer, you know, he's hot. And she wasn't that kind of an A&R person at all. She had no bullshit. A lot of people, whoever's hot at that time, they'll be like, oh, that person should produce your record. That just wasn't the way she worked, and that's kind of why I did the deal with her, because she was great. Mass and tea construction people the best of intentions he tried to patch up every hole as he went
14:13back and forth and back again and his friends have full of half concerns And their looks and tired words they brought me friends the ignorant little lives They preferred any envy their distance their lack of concern Once I shed the hole Once I shed the hole I'll be smiling cursed himself And as instinct to nurse every idea to health and all of the falls that he'd spent
15:05Trying to coax his name from the mouths of success Once I shed the hole Once I shed the hole And I'll be smiling litter me with small awareness And they ask if I'm good enough litter me with small Just to wake me up Why do the fool? Once I shed the hole
15:53Once I shed the hole I'll be smiling litter me with small awareness Just to wake me up Litter me with small awareness Just to wake me up Litter me with small awareness And they have the gall To ask if I'm good enough Litter me with small awareness Just to wake me up Why do the fool? So far the only thing is that being on a major has been a lot easier to get access to things that I've always wanted to do
16:53Whether it was the band stuff that we talked about before, or going to these radio stations and playing, but good radio, like non-commercial great stations that play amazing stuff. For me to be able to do that on my own, it was really hard to corral all that stuff. And to be on a label and to be able to kind of give them a guide: look, I want to go to these non-commercials, I want to play, I want to get in there, I want to do this thing. You know, hey, I want to be able to get records into stores. Hey, I want to be able to do this, I want to be able to play on this thing. Or let's go, when we're in LA I want to play on Napster, I want to do that. That's the kind of thing, so far it's been kind of access all areas. I kind of say, let's get this happening, and I bring it up to them and they kind of pull it together. So so far it's been a fairly pain-free situation, you know. And it's funny, because we're just kind of doing our thing.
17:40The real test is when things start to happen a lot. Like, they're going really well now and everybody's psyched, but if it starts to happen, the real challenge, I think, of being on a label and trying to remain in control a little bit, is that when things start happening, that's when they get excited, and that's when they start pushing to do things that you might not want to do. And so you've got to kind of stay firm, you've got to pick your battles in those situations. And that's the kind of thing that I think I'm just going to learn how to do. If things start going well, that's when they'll get involved. It's kind of like anything, you know, like your business is doing great and they're kind of helping, and then all of a sudden it blows up and things start going crazy, and then they're like, all right, let's go now. Because they're really good at selling millions of records. They're not so good at selling a hundred thousand records. So once things start moving, I'm sure they're going to get more involved.
18:27And then there'll be more opinions that I'll have to sort of weigh and be like, okay, I'm not really down with that, or that I can live with, you know, that kind of stuff. I think it's going to be a long time. I think this record is going to be out a long time. It's going to be a growing situation, you know. But I think I want Suspended to be the first single. Suspended, and then maybe I Saw, and then Sad Songs. But I don't know if we'll even get that far. But I feel like Suspended is a song that impacts me more, and I kind of think it's better. I like Sad Songs a lot, but I feel like Suspended's got something that I dig more. The longer I've had it, I've been like, Suspended, I like it, you know. And I like Sad Songs a lot, but Suspended I feel like has something.
19:12So I think we're going to go with that. Matt's been on the road for about two years now solo with a cellist named Matt Fish, but he is looking at getting a full band. It's a lot easier to do it, and we've been doing it this way for a long time. So I think we're going to ramp up and get a drummer for the next round of shows, and then when we tour again we'll bring a band. So it's the kind of thing where Matt and I get along really well and I feel like we accomplish a lot, and I feel like it's better to build. For me also, I was touring without a label and anything like that, so it's a lot less expensive to do it this way as well. And now that the label is involved, I still feel like as a trajectory it's a lot better to kind of slowly add pieces. And the next time you come to Boston or the next time you go to Vancouver, the next time you go, it's like, oh, they have something, oh, there's a drummer now. You know, and then, oh cool, there's a bass player and a drummer and guitar, you know, and then all of a sudden,
19:58you know, so slowly building the beast. Coming up to come around and cover every Lying on my bass my moves now
23:50They've been really, it's pretty much keeping them at bay, because their attention span is a major label's. It's difficult to sustain that kind of momentum, do you know what I mean? And so we're just trying to bring it along ourselves, and these little victories along the way where people are like, oh my god, great, great, great. Oh, great. And the SoundScan's going up and everybody's excited. And then you build this thing and then they run with it. You know, it's like you're lighting the torch and you're kind of walking it up, and then at some point they're going to come grab it and go. But it's got to be at the right time, because if it isn't, the torch might go out, and then you've lost their focus and you've lost there. Because just by nature, the major label system doesn't have the grassroots thing going on.
24:37So we've just been building it before they got involved, and now we're building it with their help, but still utilizing very few of their resources, you know. And at some point we'll engage them and go for the much wider net, you know, cast a wider net. Matt was asked to appear on the American Wedding soundtrack this past summer, recording a cover of the James song Laid. Where did that idea exactly come from? The president of Universal saw a show, heard me do some stuff. He's like, you know what song would be great for you to do? I'd like you to take a crack at this Laid song. And I was like, Laid? James? How can you redo that song? It's perfect. And so we did it in a day just for fun, and we didn't really expand on it, because you can't, it's a perfect song, you know. So we just did it and it ended up they liked it.
25:22And it was like, all right, I'm down, fantastic, that was it. That was an easy, cool thing, you know. That was pretty flattering actually, it was neat. And it was neat to go into the theater and hear it. That was one of those moments where any jaded parts of yourself go away, and you're just kind of like, this is great, I'm listening to myself in the theater. This is one of those moments, if it all ends tomorrow, I can tell my grandkids that I was in the theater and I heard my own voice. So that was pretty cool. I stood up and I yelled, that's me! Hey everybody, that's me! Now I'm like, hey, pay attention. I slapped this kid talking. Stop it, God damn it, you have no respect. That was totally cool. Passionate love, the noise is above
26:12She's on song, she's sad. 88.3 CJIQ, the Backstage Pass.
28:45This is our feature on Matt Nathanson. Right there, Laid off the American Wedding soundtrack. Before that you heard Sad Songs, and before that, I'll Be Smiling. Matt's got a bit of a problem with Good Charlotte. I think they seem like really nice people, but I wish that they wouldn't keep calling themselves punk. I wish that they wouldn't say that. Bands that are punk are like, X was punk, you know? Bands like that. And so to have a band sort of talk about it on MTV, and they're very, they seem very nice, those guys. Like, if they were hanging out here we'd have a great time. But they're just a pop band, you know what I mean? They're a pop band. They write pop music. How about P. Diddy? The best skin I've ever seen on anybody in my life. We took an elevator ride in New York,
29:31and he was friends with someone that I was in the elevator with. So they were having a conversation and I was just kind of watching. And an incredible gentleman. He's in control. The world revolves around him. And it's pretty impressive. It's not at all something that you'd be like, gross. It's more like, fuck, dude, that's impressive. And he had the nicest skin I've ever seen in my life. Like, it looked like they just shined him. I'm down with it. Yeah, I'm into it. I wouldn't have a crew if I didn't, you know. I wouldn't have a following if it wasn't for downloading and tape trading. I think it's the best. Funny, I don't download, because I'm never around. I might have dial-up on my computer, you know. And I like to, but I like records. I like to buy CDs and read liner notes and geek out. But yeah, I'm totally down with it.
30:18I just hope that people don't lose the album concept, because it's really essential. When albums are sequenced in a way that's important, when they're from beginning to end, when they have a real strong thing, there's nothing better than a journey. And I feel like downloading quite possibly, though there are great benefits to it, because I have an iPod, and when I just put it on random, it's like a dream come true, you know. But I also feel like you lose the weight of, like, if Achtung Baby was taken out of sequence, what would you have? That record is fucking perfection, you know. What would you do if Lou Reed's New York was out of sequence? There's a roll to most records. Whereas some records don't really have a roll. They have the first four songs that are good and the rest is crap. Which is fine, and like for Cyndi Lauper's greatest hits,
31:05it's good, you know, download and just have songs. But I just don't want people to lose the art of the record, because I think that's part of the fun of listening to music, is sort of taking a journey from song one to song twelve or whatever. Matt Nathanson right there with Suspended, only on the Backstage Pass.
34:24On 88.3 CJIQ. That's all for this week. We'll see you next week with Simple Plan.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.