Lennon or McCartney? Rob Thomas’ answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
VIDEOWatch
13:16 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Hey, Matt, what's up? Not much, man, how are you? Yeah, I literally just walked in. I'm walking into my house. Oh yes? Yeah, I'm going to be home for the next few days. [inaudible] Oh, that's nice. That's a change, right? I just got off the bus and got a chance to run around the house for the first time. They're freaking out.
0:24It's funny, I was going to bring up the dogs, because I saw you tweet some pictures of bringing the dog on the road. That must be different. Yeah, the only downside is that, like, last night we were in Windsor, Canada, and it was freezing cold, wind blowing, and I've been walking around, because I don't like other people walking them before the show. [inaudible] walking my dogs in the freezing cold. But there's nothing cooler in the world, man, than finishing the show and running off the stage and getting on the bus, and you open the door and they're just standing there smiling at you. It's pretty great.
1:05Do they sing? My dogs? Well, it's funny, one of them does. Whenever I start doing vocal warm-ups, she literally tries to do them with me. That's amazing. You should YouTube that stuff. I feel like there's money in that somehow. Although I'm not sure if she's singing because she likes it, or she wants me to shut up. [inaudible] I don't want to show up in some ASPCA commercial. I was like, yeah, don't do this to your dog. Rob Thomas's voice tortures dogs. That's hilarious. Yes, exactly. I've been torturing people for years. Why not my dog?
1:53Talking about torturing people live, what's a setlist like? With that many hits and the new record, obviously you want to play the new tunes. How do you guys choose a setlist every night? Well, nobody that I know likes to go to a band and all they're doing is playing all their new stuff, you know? So I think we found a good balance with all the singles, and then basically we divide it up. The singles are about half the set. If you play a corporate show, you play like an hour, and that's just all the singles. Then you have this whole other hour, because we've got about a two-hour set, so the other hour's mixed up between four or five of the new songs and album tracks from the past that we like.
2:42And then every day we're kind of learning some more. Like, we realized that we haven't played the song "Rest Stop" in a long time, and we haven't played it because there's only so many slow moments you want in your set. You don't want it to be all ballads. And then you have certain ones that we want to play every night, so we're not going to replace those. But now we realize there's a song on the new record called "The Way" that Kyle sings, and we could do that one night, but then we could do "Rest Stop" one night, or "Hang" one night, in that place. So now we're kind of going back in. But it's a sign of the times, because we're relearning our own music. We're on stage and we can't remember what tempo we played something at or what guitar tone we used. So we're standing on stage and Paul's pulling up on his phone a YouTube of us playing it live, so that we can watch it and relearn how to play our own song. That's crazy.
3:30What about having Stacy in the band now? How has that changed the dynamic? I mean, he's an amazing drummer. He's an amazing drummer, and I think he's my favourite drummer to play with since we had Paul playing drums. He's so dynamic, he's a showman, he hits really hard and he's very consistent. It's really changed up our game. I think that between having Stacy, and also us getting older and doing this for 17 years and getting better at it every year, I don't think we've ever sounded as good as we sound right now. [inaudible]
4:11You said something in there I want to touch on, but I kind of want to hold off on that for a second. I just wanted to talk about the change in the drummers, and Paul moving to guitar, and actually coming back to drumming on this record, because I know he didn't drum on the Exile record. So how did that happen? [inaudible] So he still has the desire to play? Right, right. I always found it interesting that he smokes while playing drums. I've tried that, and I always end up getting burned. I cannot pull that off. But he quit smoking a long time ago, actually. Oh, that's good. But I can picture him lighting the cigarette while he's playing. That's great. That's so rock and roll, it's amazing. But also bad for your health.
5:04But how has your approach to songwriting changed? You've obviously written with a lot of people over the years. The band is writing together a lot more. How have you evolved as a songwriter when it comes to, I guess, the confidence of putting your ideas down on paper? You know, I don't know that the process changes much. [inaudible] Once you kind of get that inspiration and you suck everything you can out of the muse, then you go to craft. It's probably the craft that kind of changes and evolves, but not the way that you do it. The only thing that changed is, when I did my first solo record, and even more on the second solo record, I had built a studio in my home. So having the ability to go downstairs and record really proper demos all by myself, not having to have an engineer there, so that I've got that same kind of solitude that I had when I'm writing, but with the ability to sit down and put down some drums and bass and keyboards and kind of build a real track, so that when I go to Matt, I could give him an idea of what I wanted it to sound like. That helped a lot.
6:14Do songs typically start on a piano or guitar for you? When you think you have an idea, where do you sit down? They usually start in my head, and I have to kind of flesh out a little bit of it in my head. And then it really depends. I'm a much better piano player than guitar player. So if it's a three-chord kind of moment, I'll go to the guitar and kind of flesh it out. [inaudible] just because I have limitations. That's a good reason. And what about when you bring it to the band? How did that change? Well, now a lot changes, because I might have an idea and I might just start with a drum beat, and then I like the way that beat sounds, and I'll start building a chord progression over that beat, and then I'll start writing the melody to the track that I'm kind of building. So that adds kind of a new life. And you wouldn't have done that before? No, because I didn't have the technology. [inaudible] I had to go through the whole process of kind of learning how to run Pro Tools and how to record.
7:15Talking about technology, on the other aspect of it, when you put out that first record there was still that mystique to rock and roll. You couldn't connect with the band if you wanted to. But now you're on Twitter all the time. So how have you... I don't really know where my question's going, but are you happy with the way things have gone, that you don't need to be connected but you choose to be so connected with the fan base? As opposed to, you know, Zeppelin would not have been able to be Zeppelin had they been connected. I mean, it's ubiquitous now. It's not an issue anymore of happy or not happy, or accepting or not accepting. This is kind of what it is. And if you're 17 years old now, you don't know any other way other than having this kind of access to music and this kind of access to artists, and you feel like if you don't have it, then that person's not really playing along with the game, you know what I mean? And that said, there's something really, really great. Like, if I were 17 or 20 years old now... I'm a big Paul Simon fan, and if Paul Simon [inaudible], I would shriek. So I get it.
8:30I think that everybody kind of focuses on the state of the music business, but the state of music is actually kind of great. The relationship you can have with music, the accessibility of how you can get the music that you love, the way that you can find all these new bands that maybe wouldn't have existed if you were just kind of relying on the old format. [inaudible] Now it's this whole free world out there, where all these bands can have really great success. I don't know that a Mumford & Sons, six or seven years ago, would have sold 600,000 copies in that first week. But thanks to the internet, they can build a real fan base and get this rabid group of people that can find them.
9:11When you're looking, where do you find your music? Where do you listen to stuff? Everywhere, you know. I'll check out new bands, and check out, like, Jools Holland, because Jools Holland always has two or three. [inaudible] But sometimes I'll spend the afternoon on iTunes, going, if you like this, you'll like this, and just kind of, well, let me hear that, let me check that out. I just find it interesting, because everyone nowadays finds music in different ways. Everyone has their own website or their own niche place to find tunes, and I find that so interesting. There's a website called We Are Hunted, and it just has kind of new bands in every genre. I've spent a lot of time on there, checking out new stuff to see if there's something I really want to get into.
10:20And would you maybe find something you dig and then maybe want to write with these people? Is that something that's ever crossed your mind, like, hey, I should write a tune with these kids? It's funny, because I'll hear a song for the first time, and I'll go online and say, you know what, I really like this song, and this is my song of the day or something. And then somebody from that band will tweet me back and be like, "Oh my God, that's so nice, thank you so much." And you end up with this kind of Twitter friendship with these bands that you've never really met. But you have a shared experience, so it's kind of easy to fall into a feeling like you guys have a lot in common.
11:05We don't have too much time here, and I do want to talk about acting a little bit, because I watched the Smooth series on Funny or Die this morning. It's hilarious. Where did that come from? [inaudible] I was in LA and my manager called them up and said, hey, I want to come talk to you about doing something, and we sat in the office and kind of fleshed that out with one of the writers. There were a bunch of ideas. I wasn't sure at first that the band was going to be into it, but all the parts that made it funny, the reasons why it was funny, they saw that too.
11:47Is it like an in-joke within the band, or was that just something one of the writers came up with? Oh yeah, I mean, everything in the band is. Like, "Oh yeah, we never played that." "Oh wow, that must have been your solo record." Or inevitably, at least once every couple of weeks, somebody at a meet and greet will come up to, like, Kyle and tell him how much they love "Smooth." And he's like, "Great, I don't have anything to do with that, that's Rob, but thank you." I like it too. Do you play that live? Does that come out in the setlist? No, that comes out when I do solo tours.
12:30Okay. Before I let you go, we do something called Five Questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. Road or studio? Road. Lennon or McCartney? [inaudible] When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. Song you've written you're most proud of? "You Won't Be Mine." And in one word, Matchbox 20? Delightful. Delightful, is that what you just said? Yeah. That's great. Thank you so much, man.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.