Lennon or McCartney? Chris Walla & Jason McGerr answered: McCartney, Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Death Cab For Cutie said about the songs
“I Will Follow You into the Dark”
Producer and guitarist Chris Walla explained that the recorded version is a one-microphone take Ben Gibbard played while waiting out a technical problem.
Chris Walla: “it's one microphone. That's it... It's just Ben performing to one microphone in a room. And it was a total fluke actually that we got that performance... he picked up a guitar and was just playing around in the room, and he started playing that song... I just poked my head out and said, hey, let's just track that real quick”
“You Are a Tourist”
The band explained that a recording of shortwave radio static sits inside the song as a harmonic bed.
Death Cab for Cutie: “if you just record dead air, you end up with this big, long chunk of pitch. So I grabbed that, and that lives inside of You Are a Tourist as sort of one of the harmonic beds.”
“Brothers on a Hotel Bed”
Chris Walla said the song grew out of one of several instrumental tracks he gave Ben Gibbard to write around.
Chris Walla: “the song Brothers on a Hotel Bed came out of, I gave Ben three or maybe it was four, I think it was four, instrumental tracks for him to write around, and the only one that he really gravitated toward was the song that became Brothers on a Hotel Bed.”
“Underneath the Sycamore”
Chris Walla wrote the music in about an hour, and Ben Gibbard had lyrics by the next morning.
Chris Walla: “I wrote the instrumental thing that Ben ended up writing the lyrics and melody around in like an hour in my basement. And it was an hour where I was supposed to be doing something else. I was procrastinating... And I think the next morning, Ben had written the lyrics.”
“St. Peter's Cathedral”
The band said this song is much older than the rest of Codes and Keys and that the lead vocal is completely dry.
Death Cab for Cutie: “St. Peter's Cathedral was written in 2002. Everything else was written between 2008 and halfway through 2010... the lead vocal on St. Peter's Cathedral is completely dry.”
VIDEOWatch

2 clips · 48:26 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #122 · Death Cab For CutieFebruary 2008 · 00:35:16
Episode #301 · Death Cab For Cutie #2April 2011 · 00:16:35
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:03Is this Chris? Yes it is, is this Matt? It sure is, man, how are you? Oh my god, I'm alright. What's with the oh my god? Oh wow, it's been an ordeal trying to figure out how to use the satellite phone from the great metropolis of Quincy, Washington. Really? Oh yeah. The Gorge? Yeah, we're out at the Gorge. Nice. Is it a nice day at least? Because that's like my favorite place in the entire world. It is not a nice day. Oh, that's too bad. No, it's raining like crazy and everybody on the main stage is sort of scrambling around with big plastic bags trying to keep the Cure's guitars dry. Oh yeah, the Cure is on tonight. That's right. That's true. Are you excited? I'm really excited. Have you seen them before? Let's see, the second half of the day goes something like Tegan and Sara, the Presidents of the United States of America,
0:53then us, then the Cure. Wow, so you're opening for the Cure. I guess ostensibly we're opening for the Cure. That's amazing. It is pretty amazing. That's right. And Tegan and Sara. That's so nice. That's not bad, and they're from Calgary. They are from Calgary. They're so from Calgary. Have you seen them in the last while or are you just gonna be chilling with them later on? We played a show with them in Las Vegas about a month ago, I guess. Okay. Yeah, and then we're playing with them again tomorrow in some town outside of Salt Lake City. Oh, you're really going everywhere. Yeah, totally. So how long have you been on the road now? Like what, a month? Not even. Well, not technically really at all yet. I mean, yesterday was technically the first show of the tour. Really? Yeah, we did like six shows down the west coast to Coachella. And then we did,
1:45you know, it's basically just been weird promo stuff, like lots of acoustic radio things and stuff. And when we got on stage and played a rock show last night, like, you know, usually the radio things kind of feel like the thing that you're not used to doing. Mm-hmm. And then we got on stage last night and it was like, oh, it's so loud and so fast, and we kind of had a weird show. Let me ask you this: what song off the new record sounds the best acoustic? What has been really working? Talking Bird sounds really good. Yeah, I can see that slowed down. That'd be kind of cool. Yeah, Talking Bird works out really well. I Will Possess Your Heart actually doesn't work out too badly. Really? Acoustic bass, is that what's going on too? No, I mean Nick's been playing his regular bass and it works out. I mean, it works out pretty cool. The thing about that song is that it's so just the
2:38like the... I don't know. I mean, it just feels a lot like it felt when we recorded it. It's just sort of a different instrument, but it actually doesn't feel all that weird. Cool. Yeah, I want to talk about that song in a little bit, but we'll hold off, because I want to start with a song that mentions Calgary in it. I Will Follow You Into the Dark mentions Calgary. You stripped it down, Blackbird style, and I'm wondering, was there, I know you're the producer, and you must have been at some point, maybe we should put strings here or do this here? Or was it always bare bones? No way, man. Bare bones. Yeah, I mean there was talk at one point before we tracked it to put some more stuff into that song, but the way that it got tracked was, I mean, it's one microphone. That's it. You know, there's no mix. There's no multitrack element to it.
3:23It's just Ben performing to one microphone in a room. And it was a total fluke actually that we got that performance. Ben was, I was having some sort of technical problem with something with his headphones, and I was trying to figure that out, and he was sort of in a holding pattern, and he picked up a guitar and was just playing around in the room, and he started playing that song, and it was still coming through the monitors, and I just poked my head out and said, hey, let's just track that real quick, that sounded really cool. And that's the song on the record. That's amazing. That's it. You can't argue with performances, and to me, more and more, that's the key thing with making records. It's like, you know, the guitar-vocal relationship wasn't totally perfect, man.
4:17You know, that's not what it's about. I mean, that's the way... You know, Ben had never performed it like that before and he certainly hasn't performed it like that since. It's really a moment. So I'm just happy we got it. It's funny you mention that. I remember talking to Randy Bachman a while ago, and he was saying some of the records he made back in the 70s, with the Guess Who and BTO, they would just have one mic in the room and that was the performance. It doesn't matter if you screw up the guitar here or there; if they felt that was a take that worked, that was the one that was going on the record. Yeah, exactly. It's totally true, and it's really funny when you've got the whole band in the room together how it changes your perspective on perfection. Like, you know, if you're doing a single overdub or something, the microscope is on whatever you're doing.
5:06And it's like, oh, that note's weird, or I'm singing that a little flat, or that's a little late, you know, that sort of thing. But when everybody's stuff is going down together, it's not like that. You end up just feeling everything together as it goes down. And it gets to this point where people start nitpicking and wanting to fix stuff, but are you really fixing it? If you dig into something, you never know what the cornerstone of the whole track is. And by fixing that thing that seems like a mistake, in quotes, maybe the whole track falls apart. And when we're working on tape, which is what we did for this record, I love that. Yeah, most of our records, you don't have any second chance. There's no safety net. So you punch it in, and if it's not as cool anymore, then it's gone. No take two.
5:55Yeah. I know your solo record was all overdubs, the new Death Cab record a lot of it live off the floor. Yep. Was it more challenging for you to... I guess, you know, Ben wears his heart on his sleeve with lyrics in the songs, but now it's you in the driver's seat, your lyrics. You're talking about pro-life, you're talking about FEMA, and I mean even just the basic rock and roll love songs kind of thing, but it's your voice, right? It's actually really easy for me. I mean, it's not easy to get all of the words and to glue everything together in a way that feels good saying, that's the trickiest part. But in terms of subject matter and what I'm singing about and sort of the basic presentation of each of the songs, it's actually pretty
6:41pretty easy. I mean, it's all the stuff that I talk about every day anyway. Every conversation that I have is political to some degree, and I don't even think about it. I wouldn't even know how to not write like that in a way. So yeah, I don't know. It was a nice thing to do and I will definitely be doing more of it. Nice. Good. We're all excited to hear it. Nice. Any of your songs gonna come out on tour, you think? I know it's a Death Cab tour and you want to play the Death Cab songs, but do you think you'll ever be like, hey guys, what about this one? No, it's not like a 'my band won't do it, man' kind of thing. It's just we're just not set up like that. I mean, this band was,
7:26like, when I met Ben, he was in a two-singer-songwriter band. He was half of the songwriting team for a band called Pinwheel, and he wanted to get out of that. It wasn't a great fellow that he was in that band with, and he really wanted to just write his own songs and do something. And that's one of the cornerstones on which the band was founded. And another one is that I record everything. Yeah. So it's not like we're so stuck in our roles that we're not open to screwing around with the formula, but it's just not important to me, and I suspect that it's not important to the people who are coming to our shows either.
8:12I would hate to get into the situation of like, we're playing some of my songs, and there's that, you know, there was always some band that you loved when you were a kid and you go to the shows and it's like, oh, this is great, and then it gets to the eighth song in the set and it's the other guitar player's song. He's got like one song per record. Totally not the thing that you signed on for. But your record's good. Well, thanks. I mean, I feel like it's good too, but I also feel like if I was going to a Death Cab for Cutie show, I'd be bummed if they decided to play one of my songs. Sure, I mean it might take the place of like Photobooth or... It's just not part of the equation, and it does not bother me or bum me out in any way. It's completely democratic and completely cool. That's awesome. Yeah. Let me ask you this.
8:59I know you're busy and you're probably gonna be on the road with Death Cab for a year and a half or so. Would you tour solo? I really want to at some point. Yeah, but it's just not in the cards. I mean, rule number one of economics is that if you spend your money on one thing then you haven't spent your money on the other thing, and that sort of opportunity cost goes for touring and making records too. If I go on a tour for a month, that means that's a month that I'm not out with Death Cab and that I'm not working on somebody else's record, which I also love to do, and I've got lots and lots of offers on the table. I want to play some of those. I want to play a Decemberists tune a little later and a Nada Surf tune, but we'll get to those. We're talking about your solo record. I want to play something off that.
9:45I'll let you choose. I hear there's two Plans outtakes on there. Is that true? I mean, basically the song Brothers on a Hotel Bed came out of, I gave Ben three or maybe it was four, I think it was four, instrumental tracks for him to write around, and the only one that he really gravitated toward was the song that became Brothers on a Hotel Bed. But the song that I turned into Two-Fifty, the first song on the record, was recorded pretty much in the same two or three days, from the same place. Well, let's play that for people. All right, sounds great. How come such close release dates? It feels like the 60s, you know, we get the Walla record and then we get Death Cab four months later. Man, it wasn't supposed to be that way. Was it our government's fault? No, no, no.
10:32Your government is not to be held responsible for any of the sort of border trauma that I experienced. It was all on the U.S. Homeland Security side. I love how it got caught, but that's insane. No, it was weird. I learned so much about that whole process though. It was really incredible. I got quite a civics lesson from Mike Millen, he's the Seattle, they call him the local, he's for the Blaine crossing. Oh yeah. The Peace Arch crossing. And he totally walked me through exactly what happened and why it happened, and that was amazing. It was really cool. More faith or less faith in your government now? I think I broke even on the whole thing. Okay. What happened was that I have a lot more respect for the people on the ground,
11:19like at the crossings. That border security job is in so many ways a difficult job, and it's not impossible, but it's certainly not that easy. And the thing about it that's the weirdest is that it's kind of a Trojan horse in the, you know, in the internet age. It used to be that confiscating a hard drive was like, yes, we got it. You know, whatever it is that's coming over the border, whether it's some terrorist plot or child pornography or some other thing that they're after, which is exactly what they're after when they're confiscating things, but that's not how,
12:10I mean, records don't even really get transported that way all that often anymore. I spend more time FTPing, you know, to people who are mixing things than I do sending drives to people. So it's really kind of strange. We heard that record got nabbed at the border, but you got a little more publicity, though. It did, certainly. I mean, it didn't happen in exactly the way that I would have wanted it to, I don't think, but, well, you know, whatever. Let's move on to the Death Cab record because it's awesome. Well, thank you. Yeah, it really is, and I liked it the first time I heard it, but now listening to it in preparation for this, it's growing on me quite a bit. Oh, thank you. It's kind of weird. It's a little bit of a sleeper. I'm starting to think that we don't know how to make a record
12:57that's not a sleeper. But yeah, thank you very much. Some songs hit you right away, and everyone I've played it for, Grapevine Fires, everyone's just been like, yes, that's the one. Really? Interesting. I told you that last week too and you were like, thanks. And I was listening to an interview, Ben's written many autobiographical songs, but this one was... Yeah, this one's actually a true story. And I think it's actually a pretty literal true story. I don't think even, you know, names were changed to protect the innocent, I suppose. But it's absolutely a true story. I mean, it's just a day in and around LA with one of our best friends and
13:43her daughter and a couple of other people, and they ended up on a hillside sort of watching the whole Grapevine fire to the north, and it just happened that the place that they stopped to have their picnic was a cemetery, which is kind of weird, I think. But yeah, it's absolutely a great song. Yeah, I think so too. I really like that one a bunch. Do you think it would be a single, or is that even up to you guys? It's funny, it's less up to us than it used to be. I mean, you know, the big record company secret these days that not everybody knows is that when the record comes out, they go to iTunes and they look at which songs are selling the best, and that sort of determines what the next single is gonna be.
14:35Yeah, it kind of does. Like, wow, what are people gravitating towards? I really hope it's a single at some point. I don't know. I mean, it's weird, I hear from sort of equal parts people that Grapevine Fires is their favorite song and that Long Division is their favorite song. Oh, that's cool too. But Long Division is so buried in the record, and people have such short attention spans, that I don't know if it'll actually get there. Yeah, what is it, like nine or ten on the record? Yeah, it's in there. I think it's number nine. It's a little buried in there, but, you know, whatever. That's what happens. Moving on to I Will Possess Your Heart. Yes. Recorded live off the floor, that four-minute jam intro. Yes, that's true. Did you feel it might be too long?
15:21Was there ever a chance where you were like, maybe we should trim it? Oh, we did trim it. I guess it's like 26 seconds out of it. It was just the amount where it was the phrase where it was just feeling too long, and it was really easy to get in there with the razor blade and just hack it out. Oh yeah, you're going on tape, so it would be a blade. It was an actual physical razor blade. That's amazing. There's a lot of that on this record. Like Pity and Fear is seven cuts, Long Division is like five cuts. Wow. I mean, you know, there are not a lot of things in this world that I feel like I'm actually really excellent at. One of them is Scrabble. Two is that I can actually make a really good espresso drink.
16:07You're good at making mid-fi indie records. Yeah, exactly. And then three, mid-fi indie records, exactly. I can cut tape. I learned how to do that. I'm really good at it. It doesn't freak me out. It freaks bands out like crazy, especially in 2008. The band starts sweating and they turn red and they stop, they can't talk anymore. And it's like, look, it's really not that big a deal, you just cut it, you put it back together, it's fine. You mentioned Pity and Fear, and I heard that tabla kind of drum machine was originally supposed to be on that track. The demos for Pity and Fear and I Will Possess Your Heart both came in with that drum machine, and with I Will Possess Your Heart it just didn't feel like much of anything. It felt like, you know, it's just an easy way to present a demo.
16:57And with Pity and Fear it really felt like it was part of the song. So we ran with it for Pity and Fear and then sort of threw it out for I Will Possess Your Heart. Yeah, I like it. Let's play it for people. The edit or not the edit? What do you want to hear? Is that too crazy for radio? It's not too crazy. Awesome, let's do it. Did you have to mix the edit too? Did they get you to do that or did they get someone else? I did that. Yeah. The edit was a real bugger to put together because it's a totally linear performance, and because Jason doesn't have a part, I mean, he's got a framework, and I definitely didn't have a part part at that point,
17:43you can't just cut it. So I had to cross-thread a bunch of stuff together with the multitrack master and kind of retool the whole thing. So that was a project. You should have just been like, screw it, you're playing the eight-minute song. Right. Well, I mean, the other thought was, god, maybe we should just cut it and go, there's your radio edit. I don't know. There were some conversations about it, but I actually really sort of enjoy the radio edit. I think it turned out all right. Yeah, they're both cool. Were you in front of the board the whole time playing guitar? I heard that you were basically in the control room the entire time, playing guitar and mixing at the same time. Yeah, I mean, the guy who does our front of house on tour, Will Markwell,
18:33he recorded about half of this record. He was always in the studio with us. We didn't do anything where he wasn't around. And he was running the tape machine and doing stuff on the fly, just so I could actually perform and not have to worry so much about headphone mixes and all that kind of thing. So he was really, really involved. He was definitely a part of the creative process all the way through, and that's the first time that's ever happened too, that I've really had somebody that I can lean on for that kind of thing for a whole record. That's kind of nice. Yeah, it was really good. Would you ever want someone else to produce a Death Cab record? At some point it's gonna happen, and I'm really,
19:20you know, I'm really looking forward to it at some point. So I don't know. I mean, I don't know when it is. Yeah, I guess we'll see. It will happen at some point. Yeah. The fellow who co-produced The Crane Wife with me, this fellow named Tucker Martine, is a good friend of mine, and he's really the only other producer I've ever worked with like that. That record, The Crane Wife, is the only co-production I've ever really worked on. And it was really fun just to be able to throw stuff at him, and I feel like we played to one another's strengths really, really well too. It was just a totally fun thing to do. So let's play something off that record. Yeah. Because I love it. I love both records actually, both Decemberists records. Well, all of them. But thank you. The two you've worked on. On The Tain as well.
20:09That's the one, it's a 20-minute song. I think they made me play all of it on Radio One. That sounds like fun. Yeah, exactly. That's great. Let me choose two, that way we can talk about war and Obama and all this, and your mail-in primaries as well. So what do you think, Yankee Bayonet or 16 Military Wives? I would say Yankee Bayonet. So you had a mail-in primary? Yes, that's true. That sounds ridiculous, but did it work? Well, I think it worked, and I don't feel like it's, I mean, for me it's not ridiculous because I've been voting absentee for years anyway. And the thing about a mail-in primary, because there's so much talk about positive voter ID and disenfranchisement and all that sort of thing, the mail-in ballot actually seems like a
21:02reasonable way to get around some of that, because you have to match signatures. You have to be registered to vote and they have to have a signature on file, but that's a positive way to match signatures, and that seems reasonable to me. I don't know. I mean, our voting system is such a disastrous wreck just in general that I don't even know where to start. Well, the electoral college is kind of... The electoral college is the least of our problems. I do remember the Democratic Party... You're lost. Like, just learning. I mean, we haven't had to think about superdelegates since 1980, I don't think, something like that. Yeah, and it's like just getting into all the,
21:49this entire primary process with Senator Clinton and Senator Obama has been just this arcane, ridiculous... I mean, it's been a huge civics lesson. It's been all these people getting into Democratic Party bylaws and ways and means committees that nobody ever even knew actually existed. And I keep hearing these interviews with people who are members of their local Democratic Party or state Democratic Party or whatever, who have always been sort of involved in politics, part of the process, but they have no idea what's going on. And it's so crazy to be hearing interviews with superdelegates who are just local party leaders who are like, oh wow,
22:35oh, I didn't know that. Oh wow, that's really crazy. It's funny to hear Howard Dean talk about it too, because he's trying to sound like, you know, but I don't think he even knows what to do. And he's probably got a better clue than most. But I mean, there's just been so much research that everybody's had to do. It's so insane that we have to research our own process to figure out how it works when it actually gets democratic. That's the thing about this primary process. It's kind of strange, because it's been an actually democratic process and it's driving people crazy because it's taking too long. I mean, it's been so funny, like,
23:23I don't know, I'm such a political junkie, and I've been following just a little bit, like before we went to the UK, it was right before Labour lost their shirts in the UK election. And then I have a bunch of Australian friends, and John Howard finally got voted out. Yeah, my roommate's Australian. He's ecstatic. Yeah, exactly. Like, Howard was in power for 11 years, I think. Yeah, something like that. And they called an election and three weeks later he was gone. That's it. It's just incredible how fast it moves, and it doesn't have to be like this. This campaign's been happening since the last campaign. It feels like you just went out on the Vote for Change tour. Can you be doing that again, something like that? I think we will end up doing something like that again. Yes.
24:11I don't know exactly what yet, but I mean, everybody's sort of waiting for the thing to get settled so they can figure out how mobilized everybody feels like they want to be, and who we're mobilizing around. Yes. I mean, it seems like it's Senator Obama, but it's so hard to tell. She's not giving up. She will not give up. No, that is true. If there's one thing that we've learned about Senator Hillary Clinton, it's that she is not a quitter. No. Yeah. I mean, somebody might pull the plug on her campaign at some point and it'll just run out of oxygen, but I don't know, we'll see. Up until then... Going back into music. Do you think the Katrina outcome would have been different had a Democrat been in power? Yeah,
24:56I don't know. I feel like... Wow, I'm sorry to hedge on this question, but I just realized how loud it is out there. [inaudible] Right? Yeah. There's a band called 65daysofstatic that is on stage right now, and they're playing like about 35 feet above my head right now, and I can't tell what's going on at all, but they're this blazing instrumental hardcore band, and they just stopped the song, and I just now realized how sort of worked up it was making me about everything. I'm calming down now. Now that I was gonna talk about Katrina, it all came together. Exactly. So I don't know. I mean, Katrina is one of those,
25:44it's one of those moments that I think any administration or any government could be blindsided by, and it's just so hard to tell what happened and why it happened. I mean, there were failures at every level of government, from the city all the way up to the federal government, with that disaster. I mean, you know, Ray Nagin, the mayor of New Orleans, was pointing his fingers at the state, and the state was pointing their fingers at FEMA, and FEMA was like, well, we didn't get any direction from the White House, and meanwhile people are drowning and everything is underwater. I don't know. I mean, the thing that I'm really disappointed by the most about that process is how
26:33crippled and how hamstrung we were by the red tape of our process, and that's the thing that I hope that our next administration can try and do away with some of. Just trying to implement some sort of a real safety switch, like when something actually terrible happens to our people. I mean, New Orleans is part of my country, and there's still thousands upon thousands of people without homes in the richest country in the world. That's wrong. That's not all right. That's not what I signed on for, that's not what I pay taxes for. It's really, really frustrating to me. So,
27:20so I don't know. It's so infuriating that it's difficult to talk about it with any level of... I don't even know where it is. Well, it is now. Yeah, exactly. And it's like, what, two, three years ago? Well, it was the same week your last record came out, Plans. Yeah, exactly. I mean, it's been two and a half years now, almost three years. That's insane. And you wrote a song about it, a lovely song about it. Well, thank you. See, I was getting into it there. Everyone Needs a Home. It's a great song, and I love the line, a FEMA trailer is not a home. And I just don't think it is. I mean, I haven't actually seen one firsthand, but I've seen some pictures. And FEMA wants them back now. So yes, you still don't have a home. And, you know, there's this nice motel that's 400 miles from where you used to live that you can move into now,
28:07but we want the trailer back. And they want them back for what? I don't know, some other disaster? I just don't understand. We ask everybody five questions, one-word answers. Yes, please. iPod or CDs? iPod. Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. Alcohol or marijuana? Neither. Song you've written you're most proud of, or I guess produced maybe? Okay, I'll say Sing Again. Oh, was that why it was a single? No, it wasn't even supposed to be the single. It just sort of happened that way. Okay. Yeah, I don't know. One word: Death Cab for Cutie. Smoking. I've never heard that before. That's good, I like that. Let's play another track off the new record. Okay. Your New Twin Sized Bed or Cath...?
28:53Cath... How come? I like Cath... It's a good song. It's not that I don't like Your New Twin Sized Bed, but I'm really loving Cath... right now. It sounds like it could have fit on one of your first records. I feel that as well, and I think that maybe that's why I am so drawn to it. I don't know. It's just a little rock song. I love the lyric and I love the way the bridge breaks down. That's sort of the lyrical home run, the bridge, the 'as you said your vows' bit. I think that Ben really, really hit one with that. Cool. You talked on the DVD about the Hall of Justice and how people turn it over and sell it back and forth. Have you sold it yet? The building has never been owned by whoever has occupied it.
29:44It's a funny little building. It was built a hundred years ago, I think. Oh wow. Yeah, I think it was built in 1909, and it was like the convenience store between the town of Ballard and the town of Fremont, two districts of Seattle, before they were annexed into the city. And I mean, it's been abandoned at different points, but it's been a studio continuously since 1978, and it's just been passed on over and over and over from rock band to rock band, or from producer to producer. You know, we've been practicing in there, and it's sort of a storage depot for all of our empty road cases
30:31most of the time. But yeah, it's a good place. It's a place that I miss when I'm not able to be in there. That's cool. Yeah. So it's still yours? Yeah. And I mean, the band has talked at different points about moving out, because it's actually kind of small at this point for what we need. But if the band does decide to move out, I think I may take the lease back over from the band and maybe make it a little bit more of a recording studio again. That'd be cool. Rent it out to whoever wants it. Yeah, exactly. Nice. Let's play one of the singles from the last record. You know how it is. Yes, of course. Soul Meets Body or Crooked Teeth? I would say Soul Meets Body. How come? Jeez, I don't even know. I mean, that's one of the songs from the last record that I have not yet tired of performing
31:20on stage. Every now and again you get to a song and people still want to hear it, and you're like, well, it's been like three years and I'm kind of over it, because I've played it, I know you weren't there for all 400 times I played it last year, but I've kind of played it a lot. I'm kind of over it, you know. But Soul Meets Body doesn't have that effect on me at all. I can hear it over and over and over again, and it just hasn't gotten old for me. And I love the kick drum melody at the beginning. It's such a cool way to do it. It's like you almost tuned the kick drum differently to make it work. Oh wow. Well, that's good. Yeah, I've never heard that before. So you're on the road for a while. What's next? Well, I mean, this is a month-long whip around the States, and only just
32:06only just Toronto and Montreal in Canada. I'm sorry, Calgary. Well, you mentioned to me in the email the other day, maybe Calgary in the fall. Yes, I certainly think so. Yeah, we'll end up doing more of Canada in the fall. We'll do Calgary and Edmonton, we'll probably do Winnipeg. We'll get into the deep interior. Yeah, maybe Saskatoon. Oh, I don't know. Maybe Inuvik. Maybe we'll go all the way up. White Stripes did it when they were here. Yeah, I know, that's the coolest thing ever. I really have the chip that makes me want to go to the far, far north. Oh, it's cool, man. I did a drive up to the Northwest Territories just for fun. Yeah, this was last summer. Did you get all the way up there to Yellowknife? Yeah, I saw them in the
32:52[inaudible]. I've been as far north as, I guess, I've never been in the Northwest Territories. I've been to the Yukon. I've been to Whitehorse and Dawson and everywhere in between, and we thought about taking the drive up to Inuvik, up the Dempster, but it was in the shoulder season, where it's not quite melty enough for the ferries going across the river and not quite frozen enough for you to be able to drive. So we didn't do it. Oh, one day. One day I hope to do it. I just can't wait for 400 miles of gravel road. Sounds like a dream. Well, that's what you're doing on the road, I guess. You have to sleep on the bus though. Well, we get to sleep on the bus, and the thing about the bus, you know, we did like 18 van tours in the first six years. We were a van band, and
33:39the thing about being on a bus is that you don't get any of that sense of travel. Like, the first time that we drove across Canada, it's so hard to fathom that you get to Winnipeg from Toronto and you're halfway to Calgary. It's so insane. It's so vast. And in the States, West Texas is like that. Between Austin and Phoenix, the first 11 hours of that is just nothing. There's nothing out there. Like Nebraska and Utah. Yeah, exactly. It's ridiculous how colonized the east is, and the west is so spread out. Yep, totally. And I do really miss some of that. I miss some of that vast expanse.
34:28I miss that, like on a 10-hour drive through the plains. I miss all the emotions that you go through on a drive like that. The first hour is like, wow, this is beautiful. Then hours two through five are, oh my god, this is interminably long. Yeah, are we there yet? And then hours six through nine are somehow just blissful and perfect. Because you've gone crazy. Yeah, it's totally crazy. You're really into this idea that this is just peaceful and it doesn't stop. And then the last hour you just really need to pee. True. And then you're at the hotel or the venue or whatever, and it's been such a long drive that you're late for soundcheck and you're all stressed out. So I miss some of that. I really do. You cannot reacquire that. Yes. Maybe someday. Thanks, man. Awesome. Sweet. Thanks, Chris. Thanks for all of it.
0:00In some ways this kind of is the first show. How so? Well, production for one. We've been kind of downsizing the operation to play smaller places before getting here. So this is the first show with the full rig. Oh, nice. The PA and lights and everything, and for a show with Bright Eyes. And yeah, it kind of feels like it's 0.5, the first, something that qualifies before the full mile kicks in. Yeah, this is maybe a little more of a show and a little less of a rehearsal with an audience. Oh, that's good. How are you guys enjoying the road so far? What's it like to be out this time? Pretty great. Good. You've caught us at the beginning, rather than asking us like six weeks in. Right. No, it's been really fun this time out.
0:45We've had a lot of time off, which makes us all hungry to be back out and play shows again. And of course, playing a new record is super fun, and getting to work those songs out, like a mini tour for new songs. Yeah, how are the songs coming? Because it's very keyboard. So you're playing a lot of keyboards, Chris, I assume, live. I'm playing, yeah. I'm juggling. Doing a lot of juggling, picking up three and four things. I thought I had to have independence, but looking over at him now, it's hands and feet and brain and voice, and it's a challenge. Did you consider bringing someone else on the road? On the road, right. Yeah, I think we talked about it for about a half a second. And well, I think that it just seemed
1:32like we should try and figure out if we can pull it off just with the four of us. And all of us sat down, and I think the answer is yes, so far. So yeah, it doesn't seem like it's probably necessary. It's sounding good for you guys, though. It works a lot as a four-piece? Yeah, it is. Yeah, for sure. Cool. I think we haven't had to cut any corners or really make any big arrangement changes or sonic decisions. I mean, largely, one of the keyboards that Chris brought out, which is all over the record, is with us. And it's so nice to be on stage and hear the same thing that inspired you in the studio. Right. Let's go through some of the songs on Codes and Keys, because it sounds like it could have been called Textures and Grooves, too. It's all just about construction and textures. And we listened yesterday.
2:18It's like nothing you guys have done before. It's something brand new. Textures and Grooves. Yeah, I mean, it's a little different. This is good, by the way, the pastry. What is it? It looks like it's chocolate. It appears to be a chocolate brownie inside of a little shortbread pastry shell, which is sort of a, I don't know what you would call this, it's probably some Edmontonian specialty of some sort. Of course. But yeah, I mean, the idea was not to make a record that was radically different than anything we'd ever made. The idea was just to try and incorporate some textures and build the songs from foundations and from places
3:03that maybe we'd never built songs from before. I was thinking about it this morning. I don't think there's a single place on the record, save for the last song, Stay Young, Go Dancing... The folk song. The folk song, where a guitar actually strums through any part of a song. The guitars are all used as punctuation. They're just little lines here and there for the most part. There's no big pastoral guitar soundscapes. Anything that fleshes something out in harmonic terms is usually a synthesizer or a piano. There's a lot of random sounds. Even at the beginning of You Are a Tourist, I heard you were tuning shortwave. Oh yeah, there's a piece of that. I found a piece of a shortwave broadcast.
3:52Because there's something that's unique to shortwave. As you cycle through the bands, you end up with this... There's something about that frequency of transmission that allows it to get all the way across the globe, but one of the artifacts that introduces is this kind of pitched warble. And if you just record dead air, you end up with this big, long chunk of pitch. So I grabbed that, and that lives inside of You Are a Tourist as sort of one of the harmonic beds. How do you decide that that's the song that it needs to sit on? Because it's so random, you can go anywhere. Well, right. Yeah, but the way that we constructed that song, it ended up that it needed some harmonic heft
4:40between the bass guitar and the vocals at a certain point. And it didn't feel like it needed another part. Really? It just needed some glue. So I ended up sort of inventing some tape loops and doing that kind of stuff. Are you playing all acoustic kits, or are there electronic kits on there too? No, on the album it's all acoustic. But live, I have a sampler for some of these beds and colors that just run underneath real quiet. Kind of our MO for operating, or mine, is if a sample goes down, it shouldn't throw the show. We don't rely that heavily on those sort of things. But it's nice, as we play these songs and take them out live, to represent as best as we can what went down on the record. It's just because the drums sound different on every song.
5:26I don't know which one of you is doing that, or the collaboration between the two of you. It's a team, right? It's a team accident. Yeah. Happy team accidents. Chris and I, I think, both have a lot of trust and faith in each other and follow each other's noses. And I mean, perfect example, we went into a studio, the Warehouse, and I think the ceilings were probably 35, 40 feet high, full of glass walls, beautiful big area, huge-sounding room. And we built the tiniest little cabin around my drum set where I had to crawl through a space, but that was the appropriate thing for that song. What song is that? It was Portable Television. Portable Television. Nice.
6:11And Stay Young, Go Dancing, same thing. We're in that giant room and I ended up being in more of a storage closet. Yeah. That was full of glass, with a whole bunch of cases and partitions in front of my bass drum, like four feet away. So I think the most refreshing thing was that I knew that with every song, it's generally gonna be a different sound, a different thing. In the past, I've brought out way too many drums, but I mostly relied on two of my favorite kits this time and knew that we could do environmental changes and everything. But it's important, I think, to do that, to address each song differently. For sure. And speaking of different songs, Stay Young, Go Dancing, you mentioned that. It sits on the record. It fits, but it doesn't fit, and I think you understand what I mean by that. Is that a precursor to maybe a folk record next?
6:57Hadn't really planned it that way. I'm just curious. No, I think, you know, of these songs, St. Peter's Cathedral was written in 2002. Everything else was written between 2008 and halfway through 2010, like while we were still recording. So the real broad range, I think, is what contributes to the different styles, and Chris wrote music for Home Is a Fire, as well as Underneath the Sycamore. And going to all the different studios, seven or eight different studios, to inform different sounds and workflows and everything. I mean, I don't think you could take any three songs and put them out as a three-song mini EP and imagine that it's going to work out. Like, how could these three things live together? But, you know, as evidenced by that last song,
7:45it's in no way, I think, an indication of it. It's not a chapter before the next chapter. It's not a setup of the scene. You mentioned St. Peter's Cathedral in there. You had mentioned something in an interview about Ben using his voice as more of an instrument this time, and I think it comes across really well in that song, especially because of the dry vocals that you put on it. It sounds like there's nothing on it at all. Is that true? St. Peter's Cathedral? For the lead vocal, yeah, that's true. Are you singing on there too? I hear you somewhere in the background. No, no, I don't sing on St. Peter's Cathedral. I sing a little bit on Codes and Keys, but not on that song at all. Okay. Yeah, the lead vocal on St. Peter's Cathedral is completely dry. There are those 'ba-dum ba-dum' bits, that little callback thing that it does.
8:31That was definitely a treatment, but yeah. Cool. You'd mentioned another EP. Are there plans for another EP like you did last time, in a couple months? Are there any songs that are left over from the sessions? There might be. We have to go through it, I think. But we're just focusing on this record for now. And I mean, it's funny, we've been rehearsing since the beginning of April. We've done just a handful of things, and this is, like I said before, the show. And the record still hasn't even come out yet. Right. So people are already asking about the future. I'm sorry. No, no. I mean, people want to know what the next single is, or are there any EPs, or what's next. And we're like, hold on, we haven't even opened the cover. Right. I haven't even pulled the book off the stand. It's still in the boxes.
9:17So. How does that affect the live show? Because now you're incorporating a bunch of new songs. I would assume, what, probably six songs make the show? Something like that. It's been between four and six. Yeah. So what leaves? What songs leave the arsenal for the set lists? I think actually the sets we've been playing are pretty long. I think we've actually just added four songs. Oh, really? Yeah, we've been playing for like two hours. Yeah, that's longer than most. 24 songs a night. Crazy. There's, I think, as many as five new songs each night on a big set. So what's your favorite to play live of the new ones? I really like how Codes and Keys has been going. Some Boys has been really fun. Some Boys has been really fun. I've been enjoying Portable Television a lot.
10:03Doors Unlocked. I mean, so from the top, we've just started playing Home Is a Fire and Codes and Keys and Some Boys. And Doors... I say Doors Unlocked. Doors Unlocked and Open. Portable Television, Underneath the Sycamore. And You Are a Tourist. And Tourist. So six. I wasn't counting for sure. That was good. Yeah. And so who knows, maybe more will surface. But I don't think that we did that for Narrow Stairs. I don't think we did that for Plans either. So it's nice to have the majority of a new album that's presentable. Codes and Keys has a real 50s groove to it. Really? You don't feel that way? Because it's mostly the drums kind of doing it, I think. It's sort of...
10:48I mean, that's in the presentation. The song, not the record, I should say. The demo definitely came in that way. It did. And that was something I was kind of trying to avoid for the album, but I guess I didn't. You're trying to avoid it? Yeah. No, no, no. Why were you trying to avoid it? Why would you avoid something that's coming? Well, it sounded to me like it could have been a bigger song than the demo. I mean, that's just the demo version, which may be out there at some point in time. It just sounded like someone was listening to 50s music and not like someone was trying to push it. Right. Yeah, it felt a little bit throwbacky, I guess, as a demo, and trying to push it out of that texturally was sort of the idea, I guess.
11:36Yeah. Cool. Underneath the Sycamore. You guys want to talk about that? Yeah. I mean, the whole musical part of it happened, I think I wrote the instrumental thing that Ben ended up writing the lyrics and melody around in like an hour in my basement. And it was an hour where I was supposed to be doing something else. I was procrastinating, and I had an idea I wanted to get out, and so I did it. Great. It worked. You sent it to everybody. And I think the next morning, Ben had written the lyrics. Yeah. So he was really excited about it. It happened really quick. Yeah. And then we re-tracked virtually everything for the album. Yeah. It's a perfect pop song.
12:22It's a pop song mixed with all these New Order-style kind of synth tones. It's cool. Right. It's well into it. It should be a single, actually. I know it's not up to you. Is it up to you? No, it's kind of tough. It's hard. Yeah, you have that kind of say? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's pretty easy to tell these days via iTunes or Amazon or whatever. The numbers are coming back. It's like, what's the next single? Oh, I guess that's the next single, because it's got the biggest bar next to it. So unless there's a whole bunch of bars next to every song, then what do you do? I don't know. Let's hope for that, for your sakes. Yeah, it would be very nice. No, it is hard to pick what's next. Like I said, that's also why we're playing a lot of stuff live, to see what we want to play as a single. Totally.
13:08Alan Moulder mixed this one. Yes. Not you. Not me. Why? Jason's got something to say? Chris mixed the first two songs. Oh, okay. Yeah. But yeah, Alan... I've had a couple of really great experiences having third parties mix records that I've produced in the last couple of years. And it's been a really, really slow evolution and process for me to get to the point where I feel like I can do that. But the experiences that I've had: Dave Sardy mixed Sainthood, the Tegan and Sara record that Howard Redekopp and Jason and I all worked on. That was awesome. And our friend John Goodmanson mixed a [inaudible] record
13:54that I did this last year. And, you know, we'd never done that for a Death Cab record, and it sort of felt like maybe it was the right time to do it. And Alan was my first choice. And I started pestering him and his management, and then we sort of got some label folks to cheerlead the process a little bit, and it turned out he was really into it. And it turned out really, really well. Yeah. How hard was it to give up control like that? Well, I mean, when you prepare for it, it's really not hard to do. If you get to a point where you're ready to start mixing the record, and then somebody is like, actually, you're not mixing the record, somebody else is mixing it, that's a really hard thing to deal with. But, you know, if the band is trying to wrestle that away from you
14:42when you're not expecting it... But preparing for it and knowing that that was going to happen from the word go made it really easy. And by the time I handed it off to him, I was more than ready to have somebody else put their ears on it and to get somebody else's perspective. Yeah, especially those shoulders. Yeah, exactly. The rest of us, the three of us, were jealous. Chris got to go to London and hang out with Alan and hear stories and watch him work. It's like you got to do some continuing education. I did. Back to school. Yeah. We do something called five questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. We've done this before, but you guys can both answer. Okay. Road or studio? Studio. Studio.
15:27Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. Well, Lennon. Most important thing in a song: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Rhythm. Rhythm. Cool. A song you've written you're most proud of. I wrote a song called Sing Again on my solo record that I'm really fond of. Cool. Field Manual, for those who don't know. That's true. Yeah. I'm still thinking. Written that I'm most proud of... I don't have a solo record, so I can't... A song I've been a part of that I'm most proud of. Yeah. We Looked Like Giants. Nice. Going back. Nothing has come up in the last three records?
16:13No. You know, I could say a whole bunch of stuff on Sainthood, too, just because that was such a [inaudible]. You played on Sainthood? Yeah. Oh, I didn't know that. Cool. A collaborative record. So I'm very proud of that record, and Chris playing bass, and it was a rhythm section in a different way. And in one word, Death Cab for Cutie. Here. Committed.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.