SONGSWhat Father John Misty said about the songs
“I'm Writing a Novel”
Asked whether the Canadian shaman story in the song is real, Josh Tillman confirmed it.
“There was a French Canadian shaman. And yeah, I went and did it. I mean, it's a period of time all kind of obviously condensed down.”
VIDEOWatch
33:05 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #478 · Father John MistyFebruary 2013 · 00:33:05
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Things going well? Yeah. Yeah, that's the way we're gonna do this interview. Just give me one word. Yes, things are good. Yeah, yeah. What do I got here? So almost a year to the day you left Fleet. Sure, I don't want to talk about it too much. But yeah, I just saw the date on the Wikipedia page and was like, oh, this is crazy. It was like this week a year ago. Oh. Yeah, that's what it says. Yeah, yeah, I guess so. So were you writing this record while you were with them, or did it happen from January, I guess April, because it came out? No, I was writing the album quite a bit before then. I think it started in almost like March, March of the previous year. So I mean, it was a long time. So that mushroom trip was a couple of years ago.
0:54Okay, so you see, and that's in the middle of playing with the other guys? Yeah, I mean. And you just took a trip away, or was it downtime on tour, I guess, kind of thing, that that was? I have no idea. I know it's in like March, March before I went to Bearsville, to Woodstock, to work on the album with them in April. I think we started working on that album in April. And then I moved to LA and started working on the album months after that. I was working on the Fleet Foxes. Yeah.
1:45Seattle. Okay, so still on the coast. So the trip down, was that the trip that made you want to move to California? Yeah, yeah, the coast drive. Yeah. What about it? Maybe we'll focus on that a little bit. What about the drive? Well, I mean, I've done the drive. I know Big Sur is the greatest place in the world. Yeah, you know. I mean, there was just kind of a convergence of factors involved in it. Just a lot of personal factors. Relationship, just a lot of things. Yeah, I don't know. I just really wanted to move, and it wasn't like I did a cost-benefit analysis
2:32and that was the right end. I wanted to do something reckless and something stupid, and moving to Los Angeles kind of fit the bill. And it seems like it informed the record a lot. You're singing about Los Angeles and California a lot. No, I'm not thinking about it. Well, I mean, I'm hearing the lyrics about. Yeah, I mean, I'm singing about myself, and in order to sing about myself, you know, with any kind of context or anything, I have to make mention of the place where I am, you know. That's interesting. Yeah, I think, well, that's the way that I write. Locations are a big thing. Yeah, I mean, it's part, you know, it doesn't magically make anything better or more personal or anything.
3:19But you know, I did think it was kind of funny that I was there, and I thought it was like a funny kind of unexpected detail. You know, I'm Writing a Novel is what I hear kicked off the writing process for the record. Mm-hmm. Yeah. How come? And how realistic is that story? Well, is it important how realistic it is? How realistic, Canadian shaman. Yes, okay. There was a French Canadian shaman. And yeah, I went and did it. I mean, it's a period of time all kind of obviously condensed down.
4:05But there was like an ayahuasca experience. There was a French Canadian shaman. Well, here, let's break it down. Okay, first one. I ran down the road, pants down to my knees. My pants were not actually down. Screaming no, no, no. Screaming please come help. I didn't actually scream that, but I thought it would be funny to. But I do remember suspecting that he'd given more to me than to other people, because I kind of went into it with a bad attitude, and I suspected that he was looking to teach me a lesson. Are we talking mushrooms? Ayahuasca. What's that? It is an organic derivative,
4:52DMT. It's a Peruvian drug that they use in the Amazon to induce pretty intense vomiting and psychedelic hallucinations. That's interesting. Yeah, so I went and did this ceremony, and then. First house that I saw, I wrote house up on the door. I didn't do that. I didn't kick anyone out of their house. My reality is realer than yours. That is kind of true. I do suspect that my reality is realer than other people's. That's an interesting one, because. You have to, and because whether you like it or not, everyone kind of does. And then third verse. I didn't burn all my clothes. There was no black dog. My friend did have a black dog around that time, but the black dog was more of a metaphor
5:46for my own, like, depression or whatever, and that's like a very old concept in blues music, the black dog. Didn't drown me a lien. I did write a novel. I didn't drown me a lien, but I did suspect that I was tired of thinking about songwriting in terms of idealizing other people, and more or less attempting to be an approximation of what other people have done. Oh, Hollywood, everywhere I go. And that verse is true. Everywhere in Hollywood,
6:32there are actresses everywhere, and everyone's trying to play it cool and pretend like they don't see them, even though they do see them. And the people that are the subject of pretending like they're not being seen, do they really want to be seen? But they also want to be left alone, and no one actually knows what they want. I wrote that line down. I find that theory fascinating. Yeah. Yeah, because you might be dealing with that now. I mean, this band has become successful over the last year. Yeah, yeah, I'm sick, yeah, definitely. I mean, the language around this whole thing is really, you know, at some point anything that's repetitive gets really exhausting, especially if you're a creative person and you thrive on
7:21newness and you thrive on destroying things to create new things. Like, you know, right now my instinct is actually to be like, okay, that's enough of this thing. You know, I mean, I understand why, but you're asking me, being asked questions about things that at this point happened, I guess, like two years ago, and just being like, I don't know, I would just as soon destroy that whole experience now, in the same way that that experience was used to destroy a previous experience. But with the nature of this kind of thing, yeah, you have to answer for these,
8:13you know, these things, that you have to drag these corpses out into the public square and beat them again and again and again. Do you feel that way playing these songs live? Sometimes, yeah, I think. I mean, sometimes not. But I mean, I really, you know, I enjoy singing them. But what I enjoy more is, you know, writing and whatever. But there shouldn't be any mystery to that. I mean, there's a whole pragmatic quotient to this that isn't really worth talking about but can't be ignored, which is just making a livelihood or something. Like, I'm playing and whatever, and it's better than digging a ditch.
9:02So yeah. But I guess the question, are you getting used to the celebrity of it all? I don't know. Is there any celebrity? I don't think so. I mean, it's not like celebrity. No, but people are coming to see you play, right? If you walked out after the venue, people would probably come up to you. People would come up and ask me where I played last night. Oh, yeah, absolutely. Interesting. People would come up to me and ask me, yeah, they would want to take a picture. And then they would ask me how I like Toronto, and then they would ask me where I played last night, and then they would ask me where I'm playing tomorrow night. Then they would ask me how long I'm on tour, and then they would ask me if I had a break after this tour, and then they'd want to know how long that break was, and then they would ask me
9:49where we go on tour after that break, how long we're gonna be on tour, and then the last question would be whether or not I'm working on a new record, which is kind of. No, it's not. Seems like everyone asks you the same thing. Oh, yeah. That's fascinating. Oh, no, it is, it is. Well, but if you know anything about, you know. I mean, people walk around, that's not limited to this kind of thing, people walk around saying the same banal bullshit to each other, you know, whether they're celebrity-involved or not. Like, how you doing? Oh, I'm good. I'm busy, really busy, but it's good. You know, I'm busy, but it's good, that kind of shit. You know, saying I'm busy being a device wherein you let people know
10:41that everything is okay, and that if you're busy, then you don't have to belabor people with your internal world. I read an article on that, how we use the word busy now just to get out of things. Oh, yeah, because you want to seem totally important to your friends. Oh, I'm busy. Really busy, but it's good. I mean, it's good. It's better to be busy than not. No, it's hard, but it's hard, but it's good, you know. And it's just constant checks and balances of, you know, placating one another. But you know, it's not because people are stupid or whatever, but
11:28truly it's because there's some novelty. To me, it's weird that I'm standing there, and that they're used to hearing me there. You know, it's just like a weird other dimension of me, and they don't care. You know, if you quizzed them the moment after I talked to them and asked them where I played the night before, where I was playing the next night, how long I've been on tour, you know, all those questions, they wouldn't know. They couldn't tell you any of them, because they're just like putting a coin in a slot to watch Mickey Mouse, you know. Do you feel like that? Oh, yeah. Interesting. I feel like Mickey Mouse for sure. I should bring Mickey Mouse gloves. But that's the performance, that'd be something else. Yeah, at least for the picture-taking. Yeah.
12:16But that's also another interesting development, now that everyone has cameras on their phone. Oh, and another thing kind of along the same line. I shouldn't be talking about any of this to you actually, because if you print any of this I will be seen as like a total asshole. No, no, I'll make it sound good. Don't worry. I mean, this is just the reality. But I find the celebrity culture fine, you know, because I've become a part of another thing. Another thing that's kind of nuts is this: the preamble to every encounter with people after a show is always, I hate to be this person, or I hate to be that person, or I hate to be annoying, or I hate to be that, or I hate to be this, but can I have a picture? Not in a long time.
13:05Maybe that'll make it seem more universal. Yeah. Well, one time I did walk up, one time Nick Cave was playing a festival, and. Let's see, so you've been on the opposite side of it, though. Well, yeah, I mean, once you're, I don't even know what I'm talking about. I mean, you asked me how I'm dealing with, like, celebrity culture, which I don't think is necessarily the case. But I also think that it's totally relative. I mean, to the right person, yeah, I'm like a bigger celebrity than whoever, sure. But yeah, now, I don't see it that way, and so it's hard to say how I think about something that I don't
13:54perceive to be the case. But yeah, I mean, I'm saying that for whatever reason there is kind of a culture of groupthink around people who are, you know. I think it's just a groupthink culture, and I do it all the time. But I don't know, there's just not much interesting to say to anyone that you don't know. Sure. You know, and you don't really have, there's rarely occasion to say much to a stranger, you know, as we're sitting here trying to have a conversation. Yeah, I mean, I don't know how to do it. Like, I don't have a rapport with much of anyone anymore. I thought we had a good talk last time.
14:42Yeah, I recall, I recall. I think you're lying, right? That's fine. Yeah, no. I mean, I don't really like interviews much. I don't think many people do. It's a weird thing that you have to do to talk. Where's it like you're saying, well, right when it's finished? When it's, yeah, when you're just kind of, you know, it takes me, I can talk at length and spin beautiful metaphors and deep insights into, you know, myself and my experience, and that's more kind of what I do in song. But that looks very different from sitting down and answering pointed questions or whatever.
15:29But yeah, I mean, I've become, like, probably when we started touring in May, I mean, I spent a lot of energy talking to people after the show. But you can only do that so long. I mean, you know, I've lost like two octaves in my voice, really just from constantly talking, constantly performing, traveling, all that stuff. But yeah, I just, the world is a boring place. Well, not much to say. The way you write about it makes it sound like a fun place. Well, that's good. I was watching an interview with you talking about watching Big Boi play. Has that changed your performance?
16:17Were you watching something like that? Because you were talking in depth about how he was able to do it with the audience. Oh, yeah. Yeah. I mean, I don't think that, I think that was more, if I'll be permitted to say it like that. Yeah, I think sometimes, I don't know that inspired is really the right thing, but sort of seeing a thread of continuity, where you're like, well, that's kind of what I do, and here it is in maybe a more extreme, well-oiled kind of manifestation. But just recognizing the thread of continuity and recognizing that there's something in that.
17:04It's like a very abstract form of musicality. Employ. What do you mean by that? That's interesting. I just mean that there's something, not like, all I mean by it is that it's non-traditional, you know. He's not moving people with an instrument or something, and I'm not doing that either. But just thinking more in terms of, or trans-musical or something, where you are a singer and a performer, you know, like a performer as a trans-musical experience or something. You know, I just think it's interesting, and something you don't really see a whole lot of these days.
17:54Or maybe you do, I don't know. Well, how come you chose not to play an instrument? No, come on. Because I found that interesting when I saw you play Bluesfest, that you weren't playing something, because I know you play on the record. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I just think that there's something that can be accomplished. I don't know, just some other, I don't know. It's hard to dance, hard to dance with a guitar. Right. Then you wanted to dance, is what it was. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, these are instincts. I mean, they're instincts, and then the intellectual, you know, the reasoning, is trying to keep up with the instincts. But I really just kind of follow my instincts. But they seem to have worked. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I trust my instincts very much.
18:45I feel like the band's grown this year. I don't know what it's been like on the inside, but at least from here, people talk about it. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's definitely, I mean, the shows have gotten, you know, all the ways in which you quantify success or whatever, those things have all fallen into place. And I think it's, you know, one thing I do take pride in, and I think that that's for very honest reasons: the show is good, the players are good, the songs are good, the album's good. Like, it wasn't like a Gap commercial or a blog post or, you know, some cheese-dick
19:33Triple A radio format song. I used to work in Triple A radio. Yeah, it's cheese-dick. Yeah, or like Pitchfork, or, you know, it wasn't any of those things that, you know, flash-in-the-pan people. It's really just been constant, you know, constant touring. And are you gonna stay on the road for all of next year? The question you're gonna, yeah. No, no, we're gonna be done on February 2nd, and then most of the spring's off. In which time I'm going to just body paint or something. A different form of art. Yeah, I paint quite a bit when I'm at home, I do that. I've got the next album written.
20:25But really, yeah, I don't want to record, because that just gets the snowball in action. And then all of a sudden the label wants to hear it, and then the label wants to know when you're gonna put it out, and then you're back on tour again answering where you played last night and where you're playing tomorrow. And you wake up one day and you're fucking 50 years old, you know, with throat cancer. And yeah. So yeah, I'm gonna paint for a little bit before that happens. And so what do you write, what are the songs about? Are you able to write on the road? I don't know, like, some people can't. Some people can't. I can. Yeah, I mean, I can write. Inspiration is very wily. I mean, sometimes I can write on the road, sometimes, you know, writing isn't, I
21:12know some people who kind of like, I'm gonna take a retreat, you know, to this cabin and write. And I don't write that way. It's like I can be sitting in traffic and a lyric or a melody comes into my head, then I start kind of chewing on it. But yeah, sometimes it happens on the road, sometimes it doesn't. But you know, working on a song isn't like working on a car or something. You don't need a designated physical space to do it, you know. Oh, some people do. Some people do. I don't understand that. And yeah, I mean, I generally kind of don't like that. I find that attitude towards songwriting really precious, sort of annoying. Need to get into my zen, in a place.
22:02Yeah, you don't think it'd be right without any distractions? Yeah, I mean, if I get into a beautiful, yeah, I mean, there's, yeah, I need a little bit of noise in order. I can't. So the record is about 45 minutes. I mean, last time I saw you, I think, festival sets are usually shorter anyway. Will these sets be longer? Like, how are you drawing out a set to make it 80 to 90? I don't know what you guys are playing. Just endless banter. Yeah, I've got a quote of you talking about that, hang on. Where the hell was it, that you're better at audience interaction than the music part? Well, that was something that, I mean, that was kind of like a
22:48gallows humour thing that I said about the J. Tillman years. You know, I do actually like that J. Tillman music very much. I understand why most people didn't have the attention span or vernacular or whatever to appreciate it. But I was just saying that I noticed that when I was telling jokes and stories and whatever, just making sarcastic quips and stuff in between songs, that the people really enjoyed it, and they would kind of light up, and then I would go back to
23:35doing the Dungeons and Dragons music, and they would glaze back over. Part of this music has kind of been about reconciling that conversational, humorous tone that I have with the songwriting thing, you know, instead of adopting my writerly, how dark is the night, how white is the rose, poeticism anytime I pick up an acoustic guitar. Do you really write with a guitar? Yeah, yeah. I've been writing a lot on piano kind of lately for the new record, but yeah, guitar. But I mean, a lot of the writing just kind of goes on
24:22up here. I feel like you'd be a pen-and-paper guy, or is it a lot of? I don't write down any lyrics really. Yeah, on this album, once they're done, I'll write them all down, and then when I'm fine-tuning them. But as I'm, but I write them all. You're able to remember, your memory? Yeah. Yeah, I have got so many songs. Yeah, that's good. Yeah. So how are you filling out the sets? Oh, no, you said that, I'm sorry, with banter and whatnot. Filling out the set. Yeah, I mean, we're playing like 11 songs off the album and then a couple covers. What are the covers? How do you curate covers? That's interesting. Well, we're doing On the Road Again by Canned Heat right now. That's like a cathartic, very literal song.
25:13That's where you play, like, your life. Yeah. And yeah, we've done Mind Games by John Lennon. We're doing an American songbook standard called nepid alas. Hmm. It seems like I realize, oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, that must be a fun one for you to sing. Yeah, I guess that goes really high. Yeah, it is, it's a big one. Cool. Well, let you go. Do five questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. Road or studio? No. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody, or rhythm?
25:58Dude, we did these last time and I said, I don't. Yeah, I do them with everybody. We do them every time, so I'm seeing if the answers change. Okay. I still stick by the fact that you can't butcher up a song, and. Yeah, not applicable. Cool. Song you've written you're most proud of? A song called Being a Dog. Is it on the record, or is it anywhere? It's a joke song. It's a joke country song, but I wrote it, and I think it's actually pretty perfect. Cool. It's like a perfect song. It's like a perfect, stupid, campy country song that, yeah, I would never put on an album. It's too perfect to put into the world.
26:45It would be a global smash. You should sell it through the publisher. Like Toby Keith. Yeah, there you go. In one word, Father John Misty. What's going on with the Chihuahua movie? Actually, I want to get that. Oh, the book? The book, yes. You're making a movie with your girlfriend and there's a chihuahua. Yeah, there's a, yeah, the chihuahua, the post-apocalyptic chihuahuas. It's in its, that's had to take the back burner, unfortunately. I scored my girlfriend's movie this past spring, winter. There's only a couple minutes. Okay. I scored that and recorded it.
27:36It's like a satanic family film. Yeah, it's like a satanic family film, and so that was fun. And see, yeah, paint. Blood painting. Story about. So the demon goat mother named Steve. It's like a big series of paintings, like 15 paintings. And this demon goat mother named Steve gives birth to a cell phone and a vomiting dog, and it's kind of like a Jacob and Esau birthright story, and the cell phone is exiled
28:24out to sea, and the dog takes favour. In a way, the cell phone. That's kind of where my head is at right now creatively. Interesting. For yourself, or do you, yeah, I think that's for a gallery or something? Weird. I'll show you. Yeah, no, I definitely just do it for myself. There, it looks like it. It looks like an alcoholic eight-year-old. Is that where the lyrics for, something about loving the work here, or something, tells very well, but you're talking about oil, for oil paintings? Oh, yeah, I mean, that's just cheeky. Cheeky. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, that song is also
29:13me talking to myself, you know, trying to reconcile how much use oil. Yeah, just be. Well, no, oil is just a metaphor for, like, look, it's not all about your preciousness. Like, it's not all about, like, maybe there is a larger, like, all this emphasis and angst, drama, distress and whatever that goes into this, like, am I making the great album? You know, like, whatever. Maybe there are other things that dwarf that, and you should just shut the fuck up. What time are you on? Is it back-to-back, co-headline tour, like, how's that work?
30:04No, we're just, we're. The others, there's a couple. Oh, they're cool. So, are they colourful? I like. Yeah. They're violent. Very fine. What do you do, do you hang them up around the house, or do you just, like, when they're done? Just kind of all in my studio. It's one outlet for my. I'd love to try. I've never done it, dude. You know, I hear it's really cathartic. It's fucking great. And how long would one of those take you? Hours, or not hours, days? This one is not done yet, but it's on its way. Now, they generally, like, how do you know it's not done? How do you know when something like that's done?
30:55You just feel it? Yeah, I mean, that's a skill. Knowing when something's done is a very important skill that kind of takes a long time to develop, you know. Well, even with a song, actually. Yeah, how do you know, especially with a song? How do you know when that's done? When something's cooked, is that Jonathan Wilson saying, I think we're done? No, I mean, you know, I don't like to ask other people, like, do you think it's done? Do you think it's, because I don't like. Yeah, I mean, it can't be, it's an instinct. Yeah. I've been drawing to make the cover of the next record.
31:42You know what else, no. No, I'm not gonna sink to that level. Nepitus. Like that one on it. Yeah, I mean, I do kind of like absorbing everything I do into the album form, like the novel. Yeah, right, etc. Like, I think there is something fun about absorbing everything into one. The album is just such a great medium for so many things to happen, you know. I mean, there's sheets of paper that the short stories can be on, and there's an album cover that a painting can be on. It's like this, you know, it's this format for everything. You can't make a painting musical,
32:29you know, but you can make a piece of music more, you know. I mean, like that album cover, the Fear Fun album cover is, I mean, that's legitimate art. Yeah. It's like. And so that's what really attracts me about the album as a format. Part of what's baffling to me is things go digital, digital. Such a missed opportunity. Anyway, yeah, I'm gonna chill my voice. It's all good. I got Hamilton to talk to anyway. Thanks for putting up with me every time, man.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.