← All interviews
Audio interview · June 2013 · Toronto

Imaginary Cities Interview

Musicians Rusty Matyas and Marti Sarbit from the band Imaginary Cities (Purple Heart, Hummingbird) chat with Matt Schichter in Toronto.

Lennon or McCartney? Rusty Matyas & Marti Sarbit answered: McCartney, McCartney. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Imaginary Cities said about the songs

“9 and 10”

Imaginary Cities revealed that the chorus of "9 and 10" is made of Shakespeare phrases.

“the whole chorus of '9 and 10' is... every line of the '9 and 10' chorus is a Shakespeare quote.”

Read it in the transcript

“Bells of Cologne”

Imaginary Cities said a field recording inspired "Bells of Cologne."

“'Bells of Cologne' definitely inspired that song. I wouldn't have made, or we wouldn't have made, that song without that recording.”

Read it in the transcript

AUDIOListen

Episode #543 · Imaginary CitiesJune 2013 · 00:20:10

Archive audio

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00Here, what, how you were in Germany, didn't have a phone, but I wanted to do like a Storytellers thing for all the songs. I don't know why you would go out of your way to do that. Sorry, one second. It's not rude or anything. Not anymore. So the needle drop is the way to start the record, like an actual record. That's a total geek thing. So where did it... is that something you've always wanted? I mean, you've made a bunch of records in your career. I don't think you've ever done that. I definitely, I'm sure there's a needle groove sound somewhere on some record, but not at the start. Not at the start. Yeah, I don't think I've done that.

0:52Hear it again. Yeah, well, and I mean, it's kind of cliché, but I mean, there's something so awesome about listening to a record with that crackle running through it. It's totally comforting. It's relaxing sounding. The crackle of the fire. Yeah. Is it safe to assume that whoever's voice I hear wrote those lyrics? But a lot of these songs we wrote very much together. One of us might have the bulk of it, and it's pretty equal.

1:37Yeah, and then we kind of flesh it out together. Yeah, right, figure it out. And we have kind of a nice, honest working relationship, where it's sort of like I can say, or she could say, that lyric's really lame. You know, the opposite end of the spectrum, that lyric's too vulnerable, too personal to me. I don't want to... I don't know if we make the lyrics like... Let's ignore that. I don't feel like we make the lyrics specific enough for them to be that vulnerable. I feel like they are usually pretty accessible. There's something nice about lyrics that are specific enough to sound like they're about something, but vague enough that

2:24they don't jump out at you, and people can kind of take what they want from it, right? I am also a big fan of lyrical clichés, like a phrase everyone's heard before but just sounds perfect. I don't know, silver linings. Yeah, I don't know, stuff like that, right? I actually have a whole list in my phone of classic English phrases. In "9 and 10," actually, "9 and 10," the whole chorus of "9 and 10" is... every line of the "9 and 10" chorus is a Shakespeare quote. That's interesting. And I, because I would just Google... No, seven-syllable phrase. It wasn't that, that's like done that, but I mean, you do that.

3:12Google, like, you know, common English phrases, and I didn't know this, but like hundreds of common English phrases that we all know are Shakespeare. Yeah, that's "as pure as driven snow," or "as cold as any stone," "twinkling in your eye," like, that's Shakespeare. No, there's a thing, I believe this goes with music as well, where 30 years after, 50, but I don't know. Yeah, McCartney just changed it, I think, something like that. Yeah, but anyway, that shit, he needs it in billions. Yeah. And he's holding on. Yeah, my Paul McCartney tickets are the most expensive ones I will ever spend here.

4:04I almost, and then I was like, no, stupid. I was in Vegas, a couple of Stones were there, $150 for your seats, and this wasn't sold out, obviously. Well, we were kind of frustrated at Paul McCartney, because he's pretty much my favorite songwriter ever, or at least up there. And I mean, come on, man, all musicians love your music, but none of us can afford to go to your show. Come on. If I do, I can't sit with the rich people in the front row. Have to listen from the parking lot or something. Although I got decent...

4:50And actually, I've mentioned, I think it was Green Day, and then I think it was in the 90s, there was something against Ticketmaster, something where they had a cap on their prices. I remember they played at the arena in Winnipeg, and the most expensive tickets were 30 bucks or 60 bucks. And Kid Rock's done the $20 thing. That's great. Yeah, we saw Kid Rock did the same thing. I mean, you guys can't be doing too bad, Germany, off the first record like that. You guys were touring places I never would have expected a first-record Canadian band to tour. That's crazy. Yeah, that was pretty good. How did that happen? Like, how did the music get out there? We had a really great record label in Germany. I would sort of say they're like the Arts & Crafts of Germany. They put out a lot of really cool music, that people, they put out a record and people will listen to it, and

5:39and we were lucky enough to get on their label. And we go there and play shows, and it was surprising that German people, when they hear music or they see a show's coming and it's promoted properly, they listen to the music. They come and know your words and songs. Yeah, like one of our first shows in Germany, people were singing along to the songs, and this is like in the first year of putting out the album, and that was just like... I'm pretty sure Rusty took out his phone while we were on stage and took a video of the audience. Well, they didn't make us, but they wanted us to play a song again. Yeah, we totally did. Free encores. I mean, that sounds so...

6:26We're very humbled by it. It was overwhelming. We were totally hugging backstage. Yeah, it was great. Like, we showed up to the venue, and this venue is far too large for us. Who were we opening for? It was pretty much sold out. It was a great feeling. There were bells of Cologne, the bells, a field recording on this record. I heard it, and after, then I read some interviews, and I found that, okay, it is a field recording. But when I heard it, I was like, oh, please, let's be real. Oh, yeah, that's actually... It's probably still in my voice notes on my phone, and the way it happened was amazing. Yeah, it's awesome. My life is on these voice notes. Yeah, it was on a different tour, but yeah, I was in Cologne sitting on our friend's rooftop, and bells just started going off, and I recorded it on my phone, and actually on the record it's just the way I recorded it.

7:17It's from the demo. We didn't redo it or anything like that. I actually just put an SM58 up to my phone and hit play. Okay, then I didn't... Okay. Yeah, party, yeah, Susan. So yeah, it's pretty lo-fi, even, because of that airy sound too. I guess more than the reverb of the mic and the phone. Yeah, it adds... I don't know, I'm going with that. I just like the sound. Thanks. Yeah, and I hear there are other field recordings on this record. Yep, there's children jumping into a lake at Rushing River campground in Ontario. And what was... the bells of Cologne makes sense. Why kids jumping around? No, yeah, I was just there. No, I often will hold out my phone if it just sounds cool. Like, we were in Australia and there were

8:09100,000 birds on this beach making the most loud, crazy noise, and so I recorded it, like, who knows, maybe I want to throw it in a song. So I often pull out my phone. Familiar. So do those field recordings inspire songs, or do you have song ideas in mind and you're like, oh, that'll fit? "Bells of Cologne" definitely inspired that song. I wouldn't have made, or we wouldn't have made, that song without that recording. But most of the time it's just like, that's a cool sound, hopefully I can fit it in a song sometime. You say we wouldn't have made that song. How did that song come about with the collaboration? Well, I don't like you singling that one out, but oh, well, it's probably the one that's getting more... But it's, well, Rusty, because he had the sound and had the idea for it. He came back to Winnipeg and was like,

8:59hey, let's write a song about this. And then we got together, and there was already that foundation of the idea there, and then we wrote the lyrics together. Yeah, I can't remember. Every song is sort of different. Like, Marti will have something fully complete, or I will, or... It doesn't really matter, we split everything up the middle. Yeah. But what about when it's a duet? How do you decide, the two of us are gonna sing this one, or maybe you should just take this? Well, Marti's definitely the lead singer. Yeah, but we're never in the position to have to make that decision. It's just, the song just suits one of us, or like "Away With Words," like, that's... Rusty's voice should be singing that song. It's one of those things you can't really describe.

9:52It's just the way the song is written. And that was the first time for Imaginary Cities we decided that I should sing. Yeah, that song. I mean, but on this record more than the last one, we definitely do a lot of guy-girl duet sort of harmonies. And it's fun, because harmonies are beautiful and we both like singing. Yeah, it just makes sense. Yeah, we make the record for fun. Like, we didn't make a record because we had to, or because we have to follow up the first record, or have hits, more hits. Like, we don't think about that. We actually just make music that we like to listen to. So, talking about making music you like to listen to, hearing Marti's voice for the first time, you're sitting in a bar, you hear her singing Motown tunes.

10:37What was it about it? What were you sitting there thinking? I need, we need to do this. Yeah, I've done that with a few different people. I did that with Ewan from The Sheepdogs as well. We've made a lot of recordings together now, sort of based on that first initial thing. I came in and wrote a song for Ewan to sing on, so I wrote a song for Marti to sing, a Motown song. Is it on the record? No, no, but my Motown cover band covered it. Yeah, they play it in their set now, and it's totally indistinguishable. It might as well be some old obscure Motown cover. And so yeah, that's just... It's a selfish endeavor. Like, I just want to have that person on a recording that I make, so I will ask them. It's fun. That's the only reason I ever do it. And you said yes?

11:27Because he's awesome, and, you know, at the time he was doing sound at the bar that I was playing at, and we knew each other. Yeah, and I knew The Waking Eyes. They're awesome, and I was a big fan, and I knew that Rusty was really good at that, so I was excited. He was the first person to ever want to do a project with me. Like, all I was doing was singing in a cover band for a couple years, so it's working out. I think it's going pretty good. Yeah, pretty good, both of us. So this one's gonna be a big one. Morning a little bit. You mentioned Ewan in there, and I thought I heard his voice. I sent a little tweet, and then he tweeted it back, and I was like, okay,

12:13so it must be his voice. So he's on this record. Yeah. Why, when you're talking about harmonizing and liking other people's voices, how come you brought other people in? I think for that song, he had mentioned that he liked that song specifically, and it was one of the first ones we had made a demo for for this record. And I don't know, he was in town, we're good friends, we've recorded together, and we just asked him, can you sing a verse? And he's like, yeah, love to. And all the guys are on it, actually, they sing gang vocals in the background. Oh, Ewan takes a full verse, which is sort of a bold move, I guess, if we're both singers, to have yet a third person come in and take a lead. That will obviously not be able to do every... But we both just love his voice so much. Yeah, it's so smooth. It didn't feel like a risk or anything. It was more like a treat. Yeah, yeah.

13:01And yeah, I think Ewan's got the best voice since 70s rock. Like, he's got the most effortless voice. And he's a real singer with a powerful voice. You know what I mean? A very manly voice. That's manly. I said it before, but I'll say it again. I think he's got the best voice since Freddie Mercury. Yeah, it has the same kind of quality to it. And well, it's got something that a lot of singers don't have, which is quality. Like, he's a quality singer. Like, he isn't even out to try. So who takes that part when you do it live? You take this part? Yeah. We're gonna try. We're gonna do it for the first time when we play these songs. Yeah, tonight. I definitely have a way different voice than Ewan.

13:48I sound like a little boy compared to him. No, you don't. Yes, I do. You have a lot of rasp. Little boys don't have a lot of... But yeah, I think it'll translate just fine. Yeah, yeah, I'm great. Thanks, Marti. Have you worked out any of these songs live yet, or is this the first time? Yeah, there's three or four that we added, completely new to the set, that haven't been shown to a crowd. Really excited for "Silver Linings." I think that's probably the one, that one and "Who's Watching." And yeah. How do you know when a song is done? I mean, you played everything on the last record, pretty much, right?

14:34Mm-hmm. Is it the same way this time? Yeah. How do you know when a song is done? Like, when I'm editing video or I'm screwing around and making music myself, I don't know when to say, okay. You can always work on it forever. Yeah, right? So how do you know, okay, I can't do this? I think once... sorry, go. Once you realize that everything is serving a purpose. Yeah. And then, like, I think that if you add something in and you think, like, oh, it's just decoration, it doesn't really need to be there, then that's the point where we seem to have started. Yeah, cut. I think I have sort of learned about myself and how I like to orchestrate a song, and I definitely have my bag of tricks, or like my... I

15:20don't want to... it's so weird talking about yourself, like you think you're awesome. Just, yeah, I have a way I like songs to be filled out in certain ways and accented by different things, and I sort of have a routine when we're working on the start, with drums, and then add bass if it needs it, or drums if it needs it, and then maybe some keyboards, and then adding organ. I don't know, I'm getting a little specific. But no, I like it, because there's strings and stuff. There's instruments, like a lot of orchestration. Yeah, yeah. And I really love strings in pop music, and so we sort of utilized that a little more on this record. And even though there's tons of stuff going on on these songs, a lot of times

16:06there'll be like 15 things doing the same thing. Yeah, it doesn't... The biggest thing is that things don't clash or conflict. All the notes always work together. Yeah, it doesn't seem cluttered. Or at least I don't think so. Yeah. Well, even the way you played, what was it, that was cool. Yeah. But I mean, even just stripped down, simple, and the song still sounds just as beautiful as it does with all the production, everything on. Thanks. So if the song... Just call them at you. People and songwriters and bands have been saying this forever. It's important that a song can be played on acoustic guitar. As long as there's a

16:52chord progression and a melody that moves us, then that's... Is this something that you start on, a guitar, or piano? Well, I just... Marti did too. We both just recently got pianos in our houses, so I've been playing it a lot. I try to write a song a day on the piano, recorded on my voice memos. Well, this record... No interesting answer for you. I don't want to take up too much time, but you seem to be one of the festival bands this summer. Like, you're on every... you've got yourself slotted at every festival across this country. It's great. Yeah, a lot of them, because I got one just recently. Yeah, we were added to the...

17:40It seems to be like a cross-country thing where people are gonna be coming to see this, like people know who you are. It's such a... Is it a similar thing to when The Waking Eyes go out? Like, does it feel similar in any way? No, it feels different. And I think it's weird, because I think it's really important to be skeptical. I never think we're that successful, and I still don't think we're that... I mean, we're doing it. It's our job. Yeah, that's a success. See, but having a friend of mine... People are ever gonna recognize you walking down the street? And they don't. No, I don't. Yeah, but you know, when we play a show and there's a lot of people there, it's always

18:29exciting and surprising and humbling, and I haven't gotten to the point where I expect people to be there, you know. And I always think that, you know, when we're playing these festivals, we're most likely gonna be on some side stage earlier in the day. Okay. Okay, five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay, I've done this before. The more I talked to you, I remember doing... I remember you guys like ten years ago in a bar with Collective Soul, and their song started playing on the radio. You guys all made fun of them, because they were sitting behind us and their song went on in this diner, and you guys were like, wow, that's cheesy. Okay, five questions, one-word answers. Road or studio?

19:17Studio. Road. Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first, lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. Song you've written you're most proud of? All the time. First one. Yes. And in one word, Imaginary Cities. Fun. No. Time. Just wonderful. Thanks, guys. Thank you.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →