Lennon or McCartney? Brian Fallon’s answer: McCartney. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Brian Fallon said about the songs
“1,000 Years”
Brian Fallon says the line about a woman's last words came from a separate situation, not the band.
“That was one of those ones where that actually came separate from the song. I was thinking of another situation... It had nothing to do with the band. And you just can't do what people want you to do sometimes.”
VIDEOWatch
10:57 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #678 · Gaslight Anthem (Brian Fallon)June 2014 · 00:11:26
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:33So you have this record done. I've heard it, I love it, and we'll talk about it and kind of give people a preview of it. But you don't want to play the songs yet, you were just saying. No. Well, we also just got done with it. So. Just got done with it? Yeah, yeah. You know, the mastering takes a little bit, and the mixing, after you're done with recording, so it's not done until then. And then usually, you know, you go do some press, or you go home for a minute. And then we haven't even gotten to rehearsals yet, so we've only just started with any kind of rehearsing at all. So no. Usually wait until the record's out, you know, to play the songs. Like, you don't want... not in this day. You can't do it. Nothing's a secret anymore. You can't, like, you can't go and just say, like,
1:20"Hey everybody, we're going to play our new record, you know, and hopefully you'll like it. You know, maybe if you could not put it on the internet," because someone will inevitably put it on the internet. So you just, you have to... it's like, you just can't. That's something I don't think about with bands. Like, I know social media has changed... Like, you don't get the mystique of Zeppelin. They probably couldn't have those stories, you know, in today's day and age. But that's, yeah, that's interesting. But you can control what you do out there. You just have to know what you're doing, and you can't blurt out every thought you have, you know what I mean? And you can't just, like, you have to be careful with how you present yourself, because how you present yourself is the way that you will be perceived. With things like Led Zeppelin, I think they could do that now,
2:05and they would just probably not talk that much, you know, if you understand that. Yeah, well, Jay-Z barely does interviews. Anyway, I do want to talk about the record, because I love it. And last time you told me there's, like, a living time and a writing time. You have to experience things so that you can write about them. So between the last record and this one, what have you been living? What have you experienced? Oh, I mean, tons of things like this. Okay, it's a vague question, I'm sorry, but specifically? I mean, nothing specifically that has anything to do with writing. I think that, you know, there's no, like, you know, specific... Again, this is kind of me showing you the way that I'm answering. Okay, so... So what I'm doing is not telling you, because I think that the records are there for
2:52the listener to decide what the songs are about. I think if you tell them, you know, like, "Hey, you know, I did this," or, like, "I did this," and then they look for it in the record, and then they look for, you know, "Where are you talking about that specific thing?" And then it sort of just becomes less theirs, and more, you know what I mean? Yeah, well, because I read, I think it was a Rolling Stone article, talking about, maybe you were talking about this record, and you wanted to evolve the band. Like, you knew you wanted to go in with a different sound. So I'm obviously consciously looking for where things are different, where things are changing. I'm noticing, like, the double-tracked vocals and, like, the lower register voice on parts. And there's still all that Gaslight stuff that we love, but then "Get Hurt" is the first single, and when I heard that, I was like, whoa, this is gonna be a different album.
3:37Yeah, yeah. No, it doesn't go that drastically different, like "Get Hurt," but it's an interesting first song to let people listen to. Yeah, I think that that was the idea, is just to kind of let it out. To throw people off? Well, not... I mean, we're not trying to make anybody upset. Like, we're not trying to rock the boat just to rock the boat. But I think that putting that out there kind of allowed people to sort of digest the fact that, okay, you know, this is not what I would expect in the first single. You know, what I'd expect, like a big rock song. But we also just thought it was a really good song. So we were like, "Well, you know, I think people would like this, so let's put this one out there." And then that was it. Cool. All right. So you don't want to talk about it too much,
4:23but sometimes it's very simple, though, as well. Sometimes there isn't, like, a story. It's just like, you kind of listen to the record and you're just like, "Well, I think that this one's a good song. Does anyone else in the room think it's a good song?" Everybody goes, "Yeah, I think that's a good song." Okay. And then you just put it out, and that's it. It's really simple sometimes. So I like how you keep using the word simple, because it's simple, like the verse is pretty simple. How do you struggle, or maybe not struggle, but toe the line between simplicity and complexity when you're composing a song? I think naturally I gravitate towards simplicity, because it's just the music I came up from. You know, like, I don't think any of the bands that I listened to growing up were exceptionally complex, you know. And I think that they had complexity in the way that they were able to... There's a siren going on.
5:08You know, I don't know what that is. But they would... Is that serious? I think it's someone's phone down here. Someone's phone. That's the most annoying ring I've ever heard in my life. It's probably someone in your band. Yeah, that is horrendous. It's not the most annoying ring, I'm going to take that back. It's not. I exaggerated there, I went too far. But you're a songwriter, you've got to exaggerate a little bit sometimes. That's something people could learn, because they say, "So did you really..." "No, I didn't. I didn't really crash my car and do a thing." Nope. There was a line in "1,000 Years," you talk about a woman's last words. Yeah. And I find that interesting. You're going to say this was someone's last words. Yeah. That's an interesting thing to choose to write, because that's a heavy thing, right? Yeah. That was one of those ones where that actually came separate from the song.
5:57I was thinking of another situation, and I was just like, you know, you can't do... It had nothing to do with the band. And you just can't do what people want you to do sometimes. And it's not... Like, some people do it out of brattiness, or out of rebellion, or out of just "you can't define me" kind of thing. And actually the truth is that sometimes, simply, you just can't do it. And you have to be like, you're not going to get what you're looking for from me. So I just can't give you what you want here. And I think that that's, like, a funny realization about life, is that a lot of our time is spent pleasing other people. It is. Everybody has a nature to want people to be happy.
6:43I mean, there are a few individuals, probably, who, you probably know someone, or I know someone, who's just like, "I don't care what anyone thinks," and who genuinely doesn't care. But usually those people just go about their own business, and they don't really... I've never had that. I've never had that. Never completely. Yeah, I think to a degree, I want people to be happy. My kind of view is very much that I obviously, like everyone else, would like to get what I want. But I think one of the things that happens is that you would let... Tom, hit the road. I love you. See, people-pleaser, even at the end. It's not the manager. Well, because you got to give the good and the bad.
7:28You got to give it a little spank and then a little "it's okay." Thank you, Jim. And you probably deal with an audience that way too, the same way? No. No. No. The audience, you just try to make them... That's one thing where, yeah, that comes in with the band, where you are a people-pleaser with the audience, because you want to give them what they want. You want to challenge them a little. You never want to reprimand your audience, and I know this from experience. You don't want to tell them they're wrong, because they're not wrong, because you're the one that's leading them in the direction anyway. So if you're not leading them in the direction that you would like them to be led in, then you're doing it wrong. Yeah, no, I like it. But it's a good segue, because I hear you were just writing the set list, like, five minutes ago.
8:14Yeah. And, you know, people want to hear certain songs. You might be sick of playing certain songs, I don't know if you are or not. I mean, I'm sure it happens to any musician at some point. Sure. So how do you decide? Well, because I think sometimes you look at your audience and you think, yeah, if you think about it from the big picture and you go, "Well, you know, the kid paid 30 bucks to come, or 35 bucks to come, and I don't really want to play this song, but I know that the majority of people want to hear this song," you sort of weigh that out and you go, "You know what, just play this song," because why wouldn't you? The song's doing something different for them than it is for you, because they haven't heard it 900 times. They've only heard it maybe once. And so it's exciting for them. And if you can learn to give and take... it's just all give and
8:59take, everything. I'm trying to remember the last time I saw you, and I'm trying to remember if you change arrangements at all to keep it interesting for yourself. Sometimes. Sometimes we change arrangements a lot, and then... What's changed the most over the years? Sometimes... We took one song called "Boxer" that was off American Slang and just completely stripped it down to, like, almost a borderline acoustic song. The version that's on the B-sides record? Yeah. And then we, you know, kept it like that. But you don't want to do that too much, because then you're... I went to see Bob Dylan once and it really bothered me. I think Bob does that. Well, it made me mad, like, because he was going in there and he changed all the songs to the point where they were unrecognizable. And the only reason I knew them is because I knew his lyrics as well. So I was like, "Oh, that's 'Blowin' in the Wind.'"
9:45I left. I got it. I left. You left? And you're a huge Dylan fan. Huge Dylan fan. I left. I was like, "This is not what I'm here for. I don't get it. I don't get what he's doing. I don't understand." Like, because he's Bob. But then I saw him another time and he played everything exactly the way it was on record, and I was happy with it. Huh. You know, whereas, like, you know, the Who and Bruce Springsteen, they're very much like, you know, "We're going to give the audience what they want." I want to let you go. I want to keep going with that, that was fun. Sorry. I don't know what they're doing. You've got a lot of interviews, that's the deal. Yeah, but they're like... that's quick. They are quick. Five quick questions, one-word answers. I mean, 3:08. How was that? We're supposed to have 3:05? I don't know. I feel like that was quick. Well, you're in charge of this all day. Well, I've got a whole... I want to talk about every song, because I love the record so much. But you don't want to talk about those. I'm not going to do that. No, I don't. The reason is, I don't want to tell you specifically, because I don't want to take the license away.
10:34I learned that from Sheryl Crow, of all people. They asked her if a song was about one of her ex-boyfriends one time. I was going to do that. But no, no, no. She said, "If I tell you, then it's about that forever, and it's never about what the listener wants it to be about." I was like, yeah. I was like, well, "If It Makes You Happy," then, Sheryl Crow. Can't be that bad. Five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay. Road or studio? Studio. Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. If someone's never heard Gaslight before, what song do they start with? "The '59 Sound." In one word, the Gaslight Anthem? Band. Band? What did you say last time? Intuit.
11:19Intuit. Intuit. All right. Thanks, Brian. Yeah, no sweat. Thank you. Appreciate it.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.