← All interviews
Interview · August 2014 · Toronto

The New Pornographers Interview

A.C. Newman and Kathryn Calder of The New Pornographers talk Brill Bruisers, a title track that opens on its hook like "She Loves You", "Champions of Red Wine", Neko Case and Twin Cinema, in this 2014 interview with Matt Schichter in Toronto. The New Pornographers are best known for "Mass Romantic", "The Bleeding Heart Show" and "Use It".

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusicians

Lennon or McCartney? Carl Newman & Kathryn Calder answered: Both. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat The New Pornographers said about the songs

“Champions of Red Wine”

A.C. Newman said this was the song that changed most from demo, and he almost dropped it. A.C.

Newman: “I think 'Champions of Red Wine' really changed a lot, because I thought it was a good song, but I didn't know what the feel of it was gonna be... I remember thinking, this song is boring, I'm just not gonna make it. But then it sort of took form and became one of my favorites.”

Watch the moment

“Backstairs”

The New Pornographers said the song started as an unused piece of film score music.

The New Pornographers: “'Backstairs' was just a little abandoned piece of soundtrack music that I just wrote into its own song.”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

The New Pornographers InterviewInterview · 19:06 · 1,200 views
Archive footage

19:06 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #696 · The New PornographersAugust 2014 · 00:19:38

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00The record does start with this... it's like a perfect opening track for shows. Like, I could see the curtain dropping and you guys on stage. Yeah, there was definitely the idea of the hook hitting the first second. Like, to have a song that doesn't build. Not that it sounds like 'She Loves You', but that's what I was thinking about,

0:46'She Loves You', how that song just bursts straight into the chorus. Well, not many songs do that, just like... I thought I wanted a song like that, where the first second of it was the main hook of the song, and to make that the first sound anybody hears on the record, just to try and make it as immediate as possible. How did the song come about? I mean, I'm sure every song is so different, the way you guys must collaborate on stuff. I don't know, it just clicked in. I didn't have the lyrics written initially. I remember when I started demoing it with John, I just thought, I don't have any lyrics. And usually if I don't have the finished lyrics, I usually have, you know, still-working lyrics for songs, but that one was just like, I was just going blah blah blah blah blah,

1:37because I just wanted to hear what it would sound like, you know, leaving my head and getting recorded. And then it clicked in, and we thought, wow, this is good. I'm gonna have to write lyrics for this. Is that the hardest part, [inaudible]? I think for me it is, because I'm so concerned with the sound of the vocals and the melody and the way they flow that the lyrics have to fit in a very specific way. Like, even if I write something that I think is a great line, if it doesn't fit in the song, well, it's just a line that I wrote, you know, so I can't force it into the song, because it'll sound clumsy. So yeah, that's the tricky part. Is there a lyric you keep working on for years that you haven't been able to figure out what song it should fit into? Is there something that's been up there? No, I'm not that attached.

2:27I'm far more attached to pieces of music I've written than I am to lyrics. It's not like there's some story I desperately need to get out. I really envy people who start with lyrics. I think it must be so much easier to write songs around... Yeah, because you get the themes and stuff, which you can kind of touch on when you're given a movie thing to score. But what about you as a lyricist? Is it the same for you? It's hard, actually. I struggle with lyrics too. But when I do it, I guess I do it in silence. You know, like, I'll have the songs, I'll have the melody, and I won't have any lyrics. I'll have kind of just gibberish, and then I'll go away, and there will be no music, and I'll write the lyrics with it in my head,

3:13because I cannot do it while the song is playing. Oh, that's interesting. I was like that in all the bands and everything. I don't know, I just noticed it for the first time, you know, on this last record that I'm working on. I don't know that I've done that, but I noticed it for the first time. I was like, actually, this is how I prefer to do it. Do your words ever show up on these records, on the New Pornos records? No. Who writes everything? Do you write anything? Carl. Dan writes. Oh yeah, except for Dan's songs, right? Yeah, of course. Yeah, pretty much, right. And what about when people are singing it? Like, I assume what he's singing are his words, but is that always the case? How do you mean? Like, does Dan ever write lyrics for you? No. You go to write lyrics for Dan and he's like, no? Okay. The only thing I've ever done on Dan's songs was occasionally do little arrangement things.

4:02Okay. But even that, not that much, and all that was years ago. I've always wondered too, like, these songs start probably with you on an acoustic or some sort of demo, I mean, drum machine, synth, whatever. How do they change? Like, what song has changed the most from a demo to what we've heard on the records? I think 'Champions of Red Wine' really changed a lot, because I thought it was a good song, but I didn't know what the feel of it was gonna be. It just seemed like me playing a song on the acoustic. And even when we did the bed tracks, I remember thinking, I'm dropping this song. I remember thinking, this song is boring, I'm just not gonna make it. But then it sort of took form and became one of my favorites. And then

4:52there's weird things, like Neko sings lead on it, but her lead was actually supposed to be the harmony. There was actually a lead vocal by me that I just dropped, because I thought it sounded better when her vocal just became the lead vocal. So I like when that sort of stuff happens. Vocalizations, all of this, where you're like... the oohs and the ahs, and the breathing in and out while vocalizing stuff. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, that's all the group vocals. That's when you just get a bunch of people to sing, and you sift through it later. You're like, okay, what works, you know, because often you just bring somebody in there and they're just singing, and, you know, it's not very tightly arranged. And then you go like, oh, it's great if it breaks down to one vocal and then explodes into eight vocals. That

5:43comes a little later, just arranging it. Right. Like the song [inaudible], that was a real crazy vocal extravaganza. How come? You just had a lot of vocals. Well, Kelly Hogan, who sings with Neko, she guested on that song, and she had a lot of crazy stuff. And then it was Neko and Kathryn and then me, so it was a lot of singing on it. When you're sifting through it, how do you know when a song is done? In a lot of ways, it's not that difficult. It's just sitting down and just doing it. It isn't like, oh, there's too much to sift, it's not like I can't make the decision. It's just like you're almost too lazy. You're like, let's do this, I'm tired, let's get this. And

6:33I feel like we're getting better at just cutting things. You know, cutting things with extreme prejudice. It's like, does it work? Toss it. It's like, are we really gonna use this? Toss it. You know, it's like doing spring cleaning. You know, it's like, whatever, am I ever gonna listen to this record? No, toss it. Let's be honest with ourselves. Okay, I'm gonna say, without this, but have you ever gone back, and then in the live show been like, oh, we shouldn't have tossed that, let's add that part back into the song? You're wrong about tossing something? I guess I think other people have been wrong. It's funny, we've been rehearsing and listening to our old records and realizing that when you play a song live for a long time without listening to the record, our live versions

7:24are sort of moving away from what the recorded one was. So it was interesting to go, oh, there should be a vocal line there, I don't sing that vocal line there, and there should be that keyboard part there. What songs changed the most that you've realized in the past few days? What do you mean, like an old song? Yeah, well, when you're going through, figuring out, this doesn't sound like that anymore. Hmm. Well, they're just little parts. Yeah, it's pretty subtle. Maybe other people wouldn't notice. Yeah, but after, you know, 10 years of playing a song, we're going, like, is anybody doing this piano part that's in there? You know, and Blaine and I are looking at each other going, why aren't you doing that? We've been doing something else. How do you pick the setlist at this point, when you have so many records to pull from?

8:13Our favorites, I guess. Is it your favorites? Because that's... Yeah. One doesn't need to go over the best. Yeah, it can be tough, but it's also easy, and it's self-evident. Like, we don't want to play for three hours. So this is album six, so when we start touring this record, we're gonna be doing most of this record, and then that leaves time for like two or three songs per other record. So if we just go through the records and pick two or three songs, it's just self-evident. It's like, okay, what do we need to have from Mass Romantic? We'll do 'Mass Romantic' and 'Slow Descent'. Okay, what are we gonna do off Electric Version? We'll do 'The Laws Have Changed' and 'Testament to Youth in Verse', and then, you know, it just goes like that. Self-evident, how come, though? Because that's what that would be? Well, just because they became singles, or is that...? Well,

8:58those are just great songs. They're songs that people really want to hear. I mean, we could do the deep cuts off those records, but then people would be annoyed that we weren't playing... You know, a few people are really happy about those. You can kind of tell, you know, like when people are shouting out songs that they want you to play, which is really nice. But they do that all the time, you can't always hear it. But, you know, generally the same songs kind of get yelled, because they want to hear the older songs, and there'll be these specific songs. And I know when we've been on tour, there have been tours where we thought, let's shake up the setlist. Like, you get a setlist together and it works, but then you go, let's shake it up and do some other songs, and you go, oh, that didn't work as well. And you try another setlist and you go,

9:43that didn't work as well. And after about two weeks of touring, you find this set where you go, that works great. You know, those are all songs that people want to hear. And, you know, we sort of go by that, and then after a while it gets to the point where we're playing very similar sets because of that reason, maybe changing a few songs. Like, when I think of Twin Cinema, that's one of those records where I feel like we have to revolve, maybe because, I guess, as if you can call anything by us hits, I guess Twin Cinema is sort of a hit-filled record. It has the song 'Twin Cinema', it has 'Sing Me Spanish Techno' and 'The Bleeding Heart Show' and 'Use It', and then maybe one or two others, or 'Jackie, Dressed in Cobras'.

10:29So I feel like that's the one where we'll just rotate those songs out. Have you figured out what opens the show every night? Like, what works best as the first song people hear? Well, I think you mentioned it. I think... Well, we've only done one show playing new songs, and we opened with 'Brill Bruisers'. Okay, there you go. And it seemed like, yeah, this is a great opening song. It just seems natural, because it's the first song on the record. I mean, it just seems natural. Like, I think when we toured Together, we opened up with 'Moves' a lot, because it seemed like this is how the record starts. Yes. It's like a cool way. Isn't it the way the record starts? I think it is. It seems like a good way to start your set. So I think we're going with that.

11:17It's interesting to go back through the years and try and remember what we used to open with. The first few years we always opened with 'Slow Descent'. That was our big first number. What about playing other people's songs in these sets, or no? It's just New Porno songs? It's hard enough to get the band to learn our own songs. Unless it's a song that the band can learn in about five minutes, it's just hard to... Like, what's the last cover we learned? We learned the song 'Shocking You' by Shocking Blue one tour. I'm amazed we learned that one. Yeah, we just have too many songs at this point. 'Don't Bring Me Down' was... I can't remember why we learned that one. We did it for a French TV show. Oh, yeah.

12:05Nice. I just want to hear some Immaculate Machine songs. I feel like I'm never gonna hear them. There's so many. There's too many songs. I mean, if we were doing... I think when we're doing two-night stands. Well, it's just not that often. I think we're making [inaudible] though. Yeah, yeah, we're doing two shows there. So that's when I think we'll have to make some effort to really shake it up and figure out what we're gonna do. It does. Yeah, there's just too many songs at this point. A good problem to have, though, I think. Yeah, yeah, I mean, it's nice. It's nice to be able to cherry-pick. Because if I'm going back listening to a record and thinking, I'm so sick of that record, it's like, well, I gotta just find two songs from it that I like, and

12:53I do want to... kind of, he's practical. I'm curious about this hating the records thing, because I've heard you talk about it before. No, I don't want to go there. It was a joke. The F Word, I guess the movie's called What If now, with Daniel Radcliffe. I saw it at TIFF last year, and I found out you did the music for it. Yeah. Well, I did the score. Yeah, I did the score. I always qualify that because there's about three or four Patrick Watson songs that are very heavily featured. So when anybody says, oh, I really loved the score you did, I'm saying, well, I just did the incidental music. The guy singing beautifully, that was not me, that's Patrick Watson. But it must be different writing with something in mind, as opposed to just, you know, I'm in my room, I'm writing a song, whatever comes. Yeah, it was nice. It was a good thing. It was all done concurrently with this record, so it was a good thing.

13:46I think it helped the writing process, in that you look at a scene and you just start writing something. Like, I didn't have anything written. I thought, I got to write something. And just out of nothing, like, I had nothing written this morning, but today I got to write something. And you're not as precious about it. And I mean, the fact there's no lyrics for the most part makes it easier. It's like, all I got to do is come up with music. It's a cakewalk. Mm-hmm. There's just no stress. And also, because you're not precious about it, I would give Mike some music, and if he didn't think it worked, I'd go, okay, well, I'll trash it. Or, you know, if it doesn't work in the scene, it doesn't work in the scene. And then it just means I've got this extra... if I like it,

14:32it just means I've got this extra piece of music that I can rework and make into my own song. And that's what the song 'Backstairs' is. I thought there was one, you know, on the record. Yeah, but 'Backstairs' was just a little abandoned piece of soundtrack music that I just wrote into its own song. It's different. That's cool. Did it change your approach to writing at all? Like, did you learn anything about songwriting from writing to visuals, I guess? I don't know. It's not that difficult. All right. Not that difficult, what I do. I really think it's just... not like writing a novel. Did it get easier over time? What, for me? Yeah, I think so. I mean, I still haven't figured it out, but,

15:21you know, I think it's just, you've gotta put your head down and start working. That's good advice. I think you take for granted, though, that you have a really strong vision at the beginning, generally, when you start making a record. That it's easy? No, no, I think he's taking for granted his strong musical sensibility, because I don't think it's easy for everybody. That's all I'm saying. To make a record. Mm-hmm. You know. Versus... right. I mean, definitely versus writing a novel, because novels take like seven years. But some people's records take seven years too. I just don't understand why. Yeah. Yeah. No, I understand that, that wasn't my point. I just think people are lazy. That's my theory. I feel like for me, if I haven't done enough, it's because of laziness.

16:10I agree. You try to write a song a day? No, that would be different. I mean, for me, writing songs is like a long... Some people like to do that. It's funny, the songwriter Dan Wilson is in the middle of that right now. He's been tweeting about it. Oh, like Semisonic Dan Wilson? Yeah. Yeah, he co-writes with Adele and never has to work again. No. Because he writes with the Dixie Chicks, from Adele. But he's a very cool guy. I met him once. And yeah, he's doing that, writing a song a day. And for me, it's like I just have a lot of songs in the works. Like, I don't go, I've written a song, okay, that's done, here's a second song, here's a third song. Like, I have like 30 songs in the air at once, and

16:56so when people ask me how many songs have you got written, my answer is always, it's either zero or 30. I don't know. But I think for me, a lot of songwriting is wrapped up in the arrangement as well. Like, I don't know if I just approach it from a very different way. Like, there's one song I think I finally got there, and I think it's finally written, and it was just a riff that I wrote in 2009. I think we've tried recording it like three times. And I thought, this is a great riff, and I was trying to find a song for it. And then once I had the music, it was like, I can't find the melody for this, or I can't find the lyric. It just didn't fit. And then

17:41I feel like I just found it. It took five years, but I just found it. It's like, I think I got this song. Well, we haven't... oh no, yeah, okay. We started recording it. I think its working title was 'Master Class', but it's not gonna have that title. In fact, you're probably singing on it. It was an abandoned song, but I just trashed it. Okay. What song did you shoot the video for? We don't have much time. Okay, but we came in here and you were talking about the video. Yeah, how much fun it was. Yeah. Yeah, that's a really surreal, very creative video that we were on a shoot for yesterday. Yeah, Scott Cudmore is the director. Yeah, I mean, the concept, you're gonna be very vague about it. Yeah, gonna be vague about it.

18:27I should have asked. You're gonna be vague about it. But it was for 'Dancehall Domine'. Yes. Yeah, fun. Yeah, okay, five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay. Road or studio? Studio. Yes, studio. Lennon or McCartney? Both. Yeah, I can't make that choice. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Oh, melody. Melody. If someone's never heard the New Pornographers before, what song do they start with? 'Mass Romantic'. Oh yeah, okay. 'Brill Bruisers'. You can say different answers. How about the new... yeah, 'Brill Bruisers'. There's... Let's go with the new album. In one word, the New Pornographers? Brill. Awesome, thanks guys. Like we had that rehearsed. Yeah. Brill.

19:20It wasn't quite like that. We're supposed to have the... it wasn't as clean. We're supposed to do it like an argument. Brill. Bruisers.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →