← All interviews
Interview · June 2012 · Toronto

Grace Potter Interview

Grace Potter talks The Lion The Beast The Beat, writing the guitar solo for "Stars" on keyboard, recording with Dan Auerbach in Nashville and singing on Kenny Chesney's "You and Tequila", in this 2012 interview with Matt Schichter. Grace Potter is best known for "Paris (Ooh La La)", "Stars" and her duet with Kenny Chesney, "You and Tequila".

Bands and ArtistsCountry MusiciansIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusiciansPop Stars

Lennon or McCartney? Grace Potter’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Grace Potter said about the songs

“Stars”

Grace Potter says the song was never meant as country; the first demo sounded like Coldplay.

“it's not meant to be a country song, it's meant to be an accidental sort of country crossover, because when I wrote it, it sounded like 'Yellow,' Coldplay. It was totally not a country song, if you listen to the first demo.”

Watch the moment

Grace Potter wrote the guitar solo by singing it, then taught it to the band.

“for the 'Stars' guitar solo, I actually sang it first and then learned it on the keyboard and then taught it to the guys who then transferred it onto the guitar, but I always knew I wanted it to be a guitar part.”

Watch the moment

“The Lion The Beast The Beat”

Grace Potter explains the title track began as two songs, the first called Steady, that the band glued together.

“The first part used to be called 'Steady.'... And it was actually two tracks, but when we went to record it, we had a little bit of a Wilco Yankee Hotel Foxtrot moment, where we were like, well, let's just glue the songs together”

Watch the moment

“Runaway”

Grace Potter says she salvaged lyrics from scrapped songs for this one.

“I scrapped a bunch of other songs, but stole some lyrics from them that I liked and put them into songs like 'Runaway.'”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

Grace Potter InterviewInterview · 18:08 · 505 views
Archive footage

18:08 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #371 · Grace PotterJune 2012 · 00:18:21

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00I remember "Ah, Mary," you know, 2007. Oh my God. I love it. Thanks, man. I appreciate it. So let's talk about this record. Cool watch. Oh, that's really cool. It's from, no, it's not from your home state. It's from your home state. Oh, well, still close enough. The single that leads off the record, it's two songs essentially, right? Yes. The first part used to be called "Steady." Okay. And it was actually two tracks, but when we went to record it, we had a little bit of a Wilco Yankee Hotel Foxtrot moment, where we were like, well, let's just glue the songs together because we're going to do it anyways. Let's just play them and perform them together. And by the time we did do that, it just felt like it was one full piece of music.

0:47It wasn't really two different things, you know, so it was a really fun process to figure out how to produce it, you know. Who's playing the riff? Is that you or is that Scotty? That's Scotty. It's funny. I wrote the riff and a lot of the guitar solos on the keyboard, which is funny. If you listen to the record, same with "Stars." I wrote the guitar solo for "Stars." I wrote a few of the guitar solos with the guitar in mind, but tried to kind of create a guitar tone on a weird little Casio keyboard that I got in Spain for like 50 bucks. And I would put on like the really bad Casio tone and just play and sort of imagine. And then Benny learned the guitar part. I didn't realize it's a hard riff to play on guitar,

1:34just fingering-wise, it's a very strange riff. So it took a while to get to a point where, I almost tried to rewrite the riff so they could play it, but then they totally balled out and they nailed it. Do you typically write on guitar? No, I just am not that good of a guitar player and I'm a better piano player, so I mean, I can play the chords and I'm a rhythm guitarist, you know what I mean? I love playing guitar, but at the heart of it, I mean, don't ask me to play a guitar solo. Don't ask me to play scales, you know what I mean? But for writing it's different, right? You're writing this as chords and melodies, and you sit at a piano and do most of that? Yeah, and sometimes I'll sing them. So like for the "Stars" guitar solo, I actually sang it first and then learned it on the keyboard and then taught it to the guys who then transferred it onto the guitar, but I always knew I wanted it to be a guitar part. Right. You mentioned "Stars" a lot, so let's talk about that tune, because it is a country song.

2:22It is? You're pushing yourself into that world and you should accept the money. But it isn't, but it isn't, dude. It's funny because I think about the Eagles, I think about Jackson Browne, I think about these people that I love. Oh, you're talking 70s. You know, 70s, but that's the thing, I think if anything, that song to me is meant to be, it's not meant to be a country song, it's meant to be an accidental sort of country crossover, because when I wrote it, it sounded like "Yellow," Coldplay. It was totally not a country song, if you listen to the first demo. It was really, you won't hear it exactly, but if you ever were sneaky and got on my computer and heard it, you would hear it's more along the lines of even the Avett Brothers have a few songs that really, I wanted it at the core to be an acoustic song and a very,

3:08very simple sentiment that was being sort of passed over. But then Kenny got his hands on it, and I don't know if you've heard the Kenny version. I was going to ask you, how did that not be on it? You know, I don't want to be anybody's protege necessarily, and I think Kenny is a dear, dear friend, and the song means a lot to him. It's something that he actually asked if he could record with me. He heard the version that we have on the record: "That's such a great song. I would love to re-cut it. I would really love to cut it with you guys and try it in Nashville." Just come down, because we were already going to be in Nashville during the Willie Nelson thing. From the bonus cut. Also, not on the record. These massive stars, not on other records. Well, you know, this is not that kind of record.

3:53I think it wasn't like a star-studded event. It was more of a band coming into their own on their own and getting a little darker and a little more evil than we usually do. Yeah, that tune, "Loneliest Soul." "Loneliest Soul," yeah. That's a weird tune. Yeah, it's a weird song, huh? Kind of sick, like bass groove tune, but I don't know what that rhythm is. Boogie. Yeah, spooky. That was one that we did with Dan Auerbach. So actually Dan produced that track, and we did that one in Nashville with Dan where we were listening to, oh, I mean, the influences on this record are pretty broad. Like, you listen to... They're there for you, though. Oh, always. But I wasn't listening to pop music. I was listening to lots of weird kind of Bollywood and some strange... Yeah, okay, I hear that. Yeah, yeah, like, especially on "Turntable" and "The Divide," you can hear the Bollywood stuff.

4:41But I also just, I tried not to listen to any pop music, like at all, over the course of the whole record. I didn't really want to, even 60s and 70s rock, I just kind of wanted to get away from it and just let us be our own temple and kind of build our own thing. And it really worked well, because you can hear how many different... It spans... Oh yeah, it's an eclectic record. But it still sonically fits. Yeah, yeah. Maybe that's the track listing. The track order has a lot to do with that, also the fact that we recorded it in so many different places. When I came back together with the producer, Jim Scott, and myself, I co-produced the record, and Dan co-producing, it was like, how do we make all these pieces fit? And there's a little bit of like a tessellation kind of conversation about...

5:28Yeah, but you know, that's what this record is. It's a tessellation of different ideas and shapes that all somehow fit together. So when did you, because I heard that you scrapped it at some point? I did. So do any of those songs make the cut in a different way? They did. Or did you redo every song just for the hell of it? No, I recut everything. But I mean, I kept a few of the songs, but I had a pile of songs in the fall that felt pretty much like a hit record, you know? But all the songs just sort of didn't feel the same. They didn't feel like they were connected to each other. I had like 13 or 15 songs that were just sort of floating around together. And I didn't feel like they were tied down to anything. It was just sort of a lot of ideas coming in from the outside. I wanted this record to be a soulful record that had a heartbeat at the center of it.

6:18And a lot of those lyrics kept sort of turning up the... And that's why it's called The Lion the Beast the Beat, is because so much of the record sort of comes back to that sort of human instinct. Well, you referenced it too. Don't you want to know something? The beat, I think? The beat, I referenced it in "Roulette," I referenced it in "Timekeeper." I referenced it in "Runaway." So was it written first and then you decided, let's try and tie it together? No, it was actually accidental. It was the other way. The lyric just kept coming back. And I started feeling really unoriginal. I'm like, can I think of a better word? Like, what's my problem, you know? That means it's a hit. That means it's got something. Maybe it was just those themes just kept coming back. So after scrapping, what did you do? I heard you went to Big Sur, which is like my favorite. I went to Big Sur, I actually continued north up to Carmel and really kind of enjoyed

7:05the idea of just being on a road trip by myself. I haven't been just by myself in a long time. What, like a notepad? Notepad and a guitar and some mushrooms. Shrooms, okay. All right. And I wandered off into the, I wasn't on shrooms driving. It was just like I would stop and wander into the woods for like, you know, a half a day or something. Okay, that's right. But I really, I know, of course, I better not. But I tried to get back to what the thing was. I thought we were doing at the beginning of the record, which was, I want to make an important, every record should be important. Every record should feel great and epic and wonderful. And to me it felt like I had a bunch of songs that could or might be on the radio. They're all kind of B-plus, A-minus kind of pop songs.

7:51And it was like all the things that it was a dream for a record company, with any other pop artist that could record them and turn them into whatever they want to be. But that's not what we are. You know, like I don't want to be Katy Perry at all. You know, I don't want to be Adele. I don't. I love, I respect them as artists, but that's not what I want. I want to have a career where when I'm, you know, 55, 60, 65, 70, I'm still singing these songs. And then it's not like a, aw shucks, like, I don't really want to be doing this, but I'm going to do it anyway. I mean, I don't want those songs. So I scrapped anything I had any questions or doubts about and started over. So what stuck? "Stars" stuck? Okay. "Keepsake" stuck.

8:36And then also the idea of "The Lion the Beast the Beat," which was like you were saying at the beginning of the interview, there were two songs. Sure. I had half of each song. I really had the lyrics quite completed. And I wanted that to be a real opus. You know, I wanted that to tell a pretty broad story and cover a lot of ground. So I wrote and finished that. I also finished "Timekeeper," finished "Parachute Heart." I scrapped a bunch of other songs, but stole some lyrics from them that I liked and put them into songs like "Runaway." And then I also wrote from scratch "The Divide." I also wrote a few other songs that I loved, but the whole point of leaving was so that I could come back and be with the band and figure out what the band wanted to do.

9:26So I brought 13 new songs to the band in January and played all of them. And we reviewed everything that we had recorded and then all the new ideas that I came back with. And I just wanted to record the ones that the band loved, basically, because that's what it's all about. I mean, we have to tour on this record for a year and a half, two years, better love every single song. And the band has to love them too. So I just went with the songs that we all played well enough together. Talking about the tour and the stadium shows, could you play "The Lion the Beast the Beat"? Oh yeah, oh my God. Because that's a stadium song. We did it. We opened with it. It's funny, because of course the country audience doesn't know what to do with us. That's a stadium song. It's a stadium song, all right. It's very fun to play live. I mean, you know, the structure of the song,

10:13a lot of times we'll record a song and then when we bring it out live, it changes. Not so with "The Lion the Beast the Beat." I knew that song was just like, it was written and built for a stadium. You're right. So I really... Cool. That's awesome. I know we don't have much time, so I want to go back a little bit. I just want to know about this artist compound you grew up in, so I can start the article with this, because obviously that's going to inform who you became. Yeah, yeah. So it's a compound of just painters and sculptors. I guess my dad and my mom, but what happened was that my dad's company, he's a sign maker and he had like 11 or 12 employees, so the whole space was constant. It's like billboards? My dad makes signs. He does a lot of signs for Ben & Jerry's ice cream. Oh, right. And he does a lot of the American Skiing Company stuff. So if you ever go on a ski trip in a state... Oh, sure, I'll pay attention to that.

10:58Yeah, exactly. Well, that's where I live. Oh, okay. Yeah, I mean, I'm from Mad River Glen, but also out in Utah. He did the Canyons Resort. He's done a lot of the bigger ski resorts out west, but he's a sign maker, and so there were all these people around all the time that were trying to figure out what these kids were doing there. I mean, I thought it was a commune basically, but it was actually just my family with a bunch of employees cruising around all the time. So no one else lived on the compound with us. Okay. It was just that they were there all day, so it felt very communal. There were all these different buildings. One was for the fabrication of the signs, one was for the painting and the vinyl printing, and one was an office for all the business side of it.

11:43And my mom had her own building for her bowl company. She used to paint hand-painted wooden bowls, beautiful wooden bowls from Vermont. You should sell them at the merch table. I know, right? Her price point's a little higher than our CDs. Sure. And they also had a production company in the 70s called Dreamon Productions, which was actually a slideshow multimedia company before MTV was around, or VH1, or any of these sort of music television channels. My parents would cruise around and tour with music and slides and take pictures. They did the 1980 Olympics, they went on cruises and they'd take pictures all day, they'd develop the film, they'd put it to music and then show it that night in

12:29the bar so people could come to the bar and see themselves. Very cool idea. So Dreamon Productions had this plethora of albums, so that's how I grew up listening to all this different music. Like what? Summer or something? Oh, Spooky Tooth, the Kinks, The Band, a lot of Beatles, Bob Dylan, Joni Mitchell and Maggie Bell, I grew up with a lot of Jefferson Airplane. Basically all the records with cool record covers, Jethro Tull, King Crimson, The Who. I loved The Who. My dad was like, "Those guys are on cocaine, Grace, that's bad stuff." And I just loved it, because there was like "Teenage Wasteland," when they get faster and faster at the end, I remember my dad being like, "That is cocaine, don't do that." It's cocaine and genius. Yeah, exactly.

13:14It's genius, exactly. But you know, it was just a great way to grow up listening to all that. Classic music and not realizing it was classic, I thought it was pop music, I didn't realize that there was new music out there. Well, you grew up, you're my age, so the 80s, and there's not so much going on. I mean, I knew Michael Jackson and Madonna and that was basically it. Yeah. And those were the only two good things that came from it. That's not true, like Talking Heads. Oh yeah, Talking Heads. Talking Heads and, yeah, there's a few other good things that happened in the 80s, but not too many. Okay, so five quick questions, one-word answer. Okay. Road or studio? Road. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Rhythm. Song you've written you're most proud of?

14:05And it's one-word answers, that's what I think. In one word, Grace Potter and the Nocturnals... Rowdy. I'll have a little bit of a three-word sound clip. And I got two Twitter questions from the same chick, but I said I'd ask them anyway. Fine. Will there be a video out for "Stars," and will there be a video for "El Cerrito Place"? Oh my goodness. Okay, yes, there's a video out for "Stars" that's actually coming out on, it's debuting Saturday at 8 a.m. on VH1 in the US. I don't know if it'll be in Canada. So yes, it's actually debuting this weekend, it's a big deal, 8 a.m. on the VH1 channel. And "El Cerrito Place," I don't know anything about a music video, Kenny hasn't talked to

14:52me about it. Yeah, "El Cerrito Place" is a new, it's Kenny's next single, but I'm not featured on it, I'm just like a backup singer, you know, on this particular song. So whereas with "You and Tequila" it's Kenny Chesney featuring Grace Potter, on this the name isn't actually in print. I love being like the ghost in the background. I'm kind of like Joni Mitchell backstage at, you know, The Last Waltz, where she's behind the curtain, that's me. I love that moment. Oh my God, I know, can you see that they're trying to, like, the 70s airbrush? Yeah, that's kind of a... Like the bad job that they did trying to airbrush it out, oh my God, I know. Well, they're just standing around, like, keep asking questions, are you cool with this? I'm totally cool with this. The T Bone record. Oh yeah.

15:37Yeah, it's shelved. It's not a hit saying that, but. Because you're really pushing yourself, and you said you're not before, but you're kind of delving into the country world more and more. Yeah, and that record actually, I mean, it's the farthest thing from country. I mean, that record was, it's a fucking awesome record. It's a really cool record. But the thing is, it's T Bone with his band, so it's not the Nocturnals, which is why it didn't go out. Is this the Plant/Krauss band? This is basically all the same guys from the Plant/Krauss era. And it's Dennis Crouch on the bass guitar, Marc Ribot playing guitar. This amazing guy Keefus is sort of a madman keyboard player, and also Jim Keltner on the drums. It's huge. So I didn't really, I didn't know what the record company was going to do with that record.

16:26I was just so excited to take the opportunity to work with T Bone. Sure. And at that time, the band was in a bit of limbo. And so I just kind of, I'm a very proactive person, so I just went out and made a record. I said, well, we'll figure out what we're doing as a band. I'm going to go do this. Right. It was a bit of a crossroads for the band. And I love that the record company recognized that, you know, it was not the end of days for Grace Potter and the Nocturnals. They saw a couple of our live shows and watched some footage of us at Bonnaroo. And it completely reignited the record company's belief, in fact. One of the

17:20things that I was talking about was the band's band. They just said, this is too good to just put out a T Bone Burnett record with all this energy and electric energy going on. So they said, just go back to the studio. It's not that we don't love the T Bone record. It's that, Grace, you know, the band deserves a platform here. Sure. It's a pretty cool thing for a record company to do. Yeah. Especially at that level. Oh my God. I mean, and with T Bone, they knew that they were looking at like an easy million records, because it was T Bone. You know what I mean? So the fact that they dug their feet in and said, you know, you really need to make sure that this is the right thing and that the Nocturnals get properly represented, I thought that was great. So the T Bone Burnett record is, as we like to say, on the back burner, because it will

18:07see the light of day. It's just a question of what the right platform is for it, you know? Cool. They're all staring at me, so I'll let you go. I think we're a second ago. You're getting stared at? Thank you. Well, they're staring at you too. You're so invested with everything. I'm very excited for the show. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →