← All interviews
Interview · June 2011 · Edmonton

Sarah McLachlan Interview

Sarah McLachlan talks Laws of Illusion, touring after Lilith with no opening acts, bringing her kids on the road, learning on ukulele, and the stories behind "Building a Mystery", "Fallen" and "Loving You Is Easy", backstage at the Jubilee in Edmonton with Matt Schichter. McLachlan is best known for "Angel", "Building a Mystery", "Adia" and "I Will Remember You", and for founding Lilith Fair.

Bands and ArtistsMusiciansPop Stars

In the collection Canadian Music

Lennon or McCartney? Sarah McLachlan’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Sarah McLachlan said about the songs

“Building a Mystery”

Sarah McLachlan summed up what the song is about.

“'Building a Mystery' is essentially about creating an interesting facade for yourself because you're masking insecurities or something, and, you know, putting forth a really creative and mysterious exterior. Pretty simple. It's sort of like a character study, really”

Watch the interview

“Fallen”

Sarah McLachlan explained the meaning of "Fallen".

“Well, it's about screwing up, and I think it speaks to a really common human condition of falling into patterns and making the same mistakes over and over again, and, you know, trying to pull yourself out of that and taking a different path.”

Watch the interview

“In Your Shoes”

Sarah McLachlan said the song grew out of one opening line, which led her to think about bullying and her own childhood.

“Like 'In Your Shoes' started with 'you turn the radio on and play your favorite song and cry', and then I had to figure out, where does that come from? What does it mean? Why did I say that? And how do I mine that? And, you know, thinking about bullying, thinking about myself as a kid”

Read it in the transcript

Sarah McLachlan said a vocal part in the chorus was moved over from another section of the song.

“And in the chorus of 'In Your Shoes', there's a lead vocal and this... And that was actually from another part, and we thought, hey, that would sound good over here, and so we stuck it over there.”

Read it in the transcript

“Lullaby”

Sarah McLachlan explained that "Lullaby" began as a charity auction prize, with lyrics from the winning bidder.

“one of the auction items was I would personally write a lullaby for someone, for lots of money... he said, well, I have some lyrics. And so he sent me those lyrics, and literally three or four hours later I'm like, okay, I know exactly what to do with this.”

Read it in the transcript

“Loving You Is Easy”

Sarah McLachlan described "Loving You Is Easy" in a sentence.

“'Loving You Is Easy' is just a simple, joyous, fluffy, first-throes-of-lust love song, where after, you know, a long dry spell, you think there's possibility, it can happen.”

Watch the interview

“Flesh and Blood”

Sarah McLachlan said the song's guitar part started out on piano.

“'Flesh and Blood', the guitar part, that was a piano part originally, but it sounded too much like Coldplay”

Read it in the transcript

VIDEOWatch

Sarah McLachlan InterviewInterview · 11:44 · 19,000 views
Sarah McLachlan Interview, with Matt Schichter
Sarah McLachlan InterviewInterview · 11:41 · 4,500 views
Sarah McLachlan Interview, with Matt Schichter
Sarah McLachlan InterviewInterview · 6:17 · 170 views
Archive footage

3 clips · 29:42 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #308 · Sarah McLachlanJune 2011 · 00:06:34

Episode #660 · Sarah McLachlan #2May 2014 · 00:12:03

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

Part 1

0:0395.7 The Sound. Sarah McLachlan, I'm sitting here backstage with her at the Jubilee in Edmonton, and such a pleasure to be sitting down with you. New record, Laws of Illusion, absolutely lovely. You're on tour now. How's the tour going? Oh, fantastic. It's really, really amazing. It's my, I think, my funnest show yet. Well, it's different than I think anything you've done. Yeah, it's a lot more inclusive. In the past we've always had opening acts, you know, which is great, and I've had the luxury to choose. But this time around, after doing Lilith this summer, I ended up playing with a bunch of the musicians who are in my band. They are also solo artists, songwriters, and I ended up going and playing in their sets, and the rest of my band followed. So when we were putting this tour together: well, why would we have opening acts? We were already all up on stage together playing, so let's just do one big mashup. And also, for me,

0:52you know, I feel like I have a pretty great audience, and I think they're pretty open-minded, and I really want to give these gals as much of a step up as I can, as opposed to... Oh, Butterfly Boucher, she's my bass player, great songwriter, and Melissa McClelland as well, in my band. People are getting their money's worth. This is like a three-hour show, from what I'm told. I think it's almost three hours in the end. Yeah, there's a 15-minute intermission in the middle. I do a lot of Q&A, which is really fun too. Really? How do you pull that off? You put like a microphone in the audience? Well, that would be very time-consuming. So when we thought this through, we thought, let's get people to ask questions. They write them down on a piece of paper at the merch table, it goes in a box, and then they come up on stage and get put in a little hat, and a couple times throughout the show I'll answer questions. And I pretty much will answer anything. Nice. What's a crazy question?

1:39There haven't been really crazy ones. There's been, you know, a couple real lowbrow ones, like, you know, does the carpet match the drapes, and things like that. But, you know, that's just really... okay. But, you know, it runs the gamut from stupidity like that to, you know, what's your sense of spirituality? And, you know, it is... but okay. Well, do you have a bottle of wine and three hours? I mean, it's not a quick and simple 30-second blurb, which you kind of need to do, unless you want to be going till 3 o'clock in the morning, which, you know, I don't think the house would like, because, you know, there's always curfews, right? So the kids are on the road with you? Yes, they are. They went out to the bus about half an hour ago. I think my little one's gonna come watch a few songs. It's very McCartney. Every time I see a family on the road,

2:27I always think of McCartney back in the '70s bringing the family on the road. It's a luxury to be able to take my kids with me. I couldn't do this if I had to leave them at home. It just wouldn't be possible for me. They're my number one priority, and luckily they both take to it like pigs, you know. They just love being out here. And I homeschool my oldest. I spend like an hour and a half every day with her teaching in the morning, and we just go swimming. We went to West Edmonton Mall today and on one of the roller coasters. So fun. Are they into music? Are they playing anything? They're not playing so much. Yeah, India, my oldest one, took piano lessons for a couple years, but it didn't go so well, because she's not one of those... She's like a punk rocker, you know. She doesn't want anybody telling her what to do. 'But Mommy, I already know how to do that.'

3:14So she's a bit tricky. I think my younger one might be interested, but, you know, I feel like they are almost rebelling against it because they see me doing it. But they're both very musical. They sing and they dance, and they both have pretty good pitch. You need to use them as a choir on a track. Yeah, you never know. They clam up whenever there's the mic, you know. I go, here, sing. What was first for you, guitar, piano? What did you grow up on? Ukulele. When I was four years old. Yeah, ukulele. I wanted to be Joan Baez when I was four, but I was too small to hold a guitar. Oh, she's got just one of those beautiful, pure, honey-like voices. And I doubt I could hit all the notes back then, but I really loved her. And so my mom got me a ukulele, and then I moved on to classical guitar, and then started taking piano,

4:02I think when I was eleven. It's interesting, because a lot of kids rebel against the piano. I loved it. I mean, a family moved away and gave us their old upright, and I loved it, because, you know, coming from a guitar background, piano felt so simple, and I got it instantly. I could just play things by ear, because all the notes are laid out. And so it was a much easier instrument for me to learn. What do you find easier to write on these days, piano? I'm more fluid on piano, more natural. I can let go and sort of have the two entities separate, whereas guitar, I feel a lot more beholden to getting the notes right. I'm just not quite as comfortable on it while singing at the same time. I know we're a little rushed, because you've got to get on stage in like 15 minutes, but I was hoping we'd get a couple of storytellers clips from you on a few of the songs we play on the station. Sure, I can try.

4:52I might not remember. Terrible, this, but okay. 'Loving You Is Easy' is just a simple, joyous, fluffy, first-throes-of-lust love song, where after, you know, a long dry spell, you think there's possibility, it can happen. You know, all the flowers start blooming and birds start singing. It's like springtime. 'Fallen'. 'Fallen'. Oh, now you're getting me, I have to think of the lyrics. Well, it's about screwing up, and I think it speaks to a really common human condition of falling into patterns and making the same mistakes over and over again, and, you know, trying to pull yourself out of that and taking a different path. Cool. And 'Building a Mystery'. 'Building a Mystery' is essentially about

5:42creating an interesting facade for yourself because you're masking insecurities or something, and, you know, putting forth a really creative and mysterious exterior. Pretty simple. It's sort of like a character study, really, like that. We do something called five questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay. Road or studio? Eesh. Depending on my mood, but today, road. Yeah. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. Most important thing in a song: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. Song you've written you're most proud of? 'Angel'. And in one word, Sarah McLachlan? One word. One word.

6:32Goof.

Part 2

0:00I don't know, how many vocal tracks are on that thing, do you think? Just the oohs and the ba-pas and the ahs, and there's so much stuff on it. No more so than normal, I think. I like doing backgrounds, and I like using my voice as an instrument, so it usually ends up on there. How do you use it in different ways? I'm asking about using your voice as an instrument because no one does it better than you, and I'm fascinated by it. Thank you. Talk to Bobby McFerrin. He's pretty good. Okay, fine, Bobby McFerrin is pretty good too. I won't deny that. Yeah, yeah, true. But yeah, I mean, it's a tool that I have, and it's versatile, so I like to play with it

0:49and do as much as I can with it. Usually when we're tracking... And in the chorus of 'In Your Shoes', there's a lead vocal and this... And that was actually from another part, and we thought, hey, that would sound good over here, and so we stuck it over there. I've heard you talk about that, how the chorus from this song will end up in this verse and you'll mix it together. And it's a process too. I mean, it is a bit of piecing together puzzles. I mean, that actually didn't happen so much on this record, because the songs melodically came out a little more in their entirety, whereas with a lot of other records there'd be, I've just got a verse for a year and I have no chorus. But I noticed when you played the song on Q today, just on the piano, you were doing Luke's guitar parts on the piano.

1:36That's right? Yeah, but the solo part, I wrote that on piano. Okay. And that was doing my question. And I asked the guitar player to play that, overdub that. Thank you very much. I'm curious, where do songs typically start for you? It will start melodically. No, I mean, on what instrument? Usually piano. I tend to write mostly on piano, although I went back to guitar. 'Song for My Father' was on guitar. But it's nice to have the ability to move around both instruments. I find as a songwriting tool it's great: if you're at a certain place and you're stuck with a chord progression or whatever, you take it to a different instrument, and it'll usually spark something different. Is it safe to say the dominant instrument we hear on a track is usually what it started with, or does it change from time to time?

2:22Well, 'Flesh and Blood', the guitar part, that was a piano part originally, but it sounded too much like Coldplay, so I... The heavy intro that you made for me for the last night? Yeah, I like it. That's the Smiths thing, yeah. Smiths. I hear that too. Yeah, yeah. Or U2. I know, I've heard that reference as well, but... It's all right. Or Sarah McLachlan. Thank you. Yeah, I think so. What I'm gonna take is about trying to be... I always wonder about this when you're seven records deep, and artists always talk about trying to reinvent themselves, and the song kind of talks about that a little bit too. Well, that was an interesting one to do. That was actually for King Kong, which is going to be a Broadway musical. It started in Australia. I think there's this 50-plus-foot animatronic gorilla that they have on stage, and Marius de Vries was doing the music for it, and he approached me and asked me if I wanted to

3:08write a song for it, for the part of Ann. It's such a great story, and it was interesting to have sort of that template from which to write, where it's not just coming out of my head, out of the... pulling it from the author. It's like, no, here's a story, write about it, and write about her struggle. I'm like, oh, I know how to write about struggle. I can do this. Sure. And it was fun, and it was for Broadway, right? I have a lot of song ideas that are a little... I don't want to say schmaltzy, but they're a little too far in that direction, and I tend to sort of leave them for something else, when something like a movie or something comes along, it makes more sense for them than having it on the record. That being said, it is on the deluxe version. Oh, it's just on the deluxe. That's why people should get the deluxe version. Yeah. There's a couple extra tracks, and there's a really sweet little lullaby on there as well.

3:54Yeah. Little B. Little B. I wrote that down. Lullaby. It had to close the record, obviously. Well, what happened was, I have a free music school in Vancouver, and we had a big charity event, and one of the auction items was I would personally write a lullaby for someone, for lots of money. And this lovely man, who's actually a friend of mine, gave me lots of money to write this lullaby, and about six months later he found me and said, so how's that lullaby going? I'm like, oh God, I forgot. Sorry, Frank. And he said, well, I have some lyrics. And so he sent me those lyrics, and literally three or four hours later I'm like, okay, I know exactly what to do with this. And it was so easy to write the song, having those words. They were so sweet. Do you find that for yourself as a writer? Do you ever write the words first?

4:40No. Very rarely. The music comes first, melody with maybe one or two lyrics. Like 'In Your Shoes' started with 'you turn the radio on and play your favorite song and cry', and then I had to figure out, where does that come from? What does it mean? Why did I say that? And how do I mine that? And, you know, thinking about bullying, thinking about myself as a kid, sitting on the couch, feeling sorry for myself because I had no friends, you know, playing my double record, double Genesis Live, and bawling my eyes out. But that must have informed you as an artist. Oh, absolutely. I think everyone, that shows you that kind of trauma. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's the hard stuff that you push up against. That's, I think, what defines most of us. That's when you figure out what you're made of, when you can work through that stuff and come out on the other side. What did you learn from this record about what you're made of,

5:26now that you've gone through it and talked about it a lot? I'm a survivor. I have a pretty great work ethic. This is great. This is great. It's a nice thing about myself. Let's go for it. I think I have a healthy dose of self-loathing and self-doubt, which continues to propel me as a musician, certainly as an artist, but as a human being too, to try and not be so hard on myself and recognize that we are all human, we're all fallible, we make mistakes, and again, it's what you do with those mistakes. As a mom of two girls, what advice would you offer for raising a grounded daughter? I would say live by example, teach by example. I found that whenever I try and teach by saying things, you should do this, you should do that, instantly they go deaf and don't want to hear anything.

6:12A very smart man once said to me, you want your kids to eat their vegetables? Just eat your vegetables and say, I love these vegetables, I love how they make me feel, they taste so good, and leave it at that. If you're like, oh, you know, it's good to eat these because they're good for you, they're going to be like, I don't care, I want candy. So I think that's a really good lesson for me, to try and lead by example. And of course I can't keep my mouth shut. I do try and tell them certain things, but, you know, I'm a working mom, and I think it's important for them to see, as young girls who are going to become young women, that I do work. I love my job, I'm passionate about what I do, and it informs the rest of my life. I say... they get mad at me sometimes and say, why are you always gone? Like, my little girl said to me the other day, how come you never pick me up from school anymore? I said, honey, I've picked you up every day for the last six years, with the exception of

7:01the last couple months. Mommy's been really busy. I have this job which I really love, and I say, when I do this thing that I do, it really fulfills me in a lot of ways, and I come back and I'm a way better mommy for it. So I do try and explain that, the balance. And I say, you know, I'm also really lucky because I get a chunk of time off in between, and, oh, you don't remember that right now, but, you know, I was home with you for a lot of years, and you came with me, so. They come on over here? They do, yeah. That's cool. It's going to be a little more challenging now, because my oldest is 12, and, you know, she's in grade six. [inaudible] Well, and school is tough, and it's hard to take them out of school. I mean, when she was younger I homeschooled her for a couple weeks, which, you know, wasn't that hard. It's just, you know, she was in grade one, I could manage that. Now it's like grade six math, I'm like, I'm already lost.

7:49So we all have phones now with calculators. Oh my God, see, Mommy needs to Google this, just give me a minute. What are your tips for instilling an appreciation of music and the arts in kids? Introducing them to a lot of different kinds of music at an early age is great. What do you play around the house? Tom Waits, Joni Mitchell, Cat Stevens, Coldplay, Peter Gabriel, U2, Annie Lennox. Pretty broad spectrum. And then they say, can we please turn this off and listen to Top 40? Well, you like the happy song. I love that. Oh, and that's great. I mean, we bonded over that, because basically, you know, that song comes on in the morning and we all just get up and start dancing.

8:34And we have dance parties. We do, often before bedtime we have little dance parties to get the ya-yas out. The ya-yas out. That's the Rolling Stones record. Get Yer Ya-Ya's Out. What are some of your favorite things to cook? A favorite recipe for you? I am more of a baker than a cook, although I've kind of gone into cooking a little more because it's more forgiving. Baking is kind of particular, but I love pies. I make a wicked rhubarb pie. But I'm very much into comfort food, like, you know, beautiful mac and cheese with lobster, and a little butterfat and sugar. I mean, I'm terrible. But I make a wicked salad. I've got some really great kale recipes, and braised lamb shank.

9:21That's a good one. Cool. And oh, also, I just harvested my rhubarb, and I stole this from Jean-Georges at ABC Kitchen in New York, but fresh ricotta and rhubarb compote with pepper and olive oil, and you dip your bread into that. Oh, it's like heaven. Yeah, I know, I'm going to have to make it now. I'm going to find some rhubarb. You can mail me something. I think it would have been nice. You travel a lot, obviously. I do. For your job. In all of your travels, where have you felt most welcomed? Probably Thailand. Oh, how come? That's interesting. I don't know. Well, because they're a very loving, welcoming people. They're very kind and generous of spirit, you know. They seem to really love people, and I went traveling all through there.

10:07In India as well. I spent a lot of time in India. Well, I went 13 years ago now, and just really warm and open. Everybody, come on and have a cup of tea, and it's very, very communal. Very community. Yeah, which is great. I mean, you know, here we're all so isolated and separated and on our devices all the time. As are they, but still, you know, when you're with a culture where people are crammed together, you just have to get along. You have to learn how to get along when you're in that kind of situation. You can't just go and close your door and be by yourself. There is no being by yourself. So I think they have a much greater understanding of how to communicate and how to be in a community. What are your favorite places to visit in Canada? Tofino, West Coast of Vancouver.

10:53Surfing. Absolutely. Cold-water surfing. Yeah. San Jose del Cabo in Mexico, for surfing without the wetsuit. I love New York City. I love Paris. But usually quiet. When I travel personally, for myself, it's to escape. It's to go someplace quiet where there are no big cities and noise. Right. Well, that actually is the next one. Where do you go to relax? [inaudible] get off the ferry. Yeah, it was beautiful too. It feels like Jurassic Park. Two and a half if you drive like mad people. Is that how you drive? You're a fast driver? Sometimes, if I don't have the kids with me. If you don't have the kids, it's very smart. Yes. Safety first. Precious cargo. What are a few of your favorite family travel destinations?

11:38Tofino. Mexico, Hawaii for sure. I love the Big Island. It's my favorite. We try and go there at least once a year, which is very decadent. I'm really simple. I'm very habitual. I go to the same restaurants. So it seems Tofino's the answer for everything. Yeah. Well, it's my happy place. I love Tofino. It's heaven on earth. Thanks, Sarah. Appreciate it.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →