Lennon or McCartney? Jon Foreman & Tim Foreman answered: McCartney, Ringo. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Switchfoot said about the songs
“Yesterdays”
Switchfoot explained the song is about loss and was co-written by the Foreman brothers.
“I wrote that with Tim, and, you know, for both of us it kind of takes on different meanings, for where we were when we wrote it. But I mean, essentially it's a song about loss”
Switchfoot recalled how quickly the song came together late one night in Portland.
“it was like, yeah, one or two in the morning, and Jon had this really pretty melody. And he had, actually, Yesterdays was one of the lyrics, and melody... it really actually kind of wrote itself pretty quickly, in a matter of like 20 or 30 minutes.”
VIDEOWatch
22:23 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #98 · SwitchfootMarch 2007 · 00:22:22
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00We have our own private place now. Yeah, last time I was in here was talking Jurassic 5. Nice. You guys fans of them? Yeah. Yeah. You do a cover of Crazy in Love, so you got a little bit... Yeah, man. You know. Beyoncé... I see you busting that on tour. God Only Knows, any of those covers. Your version is awesome. Oh, thanks, man. That's like sacred ground. You know, you can't screw that up. So, but yeah, we've done a few covers. We did the Bad Religion, Sorrow. That's kind of a... Okay, cool. Kind of a good... I don't know. That's one of my favorite Bad Religion songs. That's a little different for you guys. That song is amazing, man. We all grew up
0:46listening to Bad Religion and all the Epitaph bands. Oh, really? It's just up the road. Yeah. And like the surf videos back then. It wasn't so much Jack Johnson, it was pretty much like, you know, all the Pennywise and Sprung Monkey and all those bands. So that's kind of, I guess, if you went surfing, that was what you listened to on the way down to the beach, you know. A little more pump-up than the surf music is now. Yeah. Yeah. Have you seen the video, though, the Broke Down Melody movie? I love his... I think his films are a lot better than his music. You know, I think he's great. I think his films are amazing. They're great. They really capture the vibe of what it is to be on the road in a foreign country, you know, trying to find surf. Trying to find that up here. Yeah. Yeah. We will get some tomorrow, actually. Oh, really? Yeah. Where are you, Edmonton? Oh, the mall there has... Oh, yeah, of course. I've never been up there. Yeah. So we usually bring boards in, you know, just to try and see what we can scare up, you know. So we're going to try and see if we can
1:54kind of block everybody out of the way, pull it for an hour, and see what we can do. That'd be amazing. Yeah. I'm sure you got the star power now. Just try. You know, you got to try. If you know anyone up there, let them know we're coming. Do you notice that a lot? Like, you have the star power now, where you can just, you know, I'm Switchfoot, get me in the restaurant? No, man. It works the other way. Yeah. You're trying to get into the country or something. Hey, we're playing a show up here in Canada. And they're like, oh, yeah, you got the weed on the bus? Yeah. Go over there. It's like the long hundred-person line. I think the funny thing is when people, they'll come, like we had this one meal where everyone in the restaurant came over and wanted a picture and autograph. You know, it's cool. It's really fun, and people are friendly, we're friendly. But at the same time, it can be a little awkward, because it kind of almost presupposes the idea that you want people to notice you, you know. And
2:54yeah, I have a really hard time with that, you know, because I'm fairly awkward in that situation, you know. I don't know. It's just, it's supposed to be an awkward thing to people. You know, you're kind of like a product in that regard. Yeah. And then people, like if people ask, so you're in a band, you know, what band are you in? And then they apologize if they haven't heard of you, which is kind of a strange phenomenon, because it's like the idea is that there's some desire to be everywhere, to be a household name, you know, which I don't think we've ever had as a band, you know. So it's the type of thing where it's like, oh, there's no need to apologize. You know, we're loving exactly where we're at, you know. But at the same time, you know, you're writing music probably to get out there to people, right?
3:40To send a message. I mean, there's a lot of political songs on this record. At least the record starts off that way. Yeah. You know, you kind of want people at least to think, right? Well, you want to get the songs out there. But certainly I think the point of the music is never to get your face out there, you know. And I think a lot of times songs can change the world in very subtle ways, you know. They affect maybe the scenery of the stage more than the dialogue, you know, but it affects the plot in a much more subtle way, you know. I think for us, it's kind of been maybe a Socratic dialogue that we've kind of adopted in our songwriting, where it becomes asking questions rather than delivering, you know, pat answers.
4:28Yeah. Is that why you decided to go kind of political for a few songs? Yeah. Is that the way things are going? No, no, I think politics is something that is unavoidable. The cereal you purchase in the morning, down to the milk, down to the microphone you're talking into, it all comes from a place and a specific location in time, which is, you know, completely influenced by politics. You know, the metal in the microphone is influenced by the trade that goes on. So I mean, to some extent, we are products of politics, and politics is a product of who we are as well. What are you thinking for this next election? I'm sorry, it's just going off my head here. Don't be at all political and deep. We should be talking about music, and we will. Yeah, yeah. But you know, I'm just thinking, it's like, there's candidates on both sides, and I'm like, oh, I like Giuliani, I like Obama. Yeah. Yeah. It should be interesting. This time, for the first time in a little while, you're not voting to vote against somebody. Yeah. You're voting for somebody, you know. So it's one of those things where, that's exciting, you know. I think that hopefully there'll be a larger
5:33turnout, because it's that type of an election. You know, it's a lot easier to vote for someone than against somebody else. You know, I think it's almost like, I mean, the reason why we all believe in democracy is because we don't trust each other, you know. We trust each other to a certain degree. Yeah. It's like we have an equal mistrust for everyone, so that we put the power in everyone's hands and we'll somehow be all right, you know. Do you think your country's ready for a black president? I'd like to think so. But yeah, honestly, I hope so. I think so. I mean, I think that it would dramatically influence... It would change everything, you know, in race relations, in a lot of, especially the South.
6:19You know, do you notice it in San Diego? I mean, I remember living in LA, and you didn't hear about it as much. But I'm thinking, like, you guys tour a lot, and you go to Mississippi and Alabama, I bet it's still... It's still so tied to generations. You know, it's such a generation-old thing, and so it's hard to know. I mean, certainly among our peers, everyone's excited. Yeah, you work in music, right? Everyone loves everyone. It's such a kind of forward-thinking community that we run in that, you know, it's hard to know. Yeah, I think, I mean, again, it's the idea that whatever is different is somehow stranger or offensive or, you know. I think that type of mindset is always kind of the fallback for humanity, you know, whether it's
7:06sex or race or religion. We tend to throw stones at the things that aren't like the way we think, you know. So I hope that that wouldn't play a part in the election. But I think to some extent, you know, like Tim said, with older generations, I'm sure people... Yeah, but I think it could definitely change. I mean, certainly the voter turnout in different, you know, segments of the population that hasn't been there in the past would certainly be coming out to the polls, you know. Yeah, hopefully. Yeah. And I think if he did get elected, I think it would change even the Middle East conflict. I mean, they'd realize that, you know, you guys want to change, something's different, you know. Yeah, you're more accepting. And I think that's kind of what you need right now.
7:51I mean, I think in many ways, you know, a black president would be amazing, but in many ways, it's almost like you have to go all the way and get a black woman president to really see change, you know. There was one running, I remember, in the Democratic primaries last year. I can't remember her name. Yeah, I don't know. I don't know that the world's ready, or America's ready for that. But I mean, that would certainly mix it up. Yeah, be cool. Let's talk about the record. We should get on some music. All right, let's talk about some. Yesterdays pops out of nowhere on the record. You got the electric sounds, then you got this really cool little melodic tune in there, and then it goes back to the electrics. What made you... like, I would probably have closed the record out with that, but you decided to throw it in as like track nine, which is always the best track on a CD, I've noticed, and this one happens to be the case. What made you throw it in the middle? Well, it is a little bit
8:41different than the rest of the record, and that was the reason why we didn't want to close with it. It felt like it ended the record on kind of a reluctant, you know, kind of inside type of note, you know, where it's a little bit more introspective, and the record really isn't that, you know. And so we wanted to fit it in there, but we had to push it a little earlier. I think for us, Tim, I wrote that with Tim, and, you know, for both of us it kind of takes on different meanings, for where we were when we wrote it. But I mean, essentially it's a song about loss, you know. And I think, I mean, loss is something that's essential to being human.
9:27Mm-hmm. But at the same time, you know, pain is never a fun topic to talk about. Yeah. So it's one of those things where sometimes writing a song about it can kind of bring closure. Yeah. Now, when you say you wrote it together, how did that work for you guys? You come up with a guitar riff and then the piano, or how did that one come together? I think it was in Portland, right? And it was like, yeah, one or two in the morning, and Jon had this really pretty melody. And he had, actually, Yesterdays was one of the lyrics, and melody. Okay. He kind of had it already, kind of in an infant stage there, and we just kind of... it really actually kind of wrote itself pretty quickly, in a matter of like 20 or 30 minutes. Oh, wow. And it is a pretty, I think, emotional experience, because,
10:17you know, just writing in that headspace and trying to come to closure with these different instances that we were both kind of wrestling with at the time. It really makes you appreciate what you do have. When you're writing about issues of loss, you know, it makes you kind of take a second look at who's around you and appreciate them a whole lot more. Yeah. Brothers in a band too, pretty cool. Yeah. Things are going well, I assume? Yeah, you know, I mean, we always get the question about, like, I'm not gonna go there, and Oasis, and, you know, blood and guts, you know. And I mean, we get along pretty well, you know. I think every brother is gonna have fights every now and then. Well, it's like band members. Yeah, I fight with the other guys. Yeah, I don't want anyone to be excluded.
11:04That song at least reminds me of the first time I heard Switchfoot, Learning to Breathe, back in like first-year university, and it was going back to that sound. But you guys, the past few records have been more anthemic, more, you know... Well, like production, a lot more production, a lot more, you know, bigger sound. What made you change and go in that direction? Was it just like, well, try this? I mean, the production on this whole record has been dramatically different, and a lot of that has been kind of an intentional shift. I think I'm just kind of, I mean, for all of us, we wanted to go to a different place, you know. That's kind of why we went with Palmer and Lillywhite to make this record, because we felt like they were offering kind of more of a timeless approach to music-making, simply because they made a lot of our favorite records
11:5520 years ago, you know. So who was Palmer with? I mean, I know Lillywhite, but Palmer's... I mean, he's done... He's done U2. Oh, really? He's done Pearl Jam. Okay, cool. Yeah, yeah, I mean, Ten. He's the one who kind of... See, I heard the band doesn't like it, though. There's too much reverb. Yeah, they didn't like the way that he mixed it. Oh, okay. He was kind of transitioning from that more reverberant days of mixing. That may have been the last big record that had a big-sounding, like, reverb-out... Yeah, I think it was, man. But you know, it's one of those things where, for the production of Awakening,
12:44he actually implemented this idea that came from kind of the old-school days, where you'd set up a loop of tape that you'd run around the 24-track machine, where you'd sing one note, and then by looping the tape around a mic stand, it would go on indefinitely, right, that one note. Yeah. So then you'd sing, and then you'd sync up another tape machine and record that note onto the tape machine. And then by doing that, you end up getting a chord of voices of all one person singing one note. And then you put all of those tracks up on the faders of the board and you play it like an instrument.
13:30So it's like a real... on that song? Yeah, it's like the stuff that you hear, the voices that come in, which is kind of, I think it comes from that 10cc track that... You hear the voices coming in, and they're actually being played. That's how we did that, you know. And obviously today you don't have to use a mic stand and a loop of tape, you know, it's a little bit faster. But at the same time, it was great to be able to play my voice like an instrument. I mean, things like that. It was great to kind of go back to a little bit more of a perhaps primitive style of recording, but at the same time, I think maybe more powerful, because,
14:18you know, you're not relying on the bells and whistles. You're really fighting for the feeling of the song and really trying to make that the focus. Yeah. How are you pulling that off live? Okay, we actually haven't played that song live yet. There's that one and maybe two other songs on the record we haven't played yet. It's one of those things where, having six records now, yeah, you can only put the new ones in, you know, every so often. So, but yeah, that's probably the next one I want to learn. That's amazing. How long does it take you guys to pick up a new song, throw it in? A day? Just the soundcheck and all that? Quick, you know, especially a song like that. Yeah, it's really stripped down.
15:05I think that's been a fun thing about this record, is that, you know, one of the mottos on this record was, if there's a guitar being played, I want to hear what it's playing. You know, I don't want 10 or 15 guitars of just layers upon layers. I want to be able to hear that guitar part, and I want to hear that bass, and, you know, just... I think there's a lot of power that can be had in simplicity. Definitely. And there's definitely a feeling that can be captured, you know, in that, and that's more what we're going for. It was a feeling versus perfection. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think for all these songs, you try and reinvent them live, you know. I've never been the type where I want to play the exact record night after night. You have to mix it up, you know. We had string players with us
15:52back home in California to start and end the tour. No way. We don't get them up in Canada? Sorry. Unless you know any nearby... a couple cellos or [inaudible]. Fair enough. So it's one of those things where you're always trying to mix it up and figure out ways to make it interesting for the people that are going to multiple nights, and for yourself, you know. Most of them? Yeah. A lot of shows on this tour. Yeah, almost all. Check them out from time to time. How do you guys choose a setlist? How do you decide which old songs to throw in? I think everyone's been doing a setlist, like, we've been taking turns. Oh, you mix it up every night? Yeah. That's cool. Not only, you know, mix up the songs, but mix up who writes the setlist out. So you'll show up, you know, half hour, four or five minutes before the show, and you see the setlist, and it'll be
16:41completely different than you would have ever imagined. Yeah, well, it's partially because we all kind of space out, and then five minutes before the show, it's like, where's the setlist? Oh, well, I wrote this. Let's use that. The other reason is we're recording a bootleg of every night on this tour, and so it's out at the end of the show. Oh, that's cool. So we record like five or six songs at the beginning of the set, so by the end of the set they're all burned and ready to go. That's awesome. And so that way, at the end of this, you know, if we do a different setlist every night, we'll have 39 live CDs at the end of this tour. Yeah, like Pearl Jam, right? They're never the same CDs. That's kind of cool, in the way that music's moving that way. It's kind of unfortunate, I mean, because, you know, iTunes is kind of wrecking the whole concept of an album, at least I'm thinking it. Well... Which is too bad, though. There's a lot of indie labels and bands that are very outspoken about the idea that iTunes is ruining the record.
17:32But the record in itself is a relatively new concept. Back in the day, I mean, you look at all the old Motown records, or even the old stuff in rock and roll, it was all driven by singles, you know. And I think it's moving back to that, for better or worse, you know, where it's kind of the Motown philosophy. They'd put a bunch of guys and girls in a room and they'd play the single, and they'd say, well, would you rather buy that or a ham sandwich? You know, and then if the vote actually was for the single, then they'd actually put it out. The rest of the stuff they just shelved, you know. And it was only the biggest bands that actually got to record a record.
18:21I mean, this is true for the Beatles. Their first stuff was just singles. Yeah, and covers. So I mean, it's nothing new. It's just, you know, if you're a fan of the record, then it's unfortunate. But at the same time, I think it's actually a victory for music in many ways, because it puts the power back into the hands of small bands rather than big industry, you know. And I think that's gonna win, you know, every day. Yeah, I mean, I am with you. It's a catch-22, because I'm a fan of the concept of a record as a whole. Yeah. But I think that music fans, you know, still can and will do that, you know, dive into a record and all the nuances and how it flows from the first track to the fifth to the twelfth or whatever.
19:09You know, but iTunes is kind of just scratching the itch. I mean, the itch is there, whether they're putting out singles or not. Yeah, it's just kind of what our society is moving towards, just kind of like information on demand. Exactly. Quick, quick, quick. Now, I was talking to the Barenaked Ladies the other week, and they were saying that they're thinking about just... well, they're on their own label now, right? They're not on a major anymore. So they were thinking, we're just gonna record a song, throw it out there whenever we're done recording it. We don't really need albums anymore. Maybe one day we'll have a batch and we'll throw in a record. But, you know, they want a song, here's a song. You think you guys will do that? I don't know. I mean, we've done that kind of all along. Well, the new record, you kind of did with the first two. Yeah, the first two, and we released, just basically for everyone who's been with us for a long time, for free, a song we put out online.
19:57That, and then various other little things that we've thrown at people along the way, you know. It's the type of thing where you've got all these songs, and it feels like you're not doing your job if you're waiting three years between records. It's kind of the reason why we put this one out within a year of the last record. It was supposed to be an EP too, is that true? Yeah, we weren't trying to make a record. It was kind of a record by accident, you know. It came out pretty good for an accident. Yeah, yeah. Well, that's the thing, is it almost came out in a way that it couldn't have come out if we were trying to make a record. There's an honesty and kind of a just-anything-goes attitude when you're just recording for fun. Mm-hmm. There's no commercial, like, oh, well,
20:43that'll never get played on radio, that's this, that's that, you know. It's like, oh, do I like it? It's cool, you know, let's go, let's move on. And then, you know, 30 songs in, we're like, wow, this is kind of starting to be cohesive. I can see certain songs kind of stacking up together. And so yeah, it was kind of a record by accident, and I'm really thankful the way it came out, because I know it couldn't have come out that way if we were really trying to make a record from the get-go. Cool. I ask every band five questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. I mean, some of the questions you'll see you can't give one word, but it'll work. You guys can both answer if you want, come on into the mic. All of them? Okay, cool. iPod or CDs? iPod. Lennon or McCartney?
21:37No, but that's just, I mean, that's a really tough question, because I love them both. For the record, I go CDs too. Oh, yeah? Okay. Again in the game. Although I will say, at home I only have a record player. So, nice, third answer of vinyl. I guess that would be mine. I just hooked up my vinyl the other day, and it needs a preamp still, but I'm working on it. Alcohol or marijuana? I abstain. Cool, fair enough. Song you've written you're most proud of? Probably Yesterdays. Really cool. It's my favorite song on your record. And one word, first thing that comes to your mind, Switchfoot? Quickly, we... It's not bad. That's me, that's you.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.