SONGSWhat Steven Page said about the songs
“Pinch Me”
Steven Page said he and Ed Robertson wrote the song together from scratch.
“Ed and I wrote Pinch Me together, pretty much from the ground up. It was... I love that song. I love the lyrics.”
“The Old Apartment”
Steven Page described the sound he wanted for the recording.
“So when it came to The Old Apartment, I wanted a chorus guitar, and chorus guitar, you know, we just couldn't quite go that way. The Old Apartment, I wanted it to just be all about the power chord.”
“Jane”
Steven Page explained that "Jane" was named after a Toronto intersection that co-writer Stephen Duffy spotted on a map.
“I was writing with my friend Stephen Duffy, who's from England, and he was looking at a map of Toronto and saw the intersection of Jane and St. Clair, and he said, this must be the most beautiful intersection in the world... he had a crush on the girl at the health food store, so we just decided to call her Jane St. Clair and wrote the song later.”
“Alternative Girlfriend”
Steven Page explained the double meaning in the title.
“Alternative Girlfriend, written during the grunge era, so it was about when everything was alternative... she's an alternative, but she's also a mild alternative to my other girlfriend.”
Steven Page also appears in Matt Schichter’s documentary CFNY: The Spirit of Radio, free on PBS in the US and TVO in Canada.
VIDEOWatch
40:36 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #99 · Barenaked LadiesMarch 2007 · 00:40:36
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Stumble in something. Yeah, who knows what you guys are going to say, right? So we were playing a lot. We did a cruise for all our fans and we were playing like around the clock, the evening, and then we're out in the sea air, and I think pretty much everyone lost their voice. Oh really? Yeah, I think it was a lot of fun though. It must have been a lot of fun. It was great, and Guster was there too. Yeah, Guster was there. My all-time favorite band, and I'm so happy that you guys give them a shout out on the album. I love that, so awesome. Yeah, how'd you guys hook up with Guster for the first time? How'd you guys meet each other? We met Guster in, I think, 1994, very early on, when they were just... Oh, yeah, like Parachute era. They were just called Gus. Oh, at that time, way back, demo tape. Andy actually had a sticker on his congas. Oh, I had a Gus sticker.
0:46They opened for us at Colgate College in upstate New York, I think about '94. Then we ran into them again on the H.O.R.D.E. tour. Before that, I remember they opened for us at Harbor Lights in Boston, and Seymour Stein, the president of Sire... We were no longer on Sire, but he flew up to see them, and he grabbed me and said, what do you think of these guys? I signed them. I said, yeah, they're great. They're fun. I didn't really know them that well. I mean, kind of liked them, and we saw them on the H.O.R.D.E. tour and kind of liked them, and then they had that record. Yeah, I forget the name. Lost and Gone Forever. That was just, yeah, it took us over the top with them. Like, we just have huge respect for what they're doing. And huge respect for Brian's hands. Oh man, poor guy. Ryan gave me a copy of Lost and Gone Forever when we did a show with him at the Orpheum in Boston.
1:32I went back to my hotel room after soundcheck and I was like, holy crap. I listened to the record and was like, this is... I got this, these guys have arrived. Yeah, so then they opened for us on the... whatever that was, the Maroon tour maybe. I think so. Not Canada, unfortunately. No. Just the Flashing Lights were good though. I liked that work. Oh, are they together anymore? What's going on with them? You know, they're not together. I mean, what's his name, Matt Murphy, was in that movie? Yeah, something crazy long title. Yeah, The Life and Hard Times of Guy Terrifico. Yeah, that's right. And I heard he's trying to get the Super Friendz back together as well. Oh, okay. Steve Pitkin, our friend, the drummer, is now in Elliott Brood. Okay, they've got a new record coming out too. Yeah, nice. Let's talk about your new record. Two CDs come out at different times. How'd you guys choose songs for each record?
2:18Was it kind of like, we'll put the best up first and second on the second, kind of thing, or? I don't remember. Yeah, there's a lot of favorites that I have, like, on the second record. But you don't write anything on the second record? What's that? None of your songs are on the second record. I have one song. It's on the first record. I love that tune. Oh, thanks. Peterborough. It's an awesome song. Yeah, it's funny, I think we just tried to match them up, how they related, how they worked as a whole. So, oops, that's not what you do at interviews. You don't bring your phone. We can stop, you can answer if you want. I'll just turn it off. Okay, it's very kind of you. Sorry, honey. Yeah, I think we wanted to make the two records work as two separate entities, like albums that, as you listen through them once, it worked together.
3:07So I think that's how we put it together, as best I can tell. Yeah, it's kind of, for me, in a sense, like, I think they're both satisfying records to listen to, but I think when we were putting this together, I couldn't get my head out of the fact that it was all one record anyways. Mm-hmm. What made you decide to put them out at different times than a double album? At retail, yeah, really expensive. That was the biggest thing, was we just didn't want to give people the excuse to put it down, you know, at a $25 CD, and my worry is it's going to end up being, as a double album, it's just enough of an excuse. Yeah, it's a lot to digest as well. And we didn't want any of the songs to get lost in a double record. Fair enough. So we decided to give them a little more weight, put out one separate, smaller record. My sense is that fans who buy music online are a little more focused on trying to sort through it all and maybe making their own playlists, and yeah.
3:59Also, there's a sense of a lot of people listen to stuff on random play as well, so they don't listen to the whole record as a whole as much, or, if they're really obsessive fans, of course they're going to listen to everything. Whereas people who buy CDs exclusively tend to be more like they want something to put in the car on the way to work, and a CD should be the length of your drive to work. Yeah, and beyond that, there's all kinds of stuff that gets lost that you don't hear, and we don't want to be able to not hear anything. You playing everything live on this tour? The whole... well, probably not everything. Through it, yeah, it's only, sorting through it, trying to... We have a few tunes that we want to get out there into people's heads, so we're sort of filtering them in. Mm-hmm. How do you guys choose a setlist? About half of it is the same every night, and the other half we mix it up. On this Canadian tour,
4:46I think we're trying to be a little bit more hits focused, just because there's a certain expectation, I think, because we have such a long history here in Canada and a lot of hits, you know. You look at the audience after the show and they're like, what, no Jane? Sorry, we have so many songs. We want to play the new record too. Yeah, we want to play... we also want to play album tracks from the other albums. It doesn't all have to be just the hits. That's cool. But it's hard to get that all done. Yeah, well, I mean, people have heard Jane. I mean, if they're going to come see you now, they've probably seen you a few times at this point. Yeah, I think if you have a favorite song... Favorite songs evoke for the audience something they don't evoke for us, right? For them it's all kinds of memories that go along with those songs. For us it's just another one of our songs, in a sense. Yeah, when we play Million Dollars, I feel like I'm going on someone's grade eight band trip sometimes.
5:33Remember last summer? Nice. Go through a couple songs on the new record. Let's talk about Sound of Your Voice. Kevin was supposed to sing it originally, but I heard the manager didn't like it. What happened? I think he liked it. I think the sense was he thought it could be a single if it had a more dramatic vocal. I mean, I love Kevin's vocals, and I felt weird about taking a song that he wrote. But there's other songs like that as well, like Celebrity and Shopping and, you know, Adrift, that Ed sings, that were mostly Kevin songs that we collaborated with him on and changed a bit. But this was exclusively a Kev song, and I think because it had a certain kind of Queen element... Very much so, yeah. ...that we just thought that my
6:19more dramatic voice might be a little more appropriate. Mm-hmm. You trying to be Freddie in the song when you say that? I'm trying to be too Freddie. Yeah, fair enough. Is it hard to pull off those harmonies live? No, not there. We actually... they become second nature after a few tours. So it doesn't sound as big as it sounds on the record? Oh, okay. Yeah, we actually layered the vocals. Like, there's like 80 in total. Wow. Many voices in there. We were trying to go for that big Queen sound, but yeah, live it still sounds full. Cool. Well, I can't wait to hear it tonight. Wind It Up. Kim Mitchell plays on it. How'd you guys hook up with him? Why did you choose him out of anyone to play on that tune specifically? Well, I think that, like, when I first heard Wind It Up, I kind of said, you know, this is where you live, you know, this is where you come from.
7:08He was a huge Max Webster fan and still is, and when we played the song, it couldn't get away from Max Webster and the Kim Mitchell sound. And he had worked with Kim Mitchell a little bit previously, songwriting for his record, and he asked him, hey, would you like to blow a solo over this? And so he went in with a camcorder and recorded the whole thing. Oh, cool. Home movie style, and did about 10 tracks. Wow. It was just Kim Mitchell sounding like Kim Mitchell all over the song. Do you guys listen to him on Q107? He's good on the Q. Yeah, he's all right. I enjoy listening to his case. He's laid back. He's not doing the radio guy. Yeah, well, he's the musician, right?
7:53Yeah, so he's in it for the music. It was kind of exciting for Ed though, because he is his favorite guitar player. So to be there and, you know, yeah, being on the song, pretty exciting. Another song, Fun and Games, on the new one. Pretty political for you guys, talking about how, you know, the war is basically an inside joke for the Republicans and that whole thing. Or am I getting the wrong idea from it? No, I think it was like, the question was, well, why did the US, or the US government, take the United States to war in Iraq? And that question has often been asked, and there's never really an answer that's been proven. And so I think it was Ed and Steve's idea to kind of say, well, maybe it was just a joke. That is not right. Yeah, so. Cool. Yeah, I think it was a song about some of the
8:42just the brazenness and the disregard for the lives of their own citizens and the liberty of their own citizens, that it seemed to us so offensively callous that it was almost as if it was a cruel joke. Do you think the world would be a whole lot different if Al Gore was president? Yeah, I don't think it would have stopped 9/11 from happening, really. Oh, I don't think so. I think 9/11 was a product of all kinds of stuff before that, including the Clinton administration. But I would like to believe the US would have dealt with it a different way. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think it would have been dealt with in a different way. I think there's a lot of alienation going on. Yeah. Ralph Nader was on Jon Stewart last night, and he was talking about how it's the family upbringing, and how George W. is trying to prove it to his dad now, because his dad couldn't do it back then, and it's just
9:33it's a whole problem, and I'm hoping Al Gore runs this time. I mean, there's something in Rolling Stone about it saying he'd make the best candidate. But then again, you look at Hillary, look at Barack. Maybe the other side of the world wouldn't hate us as much, you know, if we had someone a little different in power. Yeah, funny how we say we. Basically, well, they choose what we do anyway. It's not like Harper's doing his own thing. Yeah, it's true. I just want whoever's going to win to win. Yeah, I just don't want him to win. I think one of the problems that the Democrats have is, I don't want them to win by believing the more like a Republican they become, the better chance they have to do that. I think that's a real disease in the Democratic Party in the US. I'd hate to see that happen here in Canada to us. For all of his flaws, it's nice to see somebody in Dion who sits a little bit on the left
10:22of where our previous premiers or Liberal leaders sat. So to move that way, I think, is important, to have that kind of discourse, whereas I think in the US they really feel like the more like the Republicans the Democrats become, the better chance they have, which is very possible. But is it the right thing for the country? I think you need to be able to separate the ideals and make the choice. Yeah, definitely. I mean, you must be real happy now that the whole climate thing is actually an issue in the forefront of people's minds. I don't want it to go away. I don't want it to be just a... Sad, yeah. Well, see, that's what I'm worried about too, is that, I mean, you have the movie that came out, the Al Gore movie, and it became this big thing, and now everyone's talking about it. It seems to actually be changing, but do you think people will hook on to it? Do you think it's a fad? I think what we're seeing right now is the backlash, which is good. I think it's good to have that.
11:12I think the people who are so-called skeptics about climate change will be proven more and more wrong, because I think those of us who understand the science of climate change, versus those who have a different kind of agenda... I can't understand what kind of agenda we would have, and I think that's the Michael Crichton side of things, really. I'm not pleased with him. Are you? Well, no, and I mean, there's a suggestion that those who are trying to stop global warming, or think that we as humans have had a negative impact on our planet, that we may have some kind of alternate agenda, and I'm not sure what that agenda would be apart from
12:00stewardship of our own planet and of our own species. I think, you know, whether you're a religious person or you just try and live a moral life, whatever else, it's part of being who you are, and I think anybody who tries to stand in the way of that, it's unbelievable to me. Because, I mean, even look at people who are fighting or believe in the war in Iraq. Those people, at the core, I want to believe that what they're trying to do is make the world a better place. I don't know. Oh, so yeah, I would agree with them. But I think that the climate change deniers are not interested in that. They're not interested in trying to make the world a better place. They're interested in trying to make the world a more convenient place for the marketplace, and I don't think that's why we're here on the planet. Mm-hmm. Do you guys drive hybrids? Do you plan on driving hybrids? I have a hybrid. Yeah, had one for a few years. I like it. I try to drive as little as possible.
12:48Yeah, you know, I live in Toronto, and you know, it's really nice to get right there, and I walk, take my bike. You recognized on your bike? Anybody? That's embarrassing, your helmet. Yeah, sometimes you are, but you know, it's fine. Like, I ride the streetcar and the subway and rarely get recognized. Really? Sometimes I do, yeah. I actually... my family and I, we've gone two years without a car. So, wow. Yeah, we live in downtown Toronto, where everything is very close and convenient to walk to or ride our bike or take the transit. So it's an experiment, but it's working out really well. Yeah, cool. You guys both Leafs fans? The whole band Leafs fans? You know, I think we're all Leafs
13:34affiliated. I'm not a big hockey follower. Oh, okay. I like a good hockey game. Yeah, I enjoy going, but I'm mostly there for the hot dogs. I like the jerseys. Oh, yeah, all right. Another live record, Rock Spectacular. Was it French? Is that the right thing? Montreal recording? Yeah, Rock Spectacular. Is there even a point to a live record anymore at this point? I mean, I know you guys are putting the shows out on USB and everything. We do a live album every night. Yeah. You know, the live record, you know, we also did the Live from the Glenn Gould Theatre version of... oh, yeah... and then, you know, those ones are mixed with a little more time and so on. They sometimes are a little more sonically satisfying. And a traditional live record is often made up of bits of different shows edited together in a way. Like, when Rock
14:19Spectacular came out, there were some fans who didn't like it because it didn't follow the flow of the concert. They were used to our setlist. Oh. We tried to organize it the way we organize... it was, we tried to make it flow like an album, and those two things flow very differently. But these live recordings we do every night are just the show, warts and all, which I think is... you know, people love bootlegs. People... yeah, I love them as a music fan, and the fans like it. We wanted to be able to give them good ones that didn't always have the guy next to you singing into your tape recorder. You guys a fan of the Brian Wilson cover of Brian Wilson? He does it on his live record. Yes, great. Yeah, it's pretty shocking, almost, to hear him singing it. Yeah, I'm sure, for Steve, like, you wrote it when you were 18? Really that young? Close, one of the first ones. That's probably about 20 or 21. Still early.
15:05How did you guys hear about it for the first time? Did he come and get your permission for it, or how does that work for you? He had recorded it and came to the studio we were working at and played it for us. Yeah, we were working with Don Was, and Don Was had just done a documentary on Brian Wilson, and so they invited him to the studio, and there he was, and played it for us in the studio and asked us at the end, is it cool, guys? Yeah, it's good. Yeah, Brian, everything you do is cool. Can you notice that, like, I don't want to say mental disability, but, like, is he all there? I think parts of him are all there, but not in other ways. I think he's like a five-year-old kid. Yeah. You know, I've spoken to his wife Melinda about that. I mean, she says it's like having another kid.
15:53I mean, he's not, he's an adult. Mm-hmm. Makes adult decisions and so on, but I think, you know, I've seen him at work with his band, and he's very focused and really in charge. It looks like, when you watch him on stage, it looks like he's not, but backstage he really is on top of it. But then, you know, in the dressing room, it seems like the world's kind of going on around him. Okay, interesting. I was interviewing Guster, I can't remember, like two years ago. I said, Brian, pick any tune, and he chose Oh Yoko. And now you guys are covering it. I thought that was pretty cool. What made you decide to do it? Yeah, interesting. People seem to really like that cover, by the way. I've got a lot of good feedback. Good. It just came out this week, I think. Oh, they put it out yesterday. Yeah, I just found out about it, and proceeds going to Amnesty International. That's pretty cool. Yeah, why'd you choose that song out of all the songs you could have done? Well, it was supposed to be chosen from John's solo canon. Oh, okay.
16:40Any of his solo songs, they gave us our pick, and they showed us which ones were already taken by other artists. I've always loved that song. I just always... yeah, for me it's just joyful, and it's got that breezy poppiness that I've always aspired to write. It also has that piano line that Billy Bragg stole from it to put in... what is it? Is that Waiting for the Great Leap Forwards? Yeah, right. And, you know, because we already did Be My Yoko Ono, it seemed like the perfect kind of bookend. Yeah, very nice. I like how you sing All You Need Is Love at the end, kind of like they do in All You Need Is Love with She Loves You. Yeah, is that why you did it? That's why I did it. Oh, cool. And I whistled Jealous Guy in the middle there. Is that what that is? I was trying to figure it out, I was listening today, I was like, that sounds like something, I couldn't figure out. Oh, it's Jealous Guy. Nice.
17:26Has Yoko heard it? Is Yoko a fan? I think she had to approve it in order for it to be on the record. Yeah, also. Yeah, and the first one, the Be My Yoko Ono tune, I heard she's a fan, right? I think she's, you know, she gets the joke. She's cool. Yeah, she's cool. Joke... speaking of jokes, I mean, I hate to bring it up because it's such a typical question, but you sound a lot more serious, not as jokey as you once were, and that kind of thing. Is that a conscious decision, or is that just how you're writing because you're older and you've matured more? I mean, there are jokey songs there too, but I like songs with jokes in them more than I like songs that are jokes. Yeah. I don't like to listen to a song and go, oh, all right, I already know what this is about from the first two words, and then the rest of the song is just playing that out. I think, yeah, I think when it comes in as a stream of consciousness in the song, it's just something that comes up, I always appreciate that.
18:16It lets me know that the songwriter is not too adamant and he's not driving me with an idea. He's human. Mm-hmm. Let his mind drift a little. That's cool. Desperation Records, your label. Are the Creeggan Brothers going to be on it? Is your brother's band going to be on it, or how does it all work? Yeah, I don't know. I have to figure out the kind of financial logistics of that, you know, because if I do a solo record, I don't want to have to owe the band anything or have them owe me. Like, oh, okay, I don't want to end up being in that kind of weird situation. But it'd be wonderful to be able to use the resources that Desperation Records has. I talked to Terry about that a little bit, and he's all for it. He's our manager. Okay. Which basically means it's up to us.
19:02It's our label, which means it's up to us and Nettwerk's working with us. Nice. Then yeah, all right. So I'm kind of confused with that. Nettwerk's working with you guys, you still have distribution through Warner? Yeah. What does having your own label do, then? Nettwerk Records is basically a company that we hire. Nettwerk, Nettwerk Management, is a company that we as Desperation Records hire, okay, to run our day-to-day operations. All right. But Desperation Records is our company that owns the copyright and administers it. Oh, so you keep all the publishing and all the money from that kind of stuff, and then creative freedom? All the decisions are ours. Yeah, that's kind of cool. Nettwerk Management, we give our, you know, our 15, 20% of anything we make. So they set up, like, the promo stuff? No. Okay, cool. I remember reading something Ed said not too long ago about how, well, in this day and age, you don't really even need CDs anymore.
19:49You can just, if you want... Well, his thinking is just releasing a song when you have it written and recorded, just throwing it out there on the internet, because what's the point? I'd love to see us, like, you know, every few months put out three songs, and then at the end of the year you've got 12 songs. We can make a CD of that for people who don't download stuff online or aren't that religious about checking stuff, but for the diehards, they already have it, they don't have to buy both. Mm-hmm. Yeah, how do you feel about downloading, like, the illegal stuff? I know you're for... obviously everyone's for the legal stuff, but I mean, are you at this point in your career just, get the music out there, or? Oh, yeah, I think... but I think my sense is that P2P is the future. It's also the present, and, you know, as well as emailing and IMing and all, just being able to share and trade music. And the sense that the industry has that we need to somehow change the audience behavior is
20:36futile. Our job is to try and figure out how to get money from that. Imagine that cable TV existed, but there were no cable companies, and that there were no advertisers on the TV channels. We were just changing channels and watching whatever we wanted, and no one was getting paid for it. Well, they wouldn't just stop having that TV. They would just figure out how to pay people. And so whether that's the networks learning to get advertisers, and the networks that get watched the most get the most money for their advertisements, it's the same thing we could do now. So people who download, or get their tracks downloaded the most, let's say it's Nelly Furtado or it's Coldplay or whatever else, get the biggest piece of the pie. People who, you know, get downloaded once get a sliver, but they get something. I think Hollywood doesn't like this because it means all of a sudden they have to start sharing their revenues with kids wiping out on skateboards,
21:24pornos and whatever else. But who's to say that's not legitimate media? It's all legitimate, and we're watching it. We're consuming it. So now we have to monetize it, and we can't punish the audience for that. We as a business have to figure out how to get money out of it. And how do we do that? Any ideas? Yeah, well, I know there are companies out there who track all this stuff. Okay. You know, they make a living out of tracking what's being traded online, what's being watched on the YouTube-type sites as well. And I think, you know, YouTube itself monitors what's being watched. Yeah, you would think so. It's true. So they could easily give the money, the revenues, whatever advertising revenues they generate, to copyright holders. But maybe you can have an umbrella organization who goes to all those things, like an ASCAP, like a BMI, who goes to all those different places, whether it's, you know, open P2P systems or closed ones, or you have a rating.
22:16You know, they have the Nielsen system in the United States, where they call different families and say, what are you watching on TV? You know, you're part of the Nielsen family. You could be a Nielsen ratings family for media, whatever you're trading online. What do you listen to? What do people send you? What are you sending people? And as long as you stop... you know, you're anonymous in that situation anyways. It's not like your name's being recorded. As long as people aren't afraid of being sued, they'll be happy just to tell you what they're trading and give credit to the artists, you know, they downloaded or they shared. What people don't want to have to do is go, well, geez, I bought a hundred records this month, so now I have to pay a thousand dollars. What they want is for people to say, well, I paid my ten bucks on my cable bill or on my internet bill or to my subscription service or whatever else, and I got a hundred albums, or I got ten albums, or I got one album.
23:03So you're paying for access. Yeah. Do you think people are going to switch to that? Because right now it's free if you want it. But, for instance, internet access is not free. No, that's true. You know, so you add that into the cost. It's not free. It's just part of the service, and people are happy to do those things as long as they don't have to transact individually. If they had to transact every time they changed the channel on TV, they'd stop changing channels, and eventually they'd stop watching TV. But because it's transparent and it's invisible to them, they continue to do it. They're happy to pay the premium for more content too. It's funny how some choose a minimal package that allows them to... Funny how the music industry is resisting moving into something like that, because it seems like it's the biggest... that's the way you can make money off music. It's the only way. It's the way we're going, but it democratizes it in a way that they're not comfortable with, because it will reduce their share of the
23:53pie, because more and more people in their basements without the standard means of distribution will have access to any audience they want, and the major labels don't want that. So they want to hang on as long as they can and restrict and control their audience. And they already know it, but they can't do anything about it at this point. They're just going to keep fighting that battle until they've lost. The thing is that record companies now, they still have the old infrastructure that's needed. They still have marketing. They still have distribution of, you know, the hard copies anyways, and they can have distribution of online digital music as well. Like, they still have valuable things that they can make money off. They just have to change their deals to reflect that. Yeah, they need to start providing services to other copyright holders rather than
24:41collecting and protecting their own copyrights. I think that's where their downfall is going to be, because their attitude towards that is what is poisoning the water. But the services they provide, distribution, publicity and so on, they do very well, and they're starting to cut deals like that anyways. Our deal with Warner, Warner Canada, we have a distribution deal with some marketing in there. So it's okay, we create a relationship with them. It's just more transparent. We know what we're working with them on. We know what they're doing for us. As opposed to the old version, where you just sign on, you get this dollar from every CD, and everything else just goes into the record company and they do something with it. Who knows where it goes, right? And you see it, you know, some of it
25:28reflected in some marketing and things like that, but you really don't have a lot of control of what they do with the money. Ten years from now, yes or no, major labels going to be around? I think they'll be around, but they'll be doing different things. It'll be more managing artists. They'll be doing what Nettwerk does, where they, you know, they'll take a cut of everything the artist does rather than owning the whole thing. They might share it with the artist, but also get part of the concert revenue or the merchandise or whatever else. I just remembered what Canada was getting sort of pressured or labeled as in the movie industry, all because of this camcordering all happening in Montreal. I was reading... well, the hotbed is not that bad. It's really not that bad like they say. Montreal... but Montreal, there's like half of the Hollywood stuff, half the stuff in the theaters is
26:18English and half of it's French, yeah. And so that cuts down the amount right there. It sort of diminishes the amount that they said that Canada was responsible for, for this camcordering. And it just does seem like the US, and the lobby groups, are really putting pressure on Canada to change their copyright rules, and it's just funny to get that kind of pressure from the US. It's treating Canada like a rogue state, and we can't listen to that. But, you know, they're in the process of drafting new copyright legislation here in Canada, and my fear is that it's going to end up being even more draconian than the American copyright law. Really? Because of pressure from the US. Is that what it was, a CCMA that you started, something like that?
27:05CMCC. CMCC, tell people what that is. That's the Canadian Music Creators Coalition. Okay. Essentially it was an opportunity for us as a bunch of artists ourselves, Sarah McLachlan, Avril Lavigne, the Weakerthans... Weakerthans tonight, yeah. Andrew Cash, Broken Social Scene, Feist, Stars, lots of great bands across Canada, artists across Canada, have signed on basically to say we don't agree with suing our fans. We don't need copyright legislation in this country that protects copyright holders in a sense that allows them to sue their fans for downloading their music or sharing it, that allows them to have legal protections for DRMs, which are these digital rights management technologies. Right now in Canada, if you were to circumvent those in order to...
27:50Let's say you buy a copy-protected CD, or you download a track from the iTunes Music Store that won't work on your Zune. Yeah. Right now it's legal for you to burn that to a CD and then re-import it. It's such a hassle though. It's a hassle, but that shouldn't exist, as far as I'm concerned. Yeah, but you're allowed to do it. New legislation could potentially disallow you from doing that. You download a song from the iTunes Music Store, burn it to a CD, re-import it into your Zune, and you could be either sued or taken to jail. Yeah, fined and whatnot. Yeah, and it's like, you know what, those people who are lobbying for that kind of stuff are not speaking on behalf of artists, because that's not in an artist's best interest. Distancing ourselves from our own fans is the last thing anyone wants to do. Yeah, definitely. That's cool. You guys are for it. I'm real glad to hear that. Most musicians I've talked to have been for it,
28:37which is real nice. At the beginning, my perspective has been changed. When it first started happening, I think we were like, hey, you know, this is my livelihood. But then we started seeing how it really re-energized our fan base and things like that. I soon realized that it was very beneficial to us, and also just thinking about the business models that could happen in the future, it just seems very logical that it could be worked out to be a new music industry. Yeah, definitely. And it just gets it out there, for the baby bands at least. Well, and the potential is in the future, because this technology is so strong. And right, but it's a pain in the ass, like, frankly, downloading from LimeWire or, you know, any of the BitTorrent services.
29:22It's a pain. You never know what you're going to find, what virus, whatnot. Yeah, and how many peers you're going to find out there. Everything's unreliable. Some stuff takes forever to download, whereas you've got the iTunes Music Store and it's quick. And it's, yeah, well, I'd like to find that happy medium where the sources are reliable, where the stuff is fast. And if we start charging for that and allowing people access to sharing networks that are strong, reliable, fast, all those things, it's going to be the best of both worlds. And, you know, we can't keep looking at music as a product. We talk about it, you know, downloading illegally, like it was, you know, shoplifting from a record store, from a clothing store, and you know,
30:08the more you treat music like a product, the more the audience treats it like that. And the more they treat it like that, the less passion they have for music, the more they treat it as a commodity, and the more they treat themselves as customers, disgruntled customers, which is very different from a music fan. Yeah, especially... well, you think back to the '60s and what it was like, and, you know, everyone's jamming around at these festivals and trading records, and even mixtapes in the '80s and that kind of stuff. It's getting back to that, which I kind of like. Well, also, '70s and '80s, the big slogan of the RIAA was home taping is killing music, and as you can see, they were right. Music is dead. There's no more music. No, it's gone. Okay. Yes or no, Apple going to run the world? No, but I think they're going to have a huge influence, continue to have a huge influence. Okay. I think they, you know, I think... I like them. Yeah.
30:56I know a lot of people who don't like them. I think their products are great. Yeah, you're running it. Do you all have... everyone has Apples on the buses now? And you have Macs, all of you? Yeah, it's in the music world and music industry, it's very... everyone has Macs. Everything's simpler, so integrated, operating system, everything works together. You know, nothing's... So it works good for me, because I don't like to think too much about integrating it. I want to use it. Yeah, get on with my life. Cool. Let's get back to music. So you guys were buskers, like, way back when? Wow. Yeah. Buskers festival in Waterloo, one of my favorite nights of the summer. That's where we met Tyler Stewart, in Waterloo. Yeah, at that festival. No way. Let's hear the story. We were at the busking festival. They blocked off two streets just for
31:43street performers to play. Tyler was in a band called the Would-Be-Goods, and we were the Barenaked Ladies. It was Steve and I, and we walked by the Would-Be-Goods concert. He went, he had these huge dreads, he's like, Barenaked Ladies, right on, play with us. Well, then he just chased us for about six months. Yeah. Can I just... can I join your band? No. Well, you can just have this one, boy. Can I say what I said? What do you guys... I don't really... well, okay, next show, just play the snare. Yeah, just bring a snare. And then every show he'd come back, can I play with you guys again? We'd say, well, yeah, okay. And he'd bring, like, the snare and a tom. Yeah, the drum kit slowly grew. And this is while Andy was away on
32:31Canada World Youth. So it's like he sort of moved into the open conga slot, because we were only used to playing with congas. Oh, yeah, of course. And then Andy came back and went, I guess all the drums are taken care of, maybe I'll play piano. Cool. And then Kevin replaced him. Now, was that a hard thing for Andy? I don't know if you guys are comfortable talking about it or not. It's totally great. He was actually just jamming with us on this cruise that we did. Oh, he came out with you guys? Yeah. But I think Andy just... he was the youngest guy in the band, and he came right out of high school into the group, and yeah, I think he wanted to do some more experimenting on his own, and he had a desire to learn composition and how the composers pulled it off, how Brahms
33:19okay, went down that way. And he was just too curious, I think, and wanted to go that direction. So what he did was he got a degree in composition and orchestration at McGill University. And what's been interesting lately is that we've been doing concerts with the Toronto Symphony, really, and with the Boston Pops, and Andy is our orchestrator. Cool. And it's been a really great thing, because he knows us better than anybody. Mm-hmm. And we trust him, and he also knows the symphonic world better than anybody we know. That's amazing. What do you think's one of the best songs that sounds really cool with a symphony behind it? I have fond memories of Another Postcard with Chimpanzees, with a symphony. Okay, cool. There's a wall floor I was doing called that too. It's a really good song.
34:11Just wanted to go through a couple songs. Give me a little snippet about it, so that way I can, you know, play it before we spin the tunes on your station, kind of stuff. Alternative Girlfriend. Alternative Girlfriend, written during the grunge era, so it was about when everything was alternative, before things got extreme. Right, Extreme Girlfriend. It should have a nice double entendre to it, because it was, you know, she's an alternative, but she's also a mild alternative to my other girlfriend. And then the video, we got another triple entendre, where she was actually a man in drag. Oh. Very pretty, very pretty. Billy, Billy beyond. Jane. Jane, written in the sessions before Maybe You Should Drive. I was writing with my friend Stephen Duffy, who's from England,
35:00and he was looking at a map of Toronto and saw the intersection of Jane and St. Clair, and he said, this must be the most beautiful intersection in the world. Which it isn't. It just sounds good, especially with an English accent. Yeah. Jane's... he had a crush on the girl at the health food store, so we just decided to call her Jane St. Clair and wrote the song later. Cool. Now, how come you guys aren't writing with Stephen anymore? He actually started writing with Robbie Williams, the English pop star, and co-produced his whole last record and co-wrote the whole last record and became his band leader for the whole last tour. So that consumed the last three or four years of his life. But what it meant for Stephen was he actually made some money for the first time.
35:47It's been great. So we've been, you know, busy doing our own thing, and we also decided in the band that the songs that the band performs come from within the band, which is why I did the Vanity Project record. Okay. Because I had a bunch of songs I'd been writing with Stephen that I knew the band wasn't going to use anymore. So there's my chance to get them out there. Was it a one-off thing, or could you do another one? You know what, I have a bunch of other bits and pieces of songs that I've done with Stephen, so maybe we'll do some more. Okay, cool. I'm sure he'd like to do some more writing, I just have to find the time. Fair enough. Pinch Me. There's a small bit of song with... well, no, Ed and I wrote Pinch Me together, pretty much from the ground up. It was... I love that song. I love the lyrics. You know, and the video was a lot of fun to do too. That was the first video that kind of came from us.
36:34I actually wrote the... oh no... I even... for it, and I really like that video. But the song... It's my favorite video too. Yeah, Steve was like the kind of Pillsbury Doughboy kind of figure, a hamburger icon. Yeah, and you actually had to stay very still, and were heavily made up, and was this guy's presence in the video. Ed got to do this great Busby Berkeley style dancing thing from an aerial shot in it. My favorite shot is when he lies back on the whole sea of buns. That's great. You write this stuff down, and then all of a sudden it's in a video. It's like, it's real. That song, it's got this great melancholy to it. It's got the jokiness to it, of course, and it also has the rappy thing that we do. And
37:21that was the funny thing, is that rap thing actually came from my idea, because I was joking. I was bugging Ed, saying, this part, I want it to be like, good be too much of a fun. Do you know what you want? Let's do this Chaka Khan thing. And we decided we actually would do a rap based kind of around that rhythm. Cool. The Old Apartment. Started off as a ballad, actually. I was trying, like, you know, thinking back to Back to the Old House by the Smiths. It was kind of like, you know, a melancholy ballad, and Ed said, why don't we do this as a rock song? We hadn't really done a straight-ahead kind of rock song before, and we decided to make it as... you know, wait, I sort of felt like I wanted to make it as much of a sort of cartoonish version of a rock song, because
38:08and make it all about the brand and nothing else. You know, just focus it totally on that, and to make it completely the most we could make it. Because we did Alternative Girlfriend, that was during the grunge time, and we couldn't quite be it, so we had Rhodes piano in there, which sort of made it prettier than most. Yeah. So when it came to The Old Apartment, I wanted a chorus guitar, and chorus guitar, you know, we just couldn't quite go that way. The Old Apartment, I wanted it to just be all about the power chord. Nice. And Too Little Too Late? Yeah, it was again, you know, kind of that rock and roll stomper, although I think when Ed and I started writing it, it was more along the lines of, like... what's the song I'm thinking about?
38:59It's an XTC song off Nonsuch, The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead, or something like that. Oh, the Crash Test Dummies cover. Yeah. You know, that's quite a bombastic rock thing on that record. You know, kind of that power pop kind of thing, and we ended up making it a little bit more American. Oh, nice. It's All Been Done. It's All Been Done was in a hotel room on the Pirate Ship tour, just trying to think about writing a song. I think I heard Brian Wilson on the radio and thought, what a wordy song. Can I write something a little more simple? Thought about those kind of simple, straight-ahead pop songs that I really like, and essentially stole the riff from It Falls Apart by the Odds,
39:44with their blessing. They were on the ship tour too. One day we're in it, and it turned out to be a lot of fun. Still a favorite. Cool. Can you guys do a couple? Oh, I want to talk about the box set. Tell people when that's coming out, what's going to be on it. Well, hopefully the box set's coming out this Christmas, but we have a deadline of March 9th to confirm all the content, and the problem is, like, there's lots of stuff that's sitting around on DATs and cassettes and stuff, and I'd hate to miss out on stuff and not have it on the box set. So if we can get it all done by March 9th, we'll see. Then it'll be out by Christmas, and it'll be everything from, you know, stuff from old demos... You know, we've done demos all the way up to this record. It's just all that kind of stuff, live stuff that's never shown up, B-sides, alternate versions of songs, that kind of thing. It'll be mostly the rarest type things. Thank you. You've got to go.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.