Lennon or McCartney? Tyson Ritter & Nick Wheeler answered: Harrison, Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Tyson Ritter said about the songs
“Gives You Hell”
Tyson Ritter said the song is not about an ex-girlfriend but about a man he can't stand.
“Honestly, it's about a dude I really hate. And the only reason there's a gender in the song is because I say, 'If you find a man that's worth a damn,' but that was just a clever line that fit there.”
“Another Heart Calls”
Tyson Ritter wrote the song as a duet from the start; it features the Pierces.
“I feel like that was the one song where I sort of had the foresight and knew what I wanted immediately. I wrote the song lyrically as a duet, and when we all sort of sat in the room and jammed it out, it was just a magical moment.”
“Heartbeat Slowing Down”
Tyson Ritter recalled the hook arriving at the piano after days without a song.
“I was downstairs playing on the piano, and I sang the hook for 'Heartbeat Slowing Down'... And then all of a sudden I was playing it, and Nick was like, 'It sounds cool, dude.' And then I shot upstairs and we mapped it out.”
VIDEOWatch


3 clips · 15:47 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #148 · The All-American RejectsAugust 2009 · 00:09:58
Episode #373 · The All-American Rejects #2July 2012 · 00:05:08
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Stillwater, Oklahoma. Stillwater, one of the greatest bands of all time as well, Stillwater from Almost Famous. So we're gonna start the interview with that question from that movie: what do you guys love about music? What do we love about music? That's his answer in the movie. Yeah, I mean, you can break it down into so many sections. Playing is just amazing, and, you know, we've been doing it for so long, and yet it still remains pretty much the highlight of what we do. We get to go out there and see thousands of faces rocking. It's a pretty gratifying feeling. Yeah, but I think before that, the most gratifying feeling you get is when you
0:47sort of impress yourself with a song, and it's like you find a melody, lost in this sort of, you know, I just get in like a little trance, you know, and I find some chord progression that stimulates my ear. And then when you get that, there's something really sort of magical about impressing yourself with something that you pulled out of the air. But truly, I feel like the most magical moment, where I feel about, you know, that question, what do I like about music? It's like, I like when I feel alive with something I've created, you know what I mean? There's no better reward than sort of impressing yourself. What songs impressed you recently, that you've written, or that he's written?
1:35I don't know. I think there was a moment with "Another Heart Calls." It's a song on our record When the World Comes Down that is a duet we did with this group, these girls called the Pierces. And I feel like that was the one song where I sort of had the foresight and knew what I wanted immediately. I wrote the song lyrically as a duet, and when we all sort of sat in the room and jammed it out, it was just a magical moment, because we all sort of felt the anthemic power of this song. It's very anthemic, this record. Not that the old ones aren't. I guess Move Along still has those big choruses. Yeah, but is that something you always want to do, really just get these banging choruses with everyone singing along kind of thing? I guess for the shows you're playing now, with the arenas, you kind of have to. No, I think a focus we've always had is writing catchy stuff that people want to sing along to, and, you know,
2:28get someone excited about listening to music. Hooks. Yeah, hooks, even with negative connotations, like "Gives You Hell." To sing that, I don't know, we don't always... You knew, or if it's just kind of... Yeah, a lot of people don't like the fact that it's not about a chick. So recently I've been actually changing my answer to see people's reactions. Yeah. 'Cause I feel like people sort of want to hear that, but honestly, it's about a dude I really hate. And the only reason there's a gender in the song is because I say, "If you find a man that's worth a damn," but that was just a clever line that fit there. It's about this sort of contempt I've had for this person. And I've never been sort of pointing the finger lyrically at somebody in any of our music,
3:15but this song had to sort of happen. It was so bombastic and ridiculous and circusy that it was like, yeah, I feel like we can say fuck you, you know what I mean? Can I say that here, though? No, no, I know, but I feel like there'll be a weight to that. Censor. No. So what's the deal, what's the dynamic in the band? How's it changed a little bit? Did you bring someone else on the road, or? Yeah, we brought out a bass player tech named Ethan who just shreds. And I just feel like the live show needed a different dynamic, because I have all this... You're not playing at all, or you're just singing every show? I'm playing the old songs. Okay. So on the new record, I don't play any of the new jams. Oh, yes. It just gives the show a little more variety, you know, there's scene changes. I dare anybody to say that there's a band that has more energy on stage tonight than we do. We are...
4:07Fighting words. I don't think it's fighting words. I'm just saying, it's like, we bleed up there. We bare our souls every night. Every night a show has a life. And if it has a great birth and then a beautiful sort of middle-aged period, and at the very end, when the show dies, if everybody's coming as hard as they should be, then it's a magical thing, and then you can die. You can die a happy man. Let's play a song. And we were talking about "Gives You Hell," so why don't we give people some hell, 'cause it's massive. Cool. Hey, I'm Tyson. I'm Mike. And we're the All-American Rejects. Here's our song, "Gives You Hell." Yeah. Why? Because it's different. You got the drum machines there. You don't expect that kind of stuff to go analog.
4:53Yeah, we don't have a lot of drum machines on this record. Even just the single, rather, every... that was all organic. That was, really? Yeah, that's our drummer Chris dropping a stick on a speaker. It drops, and they mic the speaker. Every sound on this record's organic. We didn't use any sort of... See, I found it weird, 'cause I didn't expect you guys to do that. Yeah, well, knowing now, we actually feel a little bit, or whatever, that we had to prove to ourselves, I think, that we are a band. A lot of bands just can't do it. A lot of bands, they track their guitars separately, and they just fudge them through Pro Tools, line them up, put the mayonnaise and generic, you know, wipe across the vocals, tune it, make it completely homogenized and take all the life out of it.
5:40And we definitely looked at ourselves and said, all right, can we play? Are we players? And we went and took six months with Eric Valentine to cut a record, when a lot of bands can do a record in about eight weeks because of the magic of Pro Tools. And then we recorded 13, and 12 ended up on the record. So where's that other one? It's waiting. It's back there, ready to jump out. Go ahead. Blazing. Yeah, we need to do something great with it. I know. The second... Yeah, we need to put out a new one. We need to put out a new one of this show, for sure. I think we're going to. Yeah, and we've been having to do a lot of live video stuff for various things.
6:29It's kind of nice. I mean, it'd be kind of cool. Before, we've done, you know, two full show DVDs. It'd be cool to do a compilation DVD. I'd like to do a compilation DVD, but also do it with every small show. Record those, like, 200 people? Yeah, just the really tight ones. I love playing arenas, but I hate playing arenas. Yeah, it's not the same. You have to be completely more of a cartoon, because you have to sort of look at the back row and go, how do I get you off? It's hard. Feed the Children with the record. That's pretty cool, that proceeds of the record go to it. Yeah, we got together right before our record came out with Feed the Children, and they're an Oklahoma-based organization that sort of feeds,
7:20is it domestically? It's the domestic hungry children. Yeah, it's, one in eight children, I guess, are completely starving. And so we took 40,000 records and we gave them the profits, a dollar from every record, which is pretty much 20 cents over our share, you know. So yeah, we gave them some cash, because we're Oklahomans, and we'd really like to help benefit anything that's a homegrown project. Especially if it's charity, especially in this day and age, too, when more people are going hungry every day. Yeah. Let's pick people up, because that's kind of sad, and play another. And I'll let you choose: "Move Along" or do a little secret? How about we do our new jam? Let's do... Yeah, let's do... I want to play it later, but all right. All right, well, fine. No, no, he says I want... You want some nostalgia? You want some nostalgia? He wants to sell.
8:07No, I dig it. I didn't know you're doing a set. That's nice. Let's do some nostalgia now. Let's throw it back. What do you want? Let's do "Move Along." Yeah, okay. I think that's, you know, it's tough to say, because it sounds egotistical, but if there's one of our songs that's going to be a classic song for us, I think "Move Along" is up there in contention with that. So yeah, I would say "Swing, Swing" over "Move Along." Really? Yeah, because I feel like there's that sort of purity in "Swing, Swing," where people didn't have any sort of locked opinions on us. It was just a fan... It's true. It's true. Five questions, one-word answers. You guys can both answer. Road or studio? Depends.
8:53I've heard that before, but come on. Writing on the road, studio on the road. I'm really starting to fudge both those worlds together, and it's really kind of nice. But I'll say, for the sake of this amazing tour, the road. There you go. Yeah, you agree? Yeah, it depends. Okay. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. I'm a McCartney. Cool. Well, that's the way a good band works for you guys. Most important thing in a song: lyrics, melody or cadence? Melody. Yeah. Talk about that hook. Cool. Song you've written you're most proud of? "Mona Lisa." "Mona Lisa" or "Another Heart Calls." I came... Or "Fallin' Apart." Sorry, those three, those three are like...
9:42It's very tough. "Another Heart Calls" is up there, for sure. Okay. One word, All-American Rejects? Everlasting radness.
0:00It's Matt with MSN. We've got Nick and Tyson from the All-American Rejects here. New record, Kids in the Street, and it's awesome. So why don't we start? Yeah, you're welcome. So why don't we start there. Talk about you guys writing together in a little cabin somewhere, talk about coming up with that one. Yeah, Nick and I were in a cabin in Maine, totally secluded, the wrong time of year. Well, not wrong, it was actually perfect for the foliage. It was perfect for the leaves, but as far as just, you know, it wasn't this hot spot, Lake Havasu kind of spring break thing. It was, you know, this bleak
0:45environment. And we'd been there for about five days and hadn't written a single song, and I was starting to go crazy. And Nick, calm as ever, was like, "Dude, just wait, man." And then I remember I was downstairs playing on the piano, and I sang the hook for "Heartbeat Slowing Down," and I put my headphones down. I was like, shit. Because sometimes when I get confidence, I sing it loud enough to see if he'll say something in the other room. And then all of a sudden I was playing it, and Nick was like, "It sounds cool, dude." And then I shot upstairs and we mapped it out. I mean, it's not like it was super quick. I think we just really cared to make sure that it was perfect, because we knew that the chorus was perfect. And we had fun with that
1:31whole breakdown that just sits on E flat for like... So we were like, let's just stay here. It was a long time. Yeah, it's a moment on the record where I felt like we were starting to find something, like the meat of the record. And then soon after that, we wrote the title track, "Kids in the Street." And I think that was about when we started saying, okay, let's get ready to make a record. We spent almost a year, actually over a year, writing. We had 20-some songs, and the last writing trip we took was up on some mountain in Colorado. And Mike and
2:16Chris flew in just so we could hang out, you know, get the band back together. And we showed them all these songs. And by this point, you know, it's been a year, so we've lost complete perspective. We don't know if we should start over or what. And, you know, he calls him the judge, jury and executioner for each and every song. And that's... Butcher now. Today I said butcher. Did you? Because after the fat's cut away, there we have it. Right. They trim the fat. So we listened to every single song that we'd written and decided that we had a cohesive record, something that made sense, and something that we were really proud and excited to go record, and that we did. And the songs with the words that we'd sing along. How have the songs changed live? Have they morphed at all?
3:03A little bit. I mean, we're having some fun with them. Honestly, we're just starting to notice kids singing along with the new stuff, which is great. I mean, we've been living with some of these songs. "Beekeeper's Daughter" is two years old now. So we've been... Exactly. In the world of, you know, publicly, it's only like a month and a half old now. So the only thing that revives, even songs we've been playing for 10 years, is looking out and seeing kids singing it. You know, we've always written records that have hits. That's always been something easy for us, I guess. But the difficult thing, I feel like, has been making a record resonate. And, you know, I feel like we did that pretty well with Move Along. But since then, I feel like this is the first record that we can stand on
3:50and say that it's a record that kids are going to come to the show knowing the entire record, as opposed to just, "Oh, that's that song I hear on the radio," you know? Five good questions, one-word answers. All right. Road or studio? See, you need like a sub-question to that. Right now, road. Sure, road. Lennon or McCartney? Harrison. Good answer. Lennon. Cool. What hits you most when you hear a song: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. I would say melody, yeah. The song you've written you're most proud of? "Heartbeat Slowing Down." Crazy. Ditto. Wow. And in one word, the All-American Rejects. It's hard to say in one word without sounding like a douche.
4:38We're awesome. I don't know. Just us. Us is good. I like that. I like that. It's all we know how to do. I like zombies. That'll work too.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.