SONGSWhat Adam Duritz said about the songs
“Speedway”
Adam Duritz explains how the song got its title, which has nothing to do with the lyrics.
“I could not come up with a name for that song... Ben, our drummer, called it 'I'm Out of Here, You Bitch.'... And then one day I just turned, kind of rolled over, and said, 'Speedway.' I have no idea why. There's nothing about a speedway in the song.”
“Up All Night (Frankie Miller Goes to Hollywood)”
Adam Duritz explains the parenthetical title and where it came from.
“That's just something, the one time I gave in to someone telling me I should change the title... I probably should have just called it 'Up All Night.'... I was really into a lot of Frankie Miller at the time, and when we recorded it, it seemed like I was channeling Frankie Miller.”
“Cowboys”
Adam Duritz says people heard it as a piano song but he always wanted it as a rock song.
“A lot of people thought that should have been a piano song. When I wrote it, people heard it on piano. They thought it should have just been me on piano. But I always heard it the other way, but it was so complicated, it didn't seem like it could be.”
“Hospital”
Adam Duritz explains how the Coby Brown cover came to the band and that their version was finished first.
“Immy brought in a demo that he and Coby Brown were working on... it was just Coby on guitar and him playing bass... we recorded that for our record before they recorded it for their record.”
AUDIOListen
Episode #367 · Counting CrowsJune 2012 · 01:01:37
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Adam. Hey man, how you doing? I'm good. How are you? I'm all right. You getting ready for the tour? How's your voice doing? Fine. Yeah, the guys from Foreign Fields drove up to Nashville yesterday and they got in last night. They're just heading down to the rehearsals, and I'm heading down there in a little while. What are you rehearsing for the tour? You're not going through the whole catalog, are you? I know it's a... I wanted a couple days for the opening bands, because there's three of them. It's more than usual, so I'm not sure how time is going to work every day for every band. So I wanted to make sure, also because it's important, I really wanted them to get on the stage the first day with great sound, great monitors, so that they can play comfortably, and so audiences can also
0:46hear how good they are right away. And a lot of gigs, you'll spend a lot of time getting their sound up to where it should be. So Foreign Fields and Good Old War are coming in today, and Filligar is coming in tomorrow. We've got the venue and we're doing lighting stuff in there anyway, so we're going through everything, and I'm going to go and supervise, try to make sure all their sound is up and running and they sound great, and all the harmonies and things they do are being picked up for the audience to hear. I had the time so that on day one they're sounding great. That's amazing. I love what you do for all these young bands. I was down in South by, at the Outlaw Roadshow, it was cool, it was amazing what you do. And I liked what you did with Augustana last summer, where you guys were all playing on stage at one time.
1:35So where did this idea come from for this tour? This really kind of grew out of the Outlaw Roadshow. I mean, everything with Ryan, you know, from Ryan's Outlaw Roadshow, everything he and I had been doing for the last few years. He's been doing it for longer, but, you know, the showcases we've been putting on are a big part of our lives and what's interesting to us. You know, my passion for working with all these bands. I think we just got into talking about, like, you know, just friend conversations about what I was going to do. You know, after the shows were over, I was kind of mentioning all that they're doing, and I really love all the interaction with all the bands and how great it was to be around so much great music. A lot of these bands are friends right now.
2:22And I was just talking to one of my managers, Nana, you know, and she was really saying, look, you're curating all this material with the bands you work with on your label, and you're curating your Outlaw Roadshow with Ryan, and it's just a big part of your life. Why aren't you integrating this more with Counting Crows? In the past, no one had really thought... It kind of was a step, I guess, in the past, but we got kind of discouraged from taking out a lot of bands like this, because people thought we had different audiences. But I was more enthusiastic about it, and Ryan had been talking about how much we like doing it, and
3:07it was going to be sort of a bummer, because I was too busy over the next year to do a lot of this kind of stuff together. And I don't know, it just sort of seemed like, well, why not? Take a Counting Crows tour and turn it into, you know, a [inaudible] in motion. Why not take what we were doing with the Outlaw Roadshow and just take some of those bands out on the road? And how did you start thinking of the bands? Yeah, it's just kind of a mixture. People suggest stuff. Some of the bands are on the Roadshow, there are bands that have been on the show in the past, there are bands that are on the record that we covered. They're coming out with us.
3:55[inaudible] played the Roadshow this year. We're already writing the third leg of the tour, I think, and they're almost certain to come out with us on that leg. Kasey Anderson had played... The Romany Rye never played the Roadshow before, but I know those guys and love that band, from around when we were recording the record. Kasey Anderson had played multiple Roadshows, and "Like Teenage Gravity" is on the record, so he's coming. We were obviously... I just completely love that band. They're brilliant and they were amazing. I saw them down there this year, we were hanging out down in Austin, and I just realized I'm going to get to see them every night, because it was so great to see them. Most of all, Foreign Fields. Sean Moeller from Daytrotter sent me
4:43an email and said, dude, you've got to check out this record. It's called Anywhere But Where I Am, by Foreign Fields. They're out of this world, they'll blow your mind. And I went on Bandcamp and got the record and flipped out. And I immediately went to Ryan and said, we've got to call these guys up for the Roadshow. We sent him a couple, and he flipped out when he got it, and they came down there and did a Daytrotter session. It was one of the best things I've ever seen. It was so fucking good. And the first time they were doing it, I walked over to Ryan... We'd been corresponding since I bought the record, and we got them to come out to South by Southwest. They were playing the Daytrotter day. It was just great, because Sean had sent the music to me, and I'm just sitting in the house down in Austin watching them play. They finished the first song, I go to Ryan and I said, man,
5:30that was so fucking good. It was amazing, because it really was, and it was so cool to see them do it live. And they go, oh, it's kind of our first gig ever, and we were a little worried about it. What do you mean? Which was just a pretty funny point: "This is our first gig ever." Right now? Oh, well, you're off to a pretty good start. All right, so Saturday was their second gig. Okay, they actually did a Daytrotter session in the middle. By timing I thought it was better. But I mean, they're coming out, they played the festival, and they're friends now, and
6:16Good Old War was on, I guess you could say. Good Old War, Ryan suggested to me, and I got the record and thought they were great. I got the first one they put out, and loved it, and now I've listened to all of them. You know, I think I called them and asked them to come out. And Filligar, they're a band that's been on two or three different Roadshow shows. Ryan has been booking them for different Outlaw concerts for ages, and they're a great band from Chicago. I love them. They really do... like, we played with them when they played CMJ last year for us. They were one of the first bands of the day, because they're pretty rock and steady. But we also like to make sure that shows start off really well. It was really important at the Roadshow in, you know,
7:04Austin this year. There were three stages running, and we needed them all to get started. The outdoor ones would be easier, since it's such a nice place to be, but the big stage, the main stage indoors, needed someone really good to open. Ryan just put Filligar on to open the show for these reasons. Number one, you want to start off really well on every stage. I don't always think of opening as opening; I think of it as starting the show. But you also want a band that can handle doing it. It's a great lesson for bands to learn, but it's a lot of responsibility starting off the show, and you can get down because there aren't many people there. There's a lot of bands that can't handle doing it. We put Filligar on first on the main stage, and at the end of the first song, our [inaudible] turned to me and said, holy crap,
7:53that rocks at noon. Jesus. It was very eye-opening, having them blow the roof off at noon. So there were your bands, you know, Foreign Fields, Filligar, and Good Old War. The next thing is... Oh, Field Report. Field Report, another band. A friend of mine who played several Roadshows works with Field Report, and he called me about them, but they didn't have any music, just a song still in unmixed form, but would Ryan consider booking these guys for the Roadshow? They hadn't played any gigs. Some guy used to be in a band with, you know, Justin Vernon. And they sent me, you know, a couple songs, and they were really good.
8:42It's hard to tell, because they were unmixed. They were very early, rough, from this first album they've made. They were pretty great. And right before we went down to South by Southwest, they dropped off the whole record for me. It was really cool, and it was mixed at that point. And when we saw them play at our show down at South by Southwest, it was epic. I spoke to those guys. I think between them and Foreign Fields, the flights via Wisconsin owned the Outlaw Roadshow this year. All the bands from Wisconsin are particularly good. And the Field Report record, when I finally got the full thing, which isn't released yet, is the most incredible record. It's just
9:32epic in scope. The songs are amazing. The melodies are beautiful, and it's big. And yes, it's not an un-vigorous record, but there is a lot of depth to it, and the songs are these big sprawling epics. They're really something. I mean, I sat there at the show before I'd really heard them very well, and every line he sang, I'm going to fuck a little dad. I was a little bad. So that's a great line. You know, it really kind of knocked me out that way, just on clever lyric stuff. Yeah. Tender Mercies are probably going to do a few shows, since they're guys from our band, but also on the record and also at the Outlaw Roadshow. And I think the [inaudible] are going to come back out for part or all of it. I'm not sure about the last one.
10:20I've been really hoping to have Young Buffalo, who played the Roadshow this year, one of my favorite bands in America right now. I don't know if they can do it. They may not be able to do it, which is too bad. But it's kind of that... it's really a lot of people that we know, but we know them because we love the band, right? And we've become friends over the years, and they've done our showcases or the record. I mean, it's a community of friends, but a community of friends that formed in the first place because a lot of people love music, and a lot of them are out playing it. Really good. You said a lot in there that I want to touch on, but maybe I'll start with South by, because I'm writing a piece on North by Northeast next week, which you're in town for but not a part of.
11:06But it's still going on in the city, and I'm wondering how festivals like that help young bands. What have you noticed, besides the Outlaw Roadshow that you do, obviously? What else do these festivals do for a lot of young bands? Well, I don't know, it's hard for me to say. I don't have a lot of experience with them, because we didn't get to play them. You know, when our record came out, it was just the wrong time of year, right after CMJ, and we'd missed South by. We just blew up within six months, and by the time they rolled around the next year, we were kind of huge. So we never had the point in America where they made a huge difference for us. Where it made a huge difference for us was in Europe, because there's a real thing going on with European festivals, the big festivals, not the club ones like CMJ or
11:56[inaudible] or something. But the European festivals have this wild thing, in that the audiences are very open musically, and they're also really into being there. So they'll get there at noon, you know. There'll be 60,000 people there at noon when the show starts. So, you know, at noon that day there'll be some [inaudible], or somebody else, a British pop band like the Cardigans... Yes, Coldplay. Yeah, then Coldplay, us, R.E.M. I remember us, Coldplay, R.E.M., I can't remember.
12:43I mean, it's a lineup like that. So there could be people who just came for R.E.M. and Coldplay, or R.E.M. and Counting Crows, and they wouldn't need to be there at noon for, you know... But they were. I went out early, I was determined to be there, so Amy and I were on the side of the stage. I got pictures of myself looking out over a massive crowd of people who were already there at noon. And I didn't know that was going to happen, but that's how we got big in Europe. We had no success with record companies and radio in Europe. We went over there at the bottom of the bill and we played the festivals. And the thing is, if you're good and you can pull it off, you're going to be able to go on stage in front of 50,000 people at noon or two or three, and you can do yourself more good playing as an opening band than you can as a headliner.
13:31I mean, you want to get to the headline spot, but the truth is, by the time you're the headliner, most of the people there want to see you. When you're third on the bill, when you're like third from the bottom of the bill, you've got 60,000 people you get to convert. It's just an enormously positive thing. Those European festivals are massive for bands breaking themselves in Europe, because the audience is there, because unlike a lot of Americans, they come out in droves at noon and they're listening. So if you can kill it, you can build yourself. And this... I've experienced American festivals in the last two years, sort of, and even more the indie festivals like South by Southwest or CMJ.
14:18But it really blew me away how indie they still are. You know, there are big people playing and stuff at South by Southwest, but the first time I went, a couple years ago, I don't think I saw any band I'd ever heard of before, except [inaudible]. It was all indie bands, you know, all sort of unknown, and all playing little clubs, and all with audiences. Every single club had an audience in it. Maybe not packed, but there were people there watching everybody all day long, and that blew my mind. I couldn't believe, after all these years, and with how mainstream everything's gotten, that there was an attentive audience there for these independent bands. Now, what it does for the band, I'm not sure, because
15:05part of that has to do with really figuring out what you want it to do for you, because you can build buzz, but you have to know what to do with that buzz. And the question is, what do you want? Do you want to get people to go to your Bandcamp site and buy your record? Do you want to get people to go to [inaudible] and give it away? Or do you want to get signed by a major label? I don't know whether that's the best thing for you or not. You know, and so I think one of the problems a lot of bands are faced with nowadays is figuring out what they want to happen, because it's very uncertain right now. Everyone's trying to figure out if there's a business model for being in the record business, and what that business model is. Is it about getting signed to a major, or is it about building, you know, a medium-sized career for yourself? Is there a way to build that up into something more?
15:51I think we're all trying to figure that out right now. And so what really affects what the thing can do for you is, you need to figure out what you want it to mean for you, because, you know, they can definitely build a lot of buzz, and people come out really hot. I don't know what that means. It's certainly not hot for the general public. It's not like it's going to sell you a billion records. No, but it is, in the surrounding industry, a big deal. You know, two questions: do you want to use that to get yourself signed, or is that a good way to reach out to all the blogs, because now they know you and they'll write about you? Do they jump on a festival like ours? I think there are people who probably would have said that maybe this isn't the thing you do, because you should be playing something bigger. I don't know, but they're going to do it.
16:38And I'm glad they are, because they're a great band. I think our fans will flip out over the passion [inaudible] and their songs. I mean, someone told me a lot of times that they reminded them of us. I didn't quite understand what they meant, because they didn't sound like us to me. I mean, I love their records, and I love his writing, but I didn't get what they meant until I was at a show. When I was at the show, I saw how much is at stake on stage when they play. The heartbreak, the passion, how much is involved, all the blood and sweat in every song. Then I got what it is, right there on stage. There's a lot at stake when we're on stage; that's probably what we do too. I mean, I think that we get pretty locked in emotionally, and Billy gets gone, seriously gone. Yeah. So I mean, I think, you know, I'm not sure that
17:28I would even have a great answer for whether this is the ideal thing for them to do or not. I don't know whether this is the right thing for them. I know that I wanted them to come on it, I'm glad they're here, I don't think it hurt them. Maybe someone would tell them otherwise. I'd say it'll certainly help, at least. Yeah, I mean, sometimes American audiences can be very blasé about opening bands. That's why we're trying to really portray this as a festival. That's why we changed what we did when we did the Traveling Circus. We went out there and played first, and everybody played once, but there wasn't an opening band at all, sort of like a big ball of music. Yeah, I feel like if you were there on time, you'd flip out for all the [inaudible]. I think people did. But we kind of have to remove the opening band thing. You do that.
18:17And we've kind of tried to do that on this tour too, because we're going to rotate. Nobody plays first every night. If you play first one night, you play second the next night, and third after that, and then get back to first. Including you guys? We're just the headline. Okay. Let me get in a lot of trouble if we did it again. Yeah, we wouldn't be playing, because we're playing a long set too, right? Playing two and a half hours at the beginning of the night wouldn't work as well. But they're going to, every night, all three of the bands are rotating spots. And I tried to set it up so that they could be at the top of it when they're in their hometown, without shuffling it around a lot. I'd totally do that for them. So basically it's just kind of rotating, with a couple bounces here and there,
19:02to get a band that spot in their hometown. But basically I didn't really do anything except set it up from the beginning the right way and have it rotate. Because these are all great bands, and they should all learn to play first, and they should all learn to play in front of more people. And also they should all be seen by different kinds of fans. That's the career. It's so important to people. You know, it really is important, especially at this point. And I just think... Well, I just don't want to get into that thing of who's more important than who. You know, I mean, I know we have the headline, but I'd be happy to have it be a circus forever, where we all play together. It was the greatest, most fun I've ever had. But you know, I want to do something different this summer, and also I want you to see these bands and how great they are, not all of us playing together.
19:50We can do some of that too, maybe. But the main thing is, I wanted people to see how much great music there is out there right now that's independent, and that you have to look in different places to find. You've got to go on the blogs, you have to go on Daytrotter, or you have to go to Ryan's Outlaw Roadshow, you have to go to, maybe, [inaudible]. And that's where you can find these guys. Or Underwater Sunshine. Yeah, unfortunately not existing, right? Oh, you can find them on the record. Right, on the record. Yeah, I mean, the thing is, I kind of want you to hear how great these bands are. Because the thing is, they're also not outside the realm of people liking them. There's this real myth that all music that's really good that you haven't heard of is probably hard for you to understand, or it's too [inaudible], you're not going to have much fun, it's not the music you like. I don't think that's true.
20:35The music is generally really great, and the better the music is, the more fun it is. Look, these guys are great. Do you think it's also that there's just too much out there for people to hear? Like, we're just inundated with music? Well, I also think that there were only two delivery systems that people were used to, period. There was MTV and there was radio. I think people are just getting into looking in different places. There's a few more. I think they need to find their own. And, I mean, the truth is, you really do want to... I don't think there's better music. There's way more, you know. And given that, you'll find stuff you love, and these people are really passionate about it. And it's just a matter of, I think, for this whole thing to work in the future,
21:24we don't have to change people's taste, because that's first of all not our business to do. But we do have to change where they go to find it, and just take a little bit more effort. It's a different effort, because you used to have to go to the store, to the record store. Now you can roll over in bed and, you know, type in the [inaudible] blog, and you're right there. You can go to AbsolutePunk. It's really simple, and all these people are delivering free music to you in a way that's [inaudible], because it's online, so you can listen, you can watch videos, you can click and get tickets, and it's all available to you. It's actually easier. It's just that people aren't used to doing it, and what we all need to do is sort of educate them. There's a lot of people who think that music sucks nowadays, or there's not much of it, or it's a dying business. It's really not. It's just a very different business.
22:11It's not a great time to be in a record company, but it is a great time to be a fan. Yeah, I tell you, there's so much music. It didn't really hurt anybody, there being so much. And the nice thing about that is, almost anywhere you look, any of these blogs you choose to go to, they're going to be talking about some great music. Also because they don't waste a lot of time talking about shit. There's a lot of mainstream shenanigans, there's a lot of column space in [inaudible] spent talking about what sucks. The blogs are people who love music, and they spend a lot more time writing about music. And you're a lot more likely to find something that you like when someone else is writing about something they like. Is that why you made this record, to expose bands or tunes that you like? Or were you just having writer's block and said, hey,
23:01here's some songs we've been playing, let's do it? Yeah, neither. I wasn't having writer's block. I wrote a lot of songs. Oh, so you have a backlog? No, no, I was working on a play. Oh, the writing went there. I just didn't want to write for two different things at once. It was just really confusing, because how do I decide where this song goes? It was much easier to get in a different mindset of writing for a play, where I was writing stuff... Also, I was in a space where I really wanted to write stuff that I wasn't going to sing. I've never done that before in my life. But I just got kind of burned out in some ways. I didn't put my head in the space to sing stuff, but I wanted to write, and I got going on that, and it went really well, and it just turned out really cool. I think once we've actually finished that project, it's going to be really awesome. But no, it's not the other reason either, because it wasn't really done to expose bands.
23:50We just wanted to make a cover album for a long time, because there's music we really love, and we felt like we had some great takes on it. You know, we were making really good covers that were like more Counting Crows songs, but we really put a lot of work into the interpretation. And then, when we started to do it, we all talked about what songs to do. Immy brought in a demo that he'd been working on with Coby. I think we were bringing in everything we wanted. I brought in a bunch of stuff too. I had a bunch of songs, because of all the Roadshow stuff, so much involvement and so much music. I had a bunch of stuff. So I had the Romany Rye song, "Untitled (Love Song)." I had Kasey. I had a bunch of songs of Kasey's, but that was the one I wanted to do. And you even got a Canadian, with "Hospital." Oh yeah. I said you even got a Canadian in there opening the record.
24:43It's a Canadian, Luke McMaster. Oh yeah. Luke, Canadian. Loose Canadian. Oh, that's... If it gets played on the radio up here, it'll count as Canadian. I don't know. I mean, I knew he was from LA when I met him. He lived in LA. So I mean, he was friends of Taylor, Taylor Goldsmith's, so I thought they grew up here. So I knew that... I did make friends with people who knew them a couple years ago, and they knew him, and they knew those guys in... I can't remember what they were called before, Delta Spirit, I can't remember what they were called. And, you know, they kind of hooked them up together because they needed [inaudible], and he knew the band, and that's how the Romany Rye got formed. I knew that, but I thought he came from, like, Taylor and some of the guys in Delta Spirit. But I thought he'd come from you.
25:30He's been in LA afterwards too, and now... Yeah, well, he had a successful pop band here in the '90s, and I guess he probably made some coin to move down there after that. And, you know, he's a successful songwriter on the side too, and I'm sure there's more business down there. Well, he looks really young. I know. Yeah, he must have been 18 when he had that hit, because that would have been like '98, '97, something like that. Oh, wow. Which makes him 23? I mean, no, he was really young. I mean, let's see, are there two Luke McMasters? There could very well be two songwriting Lukes. I don't know. Maybe. I don't know. I'm really trying to think. We got to know a lot of people, and those guys all introduced him. But maybe he had a career before. He would have had more connections than me in that.
26:21But you know what? Yeah, he's a really nice guy. I think that they showed up, they were in town for one day when we were working on the record, the second session, and they came by, and the day they came by we were working on a title. Well, yeah, just our timing, really. That's great. We should talk about... You were going to say something about "Hospital." Oh, you know, it's more like... But Immy brought in a demo that he and Coby Brown were working on, because I didn't realize... I'd known Coby for years through his brother. I didn't know Coby worked with him. And then he came in with just, like, an MP3 of this demo he and Coby worked on, and it was just Coby on guitar and him playing bass. And he loves playing bass every time. But he did a very serious [inaudible]. They played, actually. But I mean, we recorded that for our record before they recorded it for their record.
27:10Oh, no, it's a funny thing. Our version of "Hospital" got done and it's coming out, and their version got done after ours, and I don't think theirs is out yet. It's coming out very soon. So that's what we're like. It was really just a matter of what songs we wanted to make, and we picked songs we wanted to play, that we'd been playing, or something that we came up with. You know, we obviously hadn't been playing Kasey's songs or the Romany Rye song. Or, you know, I brought in songs that we'd never touched before. That kind of came from all over too. I brought in "Coming Around," the Travis song, and a Joe Jackson song, "It's Different for Girls." That didn't work in the end. And we tried "Girls Talk" by Elvis Costello and Dave Edmunds, and it turned out really good. And
27:57we also tried... and then the Romany Rye's is newer, and Kasey's is almost as new, and then the Coby Brown song "Hospital," all of which are newer songs. So it kind of came from all over, but it was really just something we wanted to do. And, you know, it's just typical. Once we get to any cover job, we're just looking for stuff we want to play. There's definitely no allegiance to, like, play the famous songs, which there are some on there. We didn't intentionally make the most obscure covers album in the world either. We're a little unintentional. It kind of happens. Well, it's all going to be a third more obscure if you do finish "Local Boy in the Photograph," which was a hit in England, as well as the Travis song. So those songs aren't even obscure over there. They're just obscure over here, kind of, right? But if you're working on this and the Joe Jackson song...
28:42You should get everywhere but [inaudible], right? But, you know, if they'd made the album, I don't know if it would change much. It's still a really obscure covers album. But the truth is, as long as we liked it, we wanted to play it, and it turned out well, that's why they're on there. I mean, it's not so much that we have a lot of processes and strategies about doing certain kinds of things. We don't have the ones that stop us from doing it. There's nothing in there that stops us and says we shouldn't do this because it's too obscure. That's more what happens. I don't think we have any attempt to make it obscure, just that there's no weighting value to one song over another, other than it being a good song and the chance to make a good version of it. And really. So, talking about making good versions, the arrangements, it's almost...
29:31You know, people like to compare records all the time. It almost sounds like This Desert Life, in terms of the country twang that this record has. Did you know that going into it? Or was that just how the arrangements came out when you guys started jamming? Well, I think for how it came out, because it feels so fun... I'd be interested, from some of the songs, I mean, the Tender Mercies songs are Sentry doppelg
30:19No. You know, I come from a really loving... especially the '70s punk, the Dead Boys, and that period. Yeah, that's really been big for me. And '82, I'm sure. So we've got pretty wide taste. And there's no band bigger for me than Big Star, which is probably why I love Young Buffalo so much. Have you heard that record, by the way? No, I've heard the name a lot, though, and I need to. It's on my list. We've got North by Northeast coming. [inaudible] piece. That's really quick. Okay, but I've got to tell you, it's so fucking good. And the whole time I've loved this band. They were our first choice to get on the Saturday show, and they couldn't do it for one reason or another. And when Ryan and I lined up South by Southwest, the first band, both of us said, who do you want to get on the show? Both: Young Buffalo.
31:04They were at the top of the list. And, you know, for me, I saw them there, and I never got what I loved about them so much until I saw them live, and now I think I get it. Big Star, I really don't know if they know that, but I mean, the commonality... and they don't sound similar to Big Star, so there's something about them that is similar. I wish I could [inaudible]. They're so melodic, for one thing. They're piercingly melodic. And they have a really raw edge, which Big Star certainly would have seemed, in 1972, '73. You know, Big Star's music must have seemed very raw at that point. I'll make you say, like... Open the emotion... No, down when it's done. We... This Desert Life, it seems like our least country record. I always think of This Desert Life as our sponsor horse record.
31:53Which I guess is kind of comfortable to me, This Desert Life. That's what we went into the studio... We threw out a lot of songs while we were in there, almost all the songs, and completely spent the whole time just experimenting in the studio with drum loops, with feedback, with recording songs on baby monitors, turning speakers inside out and turning them into microphones, or reversing the polarity. That's what we were just experimenting with. It feels like all our records have country in them, because we come from that. We've got, like, "Goodnight Elisabeth." But you also have "Angels of the Silences" and "Catapult" on there. Oh, "Have You Seen Me Lately?" on that record. And I'm... but I'm like... Funny, I'm...
32:40It's funny. There's something going on with that record for us, because that's the record... We spent this entire last tour adding songs from This Desert Life into the set, and in the end we're playing "Hanging Around," "Mrs. Potter's," "All My Friends," "High Life," "Colorblind," "I Wish I Was a Girl," "Speedway," all the time. The only songs I didn't get in the set were "Four Days" and "Amy Hit the Atmosphere." Oh, really? I was thinking also things like "I Wish I Was a Girl," and I like working all of them in tonight. But we played one, we were playing "Hanging Around" and "Mrs. Potter's." So you're not closing... Which, you're not closing the shows with "Hanging Around" anymore? That used to be the big jam. Well, I guess last summer everyone was playing the whole time. But I mean, that used to be the thing where everyone would come on stage and sing together. Oh, yeah.
33:29We do do it. It's just we don't always do it. Right. There's only something in that now. Like, "Rain King" is a great set ender, and "Hanging Around" obviously is great. And "Come Around," from Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings, has just started being a great encore. I don't think a lot of people know how powerful the emotional reaction in the audience is. I mean, you'd be careful which encores you're getting. But "Come Around" just works, over and over again. It's starting to go crazy, on camera. It gets very emotional at that point, for some reason, I guess because of what it says. But yeah, this is why... But there's something about it. It's funny that you identified that record, though, because coming out of making this record, all everybody wanted to do is play songs from This Desert Life.
34:15We started adding them all back in. I came around to really wanting to play "I Wish I Was a Girl," for some reason, and that led into... You know, we already played a bunch of those songs, but they were at the top of the set too. I mean, a typical opening set could be... We open a lot of shows with "Round Here," into "Untitled (Love Song)," into "High Life" or "I Wish I Was a Girl," into "St. Robinson," into "Hospital," "Hospital" next, and then something else. "Hospital" was playing for... I don't want to be happy about that. I mean, it's just like, the front of the set was loaded with This Desert Life and Underwater Sunshine. How do you guys know that list? It must change from night to night, I would think. Oh yeah, I mean, we make it up after. So sometimes after soundcheck or after dinner,
35:03I'll just text everybody, or I'll go walking around and I'll just ask what song everybody wants to play. And then, depending on the answers I'm getting from the band or not, I'll go to the opening bands, I'll go to the people watching, and ask them, or I'll ask the crew, because we all live together out there. So it's like, what's something that you really want to hear that night? I don't necessarily follow the lists I get from everybody, but it helps me to form an idea of what to make it. And then I'll just start making it. And we kind of get sort of structural patterns, like that thing I just made, that list, that line of songs, right? That was a pretty common structure, not the exact songs. Like, we often use those songs from the new album at the front.
35:52But I could substitute any number of things after "Round Here" at the beginning. I could substitute "High Life," and "I Wish I Was a Girl" was interchangeable. There's nothing that's a great fit after "St. Robinson," but we did, so, you know, using them like that. But, you know, we get more patterns, like repetitive structural patterns, the idea that sets can go up and down this way. More like the shape of the map than the actual things that make up the map. So then you find songs that work. Because it's interesting to find different arcs for sets. You can find different kinds of arcs that work, and then you find, given the songs inside, that you can make it work better or worse. Some nights better, some nights worse. And we do repeat, but we make the set list up
36:39around dinner or after the soundcheck every day. So it changes every day. It's not completely... A lot... If you find patterns that you like, you feel like doing it again. It feels really good to keep testing out different songs in different places within a pattern and trying to get the best possible set list. Are you guys rehearsed to play basically anything at the drop of a pin? If anyone's like, you know what, I feel like playing this one tonight, you guys are ready to go? Well, you know, and if we're not, that's what we'll be trying to [inaudible]. Oh, okay. Yeah, I wouldn't say we know everything, but that's what happened on my last tour. Like I said, I'll probably play everything right now except for [inaudible]. But we could probably play for days. They're going to [inaudible], but you don't need me.
37:27So take me back and learn how to do it. Right. But I can't really hope that we are in the... Speaking of you playing: you're not playing at all on this record, are you, on the new one? Nope. How come? No, I didn't play at all. No, it didn't work out that way, because Charlie's a much better piano player. So I will play on songs where there are certain kinds of feels that I do really well, maybe even better than Charlie, like where I'm laying down the real weight of the song and structuring it, like "A Long December." I can do that very well. I'm not sure he can do that. Or if it's something that really needs to fall a certain way, where I want to be able to really adjust the dynamics of my voice, like
38:18"Goodnight L.A." Then I'll play it. I played those on the record, for the most part. On records, I'd say, a little more in the past. Like, I played "Mrs. Potter's" on the record, but live it makes no sense for eight minutes for me to be out front. I also played "Colorblind" and "Black and Blue" and "Holiday in Spain" on the records, but they make a lot more sense for me to be out front. Can you play a little "Holiday in Spain" on the piano, though? Have you done it at some point? I've maybe done it somewhere, when it was a stripped-down version or something, but it's not normal, because at the end of the night it's a lot of songs. It's very late in the show, and it's time to be actually up front for that one. And also because Charlie is a good piano player, you know, and Charlie does need to be on that song. But still, it would be a joy, I think.
39:05I'm more likely to play on a song if I wrote it and the performance of it is based around how I want to play it. Those songs are mine, whereas these songs I didn't... They're mostly... Yeah, it didn't need me on piano. It was better with Charlie, and it freed me up to just sing. And I'll play piano when I can express something necessary, but I'm not just going to take a piano part, because Charlie is so much better than I am. I mean, I can barely play, but Charlie's great, you know. I taught myself, and I can't just play along with anybody. So I can play the things I write, and I play a lot of dynamics, but not with any sort of clear melody or any of the things Charlie can do in his sleep. I can't do it at all.
39:56Right. Yeah, I can't play piano very well. Okay. But do you ever... I might say I can't play very well. I can't play piano very well. I mean, the other instruments I'm really bad at. I'm sorry, but... I can play... we're on... obviously we can play... I'm here. Oh, "Omaha," perfect. You know, probably pretty much everything, honestly. On Satellites, we could play "Catapult," "Angels of the Silences." Yeah. We haven't played "I'm Not Sleeping" in a while; we couldn't play that today. "Goodnight Elisabeth," we can play. "Children in Bloom" and "Have You Seen Me Lately?" we'd probably have to rehearse more. We haven't done them in a while. We haven't done "Another Horsedreamer's Blues," but I bet we could. "Recovering the Satellites," we could do. "Monkey," "Mercury," "A Long December," "Walkaways," we can play all those. This Desert Life, I told you, everything. Hard Candy, we can play "Hard Candy."
40:47We would probably rehearse "American Girls." We'd probably stumble through it, but it wouldn't be [inaudible]. "Good Time," we've played... "Richard Manuel Is Dead." "Good Time," we've played a shitload. Good. I love that too. I love that song. That was like... I really wanted that to be like... that was my idea for it, kind of like really slow songs, like Hot Buttered Soul songs, with that bass that cuts off and stops. You know, it's really bass-driven, and then a guitar that rips through, which seems like a song that doesn't belong. Yeah, exactly. It comes off... because it's so intended to be Hot Buttered Soul. Oh, but people don't think of it really; they're just not thinking Hot Buttered Soul. You can play "Richard Manuel," I think, probably "Goodnight L.A.," "Butterfly in Reverse." We'd need to check
41:37"Miami," and "New Frontier," "Carriage," "Black and Blue," "Why Should You Come When I Call?" "Black and Blue" you could play, all those. "Why Should You Come When I Call?" is just hard to play without the extra singers, because everybody else is playing on it, and everybody does lots of parts, and that's the power of it. It was great on the Traveling Circus, because of all the different singers, right? You can make those walls of harmonies. That song is just really hard to... This way we could do "Up All Night," but I'd have to see it again. That song's better with more harmonies. So on this tour, if we get them to come play with us... because it worked really well on the Circus, because everyone could sing that big harmony. Yeah. Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings, we can play "1492," "Hanging Tree," "Sundays," "Insignificant," "Cowboys," "Washington Square," "On Almost Any Sunday Morning," "When I Dream of Michelangelo." We could play everything on that record except for
42:27"Anyone but You." We haven't ever gotten that one together. You mentioned Richard Manuel in there, and I'm thinking, not even the song, just as a dude, and The Band, and how it kind of went The Band and then a couple of bands after that, probably, and then you guys kind of took over that sound. And now Dawes kind of has that sound, and they're kind of the band for the people that want to hear that, and you cover them on the record. Yeah. And I saw you at the show at South by, and I'm wondering, how did you stumble upon them? How did you get to meet Taylor? I don't think it was through Ryan. I think that we were down there last year.
43:14Middle Brother was playing, and everyone was talking about it, and I hadn't really listened to the band then, I don't think. But right after that, I really started... I really didn't see what was going on, and Ryan was telling us how all three of those bands were [inaudible], Middle Brother at Newport Folk. They were all [inaudible] Delta Spirit and Deer Tick and Dawes, and they were all on Daytrotter. So I was at that point inhabiting Daytrotter, you know, just for music all day long. Okay. But, you know, I went on Daytrotter and started listening to Dawes, which is probably why the first thing we recorded from Dawes was taken from a Daytrotter session, "All My Failures," you know, on the record. But I think it was there, and then
44:00we had a ton of mutual friends. So I might have been talking about it on Twitter or something, and I heard back from Taylor, you know, because he's a big fan too. It's a little mutual admiration society. That's almost funny, because it's kind of a running joke at this point. There's a weird social media thing nowadays, just being on Twitter and being musically involved on Twitter, whether you're a blogger or a musician. There's just a lot of chatter, a lot of interaction, a lot of talk online between people. You see yourself up there, you're like, oh, that guy likes my band, I love him, I'm a fan. Or you discover them. So Taylor and I... I mean, the same with Ryan. Ryan and I had been friends for three years, I want to say, before we were actually in the same place. Yeah. There he's saying they have my friend [inaudible] on Twitter.
44:50We were all corresponding and talking, and writing for Ryan's Outlaw Roadshow. But it wasn't until we were hanging out one day in Austin last year that we suddenly realized we'd never hung out together before. And Taylor and I had talked and corresponded and texted and phoned each other and talked about stuff going on with our records for a good year, probably. And I had just never been able to make it out when they were around, in LA, or maybe they were on tour, or they were playing a gig in New York and I was either out of town or in one of my not-leaving-the-house stages. And then, I remember before, he asked me last year when they were coming in on tour with
45:37the Belle Brigade, and a band called... Blitzen Trapper. Listen, Blitzen Trapper. And they were all on tour together, and they came to Webster Hall, and he texted me the night before and said, hey, I've got [inaudible] here, a [inaudible] bar, asking if you want to come. Oh, no, no, no, no. Actually, I said, yeah, okay. I got up and went down there, and then to connect it all, I think... Hey, Sean Moeller from Daytrotter called me or texted me that day and said, I heard you're down. I'm like, no fucking way, I can stop down. They would all know... We'd gone so long without ever hanging out. You know, I think
46:23So, thinking of me and Sean Moeller: I didn't actually hang out with him ever until [inaudible] last year, when I went down to see [inaudible] and hung out with him. And I spent most of my time at South by hanging around the Daytrotter house this year. It's just so cool, and awesome. So, I mean, yeah, that's how I met Taylor, really. We'd been sort of friends, you know, acquaintances, for a long time before we actually got to hang out. And then we hung out that night at the bar, and then after the show the next time, we all went out for a while. And they had to take off, and then just, you know, wherever we could pick it up since then. I was out mixing... Let's clean up the record. The Belle Brigade were in town, and Dawes and Blitzen Trapper came through on the latter part of their tour, to the Fillmore. So me and our engineer jumped in the car and drove down from Napa
47:12and watched the show and hung out down there for a while. And it was a pretty sudden night, actually, since I ran into my thesis professor from Berkeley. I didn't turn in my thesis. It's the only reason I didn't graduate from Berkeley. Huh. Oh, what did you do? It wasn't good. I thought I got an extension on it, and she told me at the time, you need to turn it in within the first six months, or you don't. That's what happened. Okay, well, I will, but I didn't. I got really caught up in writing songs right then, and I just... Well, I couldn't seem to write a thesis anymore. Sure. And then a few years later, when we got signed, I wrote a letter and said... Before we got signed, I just wanted... I said, I thought I left it in your
47:59faculty box at Berkeley, but I thought later I might have left it in the wrong box. And I just said, look, I know I never did it, but I just want to thank you, because I learned a lot, and I don't think I'd be a writer if it wasn't for, you know, the education I got there. I don't want you to think it was nothing good for me. I just want you to know I'm in bands and writing songs. It's going really well. I never did turn it in, but I didn't want you to think that I didn't turn it in out of spite. The truth is, I really appreciated my education, and I think you made me a really good writer. But I think I left it in the wrong box, and so it always bothered me all these years. Like, 20 years later it was really bugging me, you know, that I'd never been able to tell her that. Because one of her students actually turned out to be a writer. So, you know, I wanted to tell her that I appreciated it. Because sometimes it's like, you hear people going on and on and on,
48:48"I didn't get a degree, and yeah, they do all this stuff, it didn't matter, they were writers." I don't want to feel that way. I'm a writer because of a lot of things, including my education, you know. And she came up to me at the fucking Dawes show. What was she doing at a Dawes show? She had some friend of the family who knew somebody in Taylor's family, or something. I don't know what exactly it was, but she was at the Dawes show, and she walked up to me and introduced herself, and it blew me out. I'm like, wow, I've been waiting to have this conversation for about this many years. I want to say thank you. And she was really cool. I don't think it's what she expected. I mean, I've really been waiting to tell her thank you for a long time. So that's really cool, man. Thanks. Also, I wonder how many students who actually fuck up and don't get their degree come back and thank you
49:35anyways, right? I don't know. Basically, we've been talking for like an hour. I don't know how much time you have. I feel like I'm taking up your whole afternoon here. I just got to get in the car and go watch Foreign Fields. I understand. I'm in my house, because I had a lot of extra days in New York, so they told me to stay here. Hmm. I was going to say, then we'll wrap it up. We do something called Five Questions: just five quick questions, one-word answers. Yeah, they just went down to start the rehearsal, so I'm going to go down in a few minutes. Okay, we've got some time, then jump in the car. Okay, so let's do Five Questions then. Road or studio? What was that? We prefer... yeah, I'm terrible. I'm only good at really long answers.
50:26I think they're both really important. I think there's three aspects to being in a band. I think you write songs, alone at home. I think the main thing is this incredible thing where you take a song and turn it into... You take a skeleton and turn it into a song, in the studio, when the band gets a hold of it and you make a song out of it, not just some chords and lyrics. And that's really important and really fucking hard. And I both appreciate and I'm proud of what we do, and I hate it, because it's just fighting with your friends all the time. And we go on the road, and you turn songs into something different every night. I think that's really important too. And they're all great and they're all a nightmare. It's a nightmare to be home alone by yourself trying to write, and it's a nightmare to fight with your friends and make a record,
51:13and be sick of each other, and every night might be waiting for a million years on the road. It's also great to do all three of them, and to have a life where you accomplished all that stuff. It's pretty cool. But I don't really have a favorite. I'm really bad at what favorite I should pick. All right. Well, there's a good question you never have an answer for. Like, let's mix that, and it comes with... you know, they're all really important. I'm not playing straight. We'll continue through and we'll see how these go. That's why I guess you might get it. Yeah. Lennon or McCartney? And you know what, I said Lennon or McCartney, I've got an answer. Okay. McCartney. When you hear a song... Cool. When you hear a song, what... He's a little wide. I'll tell you why, though, because... You understand that? All right, because...
51:59Because I think Lennon's a great, especially great writer, really. But melody is unquantifiable. I mean, you [inaudible] today, so you've got to [inaudible]. I don't know where people get melody from: the ability to write something that sticks in people's heads for 20, 50, a couple hundred years. The ability to be Puccini or McCartney, I don't know where that comes from. I don't know how people do it. I don't know how one guy wrote so many pieces of music that I could hum 50 years later. Yeah. I don't know how it's possible, and that to me is such a rare thing that...
52:45Cool, all the [inaudible] and perspective, cool songs in the world are great, but the only reason we love music is because of that, the [inaudible] studio stuff. So, agreeing, it's the ability to write something that we're all humming. It's not about them being dumb songs. It's just they're like... you can't stop humming, and that's all you remember. I'm sorry. It's all you remember. I've been living in great, great Lennon songs too, but McCartney's ability there is like... Picked without fear. That kind of leads into the next one a little, because the next question is: what hits you first when you usually hear a song, lyrics, melody or rhythm? I was raised on melody. I grew up in Oakland, and funk was a big part of life there, and funk is a big part of my life.
53:36And so I'd say melody or rhythm, I would think. Probably it's what I write first too. I write the melody and rhythm, not lyrics. Yeah, and I always write from music, melody and rhythm, which is very tied to that, before lyrics. Maybe I might have a line, but it always starts with a melody that I think is interesting. Cool. Song you've written you're most proud of? Well, honestly, I have a lot of trouble with this kind of question, because I don't really tend to weigh the value of one song against another, because they're kind of like... you like your elbow, you need it. I know that's a pretty big part to me.
54:22I don't know if that really changes a lot. I would have said "Cowboys" years ago, just because it's got a lot of scope to it, and also the orchestration we did for the band: to have a punk song moving at that speed, with seven of us, all of the instruments playing, weaving in and out of each other, and have it work like that one does. It's pretty... A lot of people thought that should have been a piano song. When I wrote it, people heard it on piano. They thought it should have just been me on piano. But I always heard it the other way, but it was so complicated, it didn't seem like it could be. No, it sounds good. It could have been fun. I mean, it sounds cool the way it came out. I like it as a rock song. Yeah, I mean, that's how I wanted it to be. I never thought it should be a quiet song. But I think that
55:10well, the most beautiful song, I think, that we have recorded is... Are we gonna get the answer? I think that's really, really beautiful. It's all our [inaudible], like the whole experience: writing, and the band's composition, arrangement, performance, which is a big part of the hard part of doing it. And it's so beautiful to me and so perfect as a recording. And you have that weird [inaudible], quirky beat shit going on, but it's also very, very beautiful, kind of a waltz. If I can have all that weird stuff on it and still have it be a waltz, I really love that song. I think, other than "Cowboys," for pure writing right now, there's the last song I wrote for the play, called "The Shortest Goodbye." There's the one with the [inaudible] girl, and so...
56:01a trio song. It's like three separate songs for these three women that becomes one trio in the end. Like three little vignette songs, each woman's thing, and it becomes one song. Yeah, that's my favorite thing I've written. [inaudible] to do something that we did more recently, because it's really rough and emotional. And that song, "The Shortest Goodbye," I told them, is my favorite long title I've heard. I don't write titles like that generally, but "The Shortest Goodbye" is a long title. "Richard Manuel" is a long title. I like the long title. But that's not yours. Well, isn't there something in parentheses too? Yeah. Okay, I'm not... I'm not following that. Parentheses is bullshit. That's just something, the one time I gave in to someone telling me I should change the title. Okay. I probably should have just called it "Up All Night." It was originally called "Frankie Miller Goes to Hollywood," right? About how it's fun, you're...
56:53I was really into a lot of Frankie Miller at the time, and when we recorded it, it seemed like I was channeling Frankie Miller. And then it's really hard with it. I just can't call it [inaudible], and I get stuck where I can't name a song, and you get really stuck on that. Like "Speedway": I could not come up with a name for that song. Long after I wrote it, I couldn't name it right away, and Ben, our drummer, called it "I'm Out of Here, You Bitch." It was a meeting... it's called "I'm Out of Here, You Bitch." And that stuck in my head so badly for the song that I never could get over the title for it. And then one day I just turned, kind of rolled over, and said, "Speedway." I have no idea why. There's nothing about a speedway in the song. I don't know why it's named that; it seems like the right name. I know that I'm not very rich with the long name. No, yes.
57:41Yeah, I guess my answer to that question, as you actually asked it: there are [inaudible], the most beautiful. I love what we did with "Cowboys," although I tend to take "1492," because that's so visceral. But maybe as far as writing, for me it's probably the [inaudible]. Right. Cool. And the last of Five Questions: in one word, Counting Crows. Really quickly like that. In one word. The guy that you really think you've done one-word answers... I have no idea. I want more to keep you from that. I got nothing. That's something.
58:33I'm the guy who's using this. I don't know. What do people even say for that? Some people say "live," and people say... Yeah. Yes, they'll do that. Yeah, I've heard that before. Yeah, it's a range of stuff, man. And it all depends. People just think of the first word that comes to their head. I've heard, like, "brick" and "sidewalk" before, which aren't the greatest answers, but it's funny and it works. A lot of things, you think of all shown together as one word, hyphenated, like a Twitter handle. Awesome, man. Thank you so much. I'm really excited to see you guys play next week. It's going to be awesome. All right, man. Thank you. All right, take it easy. Okay, okay. Five Questions, lame, but it's going to look really nice written out, though. I'm very excited. All right, man. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you so much. I'll go try out Young Buffalo right now.
59:21Oh, you know what else, the one other thing. Yeah, I've got to recommend everybody right now... I'm not listening to it. Have you heard of this clean? Nothing to hear. Say that again, I missed that. The band? No, this clean, this is clean. It's B-I-S... B-I-S-Q-E. Again, this clean. It's kind of like plastic wrap, I think. It's a band from Seattle, this woman [inaudible]. It's like a trio. It's so fucking good. It's like some really good songwriter... It's going to come off wrong, but like if a really good songwriter, like a little bit like Chrissie Hynde or Joni Mitchell, wrote a bunch of songs and sang them with a voice that was like Pat Benatar, or the angry part of, like, Joan Jett,
60:10but not as... maybe a little, but more like the emotionality, like [inaudible], that she has. But the melodies... But she's fucking... She plays guitar and they're a trio, and the songs are like the greatest rock songs a girl could have ever... I've ever heard. It's just knocking me out. There are these great pop melodies, like you get on a... I keep thinking about that. It's not really what I'm thinking. I think it's wrong. Yes, I'm just... but with this kind of depth through it, but not as free-flowing as [inaudible]. It's more like sticking those melodies and killing you with them. And the album is so fucking good. I'm addicted to it. I listen to it over and over and over and over again, and it just never gets old.
60:59And it's just so fucking good. There's going to be one song on the album... I like the rest of it, I could go over and over. I did for weeks too. And every time I've told someone about this, like you, you know, they write me back, or it ends up in the article how they loved it. So I'm going to say to you that the [inaudible] album is this. It's just like [inaudible]. This clean, [inaudible]. It's like one of those 35-minute records, 30 minutes. It's just awesome. Nice. Well, if you're going to give me one, I'm going to give you one from Canada. His name is Dan Mangan. I don't know if you've heard of him yet, but he's... I'm not named and then gi energy a
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.