← All interviews
Interview · April 2007 · Calgary

David Byrne (The Talking Heads) Interview

David Byrne talks his Wired essay on the music business, self-release, what artists really make from iTunes, the story behind "Once in a Lifetime" and projects with Brian Eno and Fatboy Slim, in this 2007 interview with Matt Schichter in Calgary. Talking Heads are best known for "Once in a Lifetime", "Burning Down the House", "Psycho Killer" and the concert film Stop Making Sense, and Byrne later created American Utopia.

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusic LegendsMusicians

In the collection Music Legends

Lennon or McCartney? David Byrne’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat David Byrne said about the songs

“Once in a Lifetime”

David Byrne says the verses were modelled on radio preachers, with the chorus as a release.

“inspired by a lot of the kind of radio preachers that I'd heard... I just started improvising this rant... it was a person kind of preaching to themselves about how sort of alienated they sort of felt. And then the chorus kind of is the release. The person transcends that feeling.”

Watch the moment

David Byrne explains the song was built from band jams, with Brian Eno improvising the chorus melody.

“When we recorded that record, we were recording kind of basic tracks and kind of jamming and improvising different things... I'd sometimes improvise melodies on top of it, or in that case, Brian Eno improvised the melody that became the chorus.”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

David Byrne InterviewInterview · 25:41 · 12,000 views
Archive footage

25:41 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #104 · David Byrne (The Talking Heads)April 2007 · 00:25:41

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00How are you? I'm very good. Good to hear. I want to talk to you about the Wired article quite a bit, because I find it absolutely fascinating. Oh, okay. You're in Calgary, is that right? I am, yeah. Have you ever been up here? Have you ever played up here? Yes, yeah, did a festival there about three years ago or so. Folk festival, maybe? Yeah. Oh, okay, cool. It was really good, and I rode my bike around. Yeah, it's nice. It was a nice day, so it was good. Good to hear. How are things? Where are you right now? In New York? Yeah, I'm in New York. How are things there? Just fine, just fine. Home, kind of writing. Oh yeah, a new record, or are you working on... New record stuff, and some book about biking, that kind of thing. Oh yeah. So you're a big bicycler? Yeah, not as an athlete or anything like that, just as a way of getting around. Oh yeah, very nice. Are you an American citizen? Can you vote? I used to be able to. I'm not an American citizen. I have a green card and I used to be able to vote. And then recently, either they changed the laws

1:01or I was mistaken, but I got caught, and they said, no, you can't vote. Oh. I swear I learned when I was going to grade school that I could vote for everything except the president. Hmm. Green card holders. But now maybe they've changed that. Interesting. Well, it's an interesting time to be down there, that's for sure, with everything that's going on. That's an understatement. Yeah, I know. Oh, boy. Well, even especially this week with the whole Spitzer thing. Uh-huh. Yeah, yeah. I think it got a little too much publicity for something, but maybe that's just me. Oh, man. So tell me about this thing going on... I'm still wondering, yeah. What's that? Why are they not telling us about the other clients? I read your blog about that. Yeah, it's true. I wonder who they are. Yeah, I wonder. They must be kind of wealthy and important people. And it's kind of amazing that they're only talking about Spitzer. Yeah, I wonder if one of them is Bill Clinton. Wouldn't be overly surprised. It wouldn't be

2:01surprising. Uh-huh. So tell me about this thing you've got Tuesday in Brooklyn, the benefit for peace in Iraq and justice. It's an event that I think mainly Laurie Anderson kind of came up with. I think she just said, oh, maybe it's time to do something to remind people that, although the marches against the invasion of Iraq haven't happened much recently, that we still strongly disagree with the policy. And she said it might be important to kind of make that point from time to time. And let's do a concert. Let's do a little concert to raise money and awareness and that sort of thing. So I said, sure, sure. If it's just a couple of songs, I can take a break and do that. Do you have a band that you do that kind of stuff with, or do you just sit up there on your own? No, I've got a couple of people from my own band, and I'm going to do some songs that I haven't put on records. And I've asked some of the

3:01others, like Norah Jones and Jake from Scissor Sisters, and let's see who else is there. Damien Rice. He's phenomenal. Yeah, a few of the others. I said, will you sing backup? I'll teach you the harmonies. Oh, that's cool. Then we'll just do it as like a little vocal harmony group. I like that. That's cool. I thought, oh, that'll be really nice. Yeah. Since they're all really great. So I'm excited about that. Yeah. Why not use their talents if they're going to be there? Right. Uh-huh. Okay. So let's get into this Wired article, because I do a show for local musicians here in town. And we talk a lot about the business on the show and how they can move to that next level, almost, if you will. And my major concern about the whole industry at the moment is, and I don't understand why labels, for example, I know your buddy Eno is working with Coldplay right now. The record, I think they're mixing it right now. So it'll be mastered in what, a month or so. Why can't they just put it out right away? Why must there be this marketing and promotion wait time?

4:00Yeah, you'd think that Radiohead and some others would have kind of said, well, you don't really need to do it that way. No, not when you have that brand name, right? Uh-huh. Yeah, and you have this huge fan base. As soon as you say it's available, they're going to go and get it. Yeah, the transition to the new kind of model, or whatever that's going to be, is awfully slow. I suspect that Coldplay, Coldplay's with EMI, aren't they? I think. Yeah. I think this is their last one for them too. Yeah. So I think they don't have a whole lot of choice in the matter at this point. But you would think that maybe EMI would say, this band is going to be up for it. Let's try something different. Yeah, hopefully. I know there's a band from Canada called Stars. I'm not sure if you're familiar with them, but they decided, we're just going to throw it out there as soon as it's done, because no one's going to steal it that way. There's no reason for you to steal it if it's not out there for free first. Yes,

5:02yeah, yeah. I think that's more of an issue for bands like that, where as soon as they release something it goes on to fan sites and everywhere else. I think I know the Radiohead people basically felt like, well, people are going to put our record out there for free anyway. We may as well make it available ourselves. Not everybody has that kind of problem. And not everybody has that kind of fan base. Yeah, exactly. And the Radiohead fans are diehard music fans, at least for the most part. Now I know that, yeah, there's some other things. I think Barenaked Ladies, I believe they have some kind of arrangement where they kind of run... Yeah, what did they tell me? They were on the show about a year ago. It's kind of like they have their own record company, or like their management runs their record company or something. Yeah, yeah, that's it. Nettwerk runs it. And then

6:02their label, I guess, just does the marketing and distribution kind of stuff. Yeah, yeah. Do you think that's the future? I know you talk about that in the article a little bit. That's the way the labels will go? I think that's one future. It definitely, I think, seems like a viable future, at least for hard product, for CDs, to have somebody else manage all the day-to-day running of things like that. Yeah. It could get a bit much for some of the bands. And I think if somebody, like the management or Nettwerk or somebody else, runs it for a number of groups, then it becomes cost-effective. Do you think we're going to get away from album artwork, though, if that's the case? If you're only doing a little bit of manufacturing, the product isn't as much, as it seems to be going? Yeah. Is that a shame? Are you going to miss it? I probably will. Yeah, I mean, I like reading about the artist and holding

7:01it in my hand and reading it while I'm listening to the record. That's a nice convenience. I mean, if they make a nice, a beautiful PDF or something that has lots of information about the songs and how it was done, or the band or whatever, with artwork on it, I can always print that out and read that as well. It's not quite the same as having it linked to the package that the music comes in. But as people spend more and more time in front of their computer, it does seem like that's going to be where all the stuff is based anyway. Yeah, it's true. And there you can give people things that you can't give them in a CD package. You can give them little movies, or you can give them little podcasts and recordings of interviews and all kinds of stuff like that. It's funny now that people want more. You can't just have a record.

8:02You have to throw in that extra stuff for people to buy it. Yeah. It's like DVDs. It's the bonus stuff that sells it. Yeah, exactly. It's not enough anymore just for the main product. Yeah. You have to have all these crazy features. I know it's not always the case, but do you still think for bands to actually get out there and to become, I guess not every musician wants to be famous. You just love the art and you want to do it for that. But to get those TV performances, and I work on the radio, I know how this business works. It's very homogenized. You need that label backing. How can a band without it be considered a serious act? Oh, that's, yeah. I know locally here there's all these bands now coming out of Brooklyn, and I'm familiar with not all of them, but some of them. I bought their CDs or bought their MP3s online somewhere. And some of them I really like. But I have no idea what record label they're with or anything like that. And the marketing,

9:00how I heard about them, I think, although they're written about in the press, pretty much exclusively was online. And some of these bands have then developed sizable followings. And I go, wow, there's them. And then there's some other groups I've seen that seem to sell out the small, you know, the music halls or whatever here in town. Yeah. And I go, how did everybody find out about this group? I've never seen ads for them. They're never going to get played on kind of regular radio. But they somehow managed to develop a following and connect to the people who are interested in them. How different is it now? That's very encouraging, I think. Oh yeah, for sure. Well, especially with MySpace and all that, it's completely changing the way people find out about music. Do you think there's, I don't want to say there's too many bands, because that's not the way I want to say it properly, but people are spoiled for choice. I think so too. I think so too. And

10:01I've been down to South by Southwest a number of times, not this year, but you get there, you just go, oh my God. Oh, I can imagine. We don't need any more singer-songwriters. I think we have enough. We've got our quota now. It worked. The experiment worked. But then somebody will come along and they'll write something that is in a pre-existing genre and they'll do it, and you find it really moving. And you go, well, yeah, okay, I won't write this genre off yet. Do you think we'll ever have an explosion like the Beatles again? Do you think it's possible? I kind of do, I don't... It's a little hard to imagine, because that was something that seemed to reach from like the super mainstream all the way eventually to people who were more esoteric music fans. That seems

11:03pretty hard to pull off. Yeah, I know. Well, especially now, people are spoiled for choice. People are on the internet all the time. It's not as easy to, you know, there were only three TV channels back then. Yes. You got on one, you got one third of the population, almost. Exactly. And so that was what everybody knew about that week. And yeah, you can't imagine that kind of thing happening. But at the same time, you look at other things that happen on the internet, like in blogs, or the things that get passed around and all that kind of stuff. And you realize that some slip-up or some ridiculous image or some kind of thing that somebody finds gets passed around. And it seems like half the world has seen it in two days. And you go, wow, the fact that something can be so ubiquitous and travel at such speed makes you think that, well, if it's the right kind of thing, it could kind of

12:00excite a huge amount of the population really quickly. Yeah. But then, as with those things, everybody kind of gets bored with it and turns away from it in five minutes. Very true. It's almost like they're all once in a lifetime things. Uh-huh. You like that little segue? Let's play a song. So why don't you tell us about "Once in a Lifetime"? When we recorded that record, we were recording kind of basic tracks and kind of jamming and improvising different things. And then we'd work with those jams and kind of structure them. They still didn't have words or anything like that, but we'd say, okay, this part will be the verse, and this will be the chorus, and this will be the middle eight over here, and this will be the introduction, and that'll be the ending. So although there was an awful lot missing, it had the underlying structure of a song. And then I'd sometimes improvise melodies on top of it, or in that case, Brian Eno improvised the melody that became the chorus. And I, kind of inspired

13:03by a lot of the kind of radio preachers that I'd heard that year and the year before, I kind of got myself up into this thing where I just started improvising this rant, and I'd write it down. I was at home. I'd write it down and then structured it so that it fit the song. And I thought it was like this preacher talking about, well, I was imitating a preacher. But it was a person kind of preaching to themselves about how sort of alienated they sort of felt. And then the chorus kind of is the release. The person transcends that feeling. Very nice. At least that's what I think it does. Yeah, well, definitely. They juxtapose each other quite well. Yeah, we had no idea it would be a popular song. And I don't think it was ever a single. Oh, really? No. It just became... Then, they

14:02still had singles. Yeah, they still do in England now, though. Really? And, well, whether or not it was a physical single, it also meant that it got worked to radio, and radio was told, play this one. [inaudible] And yeah, I don't think that... It really kind of happened sort of spontaneously and over a very long period of time. It wasn't like it happened when the record came out. It sort of happened over like three or four years. I also did a video for the song where I kind of imitated a kind of preacher who was kind of going into a trance and getting the fever and shaking all over and all that kind of thing. And at that time MTV was just beginning and they didn't have a lot of videos to play. And they actually did play videos. Yeah. When they played video. Yes. So between myself and, it seemed like, just a handful of other artists, if we'd give

15:01them something, they'd play it to death. Must have been nice. So that song got on there and they liked it, and people liked the video. And that, I think, really helped it a lot as well. Because as I said, it wasn't like an immediate radio single. But I think that all these little elements sort of helped people start to hear it. And I guess they liked it. And it still works to this day. Wow. It's crazy. You write a song 20 years ago and it's still, you know, out there. I know. Must be a really cool feeling. It is pretty nice. I can't deny that. You think... I remember Jason Mraz was on the show a few years ago and he was talking about, you can't be in this business to make money. He'd be fine going back to playing coffee shops and sleeping on people's floors, just because he loved playing music so much. And I wonder if that's the way it's going to go, because you can't make money off the product anymore.

16:00Yeah, I think it's going to take a serious hit, and the musicians are going to be hurting for a while. But I think a lot of them are finding that through these alternative mediums they can reach an audience. And maybe they're finding other sources of income. I don't know if it's enough. People talk about that they're getting income from kind of a corporate sponsor, or licensing songs to a TV show or a movie or something like that. Yeah. Well, I license songs to movies and TV shows. Well, you sold that song to Microsoft too, right? Yes. But I know that part of the reason I can do that is because those songs were popular to begin with. But to license an unknown song for a band that's coming up,

17:01they're not going to pay you that same amount of money. Yeah. Until you're kind of established. But then if they kind of help establish you by putting your song in TV shows or whatever, then that might work. Well, look at Feist. I mean, she has a following up here in Canada. But now, because of the Apple iPod commercial, I don't know if she's raking in the coin, but I know she's doing all right. Uh-huh. It's an interesting conundrum, because that used to be selling out, right? And now it's like, well, you've got to eat. This is how it's got to be done. Yeah, I found it a little bit iffy. But at the same time, yeah, for some artists, it really does the trick. I don't know if she got incredibly well paid by Apple, but it certainly got her song to a very large audience. I don't think anyone gets incredibly well paid by Apple. I mean, I thought you made more in the music store

18:00than it seems that you're saying in the article here, that it basically is like a record deal. You're not making the money that people think you are. Yes, it's true. Yeah. Unless, I wonder, what if you have no label and you sell your stuff yourself to iTunes? You still don't make the dollar, though. You don't. Yeah, you still don't make the whole dollar. iTunes still takes 30 percent. But you're getting a whole lot more than if you did it through a record label, where traditionally you would still get only like 15 percent of the dollar. Whereas if you do it yourself, you're getting closer to that 70 percent, which is a huge difference. Oh yeah, for sure. And you pose an interesting question in the article. In order to make more money, can recording artists band together and go on strike like the writers did? Which seems impossible, but it's not a bad idea. Uh-huh, uh-huh. Do you think it can happen? Is there even a

19:02union? [inaudible] incrementally. I have heard of some kind of big label act, I forget who it was, recently said, no, you're not going to get my record, even though we have a contract. I'm going on strike, and you're not getting it unless we kind of take another look at all this. Wow. Not too many people can do that. No, no. There's not many names. Well, look, Trent Reznor basically did that. Oh yeah, yeah. Yeah, he just said the hell with it, I'll put it up myself and see what happens. Uh-huh. And I heard it's doing really well. What did I hear, 1.6 million dollars in its first week? That is pretty good. Yeah. That's nothing to sneeze at. No, I mean, especially not in this day and age. 10 years ago, maybe not, but now it's like, wow. Yeah. It worked. Yeah, I would say so. Have you heard it? It's actually pretty cool. No, I haven't heard it. It's all instrumental tracks. Yeah, atmospheric, very, you know, just sit in the room and

20:00chill kind of thing. Yeah, it's nice. It sounds great. It's different for him, at least. Do you prefer home recording or studio? I do a mixture. I'll do the writing part at home, and sometimes I'll do like my vocals, or part of them, or guitar overdubs or something. I'll do that kind of stuff at home and then bring it into the studio to do other kinds of stuff that I might want to do. Like if I want to have a band play, I can't do that at home. Yeah, fair enough. But I can do a lot of the kind of time-consuming stuff at home. It really takes a big chunk out of the bill. Yeah, I can imagine. Yeah, when I read about artists who've made their record and just said, wow, we spent months and months and months in this, you know, X studio or Y studio, and I'd go, I know what those places cost. That's a fortune. Yeah. I thought, why would anybody spend that much time in a recording studio anymore? But some people have a lot

21:01of money and they can do that. Yeah, I guess. Or they know people and somehow got deals or whatever. I don't know. Tell people about ArtistShare, because I think it's a really cool website and a way to get the music out there that's different than anything else I've ever heard of before. Yeah, I wonder, again, it's the kind of thing that is going to work for certain kinds of artists. I think for like straight-ahead pop artists, where the kind of loyalty to the artist is not that strong, it's going to be hard to do something like that. But for the kind of jazz artists that they have, and certain other kinds of artists where there's all this loyalty and where the fans want to hear the next thing, yeah, that model could certainly work. And how does it work? You just throw money into a pile kind of thing, and then that goes to fund the record? Yeah. And it seems to work on different levels. They

22:00ask people to basically pre-buy the record. Okay. That's kind of, in a way, what they're saying. For the most part, they're asking people to contribute this amount and we'll promise you a record, and maybe other things. Maybe they might promise a concert ticket as well. And then if you contribute more, you get more stuff. And then I think the ultimate contribution is you get to be listed as like executive producer of the record. Oh, that's kind of cool. Get your name in the booklet. Everyone wants that. All that, yeah. How are you going to do it? You mentioned earlier you were working on some music. What are your thoughts, if it ends up being a record, on how you put it out there? I'm doing it, well, a bunch of those ways, because I'm working on a few different projects. And I think one will be, I will license it to a distributor, so that's kind of the Barenaked Ladies model, I guess. Yeah. And there's another one that I'm talking about selling directly online, which is more the Trent Reznor kind of thing.

23:02Yeah, doing it that same way, kind of through your own server. Yeah. Cool. And there's another one that's more conventional that I'm going through Nonesuch Records. Oh yeah. Okay. Like back in the day. And so, yeah, it's a lot of things to keep track of, but I think that's possible too, that you can kind of choose the way to do it that's right for that particular project. And what are these projects? Are they still too new or vague to talk about? Well, yeah. Okay. Well, one is a score I did for a TV show called Big Love. Oh yeah. Okay. One is a record of songs I've been doing with Brian Eno. Very nice. He's really busy these days. I know. Well, he didn't have to do that much work so far on this. He basically had a bunch of tracks that he didn't know what to do with. And I said, give them to me. I'll finish them up. Oh, okay. And the third one is a collaboration with Fatboy Slim that's

24:02kind of a song cycle about Imelda Marcos. Well, that was the play, of sorts. And so now I'm recording different singers. Okay. That's cool. Female singers, to sing each song. And that part is going fine, but it's slow. It's a lot of talking to managers and working out people's schedules and things. Oh, I can imagine. Are you going to perform that again? I know it got performed what, twice? Three times? Yeah. Yeah, we just did it a few times. Would you do it again? Yeah. Yeah. Once we get it all, now it seems like I can see the record actually getting finished. So it's like, okay, let's wait till it gets finished now. And then bring it on the road, maybe? Something. Something. Come up to Calgary, perhaps? Could be. That'd be nice. I ask everybody that comes on the show five questions, one-word answers. Okay. iPod or CDs? Wow. Oh my God. I'm looking around at, I'm sorry, this is not a one-word answer, around and there's stacks of CDs

25:00everywhere in front of me. But I mainly listen to the music on an iPod. Yeah, conundrum. Yes. Lennon or McCartney? Oh my God. Okay, I'll say Lennon. Alcohol or marijuana? Alcohol. Song you've written you're most proud of? Oh, geez. Yeah, don't make them easy ones. "The Great Intoxication," there's one. Cool. And in one word, David Byrne? Doppelganger. There you go. Very nice. Thank you so much. Okay. Let's close out with a tune. I'll give you an option. Let's go "And She Was" or "Burning Down the House"? "Burning Down the House."

Transcript edited for readability from the video's captions; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →