Lennon or McCartney? Jim Adkins & Tom Linton answered: Lennon, McCartney. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
VIDEOWatch

2 clips · 11:28 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #548 · Jimmy Eat WorldJuly 2013 · 00:10:30
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:05Hello, I'm Tom. I'm Jim. We're from Jimmy Eat World. You're watching MSN Exclusives. So I'm gonna see you guys at Bluesfest in a week. Better learn some blues. You give it a shot. I hear you guys' sound check... Is that what these sound check covers sound like? I hear you guys just start shouting out covers and you're just like, let's do this,
0:51and see how it goes. Yeah. Yeah, it's usually metal. It's usually metal. Every once in a while one of us will bust into a song that sounds vaguely like something, and the rest of us will try to match it, and it's horrible. And we've been recording. Oh really? Oh, you should put that out. I thought I saw a couple... Have you been recording them without letting anyone know? No, I thought I saw him hitting space bar on a couple of, yeah. Everyone, so, like just as a joke, one of us will start off with the Spin Doctors, Two Princes, and then it becomes like... I mean, none of us really know how to... There's a group in LA called the Legion of Rock Stars. Okay.
1:38Amazing. Is it actually a legion of rock stars, just like a bunch of guys together to jam? What it is, yeah, what it is is everybody in the group is wearing... Are you rolling? Everyone in the group is wearing these like firing range hearing protection that are converted into headphones. So you can't hear. Well, you know, it's just like you cannot hear the world around you, but everyone is listening to the same... They just hit play on... like, they don't practice. It's a good start. Yeah, and they just hit play on like a CD or whatever, and everyone's listening to the same song, everyone plays along, but they can't hear themselves and they can't hear what everyone else is doing. All they can hear is like Don't Stop Believin'
2:29really loud. So like they'll be playing and it's the most beautiful mess. 20 years as a band. Yeah, February, February '94 will be what we consider our 20th anniversary. That'd be the first show. Yeah, our first show is what I consider the anniversary. Some bands will do first jam, practice or whatever, and you're saying I think we go by this show. Okay, our first documented live performance. Right. It's a long way from playing Metallica covers in the basement. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Speaking of covers. No, that's true. We've always had a soft spot for, you know, covers, I guess. And it's also a long way, Metallica is a long way from this record. This record is a lot more
3:14alt-country, stripped down. I mean, you still have the Jimmy Eat World sound that I think everyone wants to hear, but when I pressed play, I did not expect it to sound the way it sounded. Yeah, you know, we've always felt like you got to avoid censoring yourself when you're writing or when you're recording. It's really just about the best song, you know, for what the song can be, and later on you can decide if you use it or not. But, you know, so with that in mind, there's really no rules, you know. In fact, I think if you're pushing the boundaries of what you think you sound like, then you're on the right track. I mean, how boring would it be if you're like, oh man, this sounds just like something we do. Like, that's not fun, you know, that's not challenging. You want to change it up a little bit.
4:02Yeah. Are you challenging yourself as a lyricist in that sense, to try and write from different points of view? Oh, always. Yeah. Yeah, I was looking for some different angle. I mean, maybe it's only me that sees it sometimes, but, you know. But yeah, you're always looking for something new, always looking for something to push yourself with. Well, there's a lot of you talking about... maybe not from personal experience, but writing about almost being stuck in relationships on this record, as opposed to either coming into them or leaving them. But it seems like a lot of the songs are from the point of view of being like, I'm stuck in this relationship, I can't get out, I don't know how to get out of this thing. Did I read into that a little too much? Everyone reads into it. They're all right. Yeah, I guess so. I don't know what you got going on. I was reading the lyrics yesterday. I was like, oh, I see this point of view coming up a lot.
4:50You might see that because... I don't think... because I think even in the heaviest parts, there's still hope that things can work, you know. There's not entire despair, you know, just like there isn't really an entire happiness, I suppose. Sure. You know, it's kind of... I don't think... it's not an interesting story just to be completely bummed out without any chance of something working, you know. I love... there's a lot of good harsh lines on this record. That's one thing about breakup songs that I love, is the harsh lines. Like Dylan's got this one line, I wish that for just one time you could stand inside my shoes, so you'd know what a drag it is to see you. And you've got one line where... I wrote it down too. You wrote it?
5:39I did, on my Surface, stuff. And it's just like one word that changes things, right? How'd you have me, and I only got you. Yeah. That one word changes that sentence around so much. Yeah, only. Yeah, you're the first person that's really commented on that. You know, is that a good thing or bad? No, it's good. It's good. I mean, it's interesting what people are gravitating towards or noticing. So yeah, yeah, it is. I mean, that song is kind of... yeah, I guess about like, it's easy to fall into the trap of writing the victim train, you know, when you're faced with adversity, or when you're faced with something not going your way. Right. And that's kind of like the... I
6:25guess that song is kind of like about a person who's just kind of fed up with, you know, just trying to assert more of themselves, and, you know, self-worth, like stepping back and seeing that, you know, that it's not like the worst thing that can happen to you isn't necessarily brought on by... you know, you should just value yourself more, I suppose. Sorry for a crazy, not great for TV answer. No, no, no, I like it. It's making me take a second. I'm just trying to think of where to go next from that. But I think I'm gonna leave that. Why were you on stage with Taylor Swift? She asked, man. She asked. That's kind of cool. Yeah, she was playing in town. Are you talking about when she covered The Middle and had me play with her? Is that in Phoenix?
7:11You were on stage with her. Okay, so all I heard was you rose from the stage at a Taylor Swift show. Yeah, no, she asked. She was like, I guess she's a fan and liked the tune, and wanted me to, you know... She was in town, wanted to see if I wanted to play with her. I was like, okay. Gotta get major points with the kids. Yeah, yeah, yeah, all of a sudden. Yeah, I got major credit with the 11-year-olds on my block after that. For sure, because they were at the show. No, seriously, man, like she is on top of her game. Totally. You won't... Well, you never really know, but you will not see her mess up, man. She's the real deal. She's not gonna end up like a crazy kid, that kid that, like, pick one.
7:59You know what I mean? Like, there was plenty of stuff together. Yeah. Oh yeah. No, it was fun, man. She was really cool, and her band was awesome. And yeah, the inner heavy metal fan kid in me got to be thoroughly stoked out, because I did rise from the stage in the middle of an arena with like smoke and shit going everywhere. It's awesome. Spinal Tap. Yeah, totally, but like real. We started with metal and ended with metal. Somehow you turned Taylor Swift into metal. I like that. There's always... yeah, I think there's a little metalhead in each of us that needs just the right encouragement to rise from the depths of the arena in smoke and lights.
8:46Five quick questions, one-word answers. All right, go. Road or studio? Yes. Thomas did fall. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. Yeah, I know, this should be quick. It's all good. You're Lennon. We can edit. So you guys worked the... I'll go Lennon too. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first, lyrics, melody, or rhythm? Melody. Melody. Song you've written you're most proud of? I know, I'm sorry. How about this: what are you most excited to play tomorrow? I'm excited to play...
9:37Maybe the title... maybe Appreciation, the opener. Opener. Yeah, that one seems to go over really well. Do you open the set with it? No, I Will Steal You Back. We've been switching the new hit, opening with the hit, Tom. I Will Steal You Back. In one word, Jimmy Eat World? Fun fucking a. Nice, I like that. Thanks, guys. Yeah. Yeah, we're done. It was nice hanging out. Where is this from?
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.