Lennon or McCartney? Leah Fay’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
VIDEOWatch

2 clips · 9:53 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #676 · July TalkJune 2014 · 00:08:56
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00She'll vomit and flow I'll forgive her She's my lady in a summer dream She's my lady in a summer dream. So I knew you were a big Jenny Lewis fan. Yeah. So I knew you'd be at the stage. Yeah. And then I saw you running back here. Yeah. After her set. And then autographs, and people started mobbing, and then we were like, yeah. So when did that start happening? Toronto is a very specific crowd.
0:48Because we're from here. We've been playing. They've watched our birth. They were there in the delivery room. Where are they? Yeah, and I think July Talk was probably born at the Silver Dollar. Oh yeah, okay. And so there were people there, and then they followed us when we played the Horseshoe, and then they followed us when we played the Sound Academy. And so they're kind of our godmothers and fathers and people, in a way. This year must have been nuts. I remember seeing you guys play at the North by Northeast Universal party last summer and being like, oh, this is new, this is different, this is something that... On the rooftop? Yeah. And being like, okay, I dig this. Because you don't see that very often, when there's something and you're just like, something's gonna happen with them. And now it seems like it's good. Well, it's very nice of you. I don't mean it as a compliment. It's really hard to take the opposite of a compliment.
1:34Oh, no, I'm joking. It's really hard to play those industry parties, because everyone's like this. Yeah, I know. I try not to, I try and bob a little bit, but then you feel awkward, like the only one. Yeah, totally, I've been there. I'm always that guy. Well, it's nice to take off your sunglasses. I didn't lose all my questions. So it's so crazy. So you watched Jenny's set. What did you learn as a performer? What were you looking for? I've been waiting to see her perform since I was introduced to Rilo Kiley in, you know, late high school or something like that, and I'm like 40 now, so that's a really long time. Yeah, I was completely blown away. She was magic. Her songs are just, they just tell it like it is.
2:20Always, constantly, over and over again. She's saying the things that maybe people don't want to acknowledge, or the things that people aren't saying. I feel like there's no time she's ever written a song that's just kind of like, oh, that sounds good. And just, you know, like everything she's written. So do you do that, or do you take from her stuff and try and be more personal with your own lyrics? Oh yeah, we definitely are going over things constantly and trying to not write throwaway sounds like that. But you can tell sometimes when you hear them, it's just kind of like, you know, it's like when you're singing a song and you know the two words or whatever, the three words, but the artist hasn't forced you to pay attention to exactly what they're trying to get across. And I feel like Jenny Lewis always does that. Did you get to talk to her too? We're trying! How do you talk about your band here instead of hers?
3:06She was amazing! She made me cry, it was like... Really? What song was it? Jering, I've actually never heard this song. I think it was... it must be an old one. Maybe? I don't know. I think it was old because she said, maybe you guys will remember this one. Oh, that's probably an old song. It was something about slow-fated, slow-fated love. Cool. Anyway, incredible. Is it safe to say when we hear your words in July Talk and Peter's words in July Talk, you wrote your words, he wrote his? Or do you guys write for each other at times? We did that very briefly, and we realized that because we spend all of our time together, we're often able to reiterate each other's thoughts better than ourselves, personally. And so, yeah, it's a really cool thing, because
3:53in interviews, sometimes he'll say the thing that I'm like, that's exactly what I would have said, but I wouldn't have thought to say it. And it goes both ways, and it kind of goes that way for lyric writing as well, where it's just... We literally, the whole band, all five of us, are in a band 24 hours a day, I don't know, 300 days a year or something like that. So we know each other, we know each other's blood, we know each other's rhythms and patterns and thought processes and stuff like that. And so I can say to Pete, I want to say this thing, but I want to kind of have an air of this, and I want to kind of sound like this. What is it? And he'll be like, da da da da da. And then, again, it goes both ways. Yeah, it's a really fabulous way of writing. I think collaborating can be really difficult, because obviously if you have a vision, it's your vision.
4:44But when you can find someone that your mind can do this kind of rubbing friction thing with, two are better than one. How's it going with the new stuff? Were you guys writing yesterday? Is that what I read? Yeah, let's do it. I'm up on the lots of Twitter, so I'm very hard to find out this stuff. Yeah, we've been touring so much that we haven't had a chance to actually play any of the songs that we've been writing, other than, you know, acoustic guitar and jamming and talking about ideas. But yesterday we got to go to our rehearsal space. And what was that like, getting back in there? Because that's a different creative process. It's so refreshing. Mm-hmm. Look at the baby. That's it, that's Zoey, baby Zoey, my favorite. I didn't want to ask you, no, you threw me off with the stupid baby. I'm sorry.
5:29You mentioned the word blood in there. I'm thinking about the performance of you covered in blood. Yeah. I hear you like the fake blood. I do like it. For movie fans out there, I know your band is big in filmmaking as well. True. What's the best way to make fake blood? Oh, I usually, actually for shows, I usually buy store-bought. Okay. I have like a surplus of it from Value Village, because I buy it at Value Village around Halloween time. There's just shelves of it, you can buy it. But I have made it out of corn syrup, and I put a little bit of chocolate sauce in there, red food coloring obviously. It's a good one, yeah. Yeah, cool. You just got to play around with it. Right, I hear there's a new single, Summer Dress, so you should probably talk about that a little bit. Sure.
6:14But I hear there's a story about a dress that you wore on stage that kind of got crowd-surfed, out of which the song happened. It's true. Can you tell that story? I want to hear the story. This was at Edgefest, I think last year, last summer, yeah. And I wore a wedding dress. It was really obnoxious, you know, 80s shoulder pads, polyester, sequin-embellished dress that I bought for like 60 bucks or something like that. And I wore it for a bit, and then I took it off, and then I had this idea to make it crowd-surf across the crowd, because it had this really long train. And I was like, this will just be the most beautiful thing. You didn't want to be in the dress, you just wanted to throw the dress out? Yeah, totally. It was really nice to sit back and watch it go. Don't worry about crushing anyone. And then someone got a hold of it, claimed it as their own.
7:03As they were, I was able to sign it for them before they took it away. And I remember just distinctly giving it to a woman, and then later on that day we were on the internet, and these photos were being posted of a man being escorted out of the festival by cops wearing the wedding dress. We have no idea what happened. We still don't know, but we want to know, so if anyone has, let me know. That's why we keep telling the story, get the story out there more, and maybe someone will finally see this, and then we'll be able to know. Let us know what happened. So I got to go talk to Jenny, so I'm going to let you go. Do you want a question for her? I was going to tweet you earlier, and I was like, I don't know her very well, I probably shouldn't tweet. I saw that, and I almost did tweet back at you guys. Almost, but you didn't. But the thing is, yeah, I don't have a specific question for her, I just want to,
7:51I can't even tell if I want to meet her, because I might just throw up on her, because I'm so excited to, you know. I think I get you. It's been a long time. I've had a crush on her since I was like four. Since The Wizard, for me, since The Wizard! The Wizard! Exactly, I've seen that probably 250 times. I don't remember what I loved after that, and then we got the gloves and the wearing is cool. Anyway, five quick questions, quick answers. Okay! You ready? Road or studio? Ohhh! Road! Oh yeah, we should go. Lennon or McCartney? I love the song. What usually gets you first: lyrics, melody, or rhythm? Rhythm. Someone's never heard July Talk before, what song do they start with? Summer Dress. In one word, July Talk.
8:41Rock 'n' roll chaos. Rock 'n' roll chaos. Is that one word? I like that! It's one word if you don't put any spaces. I like it, we'll put some hyphens or something. Totally. Thank you, I'm talking to you. It's talking to you, too. Great for you, I love that. Yeah! Isn't that insane? Isn't that insane?
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.