Lennon or McCartney? Justin Pierre’s answer: Lennon. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Motion City Soundtrack said about the songs
“Chicago Is So Two Years Ago”
Motion City Soundtrack's Justin Pierre, the guest vocalist on the track, described writing his part on the spot with a blown-out voice.
Justin Pierre: “I listened to this song for the first time and tried to, and then I wrote lyrics, and my voice sounded so shitty, but due to the power of Pro Tools, Sean, I don't know what he did, but he made it sound... amazing compared to what it was. And that was Chicago Is So Two Years Ago.”
“Everything Is Alright”
The band said the single was written right before they went in to record, much like "The Future Freaks Me Out" on the previous album.
Motion City Soundtrack: “this is the song that we did on this record, like, right before we went in to record. That song just happened, and so it's kind of funny, because that's become, I guess, the single for this record... A lot of neuroses and certain things that I tend to fixate about.”
Justin Pierre explained that Fall Out Boy's Patrick Stump sings on the track as payback for Pierre singing on a Fall Out Boy song.
Justin Pierre: “when we recorded the new record, as payback to that son of a bitch, we made him sing on Everything Is Alright. And I think, to his credit, he got it in about two takes, but we made him do 12, just so that, you know, we wouldn't feed his ego.”
“Resolution”
Justin Pierre said "Resolution" is one of his most exposed, personal songs.
Justin Pierre: “The first one, Resolution, is a pretty honest and horrible thing... I'm a little too brutally honest on that song.”
VIDEOWatch
18:09 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #48 · Motion City SoundtrackSeptember 2005 · 00:41:37
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Hey Justin, this is Matt Schichter calling. Hi Matt. I'm actually hanging out with Matt Taylor, our bass man. Yeah, intro for our record release shows. Oh no, we're actually going to, I'm going to take this interview outside and we're going to walk to the coffee shop and get some coffee. Okay, cool. No, that's fine. No, we're actually just recording different snippets from, like, movies. Oh, okay. And like an intro. Yeah, I think we're using the theme song from Six Feet Under. Oh, nice. And then we're a ton of morbid, but yeah. Well, hey, it's all good. All right, sorry, I'm here. I'm totally here now. No, it's all good. That's a good start to the interview. I like it. Okay. So you guys are rehearsing this week, I heard, too. Yeah, we actually just had our last rehearsal. I think tomorrow we're going to run through stuff. We just got in-ear monitors for everyone except for Jesse.
0:49But, and so we had our friend Sean O'Keefe, who actually recorded the split that we did, with us, and he's in a band called This Is Me Smiling. He put together this whole in-ear monitor package thing, and he's, you know, he's going out and he's doing our sound for some of the shows on this tour, because his band is opening. That's how we sort of did this sweet deal where his band opens and then he can do our sound, and it's awesome because their band is just fucking incredible, and I hope things happen for them. But anyway. What are they called? This Is My Smile. This Is Me Smiling. And I don't know how you can get a copy of their record,
1:35but try to find it, try to do something, because they're not on a label yet. I think they're shopping around, but they're going to be huge. They're going to be, like, I think they're going to be the next Ben Folds. Oh, Ben Folds. Yeah, it's like piano, guitar. I mean, it doesn't sound like Ben Folds, but they could definitely, you know, open for him. Oh, I mean, and they're touring with you guys a little? Yeah, for CD releases, and then also I believe there's a few shows we're doing after our first leg of Warped Tour. Cool. Are you excited for Warped Tour? Oh, yeah. Although I just did another interview, and I sort of came to realize that I don't actually know who is playing Warped Tour. Yeah, I feel kind of stupid, because they're like, are you going to hang out with them? Like, well, Fall Out Boy,
2:21I know they're playing, and so, yeah, I just don't know who's playing. That's the way. Fall Out Boy, cool. I talked to them a couple weeks ago. You talked to them? Yeah, I talked to Patrick, actually, who worked on your record. I love Patrick. I love him. How did you guys hook up with them? Yeah, no, I think the first time we ever met, and I don't even know if he was singing in the band, but we played with Fall Out Boy in Des Plaines, I think, at a movie theater, and we just kind of met them, and apparently Patrick was like a fan of our band. So we saw them at, like, the Fireside Bowl in Chicago another time, and then their band recorded a record with Sean O'Keefe.
3:08The same guy I was talking about, this is funny. And Patrick wanted to know if I would sing on the record, and I was like, yeah, hell yeah, I love you guys. And so I actually, you know, that's not true. I didn't say I love you guys, because I don't think I'd heard their record yet, but I just liked Patrick. I liked him a lot. Is that their new record or the record before that? No, that was the first record. Yeah. And so we were playing a show at the end of tour at the Metro, and I'd blown out my voice. Sean picked me up, we drove to the studio, and I listened to this song for the first time and tried to, and then I wrote lyrics, and my voice sounded so shitty, but due to the power of Pro Tools, Sean, I don't know what he did, but he made it sound, not that it sounds amazing,
3:53I'm not saying I'm a voice of angels, but he made it sound amazing compared to what it was. And that was Chicago Is So Two Years Ago. That was the song on the first record that I sang on, and so that's kind of how we started. You know, and then whenever we would play with them, I would sing that song, and then Patrick would kind of sing on The Future Freaks Me Out. And then when we recorded the new record, as payback to that son of a bitch, we made him sing on Everything Is Alright. And I think, to his credit, he got it in about two takes, but we made him do 12, just so that, you know, we wouldn't feed his ego. Well, let's play a tune right now, Everything Is Alright. You got anything you want to say about it before we play it, about that song? See, I don't know, it's a musical masterpiece. No.
4:42It's a, I don't know, it's a rock gem, said Matt Taylor. Yeah, I don't know. I think that was one of the songs that, as Josh said, on the last record we wrote The Future Freaks Me Out, which became a single, I guess, somewhat, on the last record, like, right before we went into the studio. And this is the song that we did on this record, like, right before we went in to record. That song just happened, and so it's kind of funny, because that's become, I guess, the single for this record. Yeah, so that's all I can really say about it. A lot of neuroses and certain things that I tend to fixate about. Yeah. To produce the record, well, if you want to call it produced, what exactly did he do?
8:53Nice the chilled blanks, you know. I mean, we had to do most of the work ourselves, but that's not anything new. I mean, we're used to that. Yeah. Exactly. What does he do as a producer for you guys? Do you guys come into the studio with all the songs and he just says, hey, maybe you should change this arrangement up a bit? Or is he actually sitting behind the board mixing it, stuff like that? No, what actually happened was, it was so cool that he was a fan of the music, a fan of the lyrics. He's a fan of Matt Taylor's delicious bass playing. And what he did was, we came to LA for like a month, and we were practicing in a practice space down there, and he would come every day and just kind of listen to what we were doing. And it was really weird, because he didn't write anything for us. He just sort of listened, and he'd say, like, hey, why don't you let this part breathe a little more? And, like, what do you mean?
9:43He's like, well, just, like, you know, don't be forcing all these parts together. Let's see what you can do here. Or he would kind of make these weird suggestions that were a little more vague than, you know, specific. And if anything, he was sort of amused in a way where he would kind of make us think about it, and then we would come up with something new, like, oh, what about this? He's like, yeah, yeah, I like that, you know. So he sort of, I've used this term before, but he facilitated the tanning process. And yeah. And then the thing that blew my mind, because I didn't even think about it, you know, I always thought of him as this goofy fucker from TV who ran around naked. Yeah. Before I actually met him. And I met him and he was, you know, pretty normal for a weirdo. And when we were in the studio,
10:32he'd be like, well, there's a house that we're staying in, and then the studio was behind the house. It was like a garage that was renovated, I think, into the studio. And so in the main house we had another little studio set up for doing overdubs and, I think, backup singing and stuff like that, and so we could kind of do more at once. And he'd be going back and forth between the house and the studio. And he'd come in and I'd be playing guitar, and he'd be like, what's going on here? That's totally out of tune. And neither the engineer, myself or anybody would be able to hear it. But Mark has, like, sonic hearing. I don't know, he could pick this stuff up. But that's something that I never really associated, I mean, horrible, but I never really associated him with being a genius.
11:19Yeah, I thought he just wrote pop songs and he was goofy, you know, but he actually is just a brilliant man, and he knows his stuff. So yeah, it was just a serious, serious pleasure to work with him. He was so positive, you know. That was nice to work with, instead of, you know, working with this sort of nihilist who would lock us in the basement and beat us in chains on our first record. Oh, yeah. Play a tune, your choice: Attractive Today or Time Turned Fragile. Well, one of them is a minute and a half, and the other one is like five minutes. So that's why I chose it. How much do you want to, what do you... I mean, I say play them both. Well, let's play both of them. All right, do it. Cool. Yeah.
17:44Back in the day Beatific Virginia via Chicago, but, you know, I don't know, I can't remember. How did that actually turn out? I think he called up me, was like, yo, I'm really into your shit, you want to play a show? And we're like, I don't know if it's our crowd exactly. He's like, no, man, no, man, it'll be cool, it'll be cool. So that's kind of how, I don't know, we played the show, and I think it went okay, but it was just really strange, because the crowd was definitely split, and I think it was about a 90/10 split in his favor. But it went okay, and I don't think anybody heckled us that loud, so, yeah. But yeah, and I thought there was one kid that was dancing.
18:29I couldn't tell if he was making fun of us or not, but he seemed to be into it. But then he would kind of laugh and point, so. But it was cool, and actually, I wasn't too familiar with this music, but I sat and watched a bit. When he showed up, his vehicle pulled up and, like, eight dudes came out, and they're all just huge. I don't know, it was intimidating, but he had this one... I'm sorry. There's this guy carrying a dog, and the dog's about as big as him, on the street. I'm sorry. This is just a surreal day. Yeah, sorry, I got sidetracked. It's all good. But yeah, no, it was fun. It was weird. It was cool. I'd like to do more stuff like that, you know, just mixing up the genres, so to speak. Well, you're sort of starting that with Atmosphere, playing that kind of stuff. Well, that was awesome.
19:17Like, I watched Atmosphere a lot. Oh, yeah, on that last year. Yeah, cool. Have you played any of the new tunes live yet? Yeah, we've played a couple of them, actually. Time Turned Fragile was one. We've tried Attractive Today, but we're just now, in the practices that we've been having in the last couple days, that one sounds a lot better than the first couple times we played it live. Better Open the Door we've been playing, and Everything Is Alright. Yeah, that's pretty much it. Or the song, oh, actually, Hangman was one of the first ones we wrote, and we played that one a while ago, and actually we played it on the Fall Out Boy... When we were touring with Rufio and Fall Out Boy. And which reminds me, I've got to give them shit, because I think they stole something from... There's one part of one of their songs that sounds exactly like one of our songs. I don't know who stole from who, but it's pretty funny. Cool.
20:04Play another tune, Resolution or Feel Like Rain? Resolution is pretty harsh. I mean, they're both pretty harsh. The first one, Resolution, is a pretty honest and horrible thing. And then at least, you know, it's embarrassing, but I was told, I think it was, I was talking, well, I won't keep going. But anyway, yeah, that one, I don't know. Okay, well, I was talking to Brendan, Brendan Klein, who works for Atticus, and I was talking to him about that song. He really liked that song. I was like, yeah, it's just a little too close to home. I'm a little too brutally honest on that song. And he was just saying that there was a song that Blink did, and I don't remember, what's funny was that Mark was kind of worried about the same thing. You know, but it turned out to be,
20:51you know, so much more, because, you know, he actually put himself out there, and I guess that's kind of what I'm doing. I don't know if the song's great or not by any means, but I definitely put myself out there on that one a lot. Whereas I think Feel Like Rain is a little more... I think most people can figure out what these songs are about, but that one was a little more disguised. Which was kind of, I don't know, whatever, it was kind of amazing, because I talked to some guy who had a similar experience, because, I don't know, I don't want to go too much into it, but I think he kind of figured out what Feel Like Rain is about. But I talked to a guy who had a similar experience, and he just said that, he was one of the few people that downloaded our record illegally, and it was just like, that song, you know, it did something for him. And it was cool because, you know, not a lot of guys do that sort of thing.
21:41So yeah, whatever. Well, it's cool. Well, but yeah, okay. All right. I like the universe She messes with my words I'm not talking It's a galaxy's and the distance just makes it worse I know what you're thinking this probably sounds worse. A lot of music. So if I find something I like, I usually go out and buy the record.
29:22There's one... What really upsets me is where people, and there's certain people in our band, or a certain person, or a band too, but, like, who get upset about the fact that people are downloading our music, but yet they go out and download other people's music. That to me is wrong, you know. Like, if you're going to get upset about it, then you shouldn't be downloading music at all, you know. So, like, I'm not upset about it. I think the only people that it really hurts are the people who need to sell millions of records in order to survive. It definitely hurts the record companies, because, you know, they need to make money to survive too. But I think as far as getting your music out there, it's definitely good for that. So it's kind of like, I think it's good and bad. I just kind of try to urge people that if they're going to download it early or whatever, you know, if the thing always leaks, that if they really like it, they should buy the record. And, you know, I try to practice what I preach,
30:12because I definitely know that when the Limbeck record comes out, I'm going to buy at least five to ten copies just so I can give them to people too, because it's so good. They need to be seen. And actually, also, I waited until May 24th for the new Alkaline Trio record. I did not want to hear it till it came out. That's just a personal thing, you know. It's like, I could have heard it, because I heard that other people had copies of it, but I don't know, it's just like I wanted to wait. I don't know. Maybe it's like waiting to have sex until you get married or something. Even though I didn't do that, but, you know, it's kind of like the same thing. It's like, it means more when you kind of, you know, I don't know, whatever. But people, you know, I hope I'm not sounding preachy. I'm just kind of like, there's a few different ways you can go about it. I just think that, you know, I guess it's a moral thing, who knows. Yeah, I don't know what I'm talking about anymore.
31:01Just walking up and down the street. People are looking at me weird. Do you think it's going to kill record companies eventually, and everyone will just be on indies and, you know, releasing songs through the internet just to go to iPods? Hopefully. No, I think that hopefully, if anything, it will make, you know, major labels have to change what they're doing and why they're doing it. I don't know if that's going to happen soon, and I don't even know what it is exactly that they're going to have to change, but I don't know, I hope it has some sort of positive effect as opposed to, you know, a negative effect. But I just think it's great for getting music, especially for small bands. It's great for getting them out there. Definitely, you know, because they need all the help they can get. Cool. Let's play another song.
31:48All right, Make Out Kids or Better Open the Door? Make Out Kids, because I don't think that one gets heard a lot. But usually when I'm listening to the record, that's not one that I listen to.
35:09You know, and I listen to the record a lot, but only because I need to remember the words. Yeah, all right, fair enough. Hard to remember the words on stage? For me, yeah, because I'm a dunce. But I think, I don't know what it is. It's like I can't remember, I can remember other people's words, but I just can't remember my own. Yeah, fair enough. I bet the fans like it too, when you fumble them, and I mean they're like, oh yeah, look at that. Yeah, they point and they laugh. There were these two girls in London when we were recently over there, and they were laughing at me because I forgot the words to Hold Me Down. It was the first time we'd ever played that song live. And so, yeah, that's embarrassing, but it happens. Like, every show I forget something. Cool. Is that a real letter, Hold Me Down? Is that something you actually found, or did you just write it? I don't know. Okay, well, I did find a letter. I did find a letter while I was cleaning my couch.
35:57And so that was sort of what gave birth to the idea, and all the stuff in that letter are things that happened to me, figuratively or literally. And so, I guess, that's kind of how... I mean, I tend to try to put, you know, truth and fiction together in a tasteful way, and mostly just because certain words don't rhyme well. But, you know, so that's what I'll say. Cool. I thought it was a really cool idea. I like it. That was me trying, that was me also trying to do more of a Ben Folds Five thing, or a Ben Folds thing, or, like, Tom Waits, getting outside of yourself and trying to write it from somebody else's perspective. And I only did that on two songs,
36:43like on purpose, was Hold Me Down and Time Turned Fragile, even though Time Turned Fragile is about me, but it's supposed to be from the point of view of my dad. Oh, cool. Yeah. All right. We do this thing on the show called Five Questions every week, just five quick questions, one-word answers. Okay. First one, iPod or CD? iPod. Lennon or McCartney? Oh, Lennon or McCartney. Lennon. Alcohol or marijuana? I have to go with alcohol. Song you've written that you're most proud of? That changes all the time. Let me think. Everything. I've got to come up with one, don't I? Attractive Today. Cool. And one word, Motion City Soundtrack. Awesome. Hey, cool. Thanks so much. Sorry. Appreciate it. Yeah, thank you. Take it easy. Okay. Bye. Stop.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.