Lennon or McCartney? Gary LeVox, Jay DeMarcus, Joe Don Rooney answered: McCartney, McCartney. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat Rascal Flatts said about the songs
“Rewind”
Rascal Flatts explain that the George Strait line originally named Tom Petty and was changed when Strait announced his retirement.
Rascal Flatts: “even in 'Rewind,' you know, 'try to talk,' because the original lyric was 'try to talk Tom Petty into giving us an encore.' And it was right at the time George Strait announced his retirement. So, you know, we changed it to George Strait.”
Rascal Flatts explain why they cut the song and what hooked them in the chorus.
Rascal Flatts: “The main reason we cut the song is we just thought it was a great song. It had a sexy appeal to it. It's been a while since we cut a song that had kind of a sexy appeal... We never dreamed that 'Rewind' would be that important after we cut the song.”
“Payback”
Rascal Flatts explain the story of the song and how it came from their first sessions with rock producer Howard Benson.
Rascal Flatts: “in this song, you know, the guy's going, you know, he's not talking about, you know, trying to take you home, trying to do this. He's going, hey, look, I'll help you make him jealous. So he's actually the cool guy.”
“Here's to You”
Gary LeVox says the song was written about playing arenas and thanking the fans.
Gary LeVox: “The song I wrote with Wendell Mobley and Neil Thrasher called 'Here's to You' was all about being in an arena and thanking the fans. We definitely write thinking about how it's going to translate live, for sure.”
VIDEOWatch
8:45 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #693 · Rascal FlattsAugust 2014 · 00:09:10
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:25Why was it the first song people need to hear from this record? Well, has the interview started? Yeah. Okay, so let's make sure. I know. There you go. We felt like this single was the perfect bridge between what people fell in love with in Rascal Flatts 14 years ago and kind of moving us forward into a new generation of country music listeners. We felt like it was the perfect bridge, gap-filler. See, I've heard you talk about bridging the gap, which must be an interesting road to cross as well. But also the title, Rewind, implies a look back, but it sounds like you're moving forward too. So that's interesting. Yeah, it's a funny dichotomy because it's really. You want to fuck with people. Yeah. Exactly. I mean, I can say it every year. I love it. Yeah. Rewind, that fuckers. No. That's always been a little chippy this morning. Now, it is funny, it's called Rewind.
1:11The main reason we cut the song is we just thought it was a great song. It had a sexy appeal to it. It's been a while since we cut a song that had kind of a sexy appeal. And we never dreamed, though, being the first song we cut, the three of us on the producing end of the Rewind album, we did about, what, eight tracks, I guess, together in your house. "Rewind" was the first one. And it became the lead single, became the title of the record, the name of the tour. We never dreamed that "Rewind" would be that important after we cut the song. But man, it's just done so much. What was it about the song when you heard it for the first time? You were like, we need this one. I'd say for me what it was, was the middle of that chorus when it goes, so you can let it fall, one. I could just envision a whole crowd of people singing that spot in the chorus. It was so hooky, so catchy.
1:57And I knew also that once we got it up into Gary's range and took it up, he could really sink his teeth into that chorus. That's what got it for me. I don't know. Dogs all over the neighborhood bark too. It's up there. Is it going to be different for you, Gary? I don't know. No, that's pretty accurate. Yeah. I thought it was a great lyric and a great song and a great way to say, hey, here we come. Check it out. Speaking of here, you guys have done two shows on this tour already? We did. So how many of the new songs are fitting into the set? None of them. No, I'm kidding. We've got, I think we're doing three. Yeah. We're doing "Rewind." We open the show with "Payback," and we've got a little surprise in there that we're not going to tell you about. All right. I understand.
2:43I understand that you will talk about that song. All right. How come that one needed to open the record? We started working with this producer in LA named Howard Benson. He's a rock producer. We'd never met Howard before and he had never met us, and he had never done anything in country. We'd never done anything in the rock world. And that was one of the first songs he had put on hold to work with us. And we're like, what a cool tune, "Payback." So we went into the studio, cut it, and the track turned out, you know, just fantastic. And it just felt like the right song to lead the album off. Because the sound we started finding with Howard was quite, he brought something really kind of different and fresh to the table that we were really trying to go for. And the foundation of that track, the energy behind it, Gary's vocal, there's a lot of things on that that became a very new thing for Rascal Flatts to blend into what the Rascal Flatts sound
3:28has always been. And great tempo, great message to it. All the chicks love it, you know. Everybody's been hurt. And in this song, you know, the guy's going, you know, he's not talking about, you know, trying to take you home, trying to do this. He's going, hey, look, I'll help you make him jealous. So he's actually the cool guy. He's having got it. Yeah. You know, without trying to score. We don't know what the end of that story is. Yeah, that's "Payback Part 2," on the next record. "Payback Part 2" would be extraordinary. Now they're married. Yeah. See, yeah. There you go. Yeah. So when people bring up "Payback" and bring up. How we want to bring up, we want to bring up. Oh, it's another song. Yes it is. What song is that? It's that Kanye West.
4:14Yes it is. I was going to ask you. How about you put, you got on to it. Don't worry about my shoes. When someone writes you a song like that and you have ideas, it sounds like maybe for a second part of the song, does that ever happen? Have people written you a song and you'd be like, you know what, I've got another story that can go along with this now? You know what has happened is we've taken a song that was really, really close and really good and sort of restructured it to make it even better. Well, you know, I hate to call anybody out for fear of hurting somebody's feelings, but there was a song on this record that we thought would be better from the perspective of making it a different point of view than what they presented it as. And so we went back to the writers, and they were kind and gracious enough to listen to our thoughts, and they went back and basically rewrote the whole song and brought it back.
4:59But, you know, we've done that a bunch of times. Oh, no, twice. Just little things, like even in "Rewind," you know, "try to talk," because the original lyric was "try to talk Tom Petty into giving us an encore." And it was right at the time George Strait announced his retirement. So, you know, we changed it to George Strait. So you kind of, you know, tweak little things. That's funny. I was wondering how many names you guys went through for that part to see what sounded right. It was just the one. Just the one. Yeah. He's in the booth. It was easier to sing than Tom Cochrane. Canadian, thank you for bringing that up. Oh, yeah. Well, "Life Is a Highway." You know, amazingly good to us. Speaking of Canada, you guys are here in one of my favorite cities to say, Dauphin, Manitoba. You guys are back in Toronto in the fall as well, and in Mission, BC. Sheryl Crow's on tour with you.
5:44What songs are you most excited to see from Sheryl every night, now that you get to sit on the side of the stage and just watch? I've been out the last two nights since we opened the tour, and she's just an incredible musician, incredible singer and performer, and everything she does is good. "The First Cut Is the Deepest" is a favorite of mine. "My Favorite Mistake" is a favorite of mine. So I mean, I'm scared that she's going to hire extra security to keep me away from her because I'm like, I'm like a brand of Lambert songs she does. That's kind of odd, but she kills it. Her band is a killer too, man. Geez, her band is slamming. But I tell you what, we bring her out during our show. We have some fun with her. We do one of hers. Do you want to give me what's on that? I think it's a bit. She doesn't turn for the band. She is. And we do "What Hurts the Most." She's behind us. It's like on a projection with a shadow.
6:30You've got to come see it. You've got to come see it. You've got to come see it. You know, she moves. You've got to put it up on your tour. I saw you guys in Calgary years ago, and what really stuck out was the theatrics of it. It's a show. People are going to a concert, and you guys are great musicians and all, but it's really a show at the end of the day too. So how is this tour? How do you prepare for a show like that? Does it change? It's tough to, because it's seven world tours we've done now, and a lot of touring in North America mainly, but in the northern North America. That's what I'm saying. It encompasses Canada too. We take it. But it's hard to change and evolve from each. We've done just about every kind of show you can imagine. But with this new one, we dug deep. We found some ideas. Even our band guys were giving us thoughts and opinions on what we could try to do. They're all fired up now.
7:16At least they tried. There's a couple of surprises. We can't give you too much because we want everybody to go and see it and witness it for themselves. But we did some cool things this time around that are really different from any tour in the past. We also hired Raj Kapoor, this guy that has come in and helped us put the show together and look at it from a different point of view. You get so used to knowing what works and kind of falling back on that, that it was fun to have this guy come in and go, you know what? I've watched everything you have on YouTube and I've seen a bunch of concerts, and here's what I think we can do to make it fresh. And it's been really neat to have him there sort of piloting the ship for us. Do you ever write with the live show in mind? Yeah, we have. Where you thought of how is this going to work in an arena? Absolutely. The song I wrote with Wendell Mobley and Neil Thrasher called "Here's to You" was all about
8:04being in an arena and thanking the fans. We definitely write thinking about how it's going to translate live, for sure. Cool. I've got to let you go. I know you have a big day. So five quick questions, one-word answers. Road or studio? Studio. Road. Road. Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Melody. Melody. Yeah. Melody. If someone's never heard Rascal Flatts before, what song do they start with? "Bless the Broken Road." Well, "Life Is a Highway." It's not even your own song. Okay, all right. In one word, Rascal Flatts. Dedicated. Blessed. Unworthy. Unworthy. That's the first time I've heard that one.
8:50To be around us. See. Quitters. Sons of bitches. I can't wait to edit that and hear you just crush the mic and kill all my headphones. There you go. Thanks, guys. Thank you. Appreciate it. That's good. Thanks, buddy. That was fun. Really?
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.