← All interviews
Interview · November 2005 · Kitchener, ON

Sloan (Chris Murphy & Jay Ferguson) Interview

Sloan's Chris Murphy and Jay Ferguson talk the Twice Removed reissue tour, playing the album in order, hearing "Coax Me" in context, which album is next, Action Pact and co-writing songs like "Money City Maniacs", in this 2012 interview with Matt Schichter in Toronto. Sloan are best known for "Underwhelmed", "Money City Maniacs", "The Other Man", "If It Feels Good Do It" and "Coax Me".

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusicians

In the collection Canadian Music

Lennon or McCartney? Chris Murphy & Jay Ferguson answered: McCartney, Wouldn't pick. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Sloan said about the songs

“Money City Maniacs”

A Sloan member broke down how "Money City Maniacs" was co-written with Patrick Pentland.

Sloan: “I think of it as Patrick's song, but he had the main riff and the first verse, but I helped him write the chorus, I wrote the second verse, and I would say that I even wrote the middle part.”

Watch the moment

“Underwhelmed”

Sloan said the lyrics for their first single were written before the music.

Sloan: “a song of ours like our first single, Underwhelmed, is super simple. The lyrics were written first. I would have never written that music in a finished form if I hadn't had the lyrics.”

Watch the moment

“If It Feels Good Do It”

A Sloan member said the third verse was recycled from an early band song that was thrown out.

Sloan: “If It Feels Good Do It, yeah, that's mostly him, but he gave me the third verse, because it was a lot like a song of ours that went in the garbage, from like our first year of being together.”

Watch the moment

“All Used Up”

Patrick Pentland said the song was rejected for Action Pact and only surfaced on the singles compilation.

Patrick Pentland: “that song All Used Up was actually written, it's an odd thing, it was written for our last record, Action Pact, and it wasn't picked. Nobody liked it, like, not in the band, but at the record label, and the producer we had hired. And I liked it.”

Read it in the transcript

“Fading into Obscurity”

Sloan described the structure of this Chris Murphy song.

Sloan: “It's called Fading into Obscurity, one that Chris wrote... it's kind of three or four mini songs in one long five- or six-minute song.”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

Sloan InterviewInterview · 16:24 · 6,500 views
Archive footage

16:24 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #58 · Sloan (Patrick Pentland)November 2005 · 00:59:12

Episode #436 · Sloan #2 (Chris Murphy & Jay Ferguson)November 2012 · 00:16:23

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

Part 1

0:0088.3 CJIQ, big show tonight. This is The BackStage Pass. My name is Matt Schichter. Huge show. Get to speak with one of my favorite Canadian bands tonight. Patrick from Sloan's here. How's it going? It's going very well. Start the show off with my favorite tune from your band, Losing California. Oh, okay. I'm moving down to California in a couple of weeks. Oh really? A couple of months. Yep. To do radio there. Where you gonna go? Indie 103 in L.A. We were there. Yeah, how'd you get a job there? Just an internship actually. Can't get paid yet, but I'm excited. Do they play you guys? I'm pretty sure. Ah, they play everything, like... But it's a pretty hot station out there. So cool. It's a big deal. I'm excited. Yeah, it should be fun. We'll talk about you guys breaking into the US and all that stuff in a bit. We'll play Losing California first because it's my favorite song, and you wrote it. Yes, that's right. Thanks. 88.3 CJIQ. You just heard Losing California from Sloan, sitting here with Patrick.

3:22One of the singers. That's right. You guys all sing in the band. That's right. You guys all write? Yep. Even Andrew writes too? Yeah, he's got a guitar or a piano. Yeah, or piano. Okay. Do you guys ever tour with a piano? We do. We have, not a real one, like a Rhodes piano, a Fender Rhodes or something like that, or sometimes a digital thing. But we haven't in the last little while, because it ended up that in the sets we were doing, we'd only really do one song, and the piano took up space and had to get set up, and we just decided to opt out of it for a while. Are you playing Try to Make It then? Because is that a piano riff at the beginning, or is it done on guitar? On what song? Try to Make It. Oh, right. Oh, yeah, that's a synth. Yeah. We do that song, but we don't have that synth line. Oh, okay. Does someone try to get it on guitar? Is it just a synth line kind of? It

4:08just doubles up a guitar part, so he plays it on the guitar. It doesn't really sound the same. I've actually experimented with trying to get my guitar to play that part and make it sound more synthy, but I just never end up doing it. Fair enough. Cool. How would you compare your songwriting to, say, Chris's or the other guys'? Well, I think that I tend to be more into, what's the word, like, I like to try to keep things as simple as possible, at least to start with. I'm not so worried about lots of chords and lots of chord changes and things like that. I'm more interested in creating a feel for the overall song, as opposed to... like, I usually have an idea of what I want the song to sound like

4:56before I've recorded it, whereas some guys in the band, they write on acoustic guitar or something, and they would have the chords and the melody line, but they wouldn't really know how they want it to sound till they start to record it. Yeah. So that means that my songs are, they're not so much riff-based, but they tend to be more power chord-based. But I mean, you know, it just depends on the song, because I tend to write, you know, rock songs, but then there's the more acoustic songs and they will have a different feel behind how they're written. And then there's usually the more mid-tempo ones, and they can vary as well. And that's in terms of music. In terms of lyrics, I think that everybody's got specific, you know, things that they like to write about. And so the lyrics will obviously be different. But what do you write about lyrically? I tend to write about people that I know, hard

5:43times that they're going through, or good times or whatever. It's hard, you know, when you've written a lot of songs and you've recorded a lot of records, you don't always have a lot to say all the time. And also, we're not a very political band. So we tend to write about relationships more than anything else, or ourselves a little bit. And kind of like observers more than, you know, having a political thing or trying to be a little bit more, you know, what's the word... I'm not as big... to me the lyrics are usually a personal thing, and they're not usually trying to get a big message across to people necessarily. Cool. You say you're not very political. What are your feelings towards politics in general? I mean, I'm sure you can't

6:28speak for the other guys. I think we're happy with where we're going in this country. I just found out that they're going to vote non-confidence. I don't follow Canadian politics that much. But, you know, I definitely follow American politics more because it's a lot more entertaining. It's way more, because it's ridiculous right now. I think all of us are basically left-thinking people. We're not so conservative. But it makes sense being in music. I guess so, although I know people who don't feel that way. But, you know, I'm into, you know, like I tried it. We, at my house, we eat organic food and we don't trust anything, and we don't trust the government, or not so much the government but big business. But, you know, I think that for me, I'm very into that sort of... like, it's easy

7:24now with the internet to investigate companies, like, you know, Del Monte or something like that, or whatever, and find out what they're doing in Africa or something. And you're just sort of like, you know, well, I'm not going to buy their product. And then you find out that all of the stuff you like, you know, pay or something, is owned by Del Monte, I think, something like that. And you can't drink that anymore, you know what I mean? But I'm not like that. I will drink it. I'll just feel a little guilty. It's a good... I want you to think about that, the big business thing. Hold that thought. But let's play a song for now, either one of the new ones, All Used Up or Try to Make It. Okay. Well, All Used Up... Oh, we mentioned Try to Make It. Let's do Try to Make It. Okay, cool. And imagine us not playing the synth line, and then tell me if you think it's cooler, because it's a simple line in my idea. 88.3 CJIQ, you just

11:45heard one of the new tracks from Sloan's new greatest hits CD, A Sides Win. It's a singles collection. Why singles? Why not greatest hits? Is it not your greatest hits? Well, there's not a lot of great hits. But they're all just the singles. They're all singles. They're not like a lot of people would call our best of or something like that, and that's not what this is. This is just more like songs that have videos because they were released as singles. But I mean, if you were to ask us as a band what we think are our best songs, they aren't all necessarily on the record. That makes sense, definitely. But they're the ones that got picked for singles. You mentioned big business before, and I'm thinking Sony and BMG just merged together. You were on BMG, now you're on Sony. Yeah. But you also have Murderecords. You guys have kept with your indie roots very well with that whole thing. Yeah. How are you distributing in the

12:30States and around the world? Sony BMG? No, in America it is through a label called Koch. Okay. Yeah. And who's that? Ringo. Oh, really? Yeah. And who else... I just saw somebody else. Anyway, whatever. Yeah. And we don't have a lot of distribution elsewhere. Japan, our record is coming out, and I don't know the name of the label, and Australia is the same thing, and in Spain it's love to art. And aside from that, because we tend to... we try to get records released where we tour, and we haven't always been able to get to Europe. By the time we end up finishing touring North America, we usually just want to make another record. That makes sense. So, but this record, we're going to Spain in January, and I think there's talk about going to Australia and potentially Japan. Oh, wow. That's great. So pretty cool. Well, we kind of skipped...

13:21Like we did Navy Blues and Between the Bridges, and we did a lot of touring for those records and we went overseas a lot. And then for our record Pretty Together, we toured a lot more in America because we'd spent the two records before touring a lot everywhere else. And then with Action Pact, we just did America, and then two of us had kids. So then we kind of cut it out for a while, and then we just finished up North America again. And so we didn't have a chance to get over to Europe or to Japan or Australia. So yeah, we will. How did you guys break into the States? How did that whole thing... I know you're huge up here, but how big are you in the States? Do you even care about that kind of stuff? We definitely care. But I don't know, we're in a weird situation in Canada where we're huge in terms of, like, we're known by people. All your singles get charted and your stuff gets played on the radio. You put out a song and it goes on the radio no matter what. Right. This last

14:10single, All Used Up, has played the most of anything. That's good. But in terms of, like, I think for most acts, unless they're really, really being hyped, it's really hard to get people to come out to shows. We've been around for 15 years, 14 years. So, you know, in one way, we have a loyal fan base and people will come out. On the other hand, we can play one town in Ontario and we'll play to a thousand people, and the next night we'll go and play to 200 people. And it's not because we lost popularity in one day. It's just that town, like, something. And it's a weird thing. But in America, you know, in the major cities, we play to the same size audience. It's really cool. But we don't play to thousands of people in Canada. You know, we probably played to like 800 people in Boston, and we probably played to

15:00you know, a thousand people in Ottawa. So it's similar, you know. You played CBGB in New York. We have a few times, but years ago, yeah. It's closing down. Yeah. What are your feelings on that? Does it matter to you really? I know for a lot of New York fans, it's a huge thing. I think it's a shame that they weren't able to keep it. I mean, the thing with that is that it is a historic building. But the building, I mean, if you've been there, they changed... half of it is a big store now. And then, you know, it changed a lot. When we were down there in the early 90s playing, we only played there twice, but they were in the process of sort of changing it. And I think it's gross. Like, it was horrible. Well, it's a punk club. Yeah. But I mean, they really kind of maintain that. I mean, it's a club, but it's almost like a Disneyland sort of thing. They make it so horrible, or they just don't do anything to make it halfway

15:50presentable, because of its roots. And I think it's a shame that they weren't able to keep it in that building. But of course, they could always just open up another place called CBGB. Yeah, that's true. And it's not like the police said you're never allowed to open up a club. So, I mean, you know, times change and things move on. And most of those bands didn't stay playing CBGB. They went on to play bigger places. And it seems to be almost like, why can't that club move and become a bigger club? Yeah, that's true. Well, let's play another song. One of yours, or one of Chris's, Underwhelmed or Everything You've Done Wrong? We'll play Underwhelmed for Chris. That's nice. 88.3 CJIQ. You just heard Underwhelmed from Sloan. You guys, clearly, you know,

21:04a big Halifax band back in the day. Obviously you're living in Toronto now. Yeah. Okay. So, but I mean, now you've got Matt Mays, the Novaks, the Trews, Buck 65, this huge Halifax scene, an out east scene. I guess most bands are from Halifax. Well, they're from the East Coast. Yeah. How do you feel? Like, you basically got everyone out there. You broke that scene. Well, that scene, maybe there's roots for us there, but that was what we were... Well, Flashing Lights, Matt Murphy or whatever. Yeah. Well, we were involved with the Super Friendz, which sort of became Flashing Lights, and then Thrush Hermit, and Eric's Trip from out there, which became Elevator. And, you know, there's that. I think that our success, quote unquote, that we had drew attention to that area. But I think that it was just that the press in the early 90s wanted to find another

21:51Seattle, and they picked Halifax because it was small. And the complete obstacle. Full town. Yeah. And I don't... But, you know, all those bands broke up, or they're not... I mean, Joel Plaskett's still playing, from Thrush Hermit. And... I just talked to him? Yeah, I think so. And then nothing happened for a little while. And now all these other bands have come along, and they're not really related to us. They've kind of got their start, like the Trews and the Novaks and Matt Mays. There's different management people down there. There's different labels down there. And we do have similar... like, a lot of the people that are working at these record labels or management companies are friends of ours, and maybe had worked with us or worked with bands. But we're not really related to those. Like, I don't... Do you try and help them out at all? Well,

22:38we would. I mean, we did an East Coast tour and we wanted the Novaks to play with us, and it ended up being a band called the Stills from Montreal, who we are also friends with. Oh, yeah. Good band, too. Yeah. And so we were fine with that. But I just saw the Novaks like a week ago or something. They're great. And we played with the Trews. Yeah. We played with the Trews last weekend, or the weekend before, I guess. But that was not our doing. And I like those guys as well. So yeah, of course we would. But, you know, we also... I mean, in the early, early days, we would take out some bands to open for us from the East Coast because they're friends of ours and we wanted to help them. But nowadays, I think we have a lot of friends in bands from all over North America. So if it was like, oh, well, will you take the Trews out on tour in the States? Well, we might, but we also

23:25might take our friends from this other band that we know. Yeah, well, I don't know if we'd take them to open for us, but you know what I mean? So we're into supporting people. But sometimes what we found was we were kind of cornering ourselves a bit. It's like, well, we've got to take this band out because they're from Halifax and they have a new record out. But we really wanted to go out with these guys from Vancouver, friends of ours too. So we just stopped taking these [inaudible]. And it's not so much that... I mean, we've done lots of shows with Joel. We've done some, as I said, with the Trews. And Matt Murphy, obviously. What's he doing now? Matt just had a movie coming out. Oh, yeah, that's right. I heard about that. Yeah. And he has a band called the City Field. City Field. Okay, well, grab their CDs, people. They have a CD? Yeah. Cool. The other song was The Other Man, but you didn't write that one. Well, we all kind of

24:13wrote that one. Oh, really? Because I love the point of view of that song, because you don't hear a song written from that point of view, the lyrics. Yeah. Okay. And then the music was kind of two or three of us writing that. 88.3 CJIQ, you just heard The Other Man from Sloan, sitting here with Patrick.

28:03You guys played a song at soundcheck, and I heard Chris say, did you record that? Was that a new tune? I've never heard that before. Yeah, that was never even heard before. That was Jay's. That's one of Jay's. Sounded cool. Yeah, I thought it was cool too. What are the odds of that ending up on the record? Are you guys writing a new record? We are. Yeah, we're demoing stuff now. Cool. I haven't heard any of Jay's demos. Sounds like [inaudible]. It was pretty cool. Oh, really? Not bad. Not that I want to compare you to other bands, I hate comparing bands, but it was cool. Well, it was kind of... yeah. Well, if Jay likes it, it'll probably end up on the record, because Jay often doesn't necessarily get that much on records. And if he likes a song... Well, basically the rule of thumb is if somebody in the band is really into a specific song they wrote, it'll probably end up on the record. That's pretty cool. Yeah. So most of your songs end up as singles, though. Right.

28:51Why is it? Well, it does happen. Yeah. Well, all the ones, at least, I was going through it today because I didn't know who wrote every song. I figured it was basically a four-part process, which most songs I'm sure are. But your songs all end up as the big popular songs. Yeah, kind of. They kind of do. I mean, Losing California. Well, no, sure. There's singles and there's... A favorite, I suppose, too. Yeah, definitely. And we just did this singles record. Yeah. And there's a bunch of them that I wrote. And, you know, on the one hand, I'm very happy with that, and I'm happy that we get singles, or songs that are picked, and I'm glad that I put work into... Like, I tend to write at least some songs with that in mind, whereas other people in the band don't necessarily care for that themselves. They're just writing what they consider to be good music, or what I consider as well to be good music. But I'm doing that on

29:41purpose. Like, it feels good to do it, or something that's written specifically with parts to attract people, and also to get people into, like, you know, you have a bit in the song where it breaks down, there's clapping on the record. People know that they're going to clap when that comes up, because you did it on the record. There's a lot of "here's where we're supposed to clap." So you do that kind of event song, is what I call it. So I mean, but we don't pick the singles these days so much. We let the radio people at whatever label, because they have to work the song. And if we say, no, don't go with the one that's got the good chorus, go with the one with the 10-minute guitar solo, okay, but they'd be like, well, whatever, I guess. So we just sort of were like, you know, whatever you think is cool. And they usually bring it down to like two or three, and then we'll say, oh, yeah,

30:29well, that's cool. I mean, we put the songs on the record, so they can have any song as a single. Well, I was just thinking, because you know how Lennon was pissed off, Revolution was a single and Hey Jude was... Is there a bit of resentment in the band for that kind of stuff at all? I don't think so. I mean, we split the publishing money equally. Well, that's cool. So it doesn't matter who wrote it. Everybody gets the same amount of money. So awesome. Well, let's play another song. Why don't you choose one out of your catalog? Any song you want to hear from any Sloan record, maybe not something off the demo tapes. I don't have that one. No. Well, let's play one by Jay then. Let's play I Hate My Generation, off Twice Removed. 88.3 CJIQ, you just heard Sloan, I Hate My Generation, sitting here with Patrick from the band.

33:29I want to talk about downloading and how you feel about it. Well, the illegal downloading, not iTunes, because obviously that's helping the industry. But do you think downloading is going to... well, A, do you think it's helped you or hurt you? I think that it has probably equaled out. Like, you know, nobody sells as many records as they used to. But at the same time, more people can be exposed to you, you know, because I do it. You know, I'll read about a band and I'll be like, oh, I wonder what they're like. So I'll usually go to their website first, and if there's stuff to listen to... If I can't find that, then I'll go and download it off LimeWire or something. That's what I use. Yeah. And I mean, that's a good promotional tool. But the problem with all of it is that it's perfectly...

34:15everybody is capable of doing it. So, you know, there's a moral... like, I don't agree with people who say that rock stars have enough money or something like that. It doesn't matter. They own the publishing to that. They wrote it. And so, you know, it doesn't matter if they're multi-billionaires. It's theirs. It's not the public's. But I do think that if it can be done, it can be stolen. Like, you know, if everybody that worked at a record store had to wear a blindfold, and there were no security tags on anything, and people just walked in and picked up CDs and walked out, well, it's their fault. Take the blindfold off, you know? And it's the same with record companies. This is not new technology. I had friends who were trading music online in like 1990. So it's not new technology. They

35:04just ignored it and just hoped that it would go away or something, or put warnings, or said, we're going to sue you, or whatever. And it didn't work. And what they should have done, you know, is go to the people who are making LimeWire or Napster or something, and you go to them first and you say, you know, how can we get around this, or whatever, or bring the price of CDs down. And I think iTunes is going to help, in terms of... you know, it kind of destroys the idea of an album. That's what I was going to ask you. Yeah. But you can download songs and they're a dollar. Well, I mean, I just got an iTunes account, and especially if they offer exclusive things... and things like LimeWire and that stuff, it's fine, but you can't find everything. You know what I mean? You can mainly just find what the popular songs are.

35:50And so it's good to... I just think that record companies have to offer more. They just have to work harder. And it's not... I mean, you know, I like the people, there's a lot of good people at all the labels that we've been with, but it is a pretty corrupt business. Like, the way that record contracts are put together and everything. It's like, you know... Explain that, because I'm sure most people don't know. I mean, a lot of people know Ozzy got nothing from the Black Sabbath... A lot of those, like, nothing, which is ridiculous. There's different ways of doing it, but like publishing, which is basically, if you write a song and you own it, you own the publishing for that song. So this is different from the record contract. But basically, that's one way where you can make money. And what happens is, oftentimes there'll be somebody like Ozzy Osbourne who potentially, I think he probably did

36:37make money outside, but who potentially didn't write any of the songs or didn't own any of the publishing. So whoever wrote the song would make the money off of the publishing of that song. So the singer might not have written it, and he might be known as singing it, but he doesn't make any money on that song. And record deals are different in that. What happens is a record company wants a certain quality of recording, and that costs money, because they want a producer and they want it to be done this way. And, you know, so they go to a band and say, hey, we like you, we'll sign you, and then they go into the studio to make a record. And the band's like, well, we're broke. And they're like, okay, well, we'll lend you the money to record the record. But you have to spend X amount and you have to do it the way that we would like you to do it. And in a way, that's reasonable. But what we're going to do is we're going to sell your CD for $10. But you're only going

37:26to make... because we're investing all this money, we have to make more money back. So you're only going to make $2 on the $10. Right. So then they put out your record, and this is an oversimplified way of putting it, but they put out your record and you sell 100,000 records, right? Yeah. They make $8 a record, so they would make $800,000 plus, and then you make $200,000. But out of that $200,000, you have to pay back all the money that they spent on making the record, and that's probably about $200,000. Yeah, let's say it's 200,000. So you sell 100,000 records, you make $0, and they make $800,000, because from record one sold, they make their share of the money no matter what. And they don't put their

38:12share into how much it costs to make that record. They just put it in their pocket. You pay back all the costs and then you start to make money. So a lot of times... and that's just for making the record. Also in America, if you want to have a hit single in America, it's very easy to do. You spend a million dollars in promotion, radio promo, which is payola, but they call it consulting. They're getting in trouble for that right now. And that's all it takes. Really, it does, because there's some really crappy songs out there. I'm sure there's a whole bunch of people out there going, this is really good. They're just like, oh, that sounds popular. I keep hearing it. Yeah. I like that. And so you spend a million dollars and you pay a million dollars back out of your share of it. So they spend a million dollars of essentially your money to sell

38:58a million records. And they put all of their, you know, 80% share of that extra million, whatever, in their pocket. And you have to pay back all that million out of your pocket. So they keep walking away with like... four times, I guess, what you would make, or more, because you never see the money that they spend to sell records. You have to pay it all. All you're getting is gold and platinum records on your wall. But all the money that's being made is going into their pockets. And the money that it takes to sell a million, to get that platinum record, far outweighs the value of the platinum record for you, because you never see a dime. I mean, you know, I'm oversimplifying. You will see a dime at some point, because you'll pay back that million dollars and you'll start to make a bit of profit. Yeah. But at the end, they'll make 800 million

39:45dollars and you might make four million dollars. So I think that's going to change a bit now with home studios and all the technology we have. Well, yeah, I mean, that's the other thing too. You don't have to go to the major label. You don't have to take a big advance. You don't have to spend as much money recording records. The record industry is like any industry. I would say that technology takes major leaps maybe every five years. But record company people don't, like, die off or retire every five years like that. You know, you'll have somebody who started when they were 20, and they're 65 and they're still running a record label. And so they're oftentimes sort of living a few years in the past. And I just think that it takes time for major labels to catch up to what's going on, whereas smaller labels can be equally as corrupt. Like, I'm not a big fan of independent labels as much

40:34anymore. Same with the major labels. But indie labels tend to have less money to invest in you. Therefore, you know, people are sort of like, well, if you sign to an indie, you get all the control. I mean, I read this online, I read some forums and all that stuff. Yeah, sign to an indie and then you've got all the control because you're on an indie. And that's the definition of an indie. Well, no, you don't have all the control, because they still pay you money, or you pay for the record out of your own pocket and then they'll distribute it. And they might give you a much more fair deal. But what we saw in the 90s was labels like Sub Pop, who would sign a band, maybe fund one record, which usually sounded like crap. And then that record would do okay, and then they would sell the contract for that band to a major label. And the band would make nothing, but Sub Pop, like, that's

41:19what they would... Nirvana, that's what they would sound like and stuff. Sub Pop got money for every Nirvana record sold just because they signed them initially. So they made millions of dollars off Nirvana, and Nirvana weren't even on their label. And all the real build-up and push was paid for by Geffen and not by Sub Pop. You guys were on Geffen for a while too, right? We were on DGC, which is Geffen. Yeah. Cool. Well, let's play another song. The Good in Everyone or Rest of My Life? Well, let's play The Good in Everyone, because it's short and we were basically just shitting on the music business. So let's... there's good in everyone. I got you. There you go. 88.3 CJIQ,

43:56you just heard The Good in Everyone from Sloan, sitting here with Patrick. That's a very short song. Why such a short song? That's just supposed to be a short, punky song. Yeah. Cool. You're curious about Five Questions? We do it every week on the show, called Five Questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. iPod or CDs? I just bought an iPod in September. Oh, really? Yeah. I wouldn't get one for a long time, because I just thought they were way too expensive and I heard all sorts of bad things about them. But then I started to realize that they were not going to come down in price, and all the other ones are not as good and they still cost the same or more. So I like the iPod, because I wasn't the type of person to walk around listening to music a lot. I just wasn't interested in them. When I got the iPod, I started doing that, and I find I'm listening to a lot more music and a lot of different music, because you can just load in all these... Exactly. What are you listening to? Name a couple of guys that are on there. Well, there's a guy called Adam Franklin who used to be in a band called Swervedriver

44:45out of the UK. Cool. And he has a new project called Toshack Highway. He's got a couple of records, and a friend of mine is on that record, and he just gave me the pre-mastered, pre-release version, and it's good. The perks of being in a band. A little bit. And I just downloaded off iTunes, I just paid for the Death Cab for Cutie single, which I like, and we sort of know those guys, but I didn't know their songs. Check out the whole album. It's really good. Yeah. Next question. Lennon or McCartney? I think that most of the songs, when I was younger, that I thought, you know, Beatles, and I would always picture John Lennon singing, it was Paul McCartney. But I like John Lennon as a person a little better, just because I think he was a bit more of a prick, and he spoke his mind a bit more. And, you know, I always thought of Paul McCartney as a little bit

45:37of a crybaby. But yeah, so Lennon, I guess. But I'm not the biggest Beatles listener. Like, I know tons of songs, but I don't know their names and things like that. Okay, cool. Alcohol or marijuana? For me it's alcohol, because I find with marijuana, I don't mind it, but I have to be basically sitting in front of the television with nothing to do, because I can't function. Whereas with beer... I tend to just drink beer, or maybe a gin and tonic or something, maybe a little tequila. But I find with that, you know, you can drink like eight beers or something and you're still... you're not paralyzed, or at least I'm not. Yeah. So it's a little bit more controllable. Same with hard liquor. I don't drink a lot of hard liquor anymore, because, you know, you have about four shots and you're on the floor all of a sudden. It just hits you really fast. Yeah, cool. What was that? Song you've written you're most proud of? But I'll tell you something. I'd prefer my son

46:28probably to smoke pot than to drink. So. Interesting. How old is your son? He's two. I don't want him smoking pot. Yeah. But you know what I mean? I just think, as long as it didn't lead to anything else, and alcohol can lead to stuff too, but I just think it probably does less damage to your body in the long run. Cool. Well, while we're on the topic of it, do you think it'll be decriminalized in Canada eventually? I think it should be. I think it's ridiculous that it's not. I mean, you could tax the hell out of it. Yeah, exactly. And then put that into funding to help other drug problems. I mean, you know, heroin is a huge problem. Speed, whatever. There's so much stuff going on. I mean, if you ever go out to Vancouver and hang around, it's just... and Toronto's bad. You know, I think that... and it's not so much even people being hooked on drugs, or the toll that that takes on families and the country, inevitably, but it's just the criminal

47:15element that it funds. Yeah, there's a huge violence problem in Toronto right now, and that's why 50 Cent's not allowed to come there. Well, I mean, it's just like, you know, it's because there's drugs, and it's all funded by drugs. I mean, most quote-unquote terrorist activity outside of, say, the Middle East or something, like in Northern Ireland or something, the IRA, which is where I'm from... there's so much drugs involved with that as well, that they don't talk about on TV necessarily. But, you know, that's how the people are making money. And if you legalize... I wouldn't legalize everything, because I think some drugs are very, very dangerous. But you legalize something as harmless as that, and then you control it and you tax it, basically. Tax it like cigarettes. Or alcohol or something, yeah, and make it work for itself. But now we pay for the damage that it causes out of other funding, you know, that could

48:01go towards, you know, education or something. Yeah, or homeless people, whatever. Yeah, I think it's cool. Song you've written you're most proud of? I'd have to go through them all, I don't know. Well, the song that... that song All Used Up was actually written, it's an odd thing, it was written for our last record, Action Pact, and it wasn't picked. Nobody liked it, like, not in the band, but at the record label, and the producer we had hired. And I liked it. And then we had to do this best of thing, sorry, singles record, and they were looking for songs, so I brought that demo in again. And the president of the company was there, and it was the weirdest thing. We'd never had to do this before, but we had to submit songs and go and sit in the studio, and all the top brass came in and they all sat and listened to songs. And some of them they listened to like, you know, half of, and like, okay,

48:48we can move on. And it's just like, what? That's so brutal. They didn't do that to mine, luckily. But they picked All Used Up. They were like, okay, well, that's obviously a good one. And I was just like, you turned that down. That's cool. But they turned it down a few years ago. Although I'm sure the president didn't turn it down. Well, it would be three words. It would be rock and roll. Good answer, Patrick. Thank you so much, really appreciate it. Okay. Want to close? Say anything you want. Well, you just said All Used Up, when we play on one. Okay, unless you want something else. No, that's good. Okay, thanks so much. Okay, thank you.

Part 2

0:00Why did you choose to do the Twice Removed tour and re-release everything? Well, a lot of bands have been doing the sort of playing in whole their classic record, or a couple of their great records. That's been going on for, I think, ten years now. I feel like it's been a while. I feel like the first thing I saw was when Brian Wilson did Pet Sounds, in the late 90s or 2000, and then it sort of ramped up since then, basically.

0:47We wanted to do that, and the other thing that's been going on at the same time is that Jay and I have been archiving everything that we've ever done. So how can we bring those two things together? Well, we can take our collections and put them into an amazing 32-page book that goes with the crazy repackaging, and then we can use it as an excuse to tour. And we put out a new record last year, and this would sort of, in our schedule, be sort of an off year. And it wasn't really an anniversary for Twice Removed. It was more just, like Chris said, we had this year open, and which is the best album to put forward, or if we're going to continue doing these sort of reissues, which is the best one to do. And I think it's the one we had the most photos and demo recordings for and stuff like that, so it made sense to do it first, even though the 18th anniversary doesn't really make much sense.

1:36Is that going to happen? Are there more... let's go with that. Are there more album tours? I think so, but I think that we want to temper it with new stuff so that we're not just a greatest hits group. This tour, I think, went well enough. The Twice Removed box set that we made sold well enough, they're almost gone, and the tour did well enough that I think it bodes well for doing more in the future. Where do you go next? Which one are you going to next? One Chord to Another, probably. Well, but then do you go back to Smeared for the third one, because that's the first one? We may do that. That'll be two and three, and you go back to one? Or do you keep going? Because Smeared is kind of outside of our oeuvre in a way. You don't play the songs often? Yeah, we only ever play one or two songs from that record. I actually think we should do that one third.

2:24Yeah, I think it's got an "I can't believe they're going to play these songs" kind of vibe. But I think there's definitely a high nostalgia factor for that record as well. When we do 500 Up, not even including Underwhelmed, but even 500 Up, in concert, the crowd often goes... They seem to really like it. And it's the record that's the most, I would say, of the time. It's the most early 90s sounding record, and from our second record, Twice Removed, on, we never really sounded of the time, I would say. What about the tunes off Twice Removed? I mean, I'm sure you're playing them night in, night out, which hasn't happened in twenty-odd years. So what's it been like? Are you sick of them now that it's almost done, or

3:10are you more in love with them than ever before? I'm definitely not sick of them. Well, to me it's kind of funny that there are some songs that we were forced to play by doing it this way. There are certain songs on the record that I think we would have never played otherwise. So it was fun to have the excuse, or the reason, to play them. It's really fun to play everything in order. There's a certain context. We play Coax Me, we've been playing Coax Me for 18 years, but it's fun to hear it between People of the Sky and Bells On. Maybe that means nothing to you or to someone at home, but to someone who knows the record inside out... I hate to... it's hard to talk about myself, but I don't want to talk about something as being powerful or meaningful. But, you know, I think it's possible that it was powerful or meaningful to those people.

3:57And I disagree. I just know as a fan, if I heard other records in order, like what it means, like, oh, I know what comes next, and it's fun to hear them in that context. And I think that people really responded. But the weirdest thing about it is that Twice Removed is such a kind of sensitive record that the response is less like, yeah, I'm going to go crazy. And just, like, you know, people might not be screaming to hear a song like Bells On. But then afterward, you know, someone might come up to me and say how much it meant to them, or whatever. Like, connect emotionally to something. And it's something that's sort of embarrassing for me to talk about, but I think it's something that goes on, and something that I'm happy about. What about you, Jay? I mean, the life of the song, I mean, you write it, you record it, you perform it.

4:44Now it's been 18 years since the record, you're playing these songs again. Are the arrangements changing? Is there anything you guys are doing now to the songs that you're like, we should have done that on the record? No, I mean, for me, trying to be like a purist, I almost wanted to keep them exactly, or as close to the album as possible. I even used the guitar that I used when I recorded the album, you know. I think I'd be disappointed. My favorite reference is seeing Paul Simon do my song, Kodachrome, once, and he did a reggae version. I was like, what the hell are you doing? Just play it the exact same. It was me booing from the back of the arena, like the back of the bowl. The only one that seems a little bit different, Loosens is maybe just a little bit faster and has a little bit of guitar in it, which... it's a predominantly slow piano song, and it was sped up just a little bit because it's quite long. And I don't know if

5:30Patrick... it's a Patrick song, and I don't know if he was super looking forward to playing it every night, but giving it a little bit more, just making it a little bit faster and putting some guitars on it, I think made it more comfortable for him. But it's still not that far off. And I kind of thought the majority of the rest of the songs were pretty accurate to the record. So I kind of prefer that, because I think fans would rather hear the record as it was intended, as opposed to, like, yeah, we put an extended solo on this part and changed... you know what I mean? I think it's better to keep it pure. So you're writing on the road as you're playing Twice Removed every night. Does playing those songs influence the way you write? Nope. Not at all. So you're able to remove yourself from the rest of the songs? I don't think so, although for me, almost any song that I've written since Twice Removed

6:18could have gone on any of our records. To me, I'd like to think, or sometimes I wish that we had certain... like, we'll get together and say, let's make this kind of record. I think we've only really done that once. Which one? Action Pact, from 2003. We kind of said, let's make a streamlined sort of rock record without a lot of the eclecticism that our other records have. And I think we accomplished that, but what one person would call streamlined, another might call unidimensional. What about writing for other people, does that happen? You mentioned one of the songs before is Patrick's song. Do you write with other people's voices in mind? Does that ever happen? You mean all within the context of the band? Yeah. Like, say, I've got a song for Jay, or I've got a song for Chris. No, I've talked about trying to do that kind of thing as an experiment, like, what if I write,

7:07instead of a song for myself, a song for each of the other guys? We'll see if that ever happens. But Jay and I seem to work pretty well together, and I feel that Jay's... he's right here, but I feel that I could just talk about him. He's open to collaboration, and he would say, and then there's a middle part, and then the next part is this. And I was like, well, I have sort of a bunch of middle parts, I could barf one into your song here. And he's like, sure. But we've done that before, where I'll sing the middle part of Jay's song. I kind of like that. I mean, I think that's a nice thing about being in a band, is having someone else sing a part on one of your songs, whether it's duet style or, like Chris said, singing

7:53a middle eight. But sometimes I'm stuck, like, I don't have a middle eight, and Chris is like, I've got this little bit of a song that's just kicking around, and he lets me steal it and put it in the song. And I think it makes the song better, and I think it makes for a nice... when you play it live, like, two people singing. And I feel like I've had feedback from fans that seem to like those kind of songs where two of us may sing on one track or something. Many who are fans of bands, I think, like it when there's interaction like that. You know, sometimes for expediency's sake someone will sing the lead and then sing their own backups, sort of because it's quicker, but I always prefer when you can tell it's the different guys in the band singing. It's more romantic. And I also really romanticize the songs that do have collaboration, and I kind of know over our history which ones are the most

8:42collaborative. What are some of those? I'm curious. Well, I thought that Money City Maniacs was quite collaborative. I think of it as Patrick's song, but he had the main riff and the first verse, but I helped him write the chorus, I wrote the second verse, and I would say that I even wrote the middle part. So I think of it as pretty much 50-50, and he lets me sing the second verse. And so he and I wrote that, even though I wouldn't have written it without him. But, like, If It Feels Good Do It as well, I guess. If It Feels Good Do It, yeah, that's mostly him, but he gave me the third verse, because it was a lot like a song of ours that went in the garbage, from like our first year of being together. I was like, that's a lot like this song, and he just let me throw on a verse of that song, essentially. So I love it when that happens, even though the

9:28songs might not be any better, or might not be historically thought of as any better than the others. But to me there's a romantic nature to that kind of collaboration, which I enjoy in bands. So we do something called Five Questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. Sorry, do you want us to do them at the same time? Whatever you guys want. If something pops in your head before his, that works. Okay, so it's whatever... whoever's word is here will go first. Yes, whoever's word is here will go first. Here we go. Road or studio? Purgatory. I don't know. I like... I can't do it in one word. No. I'd like to say road, just so we can have something to talk about. No, I would disagree. Like, this was probably the most fun I've had on tour, the Twice Removed tour. I mean, actually, in general I like touring, especially

10:18since we're spoiled and we have a bus and everything, and it's pretty easygoing. And it's kind of like Groundhog Day every day, you know. You have a routine and everything. But I like record, I guess. If you're talking live show versus recording, or LPs, I kind of prefer LPs, because to me that's immortal, or that lasts forever, you know what I mean? So I kind of think that's more important. Lennon or McCartney? Yeah, you can't do that. You can't do it. McCartney, just because, whatever. That's like saying food, clothing or shelter. It wouldn't make any sense. Yeah, I think I'd choose food, though. The best thing about them is the combination of the two. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Well, are you talking like a Public Enemy song?

11:08The melody. I'm not... I got that again, I can't partake. But I did have someone come at me one time saying, sort of, you know, in an aggressive way, like, you guys rely on melody, are you still relying on melody? That's music. [inaudible] No, but it's just like... that person went on to talk about some painter who relied on colors, on paint. It's just, yeah, I think they're all equally important. Well, I think a melody can draw you in, but I think everything has to be good. I mean, I'm sure there's songs of ours where the lyrics are... although I've always tried my best at lyrics, but sometimes it's last minute, like, oh, that'll do. The songs of yours that you dislike the most are the ones where you didn't put enough

11:55thought into the lyrics? That's right. Yeah, I think so. I think lyrics are... I love songs with excellent lyrics. I hate it when there's a great melody and a good beat and the lyrics are throwaway. I think I find that the most upsetting thing about music. I have nothing to add, but I will say... But you will. That I have lots of music in the can, and I hate writing lyrics, because it's the hardest part, because if you do a crappy job, then the whole thing sucks. And you're very good at lyrics. But I take my time too, like, I put a lot of time into it and try to do my best too. I've stuck it up a few times, so I don't know. But going on the lyrics thing, The Other Man is a ballsy song to write. Yeah, that's a good one. But that's an interesting angle, to come from the point of view of that person. But I don't know, I don't have very many big ones like that. Is there

12:43anyone in the band that finds lyric writing easy? I mean, you're both saying it's kind of hard. Does anyone have a... Andrew seems to sort of, like, easily... not easily, but just will write lots of lyrics. Like, he'll jam a ton of lyrics, kind of Bob Dylan style, into a simple chord progression kind of thing. And it's something that I think I could benefit from, writing songs lyrics first, which I never do, because I'm always trying to catch up to the music that I have. But a song of ours like our first single, Underwhelmed, is super simple. The lyrics were written first. I would have never written that music in a finished form if I hadn't had the lyrics. Anyway, I think it's good to write lyrics first, but I never do it.

13:31Song you've written you're most proud of? Can we pick each other's? Sure. Is that fun? Actually, the one I really like, it was kind of hanging around for a long time. Okay, now forget that question. I was going to say, of his songs, actually, specifically, would be... it's on Never Hear the End of It, which we put out in 2006. It's called Fading into Obscurity, one that Chris wrote. And it's just the kind of song that I was hoping that our band would play or work on. It's very... I don't know what you would say, like Happiness Is a Warm Gun by the Beatles, or like Abbey Road style, where it's kind of three or four mini songs in one long five- or six-minute song. And I love things like that, or The Who Sell Out. Like, they had a song called A Quick One, where it was just all little mini songs, and then it's almost like a little suite or something like that. And those

14:20are my favorite kind of songs. So I would say I really like that of his. And my own, there's a couple of really short songs that I wrote over the last couple of records that I really like. There's one on the last one called Green Gardens, Cold Montreal, which is really dense but very short, and I like trying to write those kind of songs. I don't know if it's successful or not, but that's kind of like... It's not a good... That's all right. I've trained Jay over the years to write the kind of song that I want to hear, and he's doing it really well. And Midnight Mass from the EP is really cool. I like that song, Jay's. Yeah, Jay really has not blown it. Jay was a slow starter. Yeah, it's true. Yeah, no, it's true. But I used to write... when we did Smeared, our first time, we're like, oh god, do we have to? I can't wait.

15:08And one word: Sloan. Oh god. Sloan. Well, you just said it, Sloan. What else is it? I would say McCartney. Or is this it? It was a one... it's long. I don't know. I mean, you could say democratic or something. Yeah. It's basically the same thing. Boring? Yeah, I don't think so. Tapioca. No, it's nice to know that 20 years in, it's 21 years in, it's still democratic, everyone's still friends, and it's still, like you're saying, fun on tour. Yeah, I think that's amazing. Mutual fund. Do you guys like mutual fund? I like... I've always liked mutual fund. Yeah, that's what I'd say. You know, if one person's stock is down, the other people carry it, so that

15:58it keeps gaining value. So we're the ultimate long term, because everybody contributes. That's right. That's good. Thanks so much, guys. Yeah, you got it. Okay. We're a sexy, sexy mutual fund.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →