Lennon or McCartney? Scott Avett’s answer: Lennon. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat The Avett Brothers said about the songs
“The Once and Future Carpenter”
Asked which song came to them in the middle of the night, the band pointed to this chorus.
“I think the chorus to The Once and Future Carpenter. That song wrote itself relatively quick.”
“Pretty Girl from Michigan”
The band said the song dates back to around 2005 and was recorded several times before it landed.
“I think we performed it on the radio in Athens, Georgia in 2005, maybe, it's that old. Wow, okay. And it's changed, it changed, and we've recorded it maybe three times”
VIDEOWatch
19:58 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #356 · The Avett BrothersApril 2012 · 00:19:58
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00Very good. How you doing? I'm good, man. I just listened to the record for like the fourth time. It's awesome. Thanks, man. Thank you. It's so eclectic and so different than anything you guys have done. I'm so excited to talk about it with you. Oh man, I'm glad to hear that. I'm glad to be made aware of that. Well, I'm sure you're hearing it a lot. You're probably doing a lot of press right now. Well, sure, but it's good to hear. It's good to hear the opinion of it, right? Nice. Well, let's start into it, because I know you don't have much time. Guess let's start, 'cause I'm going to try and get this up for Monday. So you guys are going to be doing Jimmy Kimmel. Are you going to do something random, like when I saw you on Conan this summer and you chose to play "Murder in the City", or are you gonna try and play one of the new things? Let's see what we did. Oh, I guess, does Jimmy Kimmel... no, that already aired. [inaudible] you mean, right? Oh, okay. Okay, maybe I'm wrong here. I think your Kimmel show is airing again this week coming up then. Okay. All right. Well, yeah, for Kimmel we did "Live and Die" and a little bit of "February"... what we did, the full
1:00performance, I think they only show this song, "February Seven". So, and then we did a little show for them, and then Fallon we'll be playing as well, and I'm not positive we're doing something from the new album, but I'm not... I think I know that. I think it's not confirmed yet. So... Well, it's interesting that you have that option to say I think we're doing something from the new record, because usually you'd have to play the single on these shows. So has that changed, or is that something you guys have just never fallen into? Well, one thing I have to say, I'm learning a lot of... like people have made... this is our second album into a major label, and I hear this often. Like someone in Canada the other day mentioned to me, they said, well, when you come back to Canada, I hope you play one of those small venues again, but you probably don't have any choice in that, right? And I was sitting there thinking, really? We don't have a choice? Like, we've always had all choice in where we play, and I've never seen it the other way. But the more that we work, the more I realize there may be a norm out there that people don't have the choice, and that surprises me, if the artist isn't the best
2:02dictator of what they make. You know, it's kind of funny to think you dictate really much of anything, control much of anything, but it seems that the artist's instinct should be the most trusted with their art. Now, with Jimmy Fallon coming up, I said what I said, I wasn't sure, because they actually asked for a song that we think is a great choice. We're game for all of them, but some of the songs on the new album are much younger for us than others, and we know when they're much younger and you're still learning them mechanically, that the spirit sometimes doesn't come through the song as well, because you're focusing on performing the song, and then you can't deliver the spirit as well because it needs to be a side note, you know? So that's why I say that they sometimes, they mention, well, maybe you could do this song, and we're going to be the first to say, well, we know our instinct will tell us immediately which song we're going to perform the
3:01best. We admit that we could be wrong sometimes about what might be marketable, but we know what we'll deliver the best, so we try to hold people to that. You mentioned in there some of these songs are younger, so where did this record start? How long ago did it start? What were some of the first songs that were written for it? Well, I think "Pretty Girl from Michigan" was... I think we performed it on the radio in Athens, Georgia in 2005, maybe. Oh, that old? Wow, okay. And it's changed, it's changed, and we've recorded it for two or maybe three other albums. We recorded it for Four Thieves Gone, we recorded it for Emotionalism, and both those recordings just didn't have what we wanted the song to have, and the song changed and took many forms. And there's other songs... well, one of the songs that did make the album, which is a really terrific... was a really terrific song to perform, was one that we also started to write probably 2004, that it finally
4:01finished itself a year or so ago, or a year... excuse me, about two years ago. So do you find that you're writing... because I know I talked to a lot of writers, right, and a few of them say that sometimes it's just the quick bursts, and that's... they know it's a good song when it all comes in in one flow. But it seems like with you, or at least with some of these songs, they take a long time to gestate and a long time to finally get right. Do you find... Absolutely. It's exactly the same. For instance, "Live and Die", the single right now, that I guess that's what we're calling it, that was a very quick happening. That song wrote itself extremely quickly. Like it was brought to the table, we started performing it with the band, and it changed very little after that. Where do you write typically? Do you need to write by yourself, or do you write with your brother and Bob, or how does that all work? Well, we're always writing together. It's kind of, you know, I'm... yeah, we're not together as much. We in...
5:00together, I think, once we get off the road, Seth and I will bring ideas together to see if things spark, like if a spark happens, if they mix quickly. But I think we inventory what we write in quiet places, together and alone, but we constantly log inspiration, concepts, ideas, choruses, thoughts, memories, all that stuff. Are you a pen and paper kind of guy or an iPhone notepad? Like how, where do you store your... I got it both. Yeah, I got it all. I sure like the pen and paper. I try to... I have different ways that I categorize the parts of my life. Like if I'm writing letters or writing journal entries, I try to write in cursive. If I'm writing songs, I try to write in all caps. If I'm writing... sometimes I put verses in lowercase and choruses in caps, and I try to inventory all that in that regard, and I still find myself putting a
6:01lot of ideas on the iPhone and voice memos and whatnot. Oh, the voice memos, I love that one. Yeah. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. Do you typically start... do you gravitate more to a banjo or a guitar when you start to write, or is it just whatever is near? I would say guitar. I have to say, the banjo will lead off and help me write songs, but if I'm looking for melodies, it's either guitar or piano. Piano is really a terrific melody reflector, I guess, you know? What have you been playing the longest? Where did you start musically? We started with both. Seth and I started with piano first. Our father insisted that if we wanted to play guitar like all the rock stars do, then you got to start with piano. That was kind of the rule. But we could play guitar, but we had to do piano first. So we all started piano. Cool. Well, there's all the background stuff, so let's talk about this record. For me... I'm going to read a quote to you that you wrote, or that you said to some journalist somewhere. "For me, in the process between I and Love
7:01and You and this album, there have been three years of me trying to refine a series of steps of letting go of certain things I've held on to." So what were you trying to let go of? I guess the broad answer would be ego and ownership and control of anything, from my day to my work. Ego because of the massive success? No, no, no, no, no, no. You know, I thought... I felt successful when I was 15. I never really... nothing that's happened materially or physically to us as a band has really made me feel any more egotistical than I did before. It's... I've been in a different process. As we've gained, I guess you have to say, as we've gained numbers, it's made me feel, certainly made me feel smaller, and shrunk my ego much more, and I'm very thankful for that. We went through a very, I
8:03guess, a seven-year period where we were in front of small crowds, very intimate crowds, very up close and personal crowds, and there were certainly times, enough times, where I just became numb to it, where I thought there'd be, you know, I just assumed there'd be 5,000, 10,000 people coming to see us when there were 125. And I started really appreciating 125, and I started treating 125 like it was 5,000. And then all of a sudden, as it continued to grow, you know, it just... I just feel like I felt it in much more of a humble way, and I realized it was a lot longer a road than I thought it was going to be. And in all honesty, I would imagine that if someone had told us how long it would take us to get to some certain number, as a young man I'd probably been like, okay, I'm going
9:00to do something different. I'm not in it for... like, this is not working out with my deadline. But instead I've learned much different things, and the letting go has been... I've found that any kind... there's trouble, which you can find so many ways to get inside your head when you travel like this, or when you're involved in a creative business as we are, also with the dynamic of business and art, which is so volatile and fragile and in such a careful line. You find that at times you have to just let go and serve somebody else, and to do that, you end up calming your heart, calming your mind quite a bit. So I've tried to apply that to many parts of my life. You talk about calming... there's... and this is an awful segue, actually, but you seem to have an obsession with death on... maybe not, obsession is not the right... but you seem to talk about it
10:01a lot, especially on this record. There's a lot of not just death itself, but winter and cold references that can be associated with death. So I'm assuming a lot of this might have been made during the winter, and why all the winter and death themes? Is it something that's going through your mind a lot? I would have to speak on it specifically per song, you know? Like in "Winter in My Heart", that's just, you know, it's just metaphorically speaking on depression. I've mentioned that in other interviews. But I really look at the theme of life and death as just much more, to me, just your simple drama of hello and goodbye, and, you know, up and down and in and out. So in a lot of ways I feel like they're just... it's kind of a metaphorical reference that, you know, as soon as you talk about death or say death, yeah, I know that I'm guilty of it, be like, okay, hold on a second, there comes the darkness, sort of. But
11:01you know, it's kind of just going straight to the point, I guess, is a little bit of our style, a little bit of our tendency. So just don't beat around the bush, let's just get down to it. And it's also part of our growing older and experiencing, literally, the death and the sickness that we've experienced as we grow older, and our children, and people we know, and other people we know's children, and people that we meet that are going through these exact things. It's just, we just can't really deny it, and we're guilty of being a bit too honest at times. I believe you only have the one daughter, right? Eleanor, as far as I know. I have a son too, Max. And they're... but they're both fairly young. Like this is all new. One and four. Yeah. Okay. So how has that changed your writing as a songwriter? How is that... obviously going on the road must be a little harder for you now, but has it, I don't know, made you more
12:00self-conscious about what words are coming out of your mouth, knowing now that your kids are going to hear them? Yeah, sure, sure. I really just don't... I don't hang everything on it as much. I mean, I still get really anxious and eager to write or to create, like I always have, but I used to act on that a lot more, and that's certainly a letting go, referencing the other question. There's certainly times when I just can't write because I've got to tend to a child when I'm home, or take an opportunity to show a child something that I can't mess it up, and song's just not important enough. My... what I make is just not important enough to miss that chance. So that's changed that quite a bit. It used to be, if there was an idea, I had this obligation to myself that if there's an idea, you get out of bed, you document it no matter what, you go downstairs to the piano, you make it happen. Well, you can't play the piano
13:00when you've got four hours of sleep, you're in that window. It's just like... and I have let go of more great ideas in the past four years that came to my mind in the middle of the night, which seems like when all the great ideas come, than ever before. And I just let go and just say, hey, it's important enough, it'll come back. Well, let's hang on that. You just sometimes just say the hell with it. I was going to say, really? Let's hang on that idea of songs coming to you in the middle of the night. What's one of those ones from this record where the idea or the melody just hit you, you woke up and were like, oh, I got it, I need to get to a piano or a guitar or something? Yeah, I think the chorus to "The Once and Future Carpenter". That song wrote itself relatively quick, but the chorus was kind of outstanding and hadn't really come yet, and that was kind of a thing where it was like, oh, hold on, and then ran down to the piano in the shop that I was
14:00living in, above a garage, and just hammered it out, and it was there. So that's certainly one that I could say, it's like I sat on the song for a long time, well, not a long time, probably six months, and then the chorus... I truly believe that the chorus was just building itself and waiting to be delivered, and I was probably inventorying those words and those melodies as I was moving along, and then it just kind of came out. I love how you call women different things on this record. In that song, you call a woman called Purpose, and in "Geraldine" you said Miss Progress. It's just a really cool way of writing. I don't have a question, I just want to say that. Appreciate it. Yeah, no worries. Thank you. I know we don't have too much time here, so I did want to talk about Dylan just for a second, because of the Dylan and Johnny cover that you guys did on Chimes of Freedom, and it's a version that has Dylan and Johnny in it, which I don't think was ever released. So did you... how did... well, let's just talk about creating that. Where did you find that
15:00recording? Sure. Well, Rick Rubin approached us with that, said, hey, we're doing this project, this is... we're really kind of throwing it out there to add or change anything about this, you know, it's really risky. But we won't... and this is our philosophy since we started working with Rick, we will not know unless we try. So we will not say no until we've heard that it sounds terrible. Well, as soon as we sat down and started... that's the extent of us discovering it. And we heard it, and we understood that Bob Dylan was open to letting us sing on it and take over some of the vocal parts that were his. So that was terrific. Seth replaced his... I'm pretty sure Seth replaced his lead on that verse, which he was down for, because apparently what we had read was he was never 100% happy with that performance, which could... may or may not be true. I would have to hear from Dylan, but
16:01we instantly, when we put that banjo and the guitar on it, like, it felt... I was removed from it. It felt like... it sounded like a banjo that would have been recorded right then. I mean, it was amazing. We just felt it right in the pocket right there. And putting Seth's vocal on it was yet an even riskier move, but it's terrific company, and it is surreal to perform. That's the second Johnny Cash song we've recorded on with Rick, and it's extremely surreal and moving to record with, you know, Johnny Cash coming through the cans and Bob Dylan coming through the cans, and you're not in the same time, you know, it's not the same time, but in that recorded world, it's the same moment, because it's kind of timeless. So it's pretty amazing. Yeah. What... I don't know if this is even a good question, but I'm going to ask it anyway. What was a cooler experience, that, or actually playing with Dylan? Well, you know, the playing part, it goes
17:01by so quick, and it's such a crazy whirlwind of things. You can kind of savour the recording quite a bit. There's... you can get, I would imagine, you can get a little closer to the spirit and the heart of something in an intimate setting with the recording than you can when somebody's... you're in the presence with somebody with so many hundreds of people around you and then thousands of people around you listening. So... but I will say that Dylan was super great to work with and really just personal and felt... he just felt like, and I've said this before, he just felt kind of like an ally, a man that's done what we do, but much longer and much more experienced and much wiser in it than we are, but just because he's at a different point in it, and his path was one way, ours was different, but we're both artists that share some common goals. So I think that was very, very special. And write some kick-ass songs, man. Man, I'd say he sure did. Yeah. So do you
18:00guys. Don't sell yourself short here. Appreciate it. Before I let you go, five quick questions, one-word answers. Road or studio? Road. Lennon or McCartney? Lennon. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first, lyrics, melody or rhythm? Lyrics. Song you've written you're most proud of? [inaudible] Cool. Oh, on the new record. Nice. And in one word... Well, some people like to go back, they say they haven't written anything as good since. Anyway, in one word, The Avett Brothers. Hold on, in one word, The Avett Brothers? Yeah. Describe? Yeah, what's the first word that comes to your mind when you think of your band, or I guess you and Seth, your music in the band? I
19:01suppose this is kind of silly, but it's just me... I shouldn't say that. I'll say it. People have said, like, brick and sidewalk before. It's all good. Yeah, I wanted to say America, but that's so silly, especially for a Canadian publication. But that's all right. That's right. It's just feel. Yeah, I want to say country. Nice. That works. That's... you know, I feel like that's in a... it's in a strange state, and I just feel like country is such a word that's been held hostage for a while, it seems. Yeah, I agree with you, and I'd love to discuss that further, but I'm sure you've got more interviews and a whole day of stuff going, so... Well, you know, I feel like Neil Young would probably have experienced some of that, you know, I mean that. Yes, he should be in the Country Hall of Fame, probably, and maybe one day he will. Well, you should work on that. You've got some sway and some pull, some strings and stuff now. Get on that. Well, maybe a couple years down the road.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.