Lennon or McCartney? Kimberly Perry, Reid Perry, Neil Perry answered: McCartney, McCartney, McCartney. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.
SONGSWhat The Band Perry said about the songs
“Better Dig Two”
The Band Perry described the song as a love song that takes the wedding vows one step further.
The Band Perry: “Our girl in this song, it's ultimately a love song... it was just this really backwards-written way of saying, hey, the vows say that's the best part, I'm going to take it one step further and say not even then.”
“Pioneer”
Kimberly Perry said the title track grew out of fans' stories.
Kimberly Perry: “'Pioneer,' 100%... we were just thinking about, you know, our fans and hearing about different stories, where they are in life... 'Pioneer' is about taking the future by the reins and telling it where to go, as opposed to it telling us where to go.”
VIDEOWatch
12:42 total
For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →
AUDIOListen
Episode #488 · The Band PerryMarch 2013 · 00:12:51
TRANSCRIPTRead
Show full transcript
0:00And I'll be honest, I'm not really a fan of country music, but I really dig your record. I've listened to it like five times now. So I don't know what you guys did going into the studio to make this thing happen and to make it sound like nothing else that's out there right now, but I don't know, maybe we'll start with you talking a little bit about that. Sure. Well, thank you so much for your comments. You know, this was a labor of love, Pioneer. The good news was we had 18 months to figure out what the heck we were going to sound like next and what we needed to say next, which seems like a short amount of time, but frankly, for a sophomore project, that was a luxury of time. And so we got to go on this journey, if you will. And we ended up at a very different place than where we began,
0:48but I feel like with every single song that we wrote, the first one being "Back to Me Without You," the last one being the last song... And it does, absolutely. We saw the kind of change, the different direction of the project. We knew in the beginning that we wanted this album to reflect more of who we are live. We're very primitive performers. We have big electric guitars and bigger drum beats live, so we wanted to accommodate more of that in the record. But we also, on the flip side of that, wanted to be more honest and more vulnerable than we had been on that first album, with songs like "Pioneer" and "Mother Like Mine." And so I feel like we really were trying to achieve both sides of that spectrum, and hopefully accomplished that.
1:37You talk about being honest. I can't remember who in the band was talking about being honest and poetic, and riding that difficult line in between the two. And I wonder how hard that is for you guys. And this is Reid answering that. And yeah, what we were saying was, it's really easy to write poetic, great-sounding rhymes, if you will, lyrically, but they won't always be as honest as they can be, or what you truly feel, as honest as you want to be. And that's really hard. And so a lot of times we would rewrite and rewrite these songs, and we'd go back and ask ourselves, is that truly how we feel? And so the answer we can say is yes, that every song off Pioneer is truly what we were feeling at the time. And we only got there from the work that went into it. And it is interesting how it's so easy to write that direct poetically, but maybe not 100% honestly.
2:33So I hope that we, you know, struck a balance between those two on the record. And Kim, you were talking about Rick Rubin working with mechanics and rhyme schemes. How did he bring that, I guess, poeticism to that honesty? Rick was a song doctor, and he did deal with our mechanics, like rhyme scheme, but it's even more important than that. He did talk about the heart behind it. I remember this one situation, we were in his studio writing in real time, and he had headphones on in the control room. And when we walked in there, he kind of teared up. We weren't saying any sort of words that made any sense. It was all kind of jibber-jabber at that point, but it was the music that he was still moved by, like the chords and the melody that we were laying on top of it.
3:18And so it was kind of, you know, one of these moments that I really learned how visceral just music is, and then what the importance is of finding the perfect set of words to, one, get out of the way of the emotion and the music, and number two, even take it to the next level. But one of my favorite memories from working with Rick was him telling us that we could not rhyme "free" and "penny." Specifically, he said those two. We're from Alabama. We can rhyme anything. Well, yeah, it's like hip hop. You just got to change the cadence of the vowel and you're good. Right. Yeah. Talk about hip hop, actually, why not go there? "Better Dig Two" has got this, like, I don't know what it is, it's an 808 that kicks off the record, but it's got something like that, that intro could easily be sampled for a hip hop tune.
4:04Have you thought about that at all? Putting it out into that world? Well, we have from time to time thought about partnering with somebody in the hip hop community, mainly because we're huge hip hop fans. And I don't know, I think there's something about what they're thinking about, like real life, and we're thinking about real life. There are so many times that you find those two genres together. So you never know. Maybe we will. I don't know. I would love to do a collaboration with either Kanye or Jay-Z, personally. So we'll see what happens. Take the two biggest names in the game. All right. Okay. Cool. Oh, let me call you out. That's right. What did you love about "Better Dig Two"? I mean, you guys write most of your songs, but that's one that was presented to you, or you heard a demo, I'm not sure how it came about. But what really struck you about that tune, that you said this one has to go on our record, and open it, for that matter?
4:56This is Neil, Matt. I think one of the things that, I don't know, drove us to "Better Dig Two" was the exciting music. You know, I think being musicians ourselves, it's one of those things we like to listen to. Not just the lyric and the melody, but the music, and the music was exciting. It was intense. It had exciting drum beats. The electric guitar was cool, but the banjo kind of played this haunting, serious lick over all the electric. So that's one thing that drove us. And, you know, lyrically, on the other side of that, it had this really aggressive bit of music, but the lyric was so vulnerable. You know, our girl in this song, it's ultimately a love song. All in all, kind of a crazy, the best love song.
5:46But it was just this really backwards-written way of saying, hey, the vows say that's the best part, I'm going to take it one step further and say not even then. And it's really a sweet turn to that, but it was so aggressive and so haunting, like Neil said. It was just kind of a mixed bag of tricks, but I think that's what drove us to "Better Dig Two." Rolling Stone called you guys death-obsessed, I guess because of that tune and other lyrics you write. So what is it about death that interests you in the songwriting process? Well, I'm not sure that we're death-obsessed, although we all at one point or another will have to deal with it. But, you know, for us, I think it's that there's nothing quite as final or as romantic as life and death.
6:33And so I think that... I heard a wise person say one time, you should make every important decision in your life sitting in the graveyard, and then ask yourself, will this matter when I'm here? So I think that we do contemplate a lot, like, life when all is said and done. Will our lives have mattered? Will the words that we've spoken have mattered? Will the songs that we sing have mattered? And so that's probably why we end up bringing that theme in a lot. Because I think it's important to contemplate, you know, what your chapter here on earth will mean to those that you know now and the future generations. Have any of you tried that graveyard decision-making process? I did it once and I was so scared. Kim, really, since you're talking, you were saying once that you get inspiration from the fans and listening to the music.
7:25So what songs on this disc came from something of that nature? "Pioneer," 100%. You know, it's the title track of the album, and we were just thinking about, you know, our fans and hearing about different stories, where they are in life. You know, so many of them are beginning or ending school. So many of them have begun and ended relationships and these sorts of things. And, you know, "Pioneer" is about taking the future by the reins and telling it where to go, as opposed to it telling us where to go. There was one really definitive moment. We debuted the song actually on a stage in the UK, and it was really close to a club show that we did. It was very intimate. There were like 500 people there.
8:12And I remember we played "Pioneer" and you could just hear a pin drop. Everybody was just really hanging on the words of this song. And then the next night we played the same set in London, and we played "Pioneer" again. There was a group of girls who had been at the show the first night, and we always started the opening. Manzlin Red on "Pioneer." They held up this sign that said, "We won't hush." And it was just like a really struck the three of us. And I remember we thought about it, each, you know, on stage, and then talked about it after, because that was the one phrase they took away from "Pioneer," and frankly from the whole night, the night before. And so that was the moment when you're like, you know what, it really is going to be an anthem, you know, for our fans. And that's why we ultimately, because of those girls, ended up naming the album Pioneer. Very smart.
9:02It must be nice to be able to tour now with a whole new batch of songs, as opposed to, I mean, with one record you're playing, I would assume, the same set every night for a good long time. So what's it been like being able to add all these new songs into the repertoire? You know, for us, it's been great, and this is Reid, because it breathes a whole new life into what we've been doing. Because we love the songs off the first album, but after two years, it's nice to be playing new music out there. And for everyone else who's seen us over these past two years, I mean, we've had fans that have seen us probably 15 times. And so to bring in some new music for them as well is great. And it's allowed us to bump up the show as well, with a lot of new production, you know, more fog jets and lights that help us take it to the next level, if you will.
9:59Reid, what are some of the songs off that first record that you feel like you have to play every night, that will remain in the set night after night because they just connect with the crowd so much, from that first disc? You know, all of the singles from the first album, as well. But "Independence" is one that we constantly love to play, and "Double Heart" as well. Those are two kind of staples so far. What's it like running the stairs every night after a show? How many, what's your record, up and down? I'll be honest with you, I haven't run stairs in a long time, but whenever I do, I feel good about myself. Yes. And I mean, what's our record? We will actually do jump roping in there, running after shows.
10:45But 45 minutes, I don't know. You got to calm yourselves down after all that high energy. Yeah, I mean, it's just so easy. It's a buzz, and, you know, turn on The Big Bang Theory and eat the last bowl of Lucky Charms. Oh, The Big Bang Theory, like Sheldon, Sheldon Cooper? We do. We are big Sheldon Cooper fans. We don't have much time here, so we do something called Five Questions, five quick questions, one-word answers, and you guys can all answer. Road or studio? Road. Lennon or McCartney? McCartney. McCartney. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody, or rhythm? Melody. Melody.
11:33Probably rhythm for me. Cool. Song you've written you're most proud of? "If I Die Young." Yeah. Well, I got yours, and waiting on the other two. Oh, I was thinking probably "Back to Me Without You." Cool. Is that all three? I think I've only gotten two there. No, you got all three. Reid said "Back to Me Without You," Neil said "Done," and I said it. Oh, I didn't hear "Done." Okay, gotcha. Cool. And in one word, The Band Perry? I know. Hard one. There's two.
12:21Fun. Who said that one? Was that Reid? That was Neil. Neil says fun. And then... And then tenacious. Tenacious is good. Kim? I did not, I'm sorry, I'm waiting for it. Then I was hardworking. Hard work. But you go back and you can go. Yeah, exactly. Amazing.
ABOUTThe archive
This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →
Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.