← All interviews
Interview · November 2012 · Toronto

Amanda Palmer Interview

Amanda Palmer talks Theatre Is Evil and its art book, "The Bed Song", the "Do It with a Rockstar" video, her Kickstarter campaign, Wayne Coyne and playing Dresden Dolls songs, in this 2012 interview with Matt Schichter in Toronto. Amanda Palmer is best known as the singer of The Dresden Dolls and for her TED talk The Art of Asking.

Bands and ArtistsIndie and Alternative Rock MusiciansMusicians

Lennon or McCartney? Amanda Palmer’s answer: Both. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat Amanda Palmer said about the songs

“Do It with a Rockstar”

Amanda Palmer explained which part of the song came first and how producer John Congleton cut it down.

“I got the title idea and the concept... And I wrote the 'do you want to go back home?' That was the part I wrote. And then I wrote the rest of the song around it... it was six minutes long when I originally wrote it.”

Watch the moment

VIDEOWatch

Amanda Palmer InterviewInterview · 7:50 · 22,000 views
Archive footage

7:50 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #435 · Amanda PalmerNovember 2012 · 00:08:09

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:24Hey, it's Matt with MSN.ca. Amanda Palmer, how are you? I'm a **** Palmer. So rock and roll. Yeah. I like this thing. I don't know if I can show all of it. I'll figure out a way to blur it out, though. But you've got this really cool art book. We'll see you in the middle. Can you go to the middle? I can go to the middle. The very middle has a four-page pullout. In the very center, it should feel different. That's the one I did for The Bed Song. It's your favorite song on the record, from what I hear. It is. It's the world's saddest bed. You always write from a sad place. Is that easier for you? Yeah, actually, it's way easier, because I don't have any happy feelings that I need to work out. They're fine. I'm really only inspired to write usually, not always,

1:10but by things that are frustrating me. Sadness, anger, frustration, whatever. Those are usually the things that give birth to songs. Where's the sadness in Do It with a Rockstar? Did you see the video? I did, and I have a whole list of questions for the video. Well, I mean, the video is generally really great and happy and crazy. But that little bit with me and Stoya, the porn star, in the bed, to me, sums up what the song was about, which is it's not what you think. Being a rock star is such a cartoon. And I mean, surely there were the golden days of Motley Crue and banging chicks every night. But my life isn't like that.

1:57I heard that scene was ad-libbed. At the end of the video, it was almost the cheers. We were supposed to just make out and get jiggy. And it made sense to me that I would have a breakdown, because it's the opposite of the myth. You're a rock star, you're in bed with a porn star, it's supposed to all just be really hot. And actually, instead, you have a panic attack and all these insecure intimacy issues, which, to me, is what my music and art is all about. It's actually taking those myths and cartoons and infusing them with a dose of reality that kind of leaves you going, what? That just happened. I like that. How much of that was Wayne Coyne, too?

2:43None. None. Nothing at all. He got in and watched, going, what is she doing? He texted me the next day: that was really weird. I was like, yeah, sorry. I'm making art. That's art, Wayne. That's art. You're telling Wayne Coyne what art is. Yeah, I love that. That's fantastic. So where did this record start? Because in your Kickstarter video, you're holding up a sign that says you've been writing these songs for four years. You've done like three or four records, though, with various projects since then. Yeah. Well, this is my song pile. Everything else that's come out, Radiohead covers, I didn't have to write those. The Evelyn Evelyn record was a strictly sit-down collaboration with Jason Webley. So this is basically the best of my last five years of songwriting.

3:30Are you able to write on the road, or do you need a room and silence by yourself? I mean, I'll occasionally get a song idea and sing it to myself and email it to myself for later. I never look at these. I've been doing that for 20 years. I never come back to them. Really? But I feel too guilty if I don't at least record them. Yeah, I really only write well when I'm not working, working, on the road, surrounded, distracted. I get my best song ideas when I'm at home driving without the radio on, and my brain can kind of get some space. And what about actually putting the songs together?

4:15Do you sit there and analyze and agonize, crossing out words here and there? Or is it usually just a stream of consciousness? It's pretty stream of consciousness. I mean, the older I get, the less I throw away. Like, instead of sitting there and going, mmm, mmm, mmm. In general, I have to write the bulk of a song in one sitting, or I'm fooled. If I don't write the bulk of a song with my ass in the chair at the piano, and I just write one little good bit and say, oh, this is really great, I'll come back to it, I just won't. Always at the piano? Or at ukulele too, sometimes? I used the uke to write Killing Type because I just didn't have a piano around, and the song was so simple in my head.

5:01And I knew it was going to be a band arrangement. I just used the uke to pick the chords out. Usually I'm at the piano. I've got more options because I know how to play the piano. I don't actually know how to play the ukulele. I mean, the song kind of has three or four lives. Just the idea, I've got an idea for Do It with a Rockstar. And actually, Do It with a Rockstar, I had a long gestation period. I got the title idea and the concept, and I was like, oh, this is... And I wrote the "do you want to go back home?" That was the part I wrote. And then I wrote the rest of the song around it. I wrote it on the piano, and that was step one.

5:47Brought it to the band and actually whittled it down with the band. Like, it was six minutes long when I originally wrote it. And then took it to the studio, where John Congleton said, it's a great song. Like, it happens. It's too long. Way too long. What? Man, it's six minutes. I know, but it's like, what would I cut? We've already cut it down. And John Congleton went in and was like, you don't need it in a half intro. And just went in with a machete, and I let him. Was he right? Oh, yeah. And, well, I still think the halving of the first verse was a little weird.

6:33And then that was it. We recorded it. And that is now the static being. That's the song as it will always be. And when we play it live, it's a pretty faithful approximation of the way it was laid down on the record. How do you choose a setlist? Are you going through your whole career? Like, are you playing Dresden Dolls songs and everything? Or is it focused on this? Oh, really? OK. OK. Which ones? We've been playing Missed Me. We sometimes do Half Jack. How come those two? Missed Me is a great, versatile, theatrical, fun song to play, and you'll see tonight. We've been playing around with it. Half Jack is just a brilliant song. It's one of my favorites.

7:18We play Astronaut. From the solo record, sometimes we play Oasis. We play Leeds United. Five quick questions, one-word answers. OK. Road or studio? Both. Lennon or McCartney? Both. Oh, come on. Line. OK. When you hear a song, what usually hits you first: lyrics, melody or rhythm? Lyrics. Song you've written you're most proud of? Mm. Bed Song. And in one word, Amanda Palmer. F***ing. Yes. Thank you so much. You're welcome. I appreciate it. Thank you.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →