← All interviews
Interview · February 2005 · Waterloo, ON

The Velvet Underground (John Cale) Interview

John Cale talks his album Black Acetate and the single "Perfect", forming The Velvet Underground with Lou Reed, Andy Warhol and the Factory, Nico and White Light/White Heat, and 1960s New York, in this 2005 interview with Matt Schichter in Waterloo, Ontario. Cale co-founded The Velvet Underground, is known for his version of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah", and produced debut albums for The Stooges and Patti Smith.

Bands and ArtistsMusic LegendsMusicians

In the collection Music Legends

Lennon or McCartney? John Cale’s answer: Both. Watch the moment. See every artist’s answer. Take the quiz.

SONGSWhat John Cale said about the songs

“Sister Ray”

John Cale recalled the volume battle with engineer Gary Kellgren during the session.

“So they told us all to turn down, and we did, but there was one point where I left it at one level all the time. Well, the organ gets louder and louder... we kept pushing his fader. And he just kept looking at the fader.”

Watch the interview

VIDEOWatch

The Velvet Underground's John Cale InterviewInterview · 17:59 · 254 views
Archive footage

17:59 total

For licensing inquiries please contact reelinintheyears.com. How licensing works →

AUDIOListen

Episode #38 · The Velvet Underground (John Cale)February 2005 · 00:50:18

TRANSCRIPTRead

Show full transcript

0:00A legend in the music industry on the show tonight. These are my favorite shows, when I get to talk to the people that actually influenced everything you're hearing today. This man, John Cale, from the Velvet Underground, a fantastic solo career as well. You just heard the brand new single off the new record, Black Acetate, "Perfect." My favorite track on the record, I'm glad you made it the single. Why'd you choose to have that one be the single? Well, I didn't. I mean, I don't make those decisions. I try and stay away from them. I let the record company decide what they... You know, you've got a whole fleet of people that can go to work for you if you just give them a chance. So you get something back from them as to what they think can work. And most of the time you go in a progression, and I think they have a progression in mind.

0:45I mean, in England anyway, because I haven't spoken to anybody here. They thought, well, we have four, maybe two, in this order, and try it. And "Perfect" was always... Is it one of your favorite tracks off the record as well? Yeah, it is. It is what it is. I mean, it was kind of a knucklehead song when we first started off with it. But then you never know what happens to the vocal. So if you get some bad attitude on the vocal, it'll make it work every time. Changing the studio: obviously when you first started, there weren't computers, there wasn't Pro Tools, there wasn't, you know, everything that's involved today. Making a record now compared to making a record 30-odd years ago, what are the biggest changes in the studio, at least in your process? Do you prefer it now? Did you like it more when it was raw? No, I mean, I couldn't get anything done. I mean, it really facilitates what you want to do.

1:33You can move fast in there. When you have this digital system, you can change your mind. You can crack things really much faster. And, you know, in the case of Black Acetate, it made it possible to make almost a one-man record. I mean, it was Herb. Did you play everything basically? Herb and I did, yeah. Oh, honestly. It was Herb. Herb Graham is a co-producer. Okay. He's a jazz fusion drummer. Oh, no. So he played drums, I played guitar. Then we got Dave Levita to do solos. But the one track, which is the last one that we did, we'd chosen what to mix, and it seemed, well, there's nothing really live here, so let's get one live track. So I got these guys that I'm on the road with. They came in and did "Sold Motel." Cool. So we got a taste of, you know, the raw edge.

2:20How'd you hook up with the guys you're on the road with? Have you known them for a long time? No, no, I didn't do auditions. No, it was really in the dark. And are they cool? They're fun to hang around with? Oh, they're great. Yeah, they're nuts. So how about it? No, are you just going to give them 5 milligrams more all the time? Whatever it is, just give them. They're fine. That's awesome. Let's play something off Paris 1919, one of your most critically acclaimed albums. What's your favorite track off that record? It would be "Hanky Panky Nohow." Sachete, the gentleman, grievance now and there.

3:05He did awesome and we're playing it and playing it. Both playing it will surely. Nothing might win me more than religion and my door. I want to talk about the Velvet Underground at least.

5:26Talk about the music of the 60s, because... Ooh, yeah. For me, the 60s is just, I wish I had grown up in, I wish I was born in 1949 so I could live through the 60s properly and really experience everything. You obviously grew up through it and became fantastically talented through that. New York, 1963, when you moved there. Were you into the folkies, Bob Dylan and Phil Ochs? Where were you in the whole New York thing? No, I hated the folkies. Yeah, I mean, the whole point of doing things with Lou was to really put this avant-garde thing together with some street poetry, and be as aggressive and nasty as possible. But as it turned out, we got the same producer that Dylan had when he did "Subterranean Homesick Blues." Oh really? Tom Wilson. And Tom was the guy that really put the electric guitar on the, you know, introduced

6:16Dylan to that whole thing and got him in trouble in Newport. But you know, I don't know. I mean, yeah, it was such an exciting period. I mean, with Lenny Bruce in and out of jail, you know, crazy things going on. And everybody very busy making films, doing performance art, all of that stuff. And we got lucky. We latched onto Andy Warhol. Yeah, Andy gave us a platform. You know, he put us in the place that everybody could see, and focused everybody's attention. Did he come see one of your gigs or something and say, "Hey, I love those guys"? I mean, he took them up? He wouldn't do that. He'd send somebody. Oh, so Gerard showed up, you know, started dancing with a whip on this. And, you know, "Come up to the Factory."

7:02I mean, I'd known Andy before from art circles. Oh, because I was in an art circle downtown, with La Monte, who were very suspicious of uptown Andy Warhol. And why is that? Oh, just turf. Oh, okay. Yeah. And of course... And so I'd seen him with a lot of people. I'd seen him at a party that we played, we played for Henry Geldzahler's birthday party, and Jackie Kennedy showed up, and there in the middle of it was Andy. But we didn't, I don't know. I was working on the music and he was doing Central Park West and trying to promote his career.

7:47And then finally we met, and it wasn't what I expected at all. Well, what was it? What did you expect, and how was it different? You know, from a theoretical point of view, which is where my head was immersed at the time, you just really think about the theory behind what Andy was doing and what La Monte was doing. And Andy was into repetition, repeated images with Coke bottles. Yeah. And everybody said, well, La Monte's doing something like it. But La Monte, you know, sustaining something for a long time, like holding a chord for three hours, it's not the same as repeating Coke bottles. So there were all these issues that crept up between, you know, that artistically people would just sniff out. But when you got up to the Factory, what was really important was that people were working

8:36like crazy in there. You know, they were down on their knees making silk screens, just work, work, work, work. And it was great. You know, it's exactly the kind of environment that I wanted to be in, and everybody in the band, you know, thrived in it. That's cool. Yeah. There's really only one real Velvet Underground record, at least, well, there's the one with Nico, but she's, is it Nico or Niko? I've never known. Nico. She's singing on it. And then, you know, after that, you guys left. But White Light/White Heat. White Light/White Heat, I love it. I was listening to it the other day. And what's your favorite track on that record? Let's play one of those, because I mean that, in my mind, probably, and I'm sure... "I Heard Her Call My Name." That's my favorite track too. Good. "I Heard Her Call My Name," off White Light/White Heat, Velvet Underground record.

13:53I want to talk about drugs for a second. Obviously very prevalent in the 60s. It's still there now in music. How do they affect you in your... So now in the world, 60% of advertising on television is for drugs. What's wrong with this picture? Well, there's different kinds of drugs. It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter. I mean, some of these drugs, you don't even know what they do. And you read them, and before it ends, you know, everybody told me, "Be careful with these drugs, it could hurt you." I mean, these guys want control, really, the ones who controlled people. And what they didn't like about what was going on in the 60s is that they couldn't. People were a little bit out of control because of everything. Do you think we'll ever get to that point again where basically music is running everything?

14:38It's still here. I mean, it's not as if it's gone away. It's just that... Well, it seems that rock and roll is not, you know, as... It was huge back then. Now it's kind of dying, which is unfortunate. What was it, drug taking? It was rock and roll? Well, I think you're looking at it being homogenized into an industry. You look at it as an industry, which means you look at it like newspapers, or television, or football, or sports. There's marketing involved. And it's the marketing that really, I don't know. I mean, the internet sort of scared everybody. I mean, they're just suddenly realizing, "You better pay some more mathematicians to get safe codes

15:24so that we can protect our own, otherwise we're going to be bankrupt." How do you feel about that? I mean, it's only self-preservation. You know, I wouldn't want anybody to be able to pay my DNA. And, you know, so I'm so... And Sony just withdrew their rootkit that was in their CDs. Yeah. Well, somebody downloaded a CD of a jazz group that they put out that contained a rootkit, which was a trace element that would open doors to anybody that copied it. So you could follow through how many copies of this one CD. Oh, really? Oh, yeah. Which meant that you left doors open. Unfortunately, the doors they left open were in the Pentagon computers, on a way...

16:13Government computers, and you could ride that train and infect. And suddenly yesterday, after denying that it was there, they withdrew it. Oh, yeah. And the guy that found it was a Microsoft analyst, and he describes in detail how he came across it and how he tried to remove it. And he found out when he did successfully remove it, after a long jolt of work, his CD player didn't work. The software of the CD was destroyed. That's awesome.

16:58Let's play another song off the new record, "Turn the Lights On." What do you think when you hear that song? Hard rock. Hard rock. Here it is, John Cale.

20:44I'm on Sony BMG. Music these days, what bands are you a fan of? Elbow. Rihanna. I like... Oh, so you like the hip-hop kind of stuff? I like Jay-Z. I mean, the production there. Those grooves are just, any Pharrell, any Dre, any Fifty. See, you're big into... Well, what is this? I'm just gonna turn you on to that. The production. Just the production? Yeah. It's incendiary. I mean, it's very irreverent of a lot of the stuff that's out there. And I'm sure they pay to get to use some of the samples that they've got. But it's really refreshing, because they're taking TV shows, they're taking film, and throwing it around. So all the, you know, the interesting ideas to me, and the way I really am now, John,

21:33it's not gonna go away. It's not as if it's... Oh, definitely not. Would you ever give, I don't even know if you have the right or the label has the right, but would you ever give stuff, like Velvet Underground stuff, to be looped and given to hip-hop songs? Yeah, I did it. Yeah, I did it. Oh, really? What song? Uh, wait a minute. Yeah, who'd I give it to? I signed up... Chili Memphis. Oh, really? Yeah. What song? I can't remember, it was years ago. They wanted the bass part of "European Son." Oh, really? Yeah. Cool. Well, I'll check that out then. I've got a list of 10 names here. Just give me, I don't know, maybe you met them in a store, a cool story, or just what you think of them. Just a list of 10 names here. John Lennon. I miss him. You miss him? Yeah, some. Paul McCartney. He's still writing tunes with more good hooks than you usually find in like three

22:24songs. Have you heard his new record? Yeah. Do you like it? I like "Vanity Fair" a lot. Yeah. Cool. Bob Dylan. He's the one guy I'd like to produce. You think it'd never come up? He never called you up? I don't know. I don't know. It almost happened once, when I talked to him, and I was just leaving on the phone, taking off on tour. But he was very interested in if I had a band, because it would make things simpler. He? Because he wanted to use the band. And I thought, you know, just as well in a way it was, if I had to move with my band I probably would not have a band anymore. That's true. Jimi Hendrix. I remember hearing "Hey Joe" on this shitty radio in the village.

23:10I bought this, and I'm sure this radio was stolen from somewhere, because this guy, man, boy, wants to buy the music. Okay. Give me the radio. I went home and I tuned to BBC World Service. And all of a sudden, in a week or so, this song came on. I couldn't believe this guitar sound, whistling out of the speakers. And I just ran away from it and I said, "You gotta hear this fucking track. I mean, this guy is ripping your head off." And then he came to play in a club downstairs in Chardonn Square, and I went there. And there he was with the trio, just playing. There was some drunk in the audience,

23:58and this guy just kept on going, and Jimi just stood there. He said, "Oh, we got a Polly parrot in the audience tonight." And the guy just shut up. Oh, I mean, well, you know, you don't want to... He's just sucking the apple. Mm-hmm. Oh, he's not gonna mess with Jimi. Lou Reed. I haven't seen him in a while. Hope he's well. Cool. Patti Smith. I saw her the other day at, before I saw her, Meltdown. Yeah. Meltdown was a festival she curated in the QEH and all over London this summer. Oh yeah. Yeah, it was the last one for like four or five years. And it was great, because she really was hands on. She's exactly the right person for curating a festival.

24:45She was in everything. She got poets, she got novelists, she got events happening. That's cool. And she had a lot of people who tried and failed at it before. Mm-hmm. So it was great. And then she performed Horses. Can you believe it's been 30 years? Does it feel like 30 years? No. No. I mean, she hasn't changed a bit. I mean, she's still great. She's, you know, she's important. Yeah. And just sit there and listen to the language bubbling up. Cool. Next one. Iggy Pop. Yeah. I wonder where his handicap is. Is it golf? Oh, really? You go for it too? No. No. Jim Morrison. I miss him. Kurt Cobain. Kurt? Wow.

25:30He broke the mold of college radio. He really, you know, college radio had been suppressed by record companies for years, right? Mm-hmm. And they said, whatever it was, "You don't go and march for college radio. You know, you don't want to get your hands dirty doing that," you know, because not a respect, because they're very sort of possessed with their own ideas of what was supposed to happen. And then Kurt Cobain came along, and I think college radio just went to war with everybody. They just said, "Yeah, this is what we were waiting for. We'll make this successful." Cool. They did. I mean, I think you were an influence on them, being experimental and having the garage, all that stuff.

26:15But I'm wondering who was the influence on you guys starting off, because obviously you've influenced everyone. Well, no, you know, it's a bit of an accident. Oh, well, quite a few of today's bands. Anything basically, anything punk or grunge. I think it was Phil Spector. I mean, there were certain people that we always listened to. We loved Phil Spector. And that's basically what we were trying to do, to put Phil and Phil Spector together in the band. Let's play another song off the new record, "For a Ride." Yeah. What do you think of when you hear that one? I've been trying to figure out how to do it live. And it's such a do-or-die kind of song. It's a recording event.

27:01You know, it's really nice on the record because you can make things happen. Mm-hmm. But really, if you don't have anything other than guitar solos going for you, doing it live, it's got something else going on, and I'm forgetting about it. So let's go. Hopefully it'll happen soon. I'd love to try. Here's "For a Ride."

30:59Speaking with John Cale. I want to play the 17-minute track "Sister Ray," off the old... Wow. Well, because you don't hear it too often, and I just love it. I think it's great. I heard there's a story of the producer just walking out of the studio, just saying, you know, "Call me when you're done." Well, the problem was that you had a stream of beautiful girls coming in to service in the back room, which just blew our minds no end. And so we kept deciding how to do this, and everybody was getting louder. So they told us all to turn down, and we did, but there was one point where I left it at one level all the time. Well, the organ gets louder and louder.

31:47Well, Gary Kellgren, the engineer, was in there. And I started playing it back, and we were listening and playing back, and we kept pushing his fader. And he just kept looking at the fader, and there was a drawer that he had down here with a huge knob in the tomb. And every time we'd push it up, we'd go, and he would close the drawer. And after a while I caught him doing it. I said, "What's that?" I asked him. That's cool. Well, we'll play it in a second, but every week on the show we do something called five questions, five quick questions, one-word answers. Lennon or McCartney? It's McCartney-Lennon, isn't it? Interesting. Alcohol or marijuana? I don't know why though.

32:34Alcohol or marijuana? Give me a break. iPod or CDs? iPod. Song you've written you're most proud of? The lying song. And one word, John Cale. Me. Cool. Thank you so much. Appreciate it.

33:35Okay. Thank you. Thank you.

34:24Thank you.

44:03Thank you.

45:17Thank you.

Transcript edited for readability from a machine-generated original; some errors may remain.

ABOUTThe archive

This interview is part of the Matt Schichter Interviews archive: more than 700 conversations with musicians, actors and filmmakers recorded between 2003 and 2014, beginning with The BackStage Pass, one of the first podcasts (2003). The archive also became Matt's short documentary Lennon or McCartney. Matt Schichter is now a Glasgow-based producer, line producer and music documentary director: he directed CFNY: The Spirit of Radio (PBS, TVO) and line produced Faith (TIFF and Rome 2026). His films → · UK film producer and line producer → · More about Matt →

Listen to the full archive on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

MORERelated interviews

Browse all interviews →